Location of Repository

Migrant child labourers in Accra : a case study of the making of an adjustment generation

By Yaw Ofosu


This is a study of child labour as a social consequence of structural adjustment\ud policies (SAP), the economic ideology of the 1980s and 1990s in Ghana. SAP\ud certainly had its positive sides. However, the systematic process of\ud impoverishment through redundancies, the high costs of living and declining\ud state support in basic welfare worsened people's lived experiences. It is therefore\ud argued that political and economic changes, epitomised by the long years of SAP,\ud have burdened families, monetised social relations and increased the pressure on\ud children. But, while child labour at the family level is an old phenomenon in\ud Ghana, these problems have transformed some children into a new category of\ud labourers who migrate to the cities to take up some of the numerous informal\ud sector activities as a way of mitigating their poverty. Against this background,\ud three broad findings regarding their motivations, lived experiences and the\ud implications of their actions emerged in a programme of qualitative research.\ud Firstly, the pervasive poverty, dwindling opportunities and the influence of\ud returning migrants in the rural areas act as both the motivation and catalyst for\ud their migration. Secondly, even though Accra offers some relative hope, the\ud children operate in adverse and hazardous conditions that have certain\ud implications for their future. Thirdly, some children's agency are enhanced by\ud the roles they assume in their families and the ability to plan for the future,\ud especially in relation to education and training. Since economic growth and\ud development appears to be elusive, it is concluded that child migration will\ud continue. However, children's education should be repositioned at the centre of\ud social policy because as a preventive measure, any hour spent in the classroom is\ud time spent away from work

Topics: HC, HD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3646

Suggested articles



  1. (1999). (~993) Street and Working Children: Summary report, Innocenti Global Seminar,
  2. (1995). (ed.) Learning or Labouring? A Comp.ilatio~ of ke~
  3. (1999). (eds.) (l988b) Combating Child Labour, Geneva: International Labour Office doi
  4. (1993). (eds.) Researching Children's Perspectives,
  5. (2001). (SSA) is the most underdeveloped region of the world. It has the lowest gross national product (GNP) of $320.6 billion, among the developing regions of the world, but a population of 642 million (World Bank,
  6. (1995). 1 The on-going steel issue between Europe and the United States is the latest contradiction of the 84There have however been considerable difficulty and lack of consensus on the exact effects of SAP on the poor. Killick
  7. (1997). 134Table 4.2: Types ofwork Types ofwork Boys Girls Total Peddling
  8. (1998). 137Table 4.3: Daily earnings h !
  9. (1998). 140Table 4.5: Educational background 1. Some years ofeducation Male Female Total 1-3 vrs.
  10. (1998). 142reproducing that family (see also UNESCO, 1997a; Fallon and Tzannatos,
  11. (1998). 2 Somalia on the other hand has been struggling to exist as a nation-state since its civil war and has no legitimate government to ratify the Convention (Kilbourne,
  12. (2000). 2 This is the percentage ofchildren attending schools that corresponds with the official age group for that particular stage. 21990 and 1996, the gross secondary school enrolment ratios (GER)3 in Ghana were only 45% for males and 29% for females (UNICEF,
  13. (1957). 2.2 Ghana's political economy: Instability, change and structural adjustment programmes The Gold Coast gained its independence from Britain in
  14. (2001). 2.3.3 Health care and child labour For a country where the majority of people are categorised as poor by the international standard of $2 a day (WorId Bank,
  15. (1980). 31Table 1.1: Population and Labour Participation Rates of Africa (1980/99) Country Population Labour Force (Millions) Total (Millions) Children:l0-14yrs: %
  16. (1999). 4.3 Learning to crawl: Motivations for migration and child labour Over a two and half year period, the Cambridge Partnership for Organisational Transformation
  17. (2000). 44order to prolong the service period. Even after acquiring the skills, some children are prevented from leaving to start their own activities until hefty graduation fees are paid (Marguerat,
  18. (1996). 5 This in itselfprovided an initial insight into the unease some children felt about their lives on the streets. 1173.3.4 Observations The second qualitative method was observation of the work and social environment. As pointed out by Sapsford and Jupp
  19. (1988). 52Table 1.3: National and International Poverty Lines (% of Population) National poverty lines International poverty lines Economy Below Below Year Rural Urban National Year $lIday $2/day Algeria
  20. (1992). 6Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) in
  21. (2001). 7 Considering that 36% ofZimbabweans survive on less that $1 a day (World Bank,
  22. (1975). 78Table 2.1: The Extent of Economic Decline (1975-1983) Year Govt. revenue ratio to GDP Govt expenditure ratio to GDP Cocoa export ratio to GDP Net Rate of reserves inflation ratio to GDP (%)
  23. (1983). 81The massive devaluations of the Cedi began in
  24. (1993). 85United Nations' conference in Sudan in 1988, at the peak of adjustments, concluded that the various adjustment measures had inflicted considerable suffering and was 'rending the fabric of African society' (Adepoju,
  25. (1999). 91of the poor (Boafo-Arthur,
  26. (2000). 96a dismal 28% (lSSER,
  27. (1971). a consensus was reached and Ghana began another round of IMP stabilisation programme. The most significant was the devaluation of the Cedi by 48.60/£', which immediately led to higher prices for essential items (Boafo-Arthur,
  28. (1999). A different type of childhood emerges in urban middle class families. Childhood here is usually experienced in more nucleated households in which the significance of kinship and extended family in children's lives is less relevant (Assimeng,
  29. (1992). A major source of this instability is that SSA nations participate in globalisation as single commodity producers. For instance, 88% of SSA countries rely on one commodity for more than half of their total export revenues (Brown and Tiffen,
  30. (1999). A number of children also work in the streets as prostitutes. At least one million children, some as young as 5 years, are thought to be under commercial sexual exploitation, with nearly 50% of them being HlV positive (UNICEF,
  31. (1981). A Political Economy ofAfrica,
  32. (1983). A Researcher in Policy Arena: The Case of Child Labour', doi
  33. (1990). A Voice for Children in Statistical and Social Accounting: A Plea for Children's Right to be heard'.
  34. (1995). According to the World Bank doi
  35. (1991). Adolescence: Replication and Elaboration, Developmental Psychology, doi
  36. (1999). and Coulombe
  37. (2000). and Steve's construction of the present economy vis-a-vis their aspirations was quite pessimistic and reflected the Ministry of Finance's
  38. (1999). Another reason IS the interpretation of light work. The majority of African children undertake domestic, farm and other family work by age five or SIX (Cockburn,
  39. (1990). Another way to look at Ghanaian children's access to education is through the net primary school attendance ratios'. Between
  40. (1997). Approaches to Child Labour, February 1997, Canadian International Development Agency, http://www.acdi-cidagc.sa/cida
  41. (1993). Approaches to Social Enquiry, doi
  42. (1994). Are adjustment Policies in Africa Consistent with .L~ng-term' Development Needs?' In
  43. (1995). As a result, the demand for rice in Ghana has shifted from the local produce to imported ones thereby displacing rice farmers (Enale,
  44. (2001). Attacking Poverty: World Development Report 200012001, doi
  45. (1997). Bearing the Weight: Human Transport in a Developing Country, Legon: Centre for Social Policy Studies. doi
  46. (1996). Better Schools Less Child Work: Child Work and Education in Brasil,
  47. (1999). Capacity Building and maintenance in measuring and monitoring child labour, A concept paper for
  48. (2000). Case Study Research Methods,
  49. (1994). Case Study Research: Design andMethods, Thousand Oaks:
  50. (1995). Changing Patterns ofEmployment and Unemployment in Africa, World Development Series7, Helsinki: World Institute for Development Economics Research Ennew,
  51. (1994). Child Employment in the Capitalist LabourMarket, doi
  52. (1988). Child Labour in Egypt: Leather Tanning in Cairo'.
  53. (1999). Child Labour ripe in Morocco',
  54. (1999). Child Labour: A Global Phenomenon', doi
  55. (1995). Child Labour: An Economic Perspective,
  56. (1997). Child labour: Background brief,
  57. (2000). Child Labour: Background Paper',
  58. (1997). Child Labour: How the Challenge is Being Met',
  59. (1996). Child Labour: Targeting the intolerable,
  60. (1999). Child Trafficking in
  61. (1982). Child Workers and Capitalist Development: An Introductory Note and Bibliography', doi
  62. (1982). ChildLabour and the Development of Capitalist Agriculture in Ghana', Development and Change, doi
  63. (1988). ChildLabour Policies and Programmes in Kenya'.
  64. (1982). Children and Adolescents in Brasil: Work,
  65. (1999). Children and Childhood'. doi
  66. (1996). Children and Development: Pursuing Policy Priority in the new South Africa', doi
  67. (1997). children are also involved in this migration. There is evidence that girls. as young as 8 years, are either financed by their parents to travel from the north to work as street and market porters or are recruited as domestic servants (Agarwal, et a!..
  68. (1999). Children First: A Market in Innocence, Issue 32, 297http://www.unicef.org.uk/children32/market.html UNICEF (2000) The State ofthe World's Children,
  69. (1988). Children in India: The Carpet Industry of Varnasi'.
  70. (1996). Children, Health andthe Social Order,
  71. (2000). Children's Work and Children's Ed ti I . " uca Ion: ssues In Development Economics, Rethinking Childhood Conference,
  72. (1984). Children's Work in Four Cultures: Determinants and Consequences', doi
  73. (1978). Colonialism and Underdevelopment in doi
  74. (1999). Considering Child Labour: Changing Terms, doi
  75. (1997). Contrary to the conclusion of Coloumbe's
  76. (1997). countries with the highest illiteracy rates, lowest school enrolment ratios and serious nutritive deficiencies are in general those that have the highest proportions of children working (Canadian International Development Agency,
  77. (2001). Criminalising Survival: Images and Reality of Street Children, doi
  78. (1996). Data Collection and Analysis,
  79. (1999). Defining the Intolerable: Child Work, Global Standards and Cultural Relativism', doi
  80. (2000). Does Children's School Work have a Value? Colonisation of Children through their Work, Rethinking Childhood Conference,
  81. (1981). Early Work Experience: Effects on Adolescent Occupational Socialisation', doi
  82. (1990). Economic Crisis and Structural Adjustment in Africa' In CRD: Structural Change andPoverty, CDR Project Paper 90.2, Copenhagen: Centre for Development Research Ghana National Commission on Children (GNCC)
  83. (1997). education and future aspirations: "I know only A, B, C..." Educational systems in Africa are often considered to be part of the child labour 235problem (UNICEF,
  84. (1999). Embedded Evaluation: Programme for Street Children, Accra: CAS Street G' I Aid (SAID) , rr s I CSAE
  85. (1999). ENEWS: Tea, Tobacco, Cotton Growers, Main Culprits on Child Labour, http://lists.essentiaI.org/intl tobacco
  86. (2000). Entering the Zl" Century: World Development Report 199912000,
  87. (1999). Family Child Labour and Migration: Child Camacho, A. an enar a, doi
  88. (2000). Family versus the Logic of the Market'.
  89. (1990). Following these arguments of social particularities, the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (ACRWC)
  90. (1973). Forced Labour in British West Africa: The Case of th Northern Territories of the Gold Coast, 1906-1927' Journal if AI;' doi
  91. (2001). Franz Fanon's uneven ribs, The Daily Graphic Friday
  92. (1996). From a different perspective, doi
  93. (1995). from Table 2, World Development Report, 200012001. For Gabon, the rate is for
  94. (2001). Ghana Traffics in Children Report, doi
  95. (1986). Ghana: Coping with Uncertainty,
  96. (1997). Ghana: Structural Adjustment's Star Pupil'.
  97. (1993). Ghana' In Adepoju, A. (ed) The Impact ofStructural Adjustment on the Population ofAfrica,
  98. (1992). Ghana's first contact with the IMF for financial assistance was in May 1965, and later that same year, it approached the World Bank also (Rimmer,
  99. (1993). Global institutions like the UNICEF, UN Economic Commission for Africa and the ILO however have been virtually unanimous on the negative impact of SAP on social services, wages, employment, and on the poor and disadvantaged (Adepoju,
  100. (1996). Globali.sati?n: Myths and Realities'
  101. (1998). Globalisation and the Third World, London: Routledge Kilbourne, S.
  102. (1999). Head-portering (kayayoo) by girls is a fully-fledged commercial activity in Accra and other major cities in southern Ghana OPEC,
  103. (1996). How to Research, doi
  104. (2000). In and Out: Chi~d Fora~s i~to the Labour Force Evidence from Panel Data for Urban Brazil, Rethinking Childhood Conference,
  105. (1994). In search of answers: Objectives, questions and intentions A review of studies on child labour in Ghana shows that the directions of enquiry are often on the role of social and cultural factors
  106. (1991). In this sense, the vibrant informal economy of Accra, itself a by-product of adjustments (Ninsen,
  107. (2000). Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper: doi
  108. (2001). Internationally Recognised Core Labour Sta~d~ds in Ghana: Report for the WTO General Council Review of Trade Policies of Ghana,
  109. (1997). Introduction In recent times, child migration from the rural areas, particularly the northern regions to southern Ghana, has become a major social problem (Korboe,
  110. (1994). Invisible Hands: The Political Economy of Child Labour in Colonial Zimbabwe 1890-1930', doi
  111. (2001). Issues of Access and Identity: Adapting Research Methods with Kampala Street doi
  112. (1999). it is estimated that 70% of kayayoos in Accra come from the north (IPEC,
  113. (1982). it is frequently claimed, as Standing
  114. (1990). Kaduna Beggar Children: A Study ofChild Abuse and Neglect in Northern Nigeria',
  115. (1992). Learning the Hard Way: The Extent and Significance of Child Working in Britain', doi
  116. (2000). Lemons into Lemonade? A Critical ~ssessme~t of E4XPRerieh~cekis.
  117. (1994). Linking Qualitative and Quantitative Data Analysis' doi
  118. (1996). mily Strate.gies and Children's Work Patterns: Some Insights from Industrialising Catalonia, 1850 - 1920'. In Cummingham H.
  119. (1991). Negative .Co~elates of Part-Time .
  120. (1997). Oslo Conference to Seek Global Strategy for Combating Child Labour: Press Releases,
  121. (2001). Pace Set in Abolition ofChild Labour, http://allafrica.com "
  122. (2000). Paternal Domination: The Typical Relationship Conditioning the Exploitation of Children'.
  123. (1995). pp.ortunity Cost' and Labour Migration: A Misinterpretation of Proletarianisation In Northern Ghana', doi
  124. (1993). Real World Research, London: Blackwell doi
  125. (1997). Relationships Between Education and Child Labour: Issues Paper,
  126. (1990). Representing Childhood: Time and Transition in the Study ofChildhood'.
  127. (1994). Research Design: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, doi
  128. (2000). Researching Children's Perspectives: A psychological Dimension'.
  129. (1998). Rights - East Africa: Child Labour on the Rise, Nairobi: International Press Service,
  130. (2000). Save the Children UK Country Report: Ghana
  131. (1992). Short Changed: Africa andWorld Trade, London; rown,
  132. (1997). Social Mobilisation for the Elimination ofChild Labour: Issues Paper, International Conference on Child Labour,
  133. (1997). social pressures and child labour A major source of the neglect of ordinary people and a potential for the commercialisation of child labour was the retrenchment of workers from the formal sector. The unemployment rate in Ghana in
  134. (1998). Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, doi
  135. (1997). Social Research: Issues, Methods and Process, doi
  136. (1997). Sociology, doi
  137. (1991). Stabilisation and Adjustment'
  138. (1987). Stabilisation Policies and the Effects on Child Health in Zimbabwe', doi
  139. (1997). Statistics on Working Children and Hazardous Child Labour in in brief,
  140. (1993). Street and Working Children: Summary Report, Florence:
  141. (2001). Street Child Phenomena: Irresponsible Fathers to Blame',
  142. (1994). Street Children in Accra -What They do in the Streets and How They Manage to Survive'.
  143. (1994). Street Children in Mozambique', doi
  144. Struct~r.al Adjustment and Structural Change in Sub-Saharan Afnca: some provtsional conclusions',
  145. (1995). Structural Adjustment and Performance in Living standards doi
  146. (1995). Structural Adjustment and Poverty Alleviation: An Interpretative Survey, Development and Change, doi
  147. (1994). Structural Adjustment in Sub-Saharan Africa'. In doi
  148. (1999). Structural Adjustment Programs (SAPS) in Ghana: Interrogating PNDC's implementation', West Africa Review, No.1,
  149. Table -tl: The origins ofparticipants Region/Country Number Distances covered -----. 0 okilometres Greater Accra
  150. (1980). Table 1.2: Demographic indicators ofselected African countries Country Annual popn. Under-5 Life expec % popn. Annual Growth mortality* tancy urbanised urban popn Rate (%) Per-l000 (years) growth-%
  151. (1997). Table 4.4: Length of stay in Accra Time Period Boys Girls '"
  152. (1982). The case of rice cultivation in the rural areas of northern Ghana is well known (see for example,
  153. (1996). The Child Business: Comments on the Management of International Policies for Children', doi
  154. (1994). The Civil Rights and Obligation of the Child'.
  155. (1982). The Differentiation ofChildren's Labour in the Capitalist Labour Market', doi
  156. (2000). The Disintegrating Social Fabric: C~ild lab~ur and Socialisation in Senegal'.
  157. (1994). The Economic Recovery Programme and the Rights of the Child'.
  158. (1978). The Economic Socialisation of Children: A Cummings, . an ae e, . neo-Marxist Analysis', doi
  159. (1992). The Emerging Problem of Child Labour', doi
  160. (1974). The Evolution ofChildhood'.
  161. (1996). The Extent of Child Labour in Britain', doi
  162. (1993). The Family Ec~nomy,
  163. (1993). The Impact ofStructural Adjustment on the Population of Africa,
  164. (1996). The interviews The detailed interviewing of the children was expected to provide what
  165. (2000). The lLO's Minimum Age Convention provides a common starting point for setting different age thresholds for different activities (Nkurlu,
  166. (1992). The National Liberation (NLC) Era In 1966, a combined team of moderate police and military leaders overthrew Nkrumah, in what was then seen as a popular coup (Rimmer,
  167. (1980). The New international Division of Labour in the World Economy'.
  168. (1990). The Philosophy ofSocial Research,
  169. (1990). The problem however is that most of the gains of SAP have not been sustainable enough to benefit poor families. Thus, claims by the BankIIMF that SAP was a success in Ghana in the 1990s often come under considerable criticism. Toye
  170. (1983). The Rawlings' Era and post-1983 structural adjustments The context The background to the adoption of SAP in 1983 by Rawlings and the PNDC lay in this political instability, corruption, the expulsion of a million Ghanaians from Nigeria and a drought in
  171. (1975). the revenue base of the government was about 16% of GDP, but by 1981 had sunk to an all time low of 4.5%. The comparable rates for other countries in West Africa at this time were between 20 and 25% (Frimpong-Ansah,
  172. (1994). The Rights ofthe Child in Ghana - The Socio-Cultural Milieu'. In
  173. (1987). The SAP-induced reforms in education appeared in two phases. The first phase, from
  174. (1990). The Social Dimensions ofAdjustment in Africa: A Policy Agenda,
  175. (1994). The Socio-economic Impact of Child Labour in Cameroon', Labour, Capital andSociety,
  176. (1989). The State ofthe World's Children
  177. (1990). The Susu Credit System: An Ingenious Way of Financing Businesses Outside the Formal Banking System', The Long-term Perspective Study ofSub-Saharan Africa:
  178. (1975). The urban informal sector: World Bank Staff Working Paper,
  179. (1993). The value ofwork: "For me this isjustfor the money..." The general view, as noted and argued earlier, is that there is little child labour in the formal sector in Ghana (Ashagrie,
  180. (2000). The Worst Forms of Child Labour' and the Worst for Working Children: The Child Labour Issue, Exploitation and the Question of Value,
  181. (1999). there is a social obligation on people to care for their parents (Assimeng,
  182. (1995). There is also the politically induced economic and social instability across Africa. Ethnic wars, political uncertainties, famine and impoverishment govern many people's lived experiences (Endale,
  183. (1994). There is greater ambiguity about childhood in Africa, however. In most cases, social criteria supersede biological age in differentiating a child from an adult (Amin,
  184. (1997). They provide little or no connection between child labour and SAP. In other cases where economic angles are introduced, the critical issues are reduced to variables in traditional econometric studies (for example,
  185. (1982). Underpaid Child Labour and Social Reproduction: Apprenticeship doi
  186. (2000). Unexploited' Labour: Social Translation in Madagascar'.
  187. (1990). UNICEF's Views on the Experiences with Structural Adjustment Programmes' In CRD: Structural Change and Poverty,
  188. (2001). uo (1999b) The ILO: What it is, What it does, Geneva: ILO uo (2001) 'A Contem~o~ary Form of Slavery: Combating Child Trafficking in West and Central Afnca, World ofWork,
  189. (1999). What Can Trade Unions do to Combat Child Labour?' doi
  190. (1998). What Works for Working Children, doi
  191. (1992). While Ghana went through five governments in a space of ten years, the population almost doubled, yet the gross domestic product at constant market prices declined by 12 % over the decade (Rimmer,
  192. (1993). Who are "Street children?" A Hierarchy of Street Use and Appropriate Responses', doi
  193. (2000). With the high unemployment and inflation rates in Ghana (lSSER,
  194. (1990). Work Street work is the epitome of informal sector activities in Africa because of its visibility. Generally, more than 100 million children are estimated to be working in the streets of the developing world (Ojanuga,
  195. (2000). Working Children and international Labour', Information Bulletin No.4, International Conference on rethinking Childhood Bondy, France 15- 17 November,
  196. (1988). Working Children: Current Trends and Policy Responses',
  197. (1990). World Bank Experience and Structural Adjustment and Poverty Alleviation'
  198. (1998). World Development Indicator, doi
  199. (1997). Youth, Gender and Part-time work- Students in the Labour Process' Work, Employment andSociety, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.