Location of Repository

Primary science in Malaysia: the implementation of a new curriculum

By Hashimah Mohd. Yunus

Abstract

This thesis investigates the implementation of the science curriculum in Malaysian primary schools. The study is concerned primarily with teachers' pedagogical content knowledge as a crucial determinant of teaching performance in implementing the new curriculum.\ud \ud The research involved the administration of a questionnaire to seven states in Malaysia to seek information regarding the implementation of the primary science curriculum. The main body of research data consists of case studies of 14 teachers. Teachers' pedagogical content knowledge and its influence of the implementation of the primary science curriculum were analysed on the basis of interviews and classroom observations.\ud \ud The lack of science pedagogical content knowledge is indeed a problem for teachers in implementing the curriculum. That knowledge is limited and constrained by other contributing factors - science instructional needs, especially the constructivist view of science teaching; knowledge of the ways in which children learn science; and the lack of resources and support. Teachers' belief in the subject and its teaching also affect the implementation. In the light of these constraints, it would be more appropriate to identify the necessary science pedagogical content knowledge, within the primary science curriculum, that teachers need to acquire in order to implement the curriculum as the developers intended.\ud \ud The key question, in the Malaysian primary school context, is how science pedagogical content knowledge is to be generated and disseminated. In-service teacher education is essential if there is to be an impact in the shorter term. Another question is the kind of initial training that will be fruitful and effective and worth investing in. Conceptual understanding and science pedagogical knowledge and skills are two promising areas of teachers' understanding of the curriculum that could be developed when planning in-service provision for Malaysian primary science education. An explicit examination to teachers' beliefs about science and the teaching and learning of science is also required in pre-service and in-service courses

Topics: LB1501
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3089

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. 11c Curriculum from 5 to 16: Curriculum Matters 2- incorpora6n& responses (2'd Ed),
  2. (1987). 150 different ways of knowing: representation of knowledge in teaching',
  3. (1993). A doi
  4. (1990). A (199 1) Workloads. Achievement and Stress: Two Folloy=up Studies of Teachers' Time in KV Stage I.., Policy Analysis Unit,
  5. (1996). A case study of a teacher's progress towards using a constructivisit view of learning to inform teaching in primary science', doi
  6. (1986). A constructivist approach t6 curriculum development in science', doi
  7. (1987). A Constructivist View of Learning and Teaching
  8. (1990). A critical look at practical work in school science",
  9. (1996). A look at primary science',
  10. (1980). A method for the investigation of conceptunderstanding in sdence'.
  11. (1980). A Practical Guide to Behavioural Research: Tool and Technigge Oxford,
  12. (1984). A qualitative approach to the study of a teacher's belief, doi
  13. (1995). A Rgport of the Inspection of the Implementwon of Science Subject
  14. (1988). A study of exemplary primary science teachers', doi
  15. (1988). A study of the efficacy of a centre-periphery curriculum implementation strategy', doi
  16. (1993). Achieving the industrial tzrgets of vision 2020: The science and technology perspective,
  17. (1989). All About the National Curricul
  18. (1988). An introduction to curriculum criticism', in
  19. (1975). An Introduction to Lifelong Learnin London,
  20. (1990). An investigation of some English primary school teachers' understanding of the concepts force and gravity', doi
  21. (1997). Analysis and description of students' learning during science classes using a constructivist based model', doi
  22. (1983). Analysis of the current problems with school science in the United States of America', doi
  23. (1999). Assessing science for children with learning difficulties', doi
  24. (1997). Assessment and recording as a constructive process,, in
  25. (1979). Attitude changes of Primary teachers according to the curriculum studied during workshop participation and their role as model science teachers', doi
  26. (1979). Cabinet Committee Rgport on thg Review of thq ! M_ Kuala Lumpur, Dewan Bahasa dan imiementation of the National Educational Pph Pustaka.
  27. (1994). Case Studies',
  28. (1988). Case study methods, in
  29. (1997). Case study methods', in Keeves,
  30. (1988). Case Study Research in Education: A Qualitative ARproach. London, jossey-Base Publishers.
  31. (1978). Case Stuk. RedigAde 26: Guides
  32. Centre (CDC) (1993a) Strategies for Integrgfipg Science Elements
  33. Centre (CDC) (1994d) Module 4- Scientific Attitude and Noble Values. Ministry of Education,
  34. (1992). Change and the Curricul London,
  35. (1994). Change at the chalk face: a case study of the factors affecting the adoption of curriculum innovation', doi
  36. (1993). Change Forces: Probing the Doths of Educational Refo LondonThe
  37. (1990). Children's Concgpts and the Primaa Curricul London,
  38. (1985). Children's Ideas in Sciencc. Milton Keyties,
  39. (1987). Children's j&gmLng in Science Project: Teaching Strategies for Develgping, Understanding in
  40. (1998). Children's learning of science concepts',
  41. (1982). Children's science and its consequences for teaching, '
  42. (1988). Classroom observation techniques', in Keeves,
  43. (1989). Constructive criticism,
  44. (1994). Constructivism: Some History', in Fensharr4
  45. (1995). Content knowledge transformation: An examination of the relationship between content knowledge and curricular', doi
  46. (1993). Coping and control: science teaching strategies in Botswana', doi
  47. (1975). Creative Teaching: An Approach to the Achievement of Educational Obiective.
  48. (1997). Creativity in L? dpM Scienc Buckingham,
  49. (1989). Curricular decision maldn in the diffiision of an educational innovation in Malaysia, unpublished Ph.
  50. (1990). Curriculum -A Comprehensive Introducti USA, Harper Collins publishers.
  51. (1991). Curriculum Development in East Asi London,
  52. (1985). Curriculum fidelity and the implementation tasks employed by teachers: a research study', doi
  53. (1987). Curriculum Innovation in Malaysia: The Case of KBSR, unpublished Ph.
  54. (1994). Curriculum Reform at Key Stage 1: Teacher Commitnent and Poligy Fail London,
  55. (1990). Curriculurn innovation: Case studies of man and environment in the Malaysian Primary School Curriculum, unpublished D.
  56. (1997). Developing Science in the Primary Classroom (2" Ed).
  57. (1998). Developing science teachers' pedagogical content knowledge', doi
  58. (1992). Developments in primary science: A New Zealand perspective', doi
  59. (1991). Educating the InguiringMind: The Challenge for School ScienceLondon, Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  60. Education (DfE) (1992)Me IMIernentation of thg Mcular Rgquircmenlrk of the ERA. An overview by IM on the First Year. 1990-1991
  61. (1998). Education and Employment (DfEE) doi
  62. (1996). Education and Employment Committee (sixth report). The Professional Status, Recruitment and Training of Teachers, London, The Stationery office.
  63. (1988). Educational Research. MethodolosL and Measurement: An International Handbo O? cford,
  64. (1994). Entering the field of qualitative research',
  65. (1995). Falling Rolls doi
  66. (1973). For a lifelong educationý, in
  67. (1987). Four patterns of teacher content decision-making', doi
  68. (1993). gClassroom strategies',
  69. (1990). Grouping children for cffective learning',
  70. (1998). Helping teachers to develop competence criteria for evaluating their professional development' doi
  71. (1994). How children learn ..... and fail' doi
  72. (1993). Human resource development: The education and training aspece. in sarji,
  73. (1985). Ibe Curriculum from 5 to 16: Curriculum Matters 2,
  74. (1984). Ihe effect of knowledge on primary science enquiry teaching',
  75. (1994). Ile accommodation of science pedagogical knowledge: the application of conceptual change constructs to teacher education', doi
  76. (1998). Ile classroom practice of pre-service teachers and their conceptions of teaching and learning science, doi
  77. (1986). Implementing a New Curriculum for Primary Schools: A case study from Malaysia, unpublished Ph.
  78. (1990). Implementing conceptual change teaching in primmy science', doi
  79. (1992). Improving primary school teachers' understanding of science conceptstheory into practice', doi
  80. (1988). In-Service Courses and Teachers' Professionality: The implementation of
  81. (1993). Industrial targets of vision 2020: The science and technology perspective',
  82. (1998). Innovations in the Spanish science curriculum: a view of systematic reform', doi
  83. (1998). Inquiry- leaming from the past'! hith an eye on the future',
  84. (1997). Inquirýbased science: strategies and techniques for encouraging inquiry in the classroom,
  85. (1990). INSET for Primary Science in the National Curriculum in England and Wales: are the real needs of teachers perceived? doi
  86. (1988). into practice II: aconstructivict approach to curriculum ý development',
  87. (1989). investigation of some primary teachers, understanding of changes in materials', doi
  88. (1993). Jadi
  89. (1994). Knowing and teaching science: the constructivist paradox', doi
  90. (1987). Knowledge and teaching: foundation of the new reform', doi
  91. (1982). Knowledge and the curriculum: teachers' thinking', doi
  92. (1993). Knowledge býses and teaching performance',
  93. (1992). KV Concepts for Understanding the Curricul _ London,
  94. (1999). KWLQ: inquiry and literacy learning in science',
  95. (1993). Laboratory practice in further and higher education: developments in the design of practical work,
  96. (1993). Leaming content through process: practical sftWegies for science teachers in developing countries',
  97. (2000). Learning concepts', in
  98. (1989). Learning processes in science: a classroom perspective' in
  99. (1999). Less-able children's learning in science',
  100. (1993). Malg3Mi: an's Vision 2020: Understanding the Concgpt, Implication and ghdlengg& Petaling Jaya,
  101. (1982). Ministry of Education Malaysia
  102. (1996). Module 12 - Teaching and Legjiýng Stmtcgy LI M Ministry of Education,
  103. (1983). New primary School Curriculum- A General Quid Book. Kuala Lumpur, Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
  104. (1999). Pasing science InSet in developing countries: reflections on the experience of the primary science programme in South Afria, doi
  105. pects of Edmn ucation: The Teaching aad
  106. (1985). Philosophy of science, science and science education", doi
  107. (1997). PMpectives: Kgy Con= for Understanding the Curriculuin 1. London,
  108. (1988). Practical work and science education', doi
  109. (1998). Practical work in science: time for re-appraisal', in
  110. (1988). Primary school teacher understanding of science concepts', doi
  111. (1997). Primary science teachers understanding of concepts of science: impact on confidence and teaching', doi
  112. (1989). Primary teachers and the National Curriculum', ResearchPglMinEducatio VoL4,
  113. (1978). Primn Education in England: A Survey by HM-L London,
  114. (1990). Primn SPACE Project Research Report Growth,,
  115. (1994). Primply Matters: A Discussion on Teaching and Learning in Primary school,
  116. (1980). Professiondisation and deprofessionalisation in education',
  117. (1998). Progression and differentiation in science: some general strategies', in
  118. (1998). Progression and diffm-entiation in s (cence: some specific strategies', in
  119. (1997). Progression in learning in science'.
  120. (1997). Promoting student inquiry', '-l'be-Science Teach
  121. (1994). Questionnaire Design: A Practical Introductio Ulster,
  122. (1988). Questionnaire', in Keeves
  123. (1993). Real World Research: A Resource for Social Scientist and --figona Oxford, Blackwel _Researcher, s
  124. (1958). Report of the Education Committee 1956, Kuala Lumpur,
  125. (1993). Research and development of science in the primary school', in doi
  126. (1992). Research for Education: An Introduction to Theoly and Methods London, ýIlyn and Bacon.
  127. (1989). Research in Education: _A ConggptuaUntroduction (2'd Ed) London, Scottý Foresman and Company.
  128. (1993). Research in science education in the USA', doi
  129. (1992). Research into English primary school teachers' understanding of the concept energy', doi
  130. (1994). Research Methods in Education (0 doi
  131. (1977). Research on curriculum and instruction implementation', doi
  132. (1971). Rgport on the Impleragqgfion of th-e: -Recommendations of the Education Review Committee
  133. (1998). Rhetoric and reality- what practical work in science education is really for', in Wellington, J Practical work in school science: which wpy now ? doi
  134. (2000). Science 3-13 'Me Past the h[e_sent and Possibl Futures London, Routledge Falmer ý Watson, K
  135. (1998). Science as conversation; come and see my air pump', in
  136. (1993). Science education in English and Welsh primary schools: a systems study', doi
  137. (1993). Science for all pupils: science and special needs',
  138. (1994). Science in the primary school: the problem of teachers' curricular experfise', doi
  139. (1983). Science Rogrt for Teachcr-s-I: Science at Age II LondonHMSO.
  140. (1992). Science teaching and teacher's knowledge prospect for, refimn of primary classrooms',
  141. (1995). Science: A Review of InVection Findings.
  142. (1993). Science: Kgy Stages 1.2.3 and 4 Fourth Year 1992-93
  143. (1993). Scientific investigation, in Sherington,
  144. (1988). Secondm School Syllabus - Scienge. Kuala Lumpur, Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
  145. (1983). Six teachers' beliefs and attitudes and their curricular time allocation' doi
  146. (1997). Social Research: Issum Method and REgM (2 ad Ed), Buckingham, open University Press. I., II11,1 .ý-ýý: :I, --, ý:
  147. Statistics for the United Kingdom (1992/1993), Cheltenham, Higher, Education Statistic Agency Limited (HESA).
  148. (1999). Stimulating constructivist teaching styles through use of an observation rubric', doi
  149. (1995). Student teachers' confidence to teach science: is more science knowledge necessary to improve self-confidence? ', doi
  150. (1986). Students thinking and the learning of science: a constructivist view',
  151. (1995). Students' conception and constructivict teaching WMy approach', in Fraser,
  152. (1996). Students' Orientation Towards Science and Mathematics: Mly are Enrolments Falling?
  153. (1964). TaxonoMy of Educational Objectives: The Classification of Edacational Goals. doi
  154. (1956). TaxonoMy of Educational Objectives: The Classification of Educational Goals. Handbook I Cognitive Domain, doi
  155. (1997). Teach I er collabýiafion across and w. ithin schools: supporting individual change in primary science teaching',
  156. (1996). Teacher beliefs and intentions regarding the implementation of science education reform strands', doi
  157. (1980). Teacher constructs and curriculum change', doi
  158. (1999). Teacher education: interface between practices and policies, The Malaysian experience 1979-1997', Teaching and Teacher Education. doi
  159. (1997). Teacher's continuing professional development: framing a model of outcomes", doi
  160. (1997). Teachers belief and instructional strategies in science: pushing analysis finther', doi
  161. (1993). Teachers' _Handbool London, Collins Educational.
  162. (1983). teachers' "practical knowledge": report of a case study', Curriculu jpqgýy,
  163. (1992). Teachers' beliefs and educational mess: cleaning up a messy construct', doi
  164. (1998). Teachers' perspectives on classroom practice in Botswana: implications for pedagogical change', doi
  165. (1979). Teachers' thinking',
  166. (1994). Teachers' thought about changing to constructivist teaching and learning approaches within junior secondary science classroom', doi
  167. (1986). Teachers'th6ught processes',
  168. (1993). Teaching and Learning Primga Science (2"d Ed),
  169. (1998). Teaching and Learning Science: Towards a Personalised AI Wroac Buckingham,
  170. (1990). Teaching Children to Cheltenham,
  171. (1994). Teaching science in primary school: what kno, %Aedge do teachers needT,
  172. (2000). Teaching. Learning and Assessing Science 5-12 (I'd Ed),
  173. (1999). The Art of Constructivist Teaching in the Primgy School: A Guide Students and Teach London,
  174. (1992). The beginning science teacher classroom narratives of convictions and constraints', doi
  175. (1992). The change of teachers' conception: A strategy for in-service science teachers education',
  176. (1989). The construction of subject matter knowledge in primary science teaching', doi
  177. (1986). The cultures of teaching',
  178. (1992). The Implementation of the Curricular R2quirem6nts Of the Education Reform Act: Science-Kqy Stage 1. and 3: ARgport-byHMIngpector. Second Year 1990-1991,
  179. (1998). The last ten years; the next ten years', doi
  180. (1991). The New Meaning of Educational Change.
  181. (1983). The Pupil As Scientist? 'Milton Keynes, ý'ffie Open
  182. (1998). The purpose of science education',
  183. (1987). The role of beliefs in the practice of teaching', doi
  184. (1991). The Science of Problem Solving: A Practical Guide for Science Teachers London,
  185. (1962). The teaching of science as enquiry' in The Teaching of Science,
  186. (1996). The Teaching of Science in Primarv Schools (I'd Ed),
  187. (1992). The Teaching of Science: doi
  188. (1986). Those who understand: knowledge growth in teaching', doi
  189. (1998). Towards critical constructivist teaching', doi
  190. (1993). Tross-cunicular elements: Science and Health Education',
  191. (1991). Tte Education (National CurrigWumi) (Assessment -Arrangements For Ensdisk Mathematics and Science) Order
  192. (1988). Videotape recording in educational research',
  193. (1993). Views and thoughts of Dr. Mahathir Mohamad, the Prime Minister of MalaysW, in SmjL A (Ed) MallUsian Vision 2020: Understanding the CoRmts. implication and Challenges Malaysia, Pelanduk Publication,
  194. (1994). What Children Bring to Light: A Constructivist Per%&ctive on Children's LomLng in Science. London,
  195. (1980). World Year Book of EjWjaon

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.