Location of Repository

Academics' perceptions of their teaching role following the introduction of Teaching Quality Assessment

By Christine Leigh

Abstract

The aim of this phenomenologically-based study was to establish, from the perspective of academics, what impact the introduction of Teaching Quality Assessment had had on teaching in higher education. Teaching Quality Assessment (TQA) was introduced by the university funding councils, in response to their obligations under the Further and Higher Education (FHE) Act (1992) and was the methodology used to assess the quality of teaching in higher education in the UK during the period February 1993 to June 1995.\ud \ud A semi-structured interview approach was chosen to generate the data. Forty-six academics from two departments (Computer Science and Business Studies) in four institutions (two pre-1992 and two post-1992 universities) were interviewed. Questions focused on academics’ personal views, opinions and aspirations with respect to teaching. These were examined together with their perceptions of the institutional context particularly with respect to support for teaching, and incorporating their experiences of TQA.\ud \ud Respondents expressed a high commitment to teaching, and a stronger professional than institutional loyalty. Teaching was very pressurised due to increasing student numbers, high student:staff ratios, demanding students and the requirements of external monitoring. Academics were also under pressure to excel at research, since status was based on research, rather than teaching excellence. These pressures had been exacerbated by the Government’s funding, expansion, and customer-service policies, to which institutions had responded with increasingly bureaucratic and less collegial systems.\ud \ud The academics felt that TQA did not benefit teaching and learning directly, but indirect benefits included promoting the improvement of administrative systems, and helping them to maintain standards. Participants also regarded the TQA methodology as inappropriate, and suggested that quality assurance systems should be audit-based and improvement-focused, with minimal external controls to assure the integrity of institutional self-regulatory mechanisms

Topics: LB
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2636

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. 1 a, 'A Long Cold Winter'
  2. 1, 'LSE Leads Revolt Against QAA'
  3. (2001). 1, 'QAA is Accused of Meddling in Universities' Autonomy'
  4. (1959). 1870, The Idea of a Universit
  5. 1921/1968, Eco IgEny
  6. (1993). A Blue Print for Quality'
  7. (1994). A Chance to Civilise' in Times Higher Education Supplement,
  8. (1965). A Histojy of the Polytechnic,
  9. (1999). A Piper Who Does Not Play the Payer's Tune'
  10. (1998). A Profession of Faith'
  11. (1988). Academic Freedom and Reaponsibilit (Buckingham, SRHE & tn y z! )
  12. (1991). Academic Freedom' doi
  13. (1992). Academic Qualily in Higher Education: a Guide to Good Practice In Framing Regulations (CNAA).
  14. (1986). Academic Standards in Universities (London,
  15. (1989). Academic Tribes and Territories: doi
  16. (2001). Academic Tribes and Territories: Intellectual Enqui and the Cultures of Disciplines, doi
  17. (1994). Academic Work: The Changing Labour
  18. (1998). Academics Responding to Change: New Higher Education Frameworks and Academic Cultures (Buckingham,
  19. (1996). Accountable to None: The ToKy Nationalisation of Britain- doi
  20. (2002). Alfred Schutz, phenomenology and research methodology for information behaviour research',
  21. (1999). An introduction to phenomenological research', paper produced as an input to the MProf/DProf research methods course at
  22. (1992). and 1995, Decline of Donnish Dominion: The British Academic Professions in the Twentieth Centu (Oxford, doi
  23. (1999). and Staff Satisfaction', paper presented at the European Association of Institutional Forum,
  24. (1994). Are Professors Professional? The Organisation
  25. (1994). Assessing Hardware and Tear',
  26. (1993). Assuring Quality through Student Evaluation'
  27. (1996). Autonomy, Bureaucracy and Competition:
  28. (2001). b, 'Randall's Exit Imperils Light Touch Regime'
  29. (1991). b, 'University Reform', pp 261 -
  30. (1993). Breaking the Shaddes will Free Q Control', tý, in Times Highe Education Supplement,
  31. (2002). Business Leaders Warn of Fall in Demand for Unqualified Workers',
  32. (1998). Calling Academia to Account: Rights and Responsibilities doi
  33. (1999). Changing Academic Work: Developing the Learning Universijy
  34. Checklist for Quality Assurance Systems 1994', a Briefing Paper from the HEQC,
  35. (2002). Clark Makes ILT Exit'
  36. (1995). Colleges Want New HEQC'
  37. (1990). Commitment to Higher Education doi
  38. (1998). Continuity and Change in the Collegial Tradition', doi
  39. (1998). Cracks Appear over QAA'
  40. (1995). CVCP Plan for Single Quality Agency'
  41. (1997). Dearing's Summary'
  42. (1994). Defenders of Academic Faith',
  43. (1994). Degrees of Difference: higher education in the 1990s (London,
  44. (2000). Departmental -Level Cultures and the Improvement of Learning and Teaching', doi
  45. (1997). Diversity: Big Issue Dearing Ducked' in Times Higher Education Supplement,
  46. (1999). Dons Get Tough on Standards'
  47. (1992). Education and Politics in the 1990s: conflict or consensus doi
  48. (1992). Education Reformed: A Guide to the Education Reform Act, 3rd Edition (London, Hodder &
  49. (1993). English People: The Experience of Teaching,
  50. (1993). English quality model snubbed'
  51. (2002). Evaluation for WhatT Teaching
  52. (1994). External Examining in the UK: How Did it StartT in Examining in Focus HEQC.
  53. (2003). Final ReDOrtof the TEQC on the Future Needs and Support for Oualitv Enhancerneat of Learning and Teaching
  54. (1994). Freedom with Responsibility',
  55. (1982). Freedoms, Rights and Accountability'
  56. (1990). From 1944 to 1988: Education, Citizenship and Democracy' Chapter I doi
  57. (1983). From Clergyman to Don: The Rise of the Academic Profession doi
  58. (2002). from the Institute of Employment Studies (IES),
  59. (2002). Fury as Hodge Calls the Shots',
  60. (1989). gement
  61. (2002). Good Teachers or Great Stage ManagersT
  62. (2002). Government and Employers Must Act Together to Prevent Public Sector Crisis',
  63. (2002). Has the Gold Standard Lost ShineT
  64. (1993). Hidden Agenda Suspected in Teaching Quality Pilot',
  65. (1997). Higher Education: A Critical Business doi
  66. (1990). Higher Education' doi
  67. (1991). History of Universities' doi
  68. (1992). Improving Higher Education, Total Quality Care doi
  69. (1996). In at the Deep End_ (Unit for Innovation,
  70. (1993). Institutional Research and Quality Assurance'
  71. (2001). Into Focus'
  72. (1990). Is an External Examiner System an Adequate Guarantee of Academic Standards'
  73. (1996). Joint Planning Group for Quality Assurance
  74. (1988). Language People: The Experience of Teaching and doi
  75. (1996). Learning from Audit 2,
  76. (1994). Learning from Audit,
  77. (1998). Licence to Teach proposal Dropped'
  78. (2001). Listen to Learners' Times Higher Education Supplement,
  79. (1999). Making Sense of Academic Life: Academics, Universities and Change
  80. (1994). Managerialism and the Academic Profession, doi
  81. (2002). Modules and Markets: Education and Work in the 'Information Age",
  82. (1991). New Universities: Their Origins and Strategic Development',
  83. (2002). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development News doi
  84. (1988). Out of the Crisis (Cambridge,
  85. (1997). Oxbridge Turns Guns on Report'
  86. (1994). Peer Review and the Assessment of Hi(,:, Fhe Education Quality: an International Perspective,
  87. (2001). Perceptions of What Helps Learn and Develop in Education', doi
  88. (1991). Personnel Management: a new approach (Hemel Hempstead,
  89. (1967). Phenomenology-, The Philosophy of Edmund Husserl and its Interpretations,
  90. (1983). Professional Autonomy and the Social Control of Expertise'
  91. (2002). QAA External Review Process for Higher Education in England: Operational Descriptio , ref.
  92. (2001). QAA Faces Boycott by 66,000 Lecturers'
  93. (1998). QAA Forced to Beef up Blueprint'
  94. (2002). QAA says that some face old-style inspection until 'light touch' arrives',
  95. (1992). Qualily Assurance in Higher Education:
  96. (1998). Qualitative Inqui[y and Research Design, Choosing Among th Five Traditions,
  97. (1996). Quality Assessor who Fell Asleep on the Job',
  98. (1993). Quality Assurance for University Teaching: Issues and Approaches' Chapter I
  99. (1993). Quality Assurance through Course Validation and Review'
  100. (2001). Quality Control'
  101. (1993). Quality Controls Tipped to Change'
  102. (1993). Quality Debate - Comment'
  103. (1998). Quality Lockout'
  104. (1995). Quality Plan Thrown Out'
  105. (2002). Rates of Return to Qualifications: A summary of recent evidence' Council for Industry and Higher Education.
  106. (1999). Realising the Universit (Buckingham, SRHE &
  107. (1999). Requests Flood in to Teaching Institute'
  108. (1995). Self-Control of Quality Assurance Assured'
  109. (1989). Some Issues in Performance Appraisal
  110. (1998). Split on Quality Blueprint'
  111. (1988). Staff and Standards'
  112. (1996). Steps to Quality Assurance',
  113. (1994). Students 'upset' by Assessors',
  114. (1988). Students and Quality',
  115. (2001). Subject to Interference' doi
  116. (1993). Teacher Training for
  117. (1982). Teachers and Staffing' Chapter I
  118. (1998). Telling it How it is: Accounts of Academic Life' doi
  119. (1998). The Academic Career Handbook (Buckingham,
  120. (1997). The Academic Labour Process: from Collegiality and Professionalism to Managerialism and Proletarianism',
  121. (1994). The Academic Profession, An International Perspective (Princeton, NJ: Carnegie Foundation for Advancement of Teaching).
  122. (1991). The Academic Profession' pp 23 - 45, in Altbach, P, doi
  123. (1988). The All-Seeing Eye of the Prince in Western Europe'
  124. (1998). The Bumpy Road to Quality'
  125. (2002). The Bureaucratisation of the British University',
  126. (1993). The Business of Learning',
  127. (2000). The Concept of Programme Specification and its Application in the New Quality Assurance Framework', doi
  128. (1970). The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenol an Introduction to Phenomenological Philosophy, translated, with an introduction, by David Carr, doi
  129. (1988). The Escaping Answer'
  130. (1995). The External Examiner System: Possible Futures (HEQC/QSC).
  131. (1991). The Future of Higher Education
  132. (1960). The Idea of a Universit (London, Peter Owen).
  133. (1990). The Idea of the Universi
  134. (1969). The Impact of Robbins (Harmondsworth Penouin).
  135. (1990). The Importance of Quality and Quality Assurance' Chapter I
  136. (1997). The International Academic Profession (Princeton, NJ: Carnegie Foundation for Advancement of Teaching).
  137. (1990). The Introduction of Staff Appraisal in Universities as a Method of Quality Assurance',
  138. (2000). The Mc )onaldization of Soýjieý New Century Edition (Thousand Oaks,
  139. (1988). The Missing Bottom Line'
  140. (1968). The New Polytechnics: A Radical Policy for Higher Education
  141. (1999). The New Quality Framework, in Perspectives, doi
  142. (2000). The New UK Quality Framework'
  143. (2002). The Quality Wars: Is the End in SightTin Higher Education Digest, Issue 43, Summer
  144. (1995). The Quest for Quality: Sixteen Forms of Heresy
  145. (1988). The UGC and Standards'
  146. (1996). The Universily in a Liberal State (Aldershot,
  147. (1994). Trends and Issues' doi
  148. (1994). Understanding Social TheoU, doi
  149. (2002). Universities and Colleges Admissions Service press release 9 doi
  150. (2001). University Standards Chief Quits'
  151. (1993). University Teaching: a Professional Model for Quality',
  152. (1995). V-cs Eye Single Quality Road'
  153. (1985). Validation in the Public Sector, Cmnd 9501,
  154. (1994). Western Europe and North America' Chapter I
  155. (1996). Which Academic Profession Are You
  156. (1966). White Paper A Plan for Polytechnics and Other Colleges
  157. (1991). White Paper Higher Education, A New Framework CM1541,
  158. (1987). White Paper Higher Education: Meeting the Challenge Cm 114
  159. (2003). White Paper The Future for Higher Education Cm 5735,
  160. (2002). With One VoiceT
  161. (1998). Writing on Academic Careers' doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.