Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Performance measures and resource allocation: the behavioural consequences of the University Research Assessment Exercise in England

By Ameen Ali Talib

Abstract

This dissertation analyses the research funding resource allocation mechanism (the Research Assessment Exercise) in England to assess its viability as a resource allocation tool and a performance control measure, to form a view on both the internal consistency of the exercise and to explore possible unintended consequences.\ud \ud Case study interviews were carried out with university administrators to investigate the institutional impact. The academics' behaviour was researched by a questionnaire survey. A survey of journal editors was also carried out. Logistic regression was applied to the survey of academics to analyse the data.\ud \ud The RAE has resulted in a "publication culture", where academics are concentrating on research that produces early publishable results and a tendency to publish as many papers, as possible, from the same research project.\ud \ud The impact of the RAE on academics was not independent of their characteristics. The level of self-assessed research activity was a significant predictor variable. The 'middle-tier' academics were the most influenced by the RAE "four-paper" effect.\ud \ud Overall, the RAE lacked coherence and consistency as a resource allocation methodology, and had unintended consequences as a performance measure

Topics: LB2300
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3040

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1985). A comment on presenting results from logit and probit models",
  2. (1961). A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organisations".
  3. (1979). A Conceptual framework for the design of organizational control mechanisms",
  4. (1978). A Contingency Framework for Management Accounting Systems Research",
  5. (1991). A course in Econometrics"
  6. (1991). A note on a general definition of the coefficient of determination",
  7. (1971). A path-goal theory of leader effectiveness",
  8. (1991). A public management for all seasons? ",
  9. (1943). A Theory of human motivation",
  10. (1988). A Weighting for Accountants in Southern Universities? A Note on the Academic Staff Recruitment Problem",
  11. (1992). Academic research performance Indicators: an assessment of the possibilities",
  12. (1990). Accounting for management control",
  13. (1994). Alternative models of government steering in higher education",
  14. (1973). An Accounting System and Managerial Behaviour",
  15. (1968). An analysis of Managerial Biasing: Evidence of a Company's Budgeting process",
  16. (1999). An analysis of the factors that influence student performance: A fresh approach to an old debate",
  17. (1994). An Empirical Assessment of the `Fit' between Strategy and Management Information System Design",
  18. (1972). An Empirical Study of the Role of Accounting Data in Performance Evaluation", Empirical Research in Accounting, Supplement to Journal of Accounting Research,
  19. (1975). An expectancy theory approach to the motivational impacts of budgets", Accounting Review ,
  20. (1989). Analysis of Binary data" 2nd edition, London, Chapman and Hall.
  21. (1984). Analysis of Ordinal Data", Wiley Series in probability and mathematical statistics,
  22. (1981). Application of classification techniq ues in business, banking and finance".
  23. (1995). Applied logistic regression Analysis", Sage University Papers series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, series no. 07-106, Sage publications.
  24. (2002). Behavioural Consequences of the Research Assessment Exercise in England",
  25. (1995). Bias in UFC research assessment exercise", The Psychologist,
  26. (1960). Budget control and cost behaviour",
  27. (1978). Budget use and managerial performance",
  28. (1996). Changing patterns of funding higher education in Europe",
  29. (1951). Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of Tests",
  30. (1990). Compensation Schemes, skill level and task performance: an experimental investigation",
  31. (1986). Configurations of strategy and structure: towards a synthesis",
  32. (1996). Contradictions and Contrasts: Funding in two universities",
  33. (1992). Control Theory in Strategic Human Resource management: The Mediating Effect of Administrative Information",
  34. (1980). Control, organisation and accounting",
  35. (1985). Control: Organizational and Economic Approaches",
  36. (1995). Department size and research in English universities: inter-university variations",
  37. (1972). Description and Investigation of Sub-Goal Oriented Approaches to Organizational Control",
  38. (1994). Developing research activity",
  39. (1986). Development and Application of a model of Personal Control in Organizations",
  40. (1997). Econometric Analysis", Upper Saddle River,
  41. (1998). Economic and Cultural Impediments to University Education in Spain",
  42. (1978). Economic incentives in budgetary control systems",
  43. (1996). Economic short-termism: the debate, unresolved issues, and implications for management practise and research",
  44. (1995). Effect of funding council policies on teaching quality",
  45. (1979). Effects of budgetary goal characteristics on management attitudes and performance",
  46. (1982). Ethical Standards within organisational behaviour",
  47. (1972). Existence, Relatedness and Growth: Human Needs in Organisational settings",
  48. (1977). Expectancy theory in a budgetary setting: an experimental examination", Accounting Review, October,
  49. (1995). Fairness as an antecedent to participative budgeting: examining the effects of distributive justice, procedural justice and referent cognitions on satisfaction and performance",
  50. (1951). Field Theory and Social Sciences",
  51. (2001). Formula Based Allocation of Public Funds: The Case of Higher Education Research Funding",
  52. (1994). Formula Funding of UK Higher Education: Rationales, Design and probable Consequences",
  53. (1964). Foundations of Behavioural Research".
  54. (1998). Funding Higher Education in England,
  55. (1990). Goal Setting and Task Performance",
  56. (1994). Influences on researchers' commitment",
  57. (1977). Information Inductance and its Significance for Accounting", Accounting, Organizations and Society,
  58. (1990). Interpreting logistic regression results: A critical commentary",
  59. (2000). Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations: Classic Definitions and New Directions",
  60. (1978). Introduction to Econometrics" Prentice-Hall,
  61. (1992). Introduction To Econometrics", 2 "d edition, Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River,
  62. (1994). Introduction", Management Accounting in Universities. edited by RH Berry,
  63. (1993). Lesson-Drawing in public policy: A Guide to Learnin across cross Space and Time".
  64. (1984). Linear, probability, logit, and probit models" Sage University Papers series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, series no 07-45 , Sage publications.
  65. (2000). LOGISTIC REGRESSION: A Primer", Sage University Papers series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, series no.
  66. (1997). Management Control Systems in Research and Development Organizations: The Role of Accounting, Behaviour and Personnel Controls",
  67. (1995). Management Control Systems",
  68. (1968). Managerial Attitudes and Performance".
  69. (1991). Managerial risk taking in diversified firms: an evolutionary perspective",
  70. (1998). Managerialism -something old, something borrowed, little new: Economic prescription versus organisational change in public agencies",
  71. (1993). Managerialism and the Public Services: The Anglo American Experience", 2 "d edition Macmillan,
  72. (1980). Managing our way to economic decline",
  73. (1995). Managing the Academics: Commodification and Control in the Development of
  74. (1985). Managing the Autonomous University", Higher-Education Policy,
  75. (1989). Marketing Academicians Perceptions of Ethical Research and Publishing Behaviour",
  76. (1980). Markets, Bureaucracies, and Clans",
  77. (1991). Matching People and Organisations: Selection and Socialisation in public Accounting Firms",
  78. (1986). Measurements to cure management myopia",
  79. (2001). Meckling
  80. (1994). Meeting the indirect costs of support services in universities: top slicing, charging-out, taxes, trading, and devolution",
  81. (1994). Modelling and Muddling: Resource Allocation in British Universities", Management Accounting in Universities, edited by RH Berry,
  82. (1975). Money, Information
  83. (1954). Motivation and P ersonality"
  84. (1987). Multivariate Analysis of Variances and repeated measures: A practical approach for behavioural scientists",
  85. (1995). Nasty, brutish and short",
  86. (1996). New modes of control in the public service",
  87. (1988). Non-Response Bias in Mail Accounting Surveys: A Pedagogical Note"
  88. (1984). Occupational Communities: Cultuie and Control in Organizations"
  89. (1988). On being economical with university autonomy",
  90. (1977). On the Treatment of Grouped Observations in Life Studies",
  91. (1986). Organisational culture in hospitals in the National Health Service",
  92. (1970). Organizational Analysis: A Sociological View",
  93. (1992). Organizational Socialization in Accounting Firms: A Theoratical Framework and Agenda for Future Research",
  94. (1967). Organizations in Action",
  95. (1993). Outcome-related performance indicators and organizational control in the public sector",
  96. (1990). Performance in a budget-based control system: an extended expectancy theory model approach",
  97. (1994). Performance Indicators: `backseat driving' or `hands off control? "
  98. (2000). Performance measurement and the use of league tables: Some experimental evidence of dysfunctional consequences"
  99. (1975). Power: The Inner Experience",
  100. Press 1961. Everitt BS (19770, "The analysis of contingency Tables",
  101. (1996). Professional identity and the Restructuring of Higher Education",
  102. (1986). Professional Powers. A Study of the Institutionalization of Formal Knowledge",
  103. (1988). Progressing Toward a Theory of Marketing Control: A Comment",
  104. (1999). Public sympathy for
  105. (1999). Quality Assurance in Higher Education in Developing Countries",
  106. (1995). Questioning the value of the research selectivity process in British university accounting",
  107. (2000). Reconsidering performance evaluative style",
  108. (1999). Reframing the debate between agency and stakeholder theories of the firm",
  109. (1972). Regression Models and Life Tables",
  110. (1997). Regression models for categorical and limited dependent var.:: bles: analysis and interpretation",
  111. (1980). Regression models with ordinal data",
  112. (1982). Regulation and Theory of Agency",
  113. (1994). Regulation, rent seeking and reform in higher education"
  114. (1967). Relationship of centralisation to other structural properties", Administrative Science Quarterly.
  115. (1989). Report on the 1989 Research Assessment Exercise", Universities Funding Council,
  116. (1993). Research evaluation systems: sources of policy information and `evaluation push'
  117. (1993). Research management for selectivity and concentration -with what effect? ",
  118. (1995). Research performance indicators for Geography",
  119. (1995). Research selectivity, managerialism and the fallacy of peer review", paper to SRHE Conference, The Changing University,
  120. (1995). Restructuring health and welfare professions in the United Kingdom: the impact of internal markets on medical, nursing and social work professions",
  121. (1995). Scale economies in academic excellence: an exploratory analysis of the United Kingdom's research selectivity exercise",
  122. (1994). Simulating trade-offs: the potential financial consequences for politics dep:: rtments of getting a better research grade in 1996", PSA News, Autumn.
  123. (1999). Simulations of the Submission Decision in the Research Assessment Exercise: The "Who" and "Where" Decision.
  124. (1988). So What is Academic Freedom", in Academic Freedom and Responsibility,
  125. (1954). Some Methods of Strengthening the Common x2 tests",
  126. (1992). Stakeholder-- Agency Theory",
  127. (1966). Statistical Methods of Econometrics", Rand McNally &
  128. (1981). Status Strain in the Professions",
  129. (1995). Stories from the Tower" paper to SRHE Conference The Changing University
  130. (1988). Strategic control systems and relative R& D investment in large multiproduct firms",
  131. (2000). Strategic performance management: A balanced approach to performance management issues in local government"
  132. (1997). Structure and Agency in an institutionalized Setting: The Application and Social Transformation of Control in the Big Six",
  133. (1996). Sub-Cultural Values and Budget-Related Performance Evaluation: Impact on International Joint Venture Managers",
  134. (2000). Supervising Professional Work under New Public Management: Evidence from an `invisible Trade"'
  135. (1994). Systems of surveillance and the silencing of University academic accounting",
  136. (1997). The
  137. (1994). The 1992/93 Research Assessment Exercise: The view from a former polytechnic",
  138. (1995). The Academic Labour Process and the Research Assessment Exercise: academic diversity and the future of non-mainstream economics in UK universities", Leicester, Occasional paper 24,
  139. (1995). The achievement of scale efficiency in UK universities: a multiple-input, multiple-output analysis",
  140. (1961). The Achieving Society"
  141. (1983). The Analysis ofD ependence inC ross-Classifications having Ordered categories, using Log-Linear Models for Frequencies and Loglinear Models for Odds",
  142. (2000). The appropriateness of RAPM: toward the further development of theory",
  143. (1986). The Clash of Cultures: Managers and Professionals",
  144. (1980). The contingency theory of management accounting: achievement and prognosis",
  145. (2000). The design and effects of control systems: tests of direct and indirect effects models",
  146. (1981). The Design of the Corporate Budgeting System: Influences on Managerial Behaviour and performance", The Accounting Review.
  147. (1985). The Economics of Agency",
  148. (1999). The effects of budget goals and task interdependence on the level of and variance in performance: a research note",
  149. (1990). The effects of financial controls on data manipulation and management myopia",
  150. (1983). The effects of job standard tightness and compensation scheme on performance: an exploration of linkages",
  151. (1987). The Effects of Setting Budget Goals and Task Uncertainty on Performance: A Theoretical Analysis",
  152. (1992). The ethical standards of Accounting Academics",
  153. (1968). The Game of Budget Control",,
  154. (1952). The Impact of Budgets on People"
  155. (1997). The impact of the
  156. (1997). The impact of the 1992 Research Assessment Exercise on higher education institutions in England",
  157. (1995). The impact of the Research Assessment Exercise on teaching in selected geography departments in England and Wales",
  158. (2000). The information Adequacy of Management Accounting Systems Amongst Islamic and Non-Islamic Banks in Bangladesh", Accounting, Commerce & Finance: The Islamic perspective
  159. (1996). The Judge, the Model of the Judge, and The Model of the Judged as Judge: Analyses of the UK
  160. (1990). The linear additive and interactive effects of budget goal difficulty and feedback on performance",
  161. (1996). The Management of Complex Tasks in Organizations: Controlling the Systems development Process",
  162. (1976). The Managerial Choice: To Be efficient and to be human",
  163. (1997). The Managerialist State",
  164. (1953). The methodology of Positive Economics",
  165. (1995). The new management and the professionals: assessing the impact of Thatcherism on the British public services", working paper no. 24, Work-Organisation-Economy Working paper Series,
  166. (1983). The Organizational Context of Accounting",
  167. (1964). The Professionalization of Everyone",
  168. (2000). The RAE and Publications: A view of Journal Editors",
  169. (1977). The relationship between organisational structure and organisational control". Administrative Science Quarterly,
  170. (2002). The Research Assessment Exercise and Motivation: A note on the difference in the impact on the active researchers and the non-active",
  171. (1995). The Research Assessment Exercise: funding and teaching quality",
  172. (2000). The Research Assessment Exercise: Strategies and Trade-offs",
  173. (1994). The restructuring of higher education in economics",
  174. (1990). The role of budgetary information in performance evaluation",
  175. (1995). The Role of Professional Control in
  176. (1985). The self-selection and effort effects of standard-based employment contracts: a framework and some empirical evidence",
  177. (1994). The U sefulness ofM anagement A ccounting Systems, Functional Differentiation and Managerial Effectiveness",
  178. (2000). The UK Research Assessment Exercise: Unintended Consequences",
  179. (1972). Theories of Motivation: From Mechanism to Cognition".
  180. (1988). Toward a Theory of Marketing Control: Environmental Context, Control Types, and Consequences",
  181. (1962). Toward a theory of motive acquisition",
  182. (1979). Toward a Theory of Organizational Socialization",
  183. (1985). Toward an Integrative Framework of Organisational Control",
  184. (1995). Transforming British higher education: a view from across the Atlantic",
  185. (1998). UK Academic Accountants' Perceptions of Research and Publication Practises",
  186. (1996). UK Universities: A Time-Series study
  187. (1997). Understanding Ripple Effects: The Cross-national Adoption of Policy Instruments for Bureaucratic Accountability",
  188. (1993). University funding changes and university efficiency",
  189. (1978). US versus UK academic accountancy: some perceived differences"
  190. (1991). What if Anything is Professionalism? Institutions and the Problem of Change",
  191. (1993). When will they ever learn that first derivatives identify the effects of continuous independent variables or ' officer you can't give me a ticket, I wasn't speeding for an entire hour' " Social Forces.
  192. (1968). Where traditional budgeting fails", Financial Executive,
  193. (1964). Work and Motivation'.
  194. (1966). Work and the nature of Man",

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.