Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Capitalising education: exploring the development of professional identity in certified accountants through the role of education and training

By Anne Patricia Stafford

Abstract

The thesis takes a disciplinary approach derived from the work of Foucault (1977), but further developed by Hoskin (1993) and Hoskin and Macve (1986), to emphasise how disciplinarity has a double positive meaning as knowledge and power. Modern disciplinarity is produced through the exercise of certain key 'disciplinary practices', in particular those of writing, examining and grading, which engender both the modern forms of powerful expert knowledge and the application of expertise-based power to the forming of humans as individuals and populations. This disciplinary approach is used here to re-theorise the study of professionalisation as a historical process, and the constitution of professionals as powerful individuals through qualification in knowledge-powerful professions.\ud \ud The growth of the ACCA is studied as an exercise in disciplinarity, in part because it constitutes such an anomaly for the jurisdictional approach developed by Abbott (1988). It has staked a successful claim to professional independence and now claims to be the largest global professional accountancy body. The study traces the history of the ACCA's development through four major stages of growth. At inception, the ACCA's founder bodies set up an examination-based education and training system like that of the chartered bodies, but with expedient differences, e.g. no requirement for articles or to work in practice. Later various ways of becoming 'more disciplinary' were developed, including the use of more active forms of pedagogy in exam-preparation, and expanding institutional linkages with colleges and then universities. While status differences survived, the ACCA became increasingly undifferentiable from the old chartered bodies. The ACCA capitalised on this lack of difference to grow the organisation. At the same time, it has bought into the higher-level disciplinary knowledge that accounting has become, and now examines potential entrants on that knowledge, and maintains its jurisdictional space on that basis

Topics: HF5601
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3041

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1980). 7g 2hoA(ghl awd,,,
  2. (1964). A career for the chartered accountant in education', Accountancy,
  3. (1995). A competency-based integrated approach to accounting education', doi
  4. (1998). A History of Accountancy in the Unites States: The cultural significance of accounting,
  5. (1905). A History ofAccounting andAccountants,
  6. (1990). A Matter of Record. doi
  7. (1998). A ring fence for the profession: advancing the closure of British accountancy 1957-1970', Accounting, doi
  8. (1996). Academic disdain? Economists and accounting in Britain, doi
  9. (1989). Academic tribes and territories: Intellectual enquiry and the cultures ofdisciplines, Milton Keynes, SRHE and Open doi
  10. (1990). Accountancy and society: a covenant desecrated', Critical Perspectives on Accounting, doi
  11. (1981). Accountancy and the British Economy 1840-1980. The evolution of Ernst and "inney, doi
  12. (1994). Accountancy at the University of Edinburgh 1919-1994: The Emergence of a 'Viable Academic Department, Edinburgh, Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland.
  13. (1990). Accountancy comes of age: Yhe development of an American profession, doi
  14. (2000). Accountancy on the periphery: The profession in Exeter to 1939', Paper presented at the annual conference of the British Accounting Association, doi
  15. (1999). Accountants and Empire: the case of comembership of Australian and British accountancy bodies, 1885 to 1914', Accounting, doi
  16. (1992). Accounting and law: an historical overview of an uneasy relationship.
  17. (1996). Accounting and the absence of a business economics tradition in the United Kingdom', doi
  18. (1987). Accounting and the construction of the governable person', doi
  19. (1986). Accounting and the Examination: A genealogy of disciplinary power', doi
  20. (1993). Accounting as Discipline: The Overlooked Supplement'. In
  21. (1956). Accounting education for new responsibilities', The Accountant,
  22. (1991). Accounting for change: proposals for rcfonn of audit and accounting',
  23. (1993). Accounting history and empirical research',
  24. (2000). Accounting history and the Emperor's New Clothes: A response to "Knowing More as Knowing Less"',
  25. (1993). Accounting history as social science: a cautionary note', doi
  26. (1990). Accounting History: definition and relevance', doi
  27. (1996). Accounting in dctail: Accounting for individual perfonnance, doi
  28. (1970). Accounting Principles and the City Code: The Casefor Reform,
  29. (1999). Accounting Standards Board doi
  30. (1994). Accounting, "economic citizenship" and the spatial reordering of manufacture', doi
  31. (1986). American Accounting Association doi
  32. (1990). An Accounting Historiography: Subject Matter and Methodology', doi
  33. (1976). An introduction to the sociology of the intelligentsia'.
  34. (1991). Assessing the Business ProfessionaL A feasibility study of alternative modes of assessment with special reference to the ICAEW qualifying examinations,
  35. (1998). Barriers to integration: some lessons from history',
  36. (1990). Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory procedures and Techniques, doi
  37. (1992). Before Writing, Volume L From Counting to Cuneiform Austin, doi
  38. (1998). Beyond good and evil: Depth and division in the management of human resources'. doi
  39. (1993). Blurring, cracking and crossing: Permeation and the fracturing of discipline'. In
  40. (1941). Business training in medieval Oxford', doi
  41. (1989). Case Study Research. Thousand Oaks Califomia and London, Sage Publications, Revised edition.
  42. (1996). Casino capitalism" and the rise of the "commercialised" service class - an examination of the accountant', doi
  43. (1997). CATS, RATS, and EARS: Making the case for ethnographic accounting research', doi
  44. (1979). Central Problems in Social Theory, doi
  45. (1977). Centres of learning. ý
  46. (1992). Changes in accounting education: preparing for the twenty-first century', doi
  47. (1991). Chartered accountants as business managers: an oral history perspective', doi
  48. (1984). Collected Papers on Accounting and Accounting Education.
  49. (1990). Coming into the light,
  50. (1995). Competence-based learning and qualifications in the UK' doi
  51. (1995). Competency standards for professional accountants in Australia and New Zealand' doi
  52. (1995). Computer programs for qualitative data analysis, Thousand Oaks, doi
  53. (1995). Computer-Aided Qualitative Data Analysis. Theory, Methods and Practice, doi
  54. (1991). Computing for qualitative research: options, problems and potential'.
  55. (1916). Cours de Linguistique Ginýrale, doi
  56. (2002). Creating the 'New Professional Accountant': Closing the Gap Between Work-Based and Qualification-Focussed Learning',
  57. (1994). Critical and Effective Histories: Foucault's Methods and Historical Sociology, doi
  58. (1996). Critical and interpretive histories: insights into accounting's present and future through its past', doi
  59. (1994). Culture andImperialism,
  60. (1995). David Solomons and British Accounting', doi
  61. (1982). Days ofJudgement, Driffield, Studies in Education Ltd, Nafferton Books. doi
  62. (1995). Different Functions of Coding in the Analysis of Textual Data'.
  63. (1993). Disciplinary boundaries and the rhetoric of the social sciences'. In doi
  64. (1987). Does the CPA belong to a professionT Accounting Horizons,
  65. (1991). Educating Accountants: Towards a critical ethnography', doi
  66. (1993). Education and the genesis of disciplinarity: the unexpected reversal'. In
  67. (1991). Education and the social order 1940-1990, doi
  68. (2000). Encounters with Nazism: British accountants and the fifth international congress on accounting', doi
  69. (1954). English Accountancy 1800-1954. A study in social and economic history, doi
  70. (1982). Examinations and the schooling of science'. In
  71. (1887). Factory Accounts: Their Principles and Practice. A Handbookfor Accountants and Manufacturers,
  72. (1954). Fifty Years,
  73. (1980). Financial Accounting Standards Board doi
  74. (1990). Firm Foundations: The Development of Professional Accounting in Scotland,
  75. (1984). Foucault among the sociologists: The 'Disciplines' and the history of the Professions', doi
  76. (1992). Foucault and Feminism: Power, Gender and the Seýf, Carnbridge,
  77. (1990). Foucault under examination: the crypto-educationalist unmasked'. In
  78. (1994). Foucault: A Critical Introduction, doi
  79. (1993). Gender and the construction of the professional accountant', doi
  80. (1993). Genealogies of calculation', doi
  81. (1999). Historiography, causality, and positioning: an unsystematic view of accounting history',
  82. (1997). ICAEWPass Rates Research: Final Report, Report to the ICAEW, mimeo,
  83. (1996). Imperialism and the Professions: A Case Study of the Development of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Trinidad and Tobago, Unpublished PhD Thesis,
  84. (2000). Imperialism and the professions: the education and certification of accountants in Trinidad and Tobago', doi
  85. (1989). Importing and exporting accounting: the British experience'.
  86. (1996). Interviews: An Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing, Thousand Oaks, doi
  87. (1993). Introduction'. In E.
  88. (1970). Josiah Wedgwood and cost accounting in the Industrial Revolution', The Economic History Review, doi
  89. (1993). Keeping the record straight: Foucauldian revisionism and nineteenth century US cost accounting history', doi
  90. (1987). Knowledges: Historical and critical studies in disciplinarity,
  91. (1973). La"ers and their society,
  92. (1979). Landmarks in Accounting History',
  93. (1986). Making Accounting Policy,
  94. (1993). Making profession and state, doi
  95. (1998). Making Up Accountants: The organizational and professional socialization of trainee chartered accountants,
  96. (1992). Managing the Shopfloor. - Subjectivity, Masculinity and WorAplace Culture, doi
  97. (1996). Manufacturing the employee: Management knowledgefrom the 191h to 21" centuries,
  98. (1982). Masters at Paris from 1170-1215: A Social Perspective'. In
  99. (1970). Masters, Princes and Merchants: the social views of Peter the Chanter and his circle, 2 vols, doi
  100. (1991). Method and madness in the application of computer technology to qualitative data analysis'.
  101. (1994). Microcomputing and Qualitative Data Analysis London, Avebury, Cardiff Papers in Qualitative Research Series.
  102. (1979). Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods: triangulation in action', doi
  103. (1990). Mutual self interest -a unifying force; the dominance of societal closure over social background in the early professional accounting bodies',
  104. (1969). Nationalism and the international transfer of accounting skills',
  105. (2002). On Becoming the New Accounting Expert: Between Formal and Informal Learning, Unpublished
  106. (1976). On qualitative differences in leaming',
  107. (2000). Oral history, accounting history and an interview with Sir John Grenside', doi
  108. (1986). Organizing the Profession: A theoretical and historical examination of the development of the major accountancy bodies in the UK', doi
  109. (1994). Overcoming barriers: early African-American certified public accountants, doi
  110. (1977). Pioneers of a Profession: Chartered Accountants to 1979,
  111. (1992). Pluralizing our past: Foucault in accounting history', doi
  112. (1979). Preachers, Florilegia and Sermons, Toronto, Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies. doi
  113. (1996). Preserving history in accounting: Seeking common ground between 'new' and 'old' accounting history', doi
  114. (1975). Profession and Monopoly: A Study doi
  115. (1934). Profession'. doi
  116. (1970). Professional Dominance, doi
  117. (1984). Professional fonnation: the case of Scottish accountants', doi
  118. (1993). Professional knowledge and social mobility: postwar changes in the knowledge-base of management accounting', doi
  119. (1966). Professional Men: the rise of the professional classes in nineteenthcentury England, London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
  120. (1987). Professionalism and intraprofessional competition in the Canadian accounting profession', doi
  121. (1972). Professions and Power, doi
  122. (1968). Professions'. doi
  123. (1974). Prospectus for a Profession: The Report of the Long Range Enquiry into Education and Trainingfor the Accountancy Profession,
  124. (1996). Radicalizing accounting history: the potential of oral history', doi
  125. (1994). Reappraising the Genesis of Managerialism: A Reexamination of the Role of Accounting at the Springfield Armory, 1815-1845', Accounting, doi
  126. (1989). Recent Trends in Accounting Education and Research in the USA: Some Implications for UK Academics', doi
  127. (1988). Regulating the UK Accountancy Profession', Paper presented at ESRC Workshop 'The State and the Professions in British Industry and Commerce: A Changing Relationship', London, Policy Studies Institute.
  128. (1983). Removing the blinkers? A critique of recent contributions to the sociology of the professions', doi
  129. (1950). Report of a special committee on education for commerce,
  130. (1993). Rethinking the profession-state dynamic: the case of the Victorian charter attempt, 1885-1906', Accounting, doi
  131. (1995). Scottish chartered accountants: internal and external political relationships, doi
  132. (1985). Setting accounting standards in the LJK: the emergence of private accounting bodies and their role in the regulation of public accounting practice'.
  133. (1995). Shaping the US academic accounting research profession: the American Accounting Association and the social construction of a professional elite', doi
  134. (1982). Silent reading: Its impact on late medieval scripts and society', Viator,
  135. (1971). Social Class and the Division ofLabour., Essays in Honour of Ilya Neustadt, doi
  136. (1985). Social Closure and Occupational Registration', doi
  137. (1997). Social closure in dynamic markets: the incomplete professional project in accountancy', doi
  138. (1992). Sociological Perspectives of Modern Accountancy, doi
  139. (1997). Spatial Formations, doi
  140. (1982). Statim invenire: Schools, Preachers and New Attitudes to the Page'. In
  141. (1975). Survey of the British Accountancy Profession, Advisory Board of Accountancy Education.
  142. (1985). Symbolic and substantive legitimation in professional practice', doi
  143. (1997). Technologies of the Self'. In doi
  144. (1966). The American Accounting Association - doi
  145. (1995). The application of competences to an accounting qualification. doi
  146. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge, trans.
  147. (1993). The Australian Institute of Incorporated Accountants (1892-1938)', Accounting, doi
  148. (1997). The AUTA/BAA 1971-1996: Living in interesting times', doi
  149. (1987). The Conceptual Framework: Not Definitions, but Professional Values',
  150. (1984). The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. doi
  151. (1976). The Culture of Professionalism: doi
  152. (1992). The decline of operational expertise in the knowledge-base of management accounting: An examination of some post-war trends in the qualifying requirements of the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants', doi
  153. (1991). The defence of professional monopoly: Scottish chartered accountants and 'satellites in the accountancy firmament' 1854-1914', Accounting, doi
  154. (1979). The development of accounting in the international context: past concerns and emergent issues'.
  155. (1995). The development of standards of competence in accounting', doi
  156. (1992). The development of the 'Big Eight' accounting firms in the United States,
  157. (1986). The development of the accountancy profession in Britain in the early twentieth century', Monograph 5, San Antonio, Texas, The Academy of Accounting Historians.
  158. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory, doi
  159. (1998). The dynamics of "closure" amidst the construction of market, profession, empire and nationhood: An historical analysis of an Australian accounting association, 1886-1903', Accounting, doi
  160. (1997). The early years of the Association of University Teachers of Accounting: 1947-1959', doi
  161. (1997). The education of accountants in the US: Reason and its limits at the turn of the century', doi
  162. (1965). The emergence of the American university. doi
  163. (1984). The end of the practical man. Entrepreneurship and higher education in Germany, doi
  164. (1993). The evolution of education policy within the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland'. doi
  165. (1976). The evolution ofaccounting in Canada,
  166. (1979). The Examination, Disciplinary Power and Rational Schooling', History ofEducation, doi
  167. (1982). The final examinations of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales,
  168. (1988). The Genesis of Accountability: The West Point Connections', doi
  169. (1995). The genesis of professional organization in Scotland: a contextual analYSis', doi
  170. (1979). The German academic community'. In doi
  171. (1997). The Henneneutic of the Subject'.
  172. (1985). The history of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, doi
  173. (1966). The history oftheICAEW]870-1965,
  174. (1994). The ideology of professional regulation and the markets for accounting labour: three episodes in the recent history of the UK accountancy profession', doi
  175. (1994). The influence of Michel Foucault on Accounting Research', doi
  176. (1999). The Institute of Accounts: a community of the competent', doi
  177. (1979). The intellectuals on the road to class power, doi
  178. (1997). The internationalization of British professional accounting: the role of the examination exporting bodies', doi
  179. (1990). The King is Dead, Long Live the King! ' doi
  180. (1988). The Legal Profession in England and Wales, doi
  181. (1975). The medieval universities: their development and organization, doi
  182. (1970). The nature of a profession'.
  183. (1991). The new accounting history: an introduction', doi
  184. (1998). The New Accounting Knowledge and the New Accounting Professional: a European realignmentT Paper presented at EAA Annual Congress,
  185. (1994). The newproduction oftnowledge,
  186. (1970). The Order of Discourse'. In
  187. (1969). The origins of modern English society 1780-1880, doi
  188. (1974). The politics of educational reform 1920-1940,
  189. (1998). The Priesthood of Industry: the rise of the professional accountant in British management, doi
  190. (1996). The professionalisation of accounting: A review of recent historical rescarch and its implications', doi
  191. (1995). The professionalization of accountancy: a history of protecting the public interest in a self-interested way', doi
  192. (1964). The Professionalization of EveryoneT, doi
  193. (1964). The Qualifying Associations. A study in professionalization. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  194. (1961). The Report on Education and Training: Failure of a Mission', Accountancy,
  195. (1978). The Research Act: a theoretical introduction to sociological methods, 2 nd ed., doi
  196. (1968). The revolt of the dons, doi
  197. (1990). The revolution in accounting education',
  198. (1977). The rise of professionalism: A sociological analysis, doi
  199. (1991). The role of oral history in accounting', doi
  200. (1982). The School of Paris and the School of Chartres'.
  201. (1988). The Society of Accountants in Edinburgh 1854 - 1914: A Study of Recruitment to a New Profession ,
  202. (1986). The Sociology of the Professions, doi
  203. (1988). The sociology of the professions: dead or aliveT doi
  204. (1982). The state and the professions: Peculiarities of the British'.
  205. (1988). The system of professions,
  206. (1983). The Theory of Professions: State of the Art'. In
  207. (1979). The UK Accounting Profession - the move towards monopoly power', The Accountants Magazine,
  208. (1985). The Use ofPleasure: The History ofSexuality,
  209. (1978). The Voice of the Past: Oral History, doi
  210. (1995). Things of Boundaries',
  211. (1994). Toward a history of accounting histories: perspectives from the Italian tradition', doi
  212. (1986). Towards a critical understanding of accounting: the case of cost accounting doi
  213. (1994). Towards a finer understanding of professionalization projects: The perils of an open and shut case', Paper presented at the Fourth Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Accounting Conference,
  214. (1988). Trainingfor the Profession: A Comparative Study,
  215. (1995). Turf battles' or 'class struggles': the intemationalisation of the market for expertise in the 'professional society", doi
  216. (1988). Understanding accounting in its social and historical context: The case of cost accounting in
  217. (1990). Understanding the Development of the Accountancy Profession in the UK.
  218. (1999). Using Foucault's Methods, doi
  219. (1995). Using Hierarchical Categories in Qualitative Data Analysis'.
  220. (1993). We have never been modern, doi
  221. (1997). What is Critical Accounting Theory? Part I: The Place of Habermas and Foucault', Paper presented at the BAA Annual Conference,
  222. (1989). What's in a nameT Accountancy,
  223. (1977). Wtither the private sectorT Entry to Accountancy
  224. (1981). Yhe History of Sexuality, Volume One, An Introduction,
  225. (1949). Yhe making of scientific management,
  226. (1974). Yhe Order of Things: an archaeology of the human sciences,
  227. (1986). Yhe Postmodern Condition,
  228. (1980). Yhe State ofKnowledge about the English Legal System,
  229. (1972). Yhe universities and British industry 1850-1970, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.