Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Contested Norms in Inter-National Encounters: the 'Turbot War' as a Prelude to Fairer Fisheries Governance

By Antje Wiener


This article is about contested norms in inter-national encounters in global fisheries governance. It illustrates how norms work by reconstructing the trajectory of the 1995 ‘Turbot War’ as a series of inter-national encounters among diverse sets of Canadian and European stakeholders. By unpacking the contestations and identifying the norms at stake, it is suggested that what began as action at cross-purposes (i.e. each party referring to a different fundamental norm), ultimately holds the potential for fairer fisheries governance. This finding is shown by linking source and settlement of the dispute and identifying the shared concern for the balance between the right to fish and the responsibility for sustainable fisheries. The article develops a framework to elaborate on procedural details including especially the right for stakeholder access to regular contestation. It is organised in four sections: section 1 summarises the argument, section 2 presents the framework of critical norms research, section 3 reconstructs contestations of fisheries norms over the duration of the dispute, and section 4 elaborates on the dispute as a prelude to fairer fisheries governance. The latter is based on a novel conceptual focus on stakeholder access to contestation at the meso-layer of fisheries governance where organising principles are negotiated close to policy and political processes, respectively. The conclusion suggests for future research to pay more attention to the link between the ‘is’ and the ‘ought’ of norms in critical norms research in International Relations theories (IR). (auhtor's abstract

Topics: Internationale Beziehungen, Ökologie, International relations, Ecology, internationale Beziehungen, Entwicklungspolitik, Ökologie und Umwelt, International Relations, International Politics, Foreign Affairs, Development Policy, Ecology, Environment, Global Governance, internationales Regime, internationale Beziehungen, soziale Norm, Normgeltung, Normsetzung, Regulierung, Tierschutz, Fischerei, Umweltschutz, Umweltschutzauflage, Interessenkonflikt, Kanada, Europa, global governance, international regime, international relations, social norm, adherence to norms, setting of norms, regulation, animal protection, fishery, environmental protection, environmental directive, conflict of interest, Canada, Europe
Publisher: MISC
Year: 2016
OAI identifier:
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • (external link)
  • (external link)
  • Suggested articles

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.