Location of Repository

A tale of twelve teachers: education and democratisation in Russia and South Africa

By Michele Schweisfurth


This study explores primary school teachers' experiences of the changes that have occurred in education since the end of apartheid in South Africa and the end of communist rule in Russia. It outlines the national educational contexts and critically examines the nature and implementation of new policies in these two 'transitologies'. International literature on teacher responses to educational reform and on the potential of schooling to be democratic and to develop democracy in society is explored as background to the study.\ud \ud The research is based on two periods of field work in each country, between 1996 and 1998. In the second phase, case studies were developed of six Russian and six South African teachers, incorporating lesson observation and interviews about their life histories, educational experiences, classroom practice, and attitudes toward the educational reforms.\ud \ud The findings, based on the individual case studies and a cross-case analysis, reveal that teachers experience a range of 'competing imperatives' which make a coherent perspective and consistent practice difficult, even where teachers agree in spirit with the reforms. Their responses to these dilemmas depend on a number of individual and contextual factors, many of them arising from the personal life experiences of the teacher. For each, the construction of a coherent self-identity, despite the scope of the changes experienced, has been an important part of the process of transition

Topics: LB, JC
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2832

Suggested articles



  1. (1993). 1 Answer with my Life: Life Histories of Women Teachers Workingfor Social Change.
  2. (1992). A (eds)
  3. (1998). A Comparative Study of Teacher Voice and Vision
  4. (2000). A Decade of Reforms of Education
  5. (1988). A Guide to the Soviet Curriculum: what the Russian child is taught in school.
  6. (1993). A Perspective on Educational Case Study: A Collection of Papers by Lawrence Stenhouse. University of Warwick: CEDAR papers.
  7. (1994). After Graduation, What? The Value of Education in the New Order'
  8. (1997). Aid to South African Education and Training in the Context of the New Aid Paradigm: a case of the reluctant recipient? Paper presented at the Oxford Education Conference,
  9. (1997). An Analysis of Educational Challenges in the New South Africa.
  10. (1999). An Introduction to Classroom Observation (2nd edition).
  11. (1998). Anti-racism and the 'New' South African Educational Order' in Cambridge
  12. (1993). Applications of Case Study Research.
  13. (1995). Background to the Reform and New Pohcies in Education mi Russia'
  14. (1992). Border Crossings: cultural workers and the politics of education.
  15. (1986). Bread and Dreams or Bread and Circuses? A critique of 'case study' research in education'
  16. (1984). Case Study Research Methods and Comparative Education"
  17. (1993). Change Forces: Probing the Depths of Educational Reform.
  18. (1994). Changes
  19. (1994). Changing English Primary Schools? The Impact of the Education Reform Act at Key Stage One.
  20. (1997). Changing School Mathematics: Systemic Reform and Teacher Decisions.
  21. (1994). Changing Teachers, Changing Times. London: Cassel Hargreaves, A
  22. (1974). Class, Codes and Control (Vol 1): Theoretical Studies Towards a Sociology of Language (Second Edition).
  23. (1994). Clever Children and Curriculum Reform'
  24. (1999). Coming in from the Cold: -a reflexive account of an outsider researching education in Russia'
  25. (1992). Comparative and International Research in Education: scope, problems and potential'
  26. (1996). Comparative Education, Modernity, and Perhaps Post-Modernity'
  27. (1958). Comparative Education: a study of educational factors and traditions.
  28. (1988). Comparative Education: what do we think of it so far? '
  29. (1999). Comparing Definitions of Democracy in Education'
  30. (1997). Conflict and Development in Education Policy'. Education Policy Unit,
  31. (1996). Contested Visions: Between Policy and Practice. Education Policy Unit,
  32. (1997). Controlling Teachers' Work: the South African State and curriculum control'
  33. (1991). Conversation Piece: the practice of interviewing in case study research'
  34. (1999). Creating a New Methodology for Comparative Education Research: the contribution of the International School Effectiveness Project'
  35. (1995). Critical Discourses on Teacher Development. (introduction: pp 1- 19)
  36. (1999). Culture in Pedagogy, Pedagogy across Cultures'
  37. (1987). Curriculum Change and the Classroom Order'. Calderhead, James (ed) Exploring Teachers' Thinking,
  38. (1990). Curriculum in Context.
  39. (1994). Curriculum Reform at Key Stage 1: Teacher Commitment and Policy Failure.
  40. (1998). Curriculum Reform in South Africa: a critical analysis of outcomesbased education'
  41. (1990). Curriculum Reform: An Overview of Trends.
  42. (1995). Democracy in the School Setting: power and control, costs and benefits'
  43. (1995). Democratic Values in Russian Education
  44. (1998). Desegregation, Racial Conflict and Educaiton for Democracy in the New South Africa: a case study of institutional change'
  45. (1998). Desegregation, racial conflict and education for democracy in the new South Africa: a case study of institutional change'
  46. (1998). Dismantling Apartheid Education: an overview of change' in
  47. (1990). Doing Educational Research in Developing Countries: qualitative strategies.
  48. (1998). Economic Rationality or Social justice? Gender, the National Qualifications Framework and educational reform in South Africa,
  49. (1990). Education and State Formation.
  50. (1995). Education in the Transition.
  51. (2000). Education of the Russian Federation
  52. (1998). Education Policy Developments
  53. (1994). Education Reform: A Critical and Post-structural Approach.
  54. (1996). Education White Paper II (Internet version).
  55. (1990). Education, Inequality and School Reform: Values in Crisis! London:
  56. (1995). Education, Teacher Development and the Struggle for Democracy'.
  57. (1997). Educational Reform and the Transition from Authoritarian to Democratic Governments: the cases Of Argentina, Colombia, Venezuela and Spain'
  58. (1993). Educational Research: Current Issues.
  59. (2000). Entering the 21st Century: world development report
  60. (1996). Explaining Variation in Teaching Practices? Effects of State Policy, Teacher Background and Curricula in Southern Africa'
  61. (1987). Exploring Teachers" Thinking.
  62. (1995). Factors Affecting Educational Quality and Quantity in the Turks and Caicos Islands: case study of a Caribbean microstate. Unpublished Master's dissertation,
  63. (1996). Finance and Govnema-nce in Recent Conflicts over Policy'. Education Policy Unit,
  64. (1996). Five Years Gone: a case study of education policy implementation in the transition to democracy in South Africa'
  65. (2000). forthcoming) 'Values and Vodka: cross-cultural anatomy of an Anglo-Russian Educational Project'
  66. (2000). forthcoming) State of Transition: post-apartheid educational reform in South Africa (personal pre-publication copy - not paginated).
  67. (1995). From Critical Education to a Critical Practice of Teaching'. Smyth,
  68. (2000). From Moscow: living and teaching among the Russians in the 1990s.
  69. (1998). Gender and Education: the place of masculinity in South African Schools'
  70. (1987). Getting to Know Schools in a Democracy: the politics and process of evaluation.
  71. (1999). Gleaning Meaning from Case Studies in International Comparison: teachers' experiences of reform in Russia and South Africa'
  72. (1995). Government Policy and Democratic Reform in the Russian Educational System'
  73. (1995). Having It Both Ways: hierarchical focusing as research interview method'
  74. (1990). Ideology and Curriculum (Second Edition).
  75. (1992). Imposed Change and the Experienced Teacher'
  76. (1995). in Russian Education: a transition between state detern-dnism and individualism'
  77. (1985). In the Company of Teachers: key informants and the study of a comprehensive school' in Burgess, R (ed) Strategies of Educational Research: qualitative methods.
  78. (1987). Individual, Institutional and Cultural Influences on the Development of Teachers' Craft Knowledge'. Calderhead, James (ed) Exploring Teachers' Thinking,
  79. (1980). Inside the Primary Classroom.
  80. (1997). Integrating Paradigms in Educational Research: issues of quantity and quality in poor countries'
  81. (1996). International Research into Primary Schooling: sources, approaches and cautions. Coventry: University of Warwick,
  82. (1993). Interviewing: a strategy in quahtative research'
  83. (1993). Introduction to Giroux, H Theory and Resistance in Education: A Pedagogyfor the Opposition.
  84. (1997). Issues in the Construction of the Culture of Learning and Teaching in South Africa'
  85. (1995). It's More than Style: Reflective Teachers as Ethical and Political Practitioners'.
  86. (1987). Judgement, Planning and Educational Change. London: Harper and Row.
  87. (1993). Just Sort of Fumbling Jun the Dark": a case study of the advent of racial integration in South African schools'
  88. (1987). Knots' in Teachers' Thinking'. Calderhead, James (ed) Exploring Teachers' Thinking,
  89. (1999). Late Modernity and the Rules of Chaos: an initial note on transitologies and rims'
  90. (1999). Learningfrom Comparing: new directions in comparative education research. Volume 1: Contexts, Classrooms and Outcomes.
  91. (1995). Levels of Comparison in Educational Studies: Different Insights from Different Literatures and the Values of Multilevel Analyses'
  92. (1994). Long Walk to Freedom.
  93. (1993). Making Sense of Teaching.
  94. (1996). Marketing, Education in South Africa? Education Policy Discourse in the *New' South Africa,
  95. (1995). Mhe Preparation and Continuing Development of Teachers'
  96. (1995). Mite Paper cf,,: Education and Training (Internet version).
  97. (1991). Modernity and Self-Identity: seýf and society in the late modern age.
  98. (2000). Motivation to Learn: the pedagogical nexus in the Russian School: some implications for transnational research and policy borrowing'
  99. (1999). New Ideologies in Postcommunist Russian Textbooks'
  100. (1997). New Policies and the Challenges of Budgetary Constraints'.
  101. (1997). New Policies and the Challenges of Budgetary Constraints'. Education Policy Unit,
  102. (1996). NIinistry of Education of the Russian Federation
  103. (1997). North-South Collaboration in Educational Research: reflections on Indian experience'
  104. (1999). Not So Much a Context, More a Way of Life? Comparative Education in the 1990s' in
  105. (1997). of Education and Link Community Development Soshanguve School Development Project: Baseline Survey.
  106. (1979). Other Schools and Ours.
  107. (2000). Paper given at the
  108. (1972). Pedagogy of the Oppressed.
  109. (1993). Perceptions of Teaching: Primary School Teachers in England and France.
  110. (1997). Planning for Case-Study Evaluation in Belize, Central America'
  111. (1970). Planning Organisational Change in Education`
  112. (1994). Planningfor Change in Turbulent Times: The Case ofMultiracial Primary Schools.
  113. (1997). Policy and Practice in Primary Education: Local Initiative, National Agenda (Second Edition).
  114. (1990). Politics and Policy Making in Education: Explorations in Policy Sociology.
  115. (1999). Portrait of a Russian School'
  116. (1990). Portrait of a Soviet School under Glasnost.
  117. (1989). Primary Teachers Talking: A Study of Teaching as Work.
  118. (1997). Qualitative Educational Research in Developing Countries.
  119. (1993). Real World Research.
  120. (1996). Realising Change: the continuing process of policy development and implementation'. Education Policy Unit,
  121. (1999). Reschooling and the Global Future.
  122. (1993). Research Traditions' in Hammersley, M (ed) Educational Research: Current Issues.
  123. (1996). Researching the Art of Teaching: ethnographyfor educational use.
  124. (1997). Review of Russian Education. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.
  125. (1996). Roles and Responsibilities in the Primary School: Changing Demands, Changing Practices.
  126. (1998). Russia - the wild East.
  127. (1998). Russia and Eastern Europe' in Arnove, R and Torres, C Comparative Education: the dialectic of the global and the local. Oxford: Rowan and Littleford.
  128. (1995). Russian Education after Perestroika: the search for new values'
  129. (2000). School, Reform and Society in the New Russia. Basingstoke: MacMillan (personal pre-publication copy - not paginated).
  130. (1999). Schooling in the New Russia: innovation and change
  131. (1998). Schools as (Dis)Organisations: the 'breakdown of the culture of learning and teaching' in South African schools' in Cambridge
  132. (1979). Selectionsfrom Michael Sadler. Liverpool: Dejall and Meyorre.
  133. (1984). Social Origins of Educational Systems.
  134. (1996). Social World of Children's Learning.
  135. (1993). Soviet Experimentalism Routed: ST Shatsky's last years'
  136. (1997). Stability Against the Odds: resilient schools in South Africa'
  137. (1997). Statement by the ANC Alliance on Education,
  138. (1995). Studying the Teacher's Life and Work'.
  139. (1995). Surviving the System: a critical appraisal of some conventional wisdoms in primary education in South Africa"
  140. (1995). Symbolic Interactionism: an introduction, an interpretation, an integration (5th edition).
  141. (1995). Symbolic Interactionism: an Introduction, and Interpretation, an Integration (Fifth Edition).
  142. (1985). Teacher Careers: crises and continuities.
  143. (1992). Teacher Education and the Developing Teacher: the role of personal knowledge'
  144. (1987). Teacher Responses to Curriculum Policy: Beyond the 'Delivery' Metaphor. Calderhead, James (ed) Exploring Teachers' Thinking,
  145. (2000). Teachers and Democratic Change in Russia and South Africa'
  146. (1992). Teachers' Struggle: the case of white English-speaking teachers in South Africa'
  147. (1995). Teaching as a Profession of Values'. Smyth,
  148. (1995). The Art of Case Study Research.
  149. (1995). The Challenges of Educational Reconstruction and Transformation in South Africa'
  150. (1995). The Chfld's Road to Democracy'
  151. (1995). The Conception of Democracy: a philosophy for democratic education'
  152. (1986). The Conduct of Educational Case Studies: Ethics, Theory and Procedures'
  153. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory: strategiesfor qualitative research. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
  154. (1994). The Educational Legacy of the Soviety Period'
  155. (1925). The HoRow Men'
  156. (1989). The International Education of the Development Consultant: communicating with peasants and princes.
  157. (1993). The Lives o Teachers.
  158. (1995). The Making of Curriculum: Collected Essays (Second Edition).
  159. (1994). The Micro-pohtics of Macro Reform'
  160. (1996). The Missing Voice in Educational Reforms around the World'
  161. (2000). The Real and the Ideal': teacher roles and competences in South African policy and practice'
  162. (1995). The Reflective Practitioner (7hird Edition).
  163. (1995). The Schizophrenic Rhetoric of School Reform and the Effects on Teacher Development'.
  164. (1996). The Social World of Children's Learning.
  165. (1999). The State of the World's Children.
  166. (1995). the Witswatersrand: Quarterly Reviews of Education and Training in South A ica,
  167. (1995). The World after Communism.
  168. (1994). Theory and Practice of Regressive Education.
  169. (1983). Theory and Resistance in Education: A Pedagogyfor the Opposition.
  170. (1976). Theory in Practice: increasing professional effectiveness.
  171. (1995). Times Education Supplement, 23/6/2000: "Baffling Curriculum Dropped'. Tkachenko, Y
  172. (1998). Transforming Education in South Africa? ' in
  173. (1998). Translation Effects in International Assessments'
  174. (1994). Transnational Knowledge Transfer and the Need to Take Cognisarice of Contextual Realities: a Papua New Guinean case study'
  175. (1981). Understanding through Talk'
  176. (1981). Uttering, Muttering: collecting, using and reporting talkfor social and educational research.
  177. (1995). Versions of Primary Education.
  178. (1997). Whatever Happened to Rural Education as a Goal for African Development? A view from contemporary South Africa' Paper presented at the Oxford Education Conference,
  179. (1995). Working with Teachers to Reform Schools: Issues of Power, Expertise and Commitment.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.