Location of Repository

A non-standard Semantics for Inexact Knowledge with Introspection

By Denis Bonnay and Paul Egré


Forthcoming in S. Artemov and R. Parikh, Proceedings of the ESSLLI 2006 Workshop on Rationality and Knowledge.Standard Kripke models are inadequate to model situations of inexact knowledge with introspection, since positive and negative introspection force the relation of epistemic indiscernibility to be transitive and euclidian. Correlatively, Williamson's margin for error semantics for inexact knowledge invalidates axioms 4 and 5. We state a non-standard semantics for modal logic which is shown to be complete for K45, without constraining the accessibility relation to be transitive or euclidian. The semantics corresponds to a system of modular knowledge, in which iterated modalities and simple modalities are not on a par. We show how the semantics helps to solve Williamson's luminosity paradox, and argue that it corresponds to an integrated model of perceptual and introspective knowledge that is psychologically more plausible than the one defended by Williamson. A generalized version of the semantics is formulated, in which modalities are iteration-sensitive up to degree n and insensitive beyond n. The multi-agent version of the semantics yields a resource-sensitive logic with implications for the representation of common knowledge in situations of bounded rationality

Topics: Epistemic logic, inexact knowledge, introspection, luminosity, T. Williamson, vagueness, modal logic, iterated modalities, common knowledge, bounded rationality, [SHS.PHIL.LOGIC] Humanities and Social Sciences/Philosophy/domain_shs.phil.logic, [SHS.PHIL.PERCEPTION] Humanities and Social Sciences/Philosophy/domain_shs.phil.perception, [SCCO.COGPSY] Cognitive science/domain_scco.cogpsy, [SHS.PHIL.MIND] Humanities and Social Sciences/Philosophy/domain_shs.phil.mind
Publisher: HAL CCSD
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:HAL:ijn_00000679v2

Suggested articles


To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.