Location of Repository

Looking at the management sciences through the lens of autopoietic theory

By John Brocklesby

Abstract

The broad aim of this research has been to employ the various propositions of Humberto Maturana, as derived from his and Francisco Varela's central concept 'Autopoiesis', as a lens or frame through which to critically reflect on both Management Science and major traditions within it. Such reflection has been carried out with both a 'critical' and a 'developmental eye'. From a critical standpoint the research identifies gaps in existing understandings, and suggests ways in which these may be plugged. Used in this mode, the research shows that Autopoietic Theory is a body of knowledge that management scientists, especially inexperienced ones, can turn to as a means of enriching and/or enhancing their practice in distinctive ways, or allowing them to better prepare for it.\ud \ud Used from a developmental standpoint, the research shows how Maturana's epistemological propositions invoke a particular kind of critically reflective Management Science practice, and, how Autopoietic Theory more generally, can stretch the limits of existing practice.\ud \ud In developing these lines of argumentation the main contribution of the work is to remind members of the various Management Science communities that theirs is an activity that is carried out by real human beings first and by impartial scientists second; moreover, that Management Science is an activity that takes place in human, social and organisational contexts. Acknowledgement of this has far reaching ramifications. In that regard, the main contribution of the research can be taken to be an argument in favour of repositioning 'humanity', in all its various facets, much more centrally within the discipline than has been the case hitherto

Topics: HD28
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3094

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1981). 2nd edn.
  2. (1989). A Behavioural Science Perspective on Operation Research Practice. Operational Research and the Social Sciences.
  3. (1968). A Biological Theory of Relativistic Color Coding in the Primate Retina. "
  4. (1988). A Constructivist Position for Family Therapy. "
  5. (1997). A Critical Evaluation of Maturana's Constructivist Family Therapy. "
  6. (1989). A Cybernetic Method to Study Organizations. The VSM : Interpretations &
  7. (1981). A Kuhnian crisis in Management Science? "
  8. (1982). A Materialist Analysis of Operational Research. "
  9. (1982). A Note on the Use of the Term 'Weltanschauung' (W) in Checkland's "Systems Thinking, Systems Practice". "
  10. (1993). After OR: An Agenda for Postmodernism and Poststructuralism in OR. "
  11. (1989). After Truth: Post-Modernism and the Rhetoric of Science. Dismantling Truth: Reality in the Post-Modern
  12. (1993). Against Method.
  13. (2000). Agricultural Extension and Rural Development : Breaking out of Traditions. Cambridge,
  14. (1994). An Epistemological View of Decision Aid Technology with Emphasis on Expert Systems. Ethics in
  15. (1995). An Exploration of the Participative Use of Soft Systems Methodology. Faculty of Arts.
  16. (1985). An Interview with Humberto Maturana. "
  17. (1960). Anatomy and Physiology of Vision in the Frog. "
  18. (1980). Applied Management Science: A Quick and Dirty Approach.
  19. (1997). Applying Autopoiesis to the Facilitation of Organisational Change. Australian and New Zealand Systems Conference,
  20. (1978). Articulate Intervention: the Interface of Science, Mathematics and Administration. London, Taylor and Francis.
  21. (1980). Autopoiesis and Cognition: The Realisation of the Living.
  22. (1981). Autopoiesis. Autopoiesis: a Theory of Living Organization.
  23. (1997). Becoming Multimethodology Literate: An Assessment of the Cognitive Difficulties of Working Across Paradigms. Multimethodoloey: Tthe Theory and
  24. (1927). Being and Time.
  25. (1998). Beyond Internal OR Groups. "
  26. (1983). Beyond Method - Strategies for Social Research. Beverly Hills,
  27. (1993). Biolose of the Aesthetic Experience. Zeichen(theorie) und Praxis,
  28. (1998). Biosphere, Homosphere, and Robosphere: What has that to do with Business? Society for Organizational Learning.
  29. (1972). Brain of the Firm.
  30. (1995). Brain, Language and the Origin of Human Mental Functions. "
  31. (1993). Breaking the Paradigm Mentality. "
  32. (1985). Breakup of the Bell System: A Case Study in Cultural Transformation.
  33. (1981). Bringing Mind Back In.
  34. (1996). Burying the Twentieth Century - Laving Down a Path of Whole System Change. Australian Systems Conference,
  35. (1982). Causal Schemata: Review and Criticism of Research on a Popular Construct. "
  36. (1992). Cognition and Autopoiesis: A Brief Reflection on the Consequences of their Understanding. State, Law, and Economy as Autopoietic Systems: Regulation and Autonomy in a New
  37. (1994). Cognitive Mapping and Problem Structuring for System Dynamics Model Building. "
  38. (1964). Collected Papers 2: Studies in Social Theory. The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff.
  39. (1972). Commentary on ORSA Guidelines. "
  40. (1988). Constructions of Self-Organising Systems. "
  41. (1988). Constructivism, Autopoiesis and Problem Determined Systems. "
  42. (1989). Creative Organization Theory.
  43. (1991). Creative Problem Solving.
  44. (1982). Critical Heuristics of Social Planning: A New Approach to Practical Philosophy.
  45. (1989). Critical Systems and the Problem of Pluralism. "
  46. (1990). Critical Systems Thinking and Methodological Pluralism.
  47. (1994). Critical Systems Thinking: Beyond the Fragments. "
  48. (1997). Critiquing Multi methodology as Metamethodology: Working Towards Critical Pluralism.
  49. (1959). Cybernetics and Management.
  50. (1984). Cybernetics: a New Management Tool. Tunbridge Wells,
  51. (1966). Decision and Control.
  52. (1981). Describing the Logic of the Living: The Adequacy and Limitations of the Idea Autopoiesis. Autopoiesis: A Theory of the Living Organization.
  53. (1952). Design for a Brain. London, Chapman and Hall.
  54. (1996). Designing a Viable Organization Structure. "
  55. (1985). Diagnosing the System for Organization.
  56. (1990). Diagnosis and Implementation: How a Large Cooperative Employed a Series of Proposals for Restructuring Based upon the VSM. "
  57. (1989). Dismantling Truth: Reality in the Post-Modern World. London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
  58. (1996). Embodying Information Systems.
  59. (1994). Ethical Concerns and Ethical Answers. Ethics in
  60. (1989). Ethics: A Lost Dimension in Soft Systems Methodology. "
  61. (1989). Evaluating the Managerial Significance of the VSM.
  62. (1986). Executive Priorities for Effective Communication in an Information Age. "
  63. (1982). Family Therapy and the Epistemology of Humberto Maturana. " Family Therapy NetWorker (July-August):
  64. (1996). Farewell to Objectivity. "
  65. (1987). Farewell to Reason.
  66. (1994). Five Sketches of Postmodernism: Implications for Systems Thinking and Operational Research. "
  67. (1988). Framework of Inquiry: OR Practice Across the Hard-Soft Divide. "
  68. (1987). From Machines to People and Organisations.
  69. (1987). From Management Science to Workers' Science. New Directions in
  70. (1988). From Problem-Structuring to Implementation. "
  71. (1992). Guest Editorial - Developments in Critical Systems Thinking. "
  72. (1997). Guidelines for a Constructivist Approach: Steps Toward the Application of Ideas from Family Therapy for Use in Organisations. "
  73. (1971). Guidelines for the Practice of OR. "
  74. (1979). Heart of Enterprise,
  75. (1994). How Do the Construction and/or Interpretation of Models Affect our Decisions? Ethics in
  76. (1993). I as in Academy: Learning to be Systemic (The Von
  77. (1997). In What Sense do Systems Exist? Systems for Sustainability: People, Organisations, and Environments.
  78. (1991). Information in Action - Soft Systems Methodology.
  79. (1983). Intentionality: An Essay on the Philosophy of Mind. Cambridge,
  80. (1989). Introduction: Old and New Paradigms of Analysis. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World.
  81. (1989). Introduction. Dismantling Truth: Reality in the Post-Modern
  82. (1994). Introduction. Ethics in Modeling.
  83. (1993). Justification and Application.
  84. (1998). Knowing in Firms: Understanding, Managing and Measuring Knowledge.
  85. (1998). Knowledge in Organizations.
  86. (2001). Knowledge management and the framing of information: a contribution to OR/MS practice and pegagogy. "
  87. (1990). Language, Structure, and Change - Frameworks of Meaning in Psychotherapy.
  88. (1994). Let the Jury Decide: Assessing the Cultural Feasibility of Total Systems Intervention. "
  89. (1990). Liberating Systems Theory: Towards Critical Systems Thinking. "
  90. (1980). Man and Society. Autopoiesis. Communication. and Society: The Theory of Autopoietic Systems in the Social Sciences.
  91. (1996). Managing Knowledge: Perspectives on Cooperation and Competition.
  92. (1994). Managing, Crafting and Researching: Words, Skill and Imagination in Shaping Management Research. "
  93. (1990). Matrix Management: Not a Structure, a Frame of Mind. " Harvard Business Review (July-August):
  94. (1980). Metaphors We Live By.
  95. (1993). Methodological Complementarism or Separate Paradigm Development -Examining the Options for Enhanced Operational Research. "
  96. (1990). Mixing Methods: Combining Conflict Analysis, SODA, and Strategic Choice. Tackling Strategic Problems: The Role of Group Decision
  97. (1990). Mixing Methods: Introduction. Tackling Strategic Problems.
  98. (1994). Models in the Public Sector: Success, Failure and Ethical Behavior. Ethics in
  99. (1994). Morality and Models. Ethics in
  100. (1997). Multimethodology: Towards A Framework For Mixing Methodologies. " Omega -
  101. (1990). Multiparadigm Perspectives on Theory Building. "
  102. (1992). My Two Cents on how OR should Develop. "
  103. (1989). North Labrador and the Torngat Co-op: An Exploration of Checkland's Soft Systems Methodology Through its Application to Fisheries Development,
  104. (1994). On Model Building. Ethics in
  105. (1996). On the Nature of OR - Entering the Fray. "
  106. (1992). On the Reality of Systems. "
  107. (1988). Ontology of Observing: The Biological Foundations of Self Consciousness and the Physical Domain of Existence,
  108. (1991). Operational Research and Systems.
  109. (1998). OR as Technology Revisited. "
  110. (1989). OR as Technology: Some Issues and Implications. "
  111. (1982). Organisational Learning -a Research Perspective.
  112. (1996). Organisational Transformation and Learning: A Cybernetic Approach to Management.
  113. (1992). Organization Studies and Scientific Authority. Rethinking
  114. (1997). Organization Theory and Systems Thinking: The Benefits of Partnership. "
  115. (1995). Organizational Epistemology.
  116. (1993). Paradigm Gridlock: A Reply. "
  117. (1993). Paradigms and Barriers - How Habits of Mind Govern Scientific Beliefs.
  118. (1980). Paradigms, Metaphors, and Puzzle Solving in Organization Theory. "
  119. (1988). Paradox and Transformation : Toward a Theory of Change in Organisation and Management.
  120. (1983). Perceptions of Organisational Effectiveness over Organisational Life Cycles. "
  121. (1961). Phenomenology of Perception.
  122. (1953). Philosophical Investigations.
  123. (1997). Pluralism in Systems Thinking and Practice. Multimethodoloev: the Theoryand Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies.
  124. (1994). Postmodernism - Why Bother? "
  125. (1980). Preface to: Autopoiesis: the Organization of the Living. Autopoiesis and Cognition -
  126. (1987). Present Positions and Future Proposals in Management Science. "
  127. (1989). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World.
  128. (1991). Re-inventing the Already Punctured Wheel: reflections on a Seminar with Humberto Maturana. "
  129. (1988). Reality: The Search for Objectivity or the Quest for a Compelling Argument. "
  130. (1992). Recent Developments in Critical Management Science. "
  131. (1989). Reclaiming Reality.
  132. (1996). Reflecting on SSM: The Dividing Line Between 'Real World' and 'Systems Thinking World'.
  133. (1991). Reframing Organisations - Artistry. Choice, and Leadership.
  134. (1991). Response to Jim Birch. "
  135. (1994). Responsible Policy Modeling. Ethics in
  136. (1979). Ressurrecting the Future of Operational Research. "
  137. (1990). Science and Daily Life: The Ontology of Scientific Explanations. Selforganization: Portrait of a Scientific Revolution.
  138. (1994). Seized by Agreement. Swamped by Understanding.
  139. (1995). Self-Producing ystems - Implications and Applications of Autopoiesis.
  140. (1991). Sensemaking and Sensegiving in Strategic Change Initiation. "
  141. (1994). Separating the Wheat From the Chaff: A Modernist Appropriation of the Postmodern. "
  142. (1997). Situated Learning Theory Versus Traditional Cognitive Learning: Why Management Education Should Not Ignore Management Learning. "
  143. (1985). Social Systems Theory and Practice: the Need for a Critical Approach. "
  144. (1993). Social Theory and Operational Research Practice. "
  145. (1996). Social Work: 'Profession Without Qualities'. Attempt to Link Social Work and Cybernetics. "
  146. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis,
  147. (1990). Soft Systems Methodology in Action.
  148. (1989). Soft Systems Methodology. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World.
  149. (1998). Some Observations on Practising Successful Operational Research. "
  150. (1985). Structure and Development of Social Schemata: Evidence from Positive and Negative Transfer Effects. "
  151. (1984). Subjectivism and Soft Systems Methodology -A Critique. "
  152. (1998). Success and Survival of OR Groups - Where to from Here? "
  153. (1995). Systemic Development: A Learning Approach to Change.
  154. (1994). Systems and Decision Making: A Management Science Approach.
  155. (1992). Systems and Scholarship: the Need to do Better. "
  156. (1991). Systems Methodology for the Management Sciences.
  157. (1995). Systems Theory and Management Thinking. Critical Issues in Systems Theory
  158. (2000). Systems Thinking and Modelling.
  159. (1981). Systems Thinking. Systems Practice,
  160. (1989). Teaching MBA's Transformational Thinking. Paradox and Transformation : Toward a Theory of Change in Organisation
  161. (1992). The Application of Autopoiesis in Systems Analysis: Are Social Systems also Autopoietic Systems? "
  162. (1965). The Art of Judgement. London,
  163. (1986). The Autopoiesis of Social Systems. Sociocvbernetic Paradoxes.
  164. (1988). The Bringing Forth of Pathology. "
  165. (1993). The Classical System - Organisational Insights into What Made Periclean Athens Great. "
  166. (2001). The Contribution of Critical Realism as an Underpinning Philosophy for OR/MS and Systems. "
  167. (1984). The Creative Circle: Sketches on the Natural History of Circularity. The Invented Reality.
  168. (1996). The Current Relevance of Merleau-Ponty's Phenomenology of Embodiment. Perspectives
  169. (1994). The Cybernetics of Conceptual Systems.
  170. (1985). The Cycle of Cultural Evolution in Organisations. Gaining Control of the Corporate Culture.
  171. (1994). The Death of the Expert. "
  172. (1999). The Deceptive Allure of Stage Models of Strategic Processes. "
  173. (1971). The Design of Inquiring Systems.
  174. (1991). The Embodied Mind - Cognitive Science and Human Experience.
  175. (1996). The End of Theory. "
  176. (2001). The Evolution of Competitive Capability: a Biological Perspective. The Evolution of Competitive Capability in New Zealand Firms.
  177. (1990). The Fifth Discipline.
  178. (1998). The Foundation, Development and Current Practice of OR: an Editorial Introduction and Overview. "
  179. (1992). The Four Cultures of the Academy.
  180. (1979). The Future of Operational Research is Past. "
  181. (1987). The Great Philosophers - An Introduction to Western Philosophy.
  182. (1994). The Greater Whole: Towards a
  183. (2001). The Hero Manager: Learning from New Zealand's Top Chief Executives.
  184. (1989). The Ideology of Representation and Role of the Agent. Dismantling Truth: Reality in the Post-Modern
  185. (1990). The Meaning of Alternative Paradigms for Practice. The Paradigm Dialog.
  186. (1991). The Missing Link: a Transformational View of Metaphors in Organisational Science. "
  187. (1982). The Nature of Soft Systems Thinking, the Work of Churchman, Ackoff, and Checkland. "
  188. (1995). The Nature of Time,
  189. (1970). The Neurophysiology of Cognition. Cognition: A Multiple
  190. (2000). The Next Frontier: Edgar Schein on Organisational Therapy. "
  191. (1996). The Observer Web: The Internet Nexus for Autopoiesis and Enaction,
  192. (1989). The Organization of a Fortress Factory. The VSM : Interpretations &
  193. (1998). The Origins and Diffusion of Operational Research in the UK. "
  194. (1990). The Philosophical Implications of Maturana's Cognitive Theories. "
  195. (1994). The Pragmatic Dimension - Paradigmatic and Pragmatic Aspects of Choosing a Qualitative or Quantitative Method. "
  196. (1992). The Problems of Social Autopoiesis. "
  197. (1955). The Psychology of Personal Constructs: A Theory of Personality.
  198. (1980). The Quest for the Intelligence of Intelligence. "
  199. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action.
  200. (1994). The Role of Models in Managerial Decision Making - Never Say the Model Says. Ethics in
  201. (1989). The Roots of Reality: Maturana and Vareläs 'The Tree of Knowledge'. "
  202. (1992). The Sacred and Profane in Critical Systems Thinking. "
  203. (1990). The Seduction of Systems: A Response to RL Flood's Editorial, "From Positivism to Critique". "
  204. (1987). The Self in the System: Expanding the Limits of Family Tpy.
  205. (1998). The Six Principles for Effective OR - Their Relevance in the 90's. "
  206. (1974). The Social Responsibility of Operational Research.
  207. (1970). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
  208. (1979). The Systems Approach and Its Enemies.
  209. (1967). The Tacit Dimension.
  210. (1984). The Theory of Communicative Action Vols. I and II.
  211. (1987). The Tree of Knowledge - The Biological Roots of Human Understanding.
  212. (2000). The Use of Multi methodology in Practice - Results of a Survey of Practitioners.
  213. (1992). The Use of Soft Systems Methodology in Practice. "
  214. (1986). The Use of the Term Weltanschauung in Soft Systems Methodology. "
  215. (1993). The Viplan Method: A Method to Study the Structure of an Organisation.
  216. (1989). The VSM Revisited. The VSM :
  217. (1989). The VSM: An On-Going Conversation. The VSM : Interpretations &
  218. (1996). The Web of Life -A New Synthesis of Mind and Matter.
  219. (1996). The Word and the World: A Critique of Representationalism in Management Research. "
  220. (1985). The World According to Humberto Maturana. "
  221. (1996). Tools for Thinking: Modelling in Management Science.
  222. (1994). Tools-R-Us. "
  223. (1989). Touching Truth. Dismantling Truth: Reality in the Post-Modern
  224. (1989). Towards a 'Custom and Practice'
  225. (1967). Towards a Sociology of Management.
  226. (1984). Towards a System of Systems Methodologies. "
  227. (1984). Towards a Theory of Social Systems: Self Organisation and Self-Maintenance, SelfReference and Syn-Reference.
  228. (1980). Towards an Appropriate Social Theory for Applied Systems Thinking: Critical Theory and Soft Systems Methodology. "
  229. (1997). Towards Critical Pluralism. Multi methodology: Towards the Theory and
  230. (1989). Transformational Thinking Seen From a Developmental Perspective. Paradox and Transformation: Toward a Theory of Change
  231. (1975). Truth and Method.
  232. (1996). TSI as Critique: the Critical Review Mode. Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research
  233. (1990). Uncertainty and Conflict: Combining Conflict Analysis and Strategic Choice. "
  234. (1994). Undercover Agency? - Ethics, Responsibility and the Practice of OR. "
  235. (1985). Understanding Bateson and Maturana: Toward a Biological Foundation for the Social Sciences. "
  236. (1987). Understanding Computers and Cognition.
  237. (1989). Using Cognitive Mapping for Strategic Options Development and Analysis (SODA). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World.
  238. (1995). Using Soft Systems Methodology to Identify Competence Requirements in Human Resource Management. "
  239. (1970). Value Systems and Social Process.
  240. (1994). Varieties of Systems Thinking: the Case of Soft Systems Methodology. "
  241. (1990). Viable Systems Diagnosis: Application with a Major Tourism Services Group. "
  242. (1986). Vickers' Concept of an Appreciative System: A Systemic Account. "
  243. (1993). Videotaped Seminar - Language and Cognition.
  244. (1996). Viewpoint: New Methods for Old. "
  245. (1983). What is it to See? "
  246. (1998). What We Learned Early in the US Airforce about Establishing and Maintaining OR Groups. "
  247. (1988). Works and Lives: the Anthropologist as Author. Cambridge,
  248. (1985). You Can't Get There From Here: What Will Make CultureChange Projects Fail.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.