Location of Repository

Empirical modelling as a new paradigm for educational technology

By Antony Harfield


Educational technology has yet to deliver the benefits or successes that were expected in educational practice, especially in relation to issues other than the communication and delivery of teaching materials. Evidence suggests that these difficulties stem from the mismatch between formalised virtual learning environments and everyday sensemaking and between the rich potential for enhanced learning afforded by new technology and the constraints of old-style educational practice. In addressing this mismatch, some commentators suggest that the primary need is for a new culture of educational practice-and even that such a culture is already emerging, and others identify the need for a new paradigm for educational technology. The aim of this thesis is to explore the potential for a new paradigm for educational technology based on the principles and tools of Empirical Modelling (see http://dcs.warwick.ac.uk/modelling). The thesis builds upon previous research on Empirical Modelling as a constructionist approach to learning, and in particular Roe's doctoral thesis 'Computers for learning: an Empirical Modelling perspective'. Roe's treatment of Empirical Modelling can be viewed as generalising the use of spreadsheets for learning through applying 'programming by dependency' within the framework of existing educational practice. In contrast, this thesis is concerned at a more fundamental level with the contribution that Empirical Modelling can make to technology enhanced learning that may lead to new educational practices. In particular, it identifies eight significant characteristics of learning that are well-matched to Empirical Modelling activity, and associates these with experimental, flexible and meaningful strands in learning. The credentials of Empirical Modelling as a potential new foundation for educational technology are enhanced by demonstrating that Empirical Modelling is radically different from traditional software development and use. It provides a methodology for modelling with dependency that is more closely related to the use of spreadsheets for learning. The thesis elaborates on the relationship between Empirical Modelling and learning in a variety of different contexts, ways and applications. Three examples drawn from computer science higher education are explored to emphasise the experimental, flexible and meaningful characteristics of Empirical Modelling. This discussion of Empirical Modelling in a specific educational context is complemented by an investigation of its relevance to learning in a wider context, with reference to a broad range of subjects, to specific issues in language learning, and to the topics of lifelong learning and collaborative learning. Although the application of Empirical Modelling for learning is as yet too immature for large scale empirical studies, its potential is evaluated using informal empirical evidence arising from Empirical Modelling practice at Warwick. The sources for this evaluation are well-established teaching activities relating to Empirical Modelling in Computer Science at the University of 'Warwick, comprising an introductory module and a number of final year undergraduate projects. The thesis concludes by considering the extent to which Empirical Modelling can go beyond the support for constructionism envisaged by Roe, to address the broader agenda of supporting constructivist learning using computers. To this end, a close relationship between Empirical Modelling and a vision of constructivism recently set out by Bruno Latour in his paper 'The Promises of Constructivism' is demonstrated

Topics: LB
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2404

Suggested articles



  1. (1989). 2nd edition.
  2. (1998). 3D Physical Modelling with Definitive Notations. Final year project report,
  3. (2004). A Brief History of Spreadsheets, DSSResources. com, URL: http: //dssresources. com/history/sshistory. html, version 3.6,08/30/2004. (Cited on
  4. (1999). A comparison of the comprehension of object-oriented and procedural programs by novice programmers.
  5. (2003). A computerbased environment for the study of relational query languages.
  6. (2006). A conception of computing technology better suited to distributed participatory design.
  7. (1985). A conceptual change view of learning and understanding. In
  8. (1993). A small matter of programming: perspectives on end user computing.
  9. (2002). A survey of socially interactive robots. Robotics and Autonomous Systems,
  10. (1912). A treatise on government (Politics). Translated by William Ellis.
  11. (2002). A treatise on modelling with definitive scripts. PhD Thesis.
  12. (1974). About Behaviorism.
  13. (1996). Abstract Geometry for Design in an Empirical Modelling Context.
  14. (2002). Adaptive educational hypermedia on the web.
  15. (2003). Agent-oriented parsing. Third year project report,
  16. (1993). AgentSheets: A tool for building domain-oriented dynamic, visual environments.
  17. (1995). Alternative epistemologies: an educator's perspective. In
  18. (2005). Alternative model-building for the study of socially interactive robots.
  19. (2000). An agent-based parsing system in EDEN. Third year project report,
  20. (1990). An exposition of constructivism: Why some like it radical. In
  21. (1998). An investigation into the application of the distributed definitive programming paradigm in a teaching environment: the development of a virtual electrical laboratory.
  22. (2007). Analysis of planimeter model week 9 revisions.
  23. (1984). Andragogy in Action: Applying modern principles of adult education. San Francisco: Jossey Bass. (Cited on
  24. (1999). Andragogy. The encyclopaedia of informal education, http: //www.
  25. (1999). Ant Simulation in Java. Third year project report,
  26. (2000). As Distance Education Comes of Age, the Challenge Is Keeping the Students. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Issue published:
  27. (1971). Biology and Knowledge: An Essay on the Relations between Organic Regulations and Cognitive Processes. Translation by
  28. (2001). Building rules.
  29. (2006). C-GRAPH: A case study in the design, implementation and application of a definitive notation.
  30. (2005). Catalyzing Debate about Fundamental Change in Education. In
  31. (1999). Challenging the Computational Metaphor: Implications for How We Think.
  32. (1985). Communicating Sequential Processes.
  33. (1999). Communities of practice: learning, meaning and identity.
  34. (2005). Computational Support for Realism in Virtual Environments.
  35. (2005). Computer Biographies -A Biographical Research Perspective on Computer Usage and Attitudes Toward Informatics.
  36. (1986). Computer Graphics.
  37. (1984). Computer Software. Scientific American,
  38. (1996). Computer-assisted language learning: An introduction. In
  39. (1999). Computer-mediated communication: a Distributed Empirical Modelling perspective,
  40. (2003). Computers for learning: An Empirical Modelling perspective.
  41. (1990). Computing before Computers.
  42. (2006). CS324 Computer Graphics course material 2005/6.
  43. (2007). CS324 Computer Graphics course material 2006/7.
  44. (1995). Databases from an Agent-oriented Perspective.
  45. (1993). Definitive Programming: a Paradigm for Exploratory Programming.
  46. (1959). Dewey on Education.
  47. (2002). Dewey's transactional constructivism.
  48. (1996). Distributed constructionism.
  49. (2007). E-learning Showcase Day
  50. (2007). EDEN Documentation: Guides to
  51. (1990). EDEN: An Engine for Definitive Notations.
  52. (2006). EditGrid, an excellent Web 2.0 spreadsheet. Web Applications Newsletter, Network World,
  53. (2005). Editorial: Developing innovation in e-learning: lessons to be learned.
  54. (1968). Educational psychology: A cognitive view.
  55. (2007). Educational technology and practice: types and timescales of change.
  56. Effective Practice with e-Learning. Online guide.
  57. (2003). Effectiveness of PowerPoint presentations in lectures.
  58. (1995). Emergence in social simulation. In
  59. (1911). Emile or Education. Translation by B. Foxley.
  60. (2003). Empirical Modelling and math-based tutorial software. Final year project report,
  61. (2004). Empirical Modelling for crowd behaviour. Final year project report,
  62. (1997). Empirical Modelling for Educational Technology.
  63. (2001). Empirical Modelling in Product Design.
  64. (2005). Empirical Modelling in Support of Constructionist Learning: a Case Study from Relational Database Theory.
  65. (2005). Empirical Modelling in support of constructionist learning: a case study.
  66. (1912). Essays in Radical Empiricism. London: Longmans, Green. Republished by
  67. (2007). Evaluating constructivist computing for education. A research proposal submitted to the TLRP Technology Enhanced Learning Call 2. (Cited on
  68. (1959). Experience and Education. New York: Macmillan. (Cited on page 6,21,22,24,25,27) [DG05J
  69. (1997). Experiencing and the creation of meaning: a philosophical and psychological approach to the subjective.
  70. (1984). Experiential Learning: Experience as The Source of Learning and Development.
  71. (1990). Experiment and the making of meaning.
  72. (1997). Exploring the Difficulties of Learning Object-Oriented Techniques.
  73. (2000). Extreme programming explained: embrace change.
  74. (2002). From radical empiricism to radical constructivism, or William James meets Ernst von Glasersfeld. In
  75. (1999). Geometric Aspects of Empirical Modelling: Issues in Design and Implementation.
  76. (2007). Graphics presentation using 3D room.
  77. (2007). Guitar tutor. Final year project,
  78. (2007). Half-baked Logo microworlds as boundary objects in integrated design.
  79. (1969). Heuristic programming: Ill-structured problems in progress.
  80. (2000). History of CALL. An online presentation originally made at EuroCALL
  81. (1995). How Compatible are Radical Constructivism, Sociocultural Approaches, and Social Constructivism? In
  82. (2004). Human-robot interaction in rescue robotics.
  83. (2005). Humanities Computing. London: Palgrave. (Cited on
  84. (2004). ICT and e-learning in Further Education: embedded technology, evolving practice. A report to the Learning and Skills Council.
  85. (1975). If you want to get ahead, get a theory.
  86. (2004). Illustrating the History of the Planimeter. Third year project report,
  87. (2000). Imagine... a new Generation of Logo: Programmable Pictures.
  88. (2004). Informality and formality in learning. A report to the Learning and Skills Research Centre from the Lifelong Learning Institute at the University of Leeds,
  89. (2004). Intelligent house. Third year project report,
  90. (2004). Interaction with meaningful state: implementing dependency on digital computers.
  91. (2000). Interactive VRML front-end to dtkeden. Final year project,
  92. (1989). Interpretive biography.
  93. (1997). Investigating the applications of Empirical Modelling techniques to historical railway accidents.
  94. (2002). Kids' club as an ICT-based learning laboratory.
  95. (2003). Knowing true things by what their mockeries be: modelling in the humanities. CH Working Papers,
  96. (1974). La prise de conscience. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France (English translation by S. Wedgwood as The grasp of consciousness,
  97. (1979). Laboratory life: the social construction of scientific facts. London: Sage. (Cited on
  98. (2002). Learners' perception on the value of PowerPoint in lectures.
  99. (2006). Learning about and learning through Empirical Modelling. Presentation at
  100. (1984). Learning How to Learn. Cambridge University Press.
  101. (2007). Learning in the 21st century: The case for harnessing technology.
  102. (2007). Lecture notes on Empirical Modelling for concurrent systems.
  103. (2001). Liberating the Computer Arts.
  104. (2007). Lifelong Learning, Empirical Modelling and the Promises of Constructivism.
  105. (2002). Literature review in languages, technology and learning. A report for NESTA Futurelab,
  106. (1985). Lotus Symphony; a full-blown big brother for 1-2-3.
  107. (1999). Mathematics and virtual culture: an evolutionary perspective on technology and mathematics education.
  108. (2007). Microsoft PowerPoint.
  109. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. MA:
  110. (1980). Mindstorms: Children, Computers, and Powerful Ideas. New York: Basic Books. (Cited on
  111. (2006). Modeling with technology: Mindtools for conceptual change.
  112. (2005). Modelling Navigation and Landmarking in Ants. Third year project report,
  113. (1999). Models as Mediators. Ideas in Context Series,
  114. (2004). Models that manage user experience of analog devices,
  115. (2004). NetMeeting Software.
  116. (1972). Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach.
  117. (1961). On becoming a person.
  118. (1989). On the Cruelty of Really Teaching Computer Science.
  119. (1859). On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life. London: John Murray. (Cited on page 21) [Dau07J Dautenhalln,
  120. (1996). On the origins of objects.
  121. (1998). On two metaphors for learning and the dangers of choosing just one,
  122. (2003). Opening up lifelong learning. Paper presented at SCUTREA, 33rd annual conference,
  123. (1998). Opportunity Scotland: A Paper on Life-long Learning. Presented to Parliament by Secretary of State for Scotland, The Stationery Office,
  124. (1991). Origins of the modern mind: three stages in the evolution of culture and cognition.
  125. (2003). Powerpoint: shot with its own bullets.
  126. (2007). Principles into practice: A teacher's guide to research evidence on teaching and learning.
  127. (1982). Principles of Database Systems.
  128. (2005). Putting the learning back into elearning.
  129. (2005). Radical Empiricism, Empirical Modelling and the nature of knowing.
  130. (1998). Readings/Writings. Melbourne:
  131. (2005). Recreating an experience of the Clayton Tunnel railway accident in 1861. Poster for Kaleidoscope Showcase
  132. (2006). Rethinking Programming.
  133. (2005). Reviving ancient greek battle through the use of Empirical Modelling. Final year project report,
  134. (1986). Robert Fitzroy and the Early History of the Meteorological Office.
  135. (2006). Romanization, Transliteration, and Transcription for the Globalization of the Thai Language.
  136. (1999). Serious Play: How the World's Best Companies Simulate to Innovate. Harvard Business School Press. (Cited on page 45) 252 [Se199] Selwyn,
  137. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning.
  138. (1991). Situated Learning: legitimate peripheral participation.
  139. (1991). Situating Constructionism.
  140. (2005). Social creativity: making all voices heard.
  141. (2005). Software Engineering: A Practitioner's Approach
  142. (1992). Software Tools in Science Classrooms,
  143. (1994). Spreadsheets
  144. (1996). Spreadsheets and programming.
  145. (2003). Spreadsheets in Education: The First 25 Years. Spreadsheets
  146. (1995). Subject Cultures and the Introduction of Classroom Computers.
  147. (2007). Sudoku classic,
  148. (1962). Tacit knowing: its bearing on some problems of philosophy.
  149. (1925). Talks To Teachers On Psychology; And To Students On Some Of Life's Ideals. New York: Henry Holt. (Cited on
  150. (2006). Technological challenges for the re-design of the education system. Keynote address at
  151. (2000). Technology & Revolution in Education: Ending the Cycle of Failure. Liberal Education, Fall 2000,40-49. (Cited on
  152. (1929). The Child's Conception of the World. Translation by
  153. (2003). The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint. Chesire,
  154. (2007). The crisis of educational technology, and the prospect of reinventing education.
  155. (1996). The Culture of Education.
  156. (1999). The EMPTY project.
  157. (2005). The First Warwick Electronic Bulletin on Empirical Modelling
  158. (1995). The good, the bad, and the ugly: The many faces of constructivism.
  159. (1966). The Hidden Dimension. Doubleday. (Cited on
  160. (1998). The Not-So-Quick Guide to dtkeden. urllittp:
  161. (1995). The one and the many. In
  162. (2003). The Promises of Constructivism. In
  163. (1988). The psychology of computer programming.
  164. (1950). The Psychology of Intelligence.
  165. (1955). The Republic. London: Penguin (translated by
  166. (2006). The Second Warwick Electronic Bulletin on Empirical Modelling
  167. (2007). The Third Warwick Electronic Bulletin on Empirical Modelling
  168. (2005). The usefulness of Karl Popper's selectionist theory of learning for educational practice.
  169. Three Objections to Learning Objects and E-learning Standards. In
  170. (2004). Title. Final year project report.
  171. (1966). Toward a Theory of Instruction.
  172. (2007). Transforming Education Through Technology. Speech at
  173. (2007). Uncovering Empirical Modelling. Masters thesis.
  174. (2003). US Patent for Language teaching system. Patent number:
  175. (2000). Using IT in the undergraduate classroom: should we replace the blackboard with PowerPoint?
  176. (1986). Using Spreadsheets to Teach Computer Science.
  177. (2005). Varieties of Concretisation: an illustrative case-study.
  178. (1992). Visual landmarks and route following in desert ants.
  179. (2001). Vygotsky's learning theory. In
  180. (2006). What can we expect from program verification?
  181. (1993). What engineers know and how they know it: analytical studies from aeronautical history. The Johns Hopkins University Press. (Cited on

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.