Location of Repository

Applying activity theory to the study of new public management: an exploration of the local implementation of Bail Support and Supervision

By Nathan Hughes


This thesis draws upon three years spent evaluating the implementation of a Bail Support and Supervision Scheme in one local authority. It describes the development of the scheme within the locality, exploring its relation to the Youth Offending Team and youth court, and their associated liaison groups. In doing so I offer an exploration of theoretical considerations that explain how managerialist policies are translated into localised practice, from which a means to learn from and develop such policy will emerge. I develop a particular strand of activity theory, primarily from within the tradition established by Yrjö Engeström, and demonstrate its usefulness to the examination and understanding of nationally determined yet locally implemented social policies. Using the notions of object trajectory and expansive transformation, I show how local context has impacted upon the idealised object formation arising out of the managerialist policy aims. By exploring activity in the boundary zones between activity systems, I describe a series of material or transitory objects emerging in order to overcome the tensions and contradictions inherent in situated practice, culminating in a reinterpretation of the purpose of the scheme. I conclude by addressing the extent to which local context has altered the intent of the policy in implementation

Topics: HV
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2328

Suggested articles



  1. (2000b) „Guarding the Public Interest? Auditing Public Services‟,
  2. (1999). (Eds.), Perspectives on activity theory. New York:
  3. (1998). (website) Using complexity thinking in the Knowledge Era (undated) http://website.lineone.net/~frank.smits/Essays/Knowledge-Era.htm
  4. (1998). A crisis of youth or of judicial response?‟, from
  5. (2000). Activity theory and the social construction of knowledge: a story of four umpires‟,
  6. (1997). Activity Theory as Framework for Cooperative Work (http://www-sv.cict.fr/cotcos/pjs/TheoreticalApproaches/Activty/)
  7. (2004). Activity Theory, Discourse and Bernstein‟,
  8. (1997). Activity Theory, version 2.0,
  9. (1978). Activity, consciousness, and personality. Englewood Cliffs:
  10. (2000). ASSET Core Profile – Guidance. London: Youth Justice Board. 315 Youth Justice Board (2001a) National Standards for Bail Supervision and Support Schemes. Youth
  11. (2000). Attitudes to Crime and Criminal Justice: Findings from the
  12. (1980). Autopoiesis and Cognition,
  13. (1993). Bail: The Law, Best Practice and the Debate. Winchester: Waterside Press. Center for Activity Theory and Developmental Work Research (website) http://www.edu.helsinki.fi/activity/ Last accessed 11/04/05.
  14. (1997). Beyond Managerialism in Criminal Justice‟,
  15. Board (2001b) Risk and protective factors associated with youth crime and effective interventions to prevent it: Youth
  16. (2002). Board (2002a) National Standards for Youth Justice. London: Youth Justice Board Youth Justice Board (2002b) Splash
  17. Board (2002c) Youth Crime Prevention Strategy.
  18. (2003). Boundary Crossing and Learning in Creation of New Work Practice‟,
  19. (2002). Changing Work Practices in a Finnish District Court. Helsinki:
  20. (2001). Chaos and Complexity: Their Bearing on Social Policy Research‟,
  21. (1994). Chaos Theory and Strategy, Theory, Application and Managerial Implications‟,
  22. (2000). Child Incarceration and the New Youth
  23. (2001). Complexity Science and Transformations in Social Policy‟, Social Issues 1(2). www.whb.co.uk/socialissues/index.htm. (Last accessed 30.09.05)
  24. (1997). Complexity Theory and Social Research‟, Social Research Update,
  25. (2001). Complexity theory and the new public management‟,
  26. (2003). Complexity Theory, Globalisation and Diversity‟, Paper presented to conference of the British Sociological Association,
  27. (2000). Complexity Theory‟,
  28. (1998). Complexity: A Philosophical Overview.
  29. (1992). Complexity: The Emerging Science of Order and Chaos.
  30. (1999). Complexity: the Science, its Vocabulary, and its Relation to Organisation‟, Emergence,
  31. (1925). Consciousness as a problem in the psychology of behavior, New translation by
  32. (1998). Creating a safer society‟, from
  33. (1998). Crime and the sense of one‟s place: globalisation, restructuring and insecurity in an English town‟, from
  34. (1998). Crime, market-liberalism and the European idea‟, from
  35. (1996). Cultural Psychology: A once and future discipline,
  36. (2000). Cultural Psychology. Harvard:
  37. (2000). Defending Young People in the Criminal Justice System. London: Legal Action Group.
  38. (1993). Developmental studies of work as a testbench of activity theory: the case of primary care medical practice‟, in:
  39. (1995). Directory of Bail Support. London: Nacro Nacro
  40. (2000). Editor‟s Introduction: The New Youth
  41. Education and Skills (2004a) Every Child Matters: Next Steps. London: The Stationery Office.
  42. Education and Skills (2004b) The Children Act. London: The Stationery Office.
  43. (2000). Emergence: From Chaos to Order.
  44. (2004). Employing the Concept of the Object in the Discussion of the Links between School Pedagogies and Individual Working Lives in Pre- and Post-Soviet Russia‟, Educational Review,
  45. (1983). Ethnography: Principles in Practice.
  46. (2002). Evaluating Complexity: Theory, Evidence and Practical Guidance‟, Paper prepared for Symposium on „Theory-Based Evaluation‟,
  47. (2000). Evaluation of complex policy systems‟,
  48. (2000). Evaluation of the Youth Court Demonstration Project.
  49. (2001). Expansive Learning at Work: toward an activity theoretical reconceptualization‟.
  50. (2005). Fashion item or symbol of fear?‟,
  51. (2000). Framework for Evaluation for Projects Funded in the Grant Round for Bail Support‟,
  52. (1998). From inclusive to exclusive society: nightmares in the European dream‟, from
  53. (1994). From old public administration to new public management‟,
  54. (2000). Further Diagnostic Thoughts on What Ails Evaluation Practice,
  55. (1998). Globalization,
  56. (2001). Guide to the National Standards for Bail Supervision and Support Schemes. Bail Support Policy and Dissemination Unit,
  57. (1995). Hidden Order: How Adaptation Builds Complexity.
  58. (1997). How can Theory-Based Evaluation Make Greater Headway?
  59. (1993). In the Wake of Chaos: Unpredictable Order in Dynamical Systems.
  60. (1997). Incessant Chatter: Recent Paradigms in
  61. (1999). Innovative learning in work teams: Analyzing cycles of knowledge creation
  62. (1999). Institutionalized Intolerance: Youth Justice and the
  63. (2004). Interagency Collaboration: a review of the literature. (http://www.education.bham.ac.uk/research/proj/liw/default.htm) Weick, K
  64. (2001). Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Talk, Text and Interaction, Second edition,
  65. (1995). Introduction to nonlinear science.
  66. (1999). Introduction to Youth Justice,
  67. (1996). Introduction, in
  68. (1999). Laws, logics and human activity‟, In
  69. (1987). Learning by expanding.
  70. (1995). Lessons from Ilyenkov‟,
  71. (2001). Lessons from pilots : a summary of the national evaluation of the pilot youth offending teams, London: National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders.
  72. (1993). Managerialism and Public Services.
  73. (1994). Managing Criminal Justice‟,
  74. (1959). Men Who Manage.
  75. (1991). Modernity and Self-Identity,
  76. (1996). Mundane tool or object of affection? The rise and fall of the Postal Buddy‟,
  77. (2001). New Agendas for Social Policy and Criminology: Globalization, Urbanism and the Emerging Post-Social Security State‟,
  78. (1997). No More Excuses: A New Approach to Tackling Youth Crime
  79. (1997). Not „One of the Boys‟: women researching the police‟,
  80. (1994). On the evolution of complexity', in
  81. (2002). Outcome Focused Management in the United Kingdom.
  82. (1982). Participant Observation: The analysis of Qualitative Field Data‟
  83. (1997). People Like Us: The Report of the Review of the Safeguards for Children Living Away from Home,
  84. (1999). Perspectives on Activity Theory. UK:
  85. (2001). Policy and Dissemination Unit
  86. Policy and Dissemination Unit (2000a) First Evaluation Report: Evaluation of Projects Funded Under the Youth Justice Board: Bail Support and Supervision Grants. Nacro Cymru:
  87. Policy and Dissemination Unit (2000b) Terms of Reference (letter to local evaluators).
  88. (1999). Power, Politics and Crime.
  89. (2000). Pragmatic Realism: Searching for Criminology in the New Youth Justice‟,
  90. (2001). Pre-Trial Guide: Working with young people from arrest to trial. London: The Children‟s Society.
  91. (2004). Preventing Children's Involvement in Crime and AntiSocial Behaviour: a Literature Review.
  92. (1993). Prison Reform Trust
  93. (2003). Project TALENT: Infusing Technology in K-12 Field Placements Through a Learning Community Model.
  94. (1998). Public Services for the Future: Modernisation, Reform and Accountability.
  95. (1985). Punishment and Welfare,
  96. (2002). Pursuing an Evolving Object: A Case Study
  97. (1988). Quantity and Quality in Social Research. London: Unwin Hyman.
  98. (1989). Reclaiming Reality: a critical introduction to contemporary philosophy,
  99. (2004). Reflections on Activity Theory‟, Seminar at the Centre for Sociocultural and Activity Theory Research,
  100. (1992). Researching recruitment: Qualitative Methods and sex Discrimination‟,
  101. (2001). Return to Reason.
  102. (1986). Scientific Realism and Human Emancipation,
  103. (1995). Simple Theories and Complex Policies: Linking Policy Network Analysis and Complexity Theory‟, Policy Networks in a Changing World, Contemporary Political Studies
  104. (1999). Society versus context inindividual development: Does theory make a difference?‟ In
  105. (1980). Street –Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services, Russell Sage Foundations:
  106. (1996). Studying context: a comparison of activity theory, situated action models, and distributed cognition‟,
  107. (1982). Styles of Data Analysis: Approaches and Implications‟
  108. (1984). Subject, object, cognition.
  109. (1992). Suicides in Prison.
  110. (1998). Task Force
  111. (1991). The Children Act
  112. (1981). The Concept of Activity
  113. (1999). The content and unsolved problems of activity theory‟
  114. (1982). The dialectics of the abstract and the concrete in Marx’ Capital. Moscow: Progress (original work published
  115. (1999). The Edge of Organization: Chaos and Complexity Theories of Formal Social Systems. Thousand Oaks: Sage Marx, K
  116. (1992). The ethnography of a medical setting: reading, writing and rhetoric‟,
  117. (1999). The Exclusive Society,
  118. (2001). The Horizontal Dimension of Expansive Learning: Weaving a texture of cognitive trails in the terrain of health care in Helsinki‟, Paper presented at the international symposium New Challenges to Research on Learning,
  119. (1982). The Life Study: On Mutual Recognition and the Subjective Inquiry’
  120. (2004). The National Standards for Youth Justice Services. YJB: London Youth Justice Board (website) http://www.youth-justice-board.gov.uk/ last accessed 30/09/05.
  121. (1992). The New Science and the Old: Complexity and Realism in the Social Sciences.
  122. (2000). The New Youth Justice and the Politics of Electoral Anxiety‟ from Goldson, Barry (ed) The New Youth Justice, Russell House: Lyme Regis.
  123. (2000). The New Youth Justice,
  124. (2004). The Offenders of the Future? Assessing the Risk of Children and Young People Becoming Involved
  125. (1993). The Origins of Order: Self-Organisation and Selection iN Evolution.
  126. (1982). The Participant Observer as a Human Being: Observations on the Personal Aspects of Fieldwork‟,
  127. (2001). The permanent revolution: New Labour, new public management and the modernization of criminal justice‟,
  128. (2004). The Politics of Decency. London: Mutuo Brownlee, I.
  129. (1979). The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences, 2 nd Edition. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  130. (1959). The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
  131. (1966). The psychology of set.
  132. (1995). The Spirit of Community,
  133. (1999). The Stakeholding Society. Cambridge: Polity Press Il‟enkov,
  134. (1995). The State We’re In,
  135. (2001). The Youth Court 2001: The Changing Culture of the Youth Court: Good Practice Guide. Home Office Lord Chancellor‟s Department Home
  136. (1994). The Youth Court: One Year Onwards.
  137. (1985). Time Frames: The Rethinking of Darwinian Evolution and the Theory of Punctuated Equilibria.
  138. (1994). Towards a Post-Fordist Welfare State?,
  139. (2001). Treasury and Sure Start Unit
  140. (2003). Treasury, Cabinet Office and National Audit Office
  141. (2001). Treasury, Cabinet Office, National Audit Office, Audit Commission and Office for National Statistics
  142. (2000). Underage Drinking: Findings from the 1998-99 Youth Lifestyles Survey, London: Home Office,
  143. (1996). Understanding and preventing youth crime,
  144. (2000). Understanding organizational learning by focusing on “activity systems”‟. Accounting Management and Information Technologies.
  145. (2003). Understanding risk in criminal justice,
  146. (2001). Understanding workplace practice with College mathematics: theoretical frameworks and perspectives on „transfer‟‟, Maths Into Work: Knowledge in transition - theoretical perspectives,
  147. (1985). Unfinished Synthesis: Biological Hierarchies and Modern Evolutionary Thought.
  148. (1999). Using Mentors to Change Problem Behaviour in Primary School Children, London: Home Office,
  149. (1993). What Is To Be Done About Law and Order? Crisis in the Nineties,
  150. (2004). When particles collide‟,
  151. (2000). Which Links in Which Theories Shall We Evaluate?‟ in
  152. (1988). Why Do Men Batter Their Wives?’
  153. (1989). Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History.
  154. (1998). Work, consumerism and the new poor,
  155. (1995). Young People and Crime, London: Home Office,
  156. (2004). Youth Crime and Youth Justice: Public Opinion in England and Wales. London: The Nuffield Foundation Hughes,
  157. (2000). Youth Crime: Findings from the 1998/99 Youth Lifestyles Survey, London: Home Office,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.