Location of Repository

Policy evaluation and design in the light of rational expectations

By Andrew John Snell


This thesis examines certain key problems that the existence of forward rational expectations poses for policy analysis. The separate stages of estimating, testing and solving an econometric model are dealt with in turn. The main body of original work is in chapters four and six. In chapter four the problem of the existence of a continuum of solutions to a rational expectations model is addressed. We show that the existing practice of imposing terminal conditions is arbitrary and a procedure is advanced which in principle at least, can be used to estimate the solution jointly with the parameters. In chapter six analytical closed forms for the first order conditions of the likelihood function of the endogenous variables of a general rational expectations model are derived. We believe this is a major contribution to the literature because it opens the door to computationally efficient and cheap likelihood estimation, something not previously available. The first order conditions for a class of models with no predetermined variables has been programmed in Fortran IV and this has been used in chapter seven to estimate a model of financial asset demands. A likelihood ratio test of restrictions implied by rational expectations is comfortably passed so establishing empirical support for the hypothesis. Other original work in the thesis is contained in chapter five. Here we scrutinise the validity of a simulation technique advanced by Fair and Anderson which it is claimed solves a standard non rational model to yield an approximate rational expectations solution. The results of the chapter suggest the method is better in certain circumstances than in others and these circumstances pertain to the make up of the model in question. Finally, chapters two and three cast a critical eye over the policy analysis literature to which a minor contribution is made

Topics: HB
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2612

Suggested articles



  1. (1976). A Model of Macroeconomic Activity. Volume II: The Empirical Model", doi
  2. (1978). A note on Terminal Conditions and the Analytic Solutions of Rational Expectations Models", doi
  3. (1984). A simple disaggregate model of the U. K. financial sector",
  4. (1982). A technique for extracting a measure of Expected Inflation from the Interest Rate Term Structure", The Review of Economic Studies. doi
  5. (1979). An analysis of a macroeconometric model with rational expectations in the bond and stock markets",
  6. (1968). An application of strategy and certainty equivalence concepts to the economy of the U. doi
  7. (1975). An equilibrium model of the business cycle", doi
  8. (1980). Backward and Forward Solutions for Economies with Rational Expectations",
  9. (1977). Conditions for Unique Solutions in Stochastic MacroEconomic Models with Rational Expectations", doi
  10. (1970). Discount house portfolio and debt selection", Review of Economic Studies. doi
  11. (1980). Econometric implications of the rational expectations hypothesis", doi
  12. (1976). Econometric policy evaluation: A critique", doi
  13. (1972). Expectations and the neutrality of money", doi
  14. (1979). Feedback and the use of current information: The use of general linear policy rules in rational expectations models", doi
  15. (1982). Identification of Rational Expectations Models", doi
  16. (1970). Incomes Policy: A Re-appraisal", doi
  17. (1965). Linear Statistical Inference",
  18. (1981). Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Rational Expectations Models",
  19. (1976). Modelling macro-economic time series (with discussion)",
  20. (1968). Monetary and Fiscal Actions: A Test of Their Relative Importance in Economic Stabilisation" The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review,
  21. (1984). Monetary theory and practice: The U. doi
  22. (1968). Multi-Sector Growth Models", Lecture Notes for the M. Phil Degree at Oxford.
  23. (1977). On the Indeterminacy of Interest Rates and Wages with Perfect Foresight - Some Examples", mimeo, doi
  24. (1960). Optimal Properties of Expontially Weighted Forecasts",
  25. (1978). Rational Expectations and Stability in a Stochastic Monetary Model of Inflation", mimeo,
  26. (1973). Rational Expectations and the Dynamics of Hyperinflation", International Economic Review, Volume U. doi
  27. (1976). Rational Expectations and the Estimation of Econometric Models: An Alternative Procedure", doi
  28. (1975). Rational expectations and the estimation of econometric models", doi
  29. (1982). Rational Expectations and the Theory of Policy" in "The Theory of Economic Policy: Statics and Dynamics", doi
  30. (1979). Rational expectations forecasts from non-rational models", doi
  31. (1982). Rational Expectations Models - Analysis of the Solutions", doi
  32. (1975). Rational xpectations, the optimal monetary instrument and the optimal money supply rule", doi
  33. (1977). Rules rather than discretion: the inconsistency of optimal plans", doi
  34. (1983). Solution and Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Dynamic Nonlinear Rational Expectations Models", doi
  35. (1972). Some Implications of Endogenous Stabilisation Policy", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. doi
  36. (1973). Some International evidence on output-inflation trade offs",
  37. (1953). Stochastic Processes", doi
  38. (1980). Testing of the Rational Expectations Hypothesis", doi
  39. (1981). Testing the Restrictions Implied by the Rational Expectations Hypothesis", doi
  40. (1976). The Analysis and Control of Dynamic Economic Systems",
  41. (1979). The Current State of the Policy Ineffectiveness Debate", American Economic Review.
  42. (1971). The Dynamic Impacts of Autonomous Expenditures and the Monetary Base on Aggregate Income", doi
  43. (1982). The Efficient Estimation of Econometric Models with Rational Expectations", The Review of Economic Studies. doi
  44. (1980). The Implications of Rational Expectations for the Forcasting and the Simulation of Econometric Models", Economic Forecasting Unit Discussion Paper.
  45. (1978). The Macroeconomic Impact of Changes in Income Taxes in the Short and Medium Runs", doi
  46. (1975). The Phillips Curve: A Revisionist's Interpretation". doi
  47. (1966). The Wage, doi
  48. (1980). Time inconsistency and 'rules vs. discretion' in macroeconomic models with rational expectations". Universtiy of Southampton Working Paper.
  49. (1976). Time series modelling and interpretation", doi
  50. (1977). Unanticipated money growth and unemployment in the United States",
  51. (1967). Uncertaintly and the Effectiveness of Policy",
  52. (1971). Wages, Prices and Incomes Policies: Some Comments", doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.