Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Contrastive rhetoric of English persuasive correspondence in the Thai business context : cross-cultural sales promotion, request and invitation

By Ora-Ong Chakorn

Abstract

This research focuses on the contrastive analysis of authentic persuasive business\ud correspondence written in English by Thai speakers and native English speakers in the\ud Thai business context. Three types of persuasive correspondence - sales promotion,\ud request, and invitation - were analysed from contrastive text linguistic and pragmatic\ud perspectives. The purpose was to examine, compare and contrast their rhetorical\ud structures, functions and linguistic realisations as well as persuasive and politeness\ud strategies, and to compare these features to those found in textbook samples of\ud persuasive letters in order to investigate the extent to which those samples represent\ud the authentic, real-life correspondence.\ud The findings report on cross-cultural variations which differentiate the persuasive\ud writing patterns and strategies of Thais and native English speakers. Despite some\ud shared writing conventions, the findings reveal diversity in some rhetorical moves,\ud linguistic realisations, rhetorical appeals and politeness strategies. The diversity\ud includes some cultural-bound discourse patterns and cultural-specific textual features,\ud many of which can be traced to interference from the Thai language and culture. An\ud exploration of the nature of sales promotion, request, and invitation letters presented\ud in one American and two Thai textbooks on Business English writing reveals that\ud their letter samples reflect the characteristics of the authentic corpus in the business\ud contexts to which they belong.\ud The implications of this research are twofold. First, it has implications for the\ud teaching of English business letter writing especially in the Thai context and the\ud innovation of more advanced materials and methods for this pedagogical purpose.\ud Second, it raises an awareness of differences in persuasive writing across languages\ud and cultures, worth noting for developing cross-cultural understanding and\ud communication strategies for effective intercultural business interactions in the\ud dynamic business environment of the 21st century

Topics: HF, PE
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3660

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. 1. 'Thai Reforms Failing to Reach Needy'. The Guardian Weekly. TEFL supplement in association with the BBC World Service: Learning English.
  2. 18,2000, from hqp: //www. thaitrade. com Department of Foreign Trade (DFT),
  3. 1996. Academic Writing: Intercultural and Textual Issues. Amsterdam: Benjamins. 199 1. 'Non-native Writing and Native Revising of Scientific Articles'. doi
  4. (2000). 21: 41 Subject: Tourist Information Dear Sir/Madam, My wife and have booked a holiday in the Far East during January and
  5. (1999). 322 Board of Investment of Thailand (BOI). Retrieved January 24,2000, from http: //www.
  6. (1983). A A-Z ofEnglish Grammar & Usage. London: Longman. Leki, 1.199 1. '25 Years of Contrastive Rhetoric - Text Analysis and Writing Pedagogies'.
  7. (1976). A Classification of Illocutionary Acts'. doi
  8. (1993). A Comparative Study ofBusiness Letters Written by Native and NonNative English Speakers. MA AEL dissertation.
  9. A Comparison Approach to the Learning of Specialised Written Discourse'.
  10. (1992). A Computer Text Analysis of Four Cohesion Devices in English Discourse by Native and Nonnative Writers'. doi
  11. (1988). A Contrastive Study of Persuasive Business Correspondence: American and Japanese'.
  12. (1998). A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Letters of Recommendation'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  13. (1985). A Genre-Based Approach to Language Across the Curriculum'.
  14. A My letter regarding data collection (in
  15. (1984). A Study of Cohesion and Coherence in ESL Students' Writing'. Papers in Linguistics: doi
  16. A Study ofMaterials and Methods in Teaching Business English to IMA Students at a University in Thailand: Materials Evaluation and Syllabus Designfor the Communicative Classroom. Unpublished MA Dissertation.
  17. (1996). A Survey of Communication Patterns in the Brazilian Business Context'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  18. (1980). A Survey of the Needsfor the Use ofEnglish Business of Private Sectors. Unpublished MA Thesis.
  19. (1985). Academic Writing and Chinese Students: Transfer and Development Factors'. doi
  20. (1994). Advances in Written Text Analysis. doi
  21. (1999). Affairs.
  22. (1989). An Analysis ofFeatures ofSpoken Discourse in a Stimulated Business Negotiations: A Comparison between Innsbruck Sowi-Sprachenzentrum Students and Swarovski Marketing Specialists. Unpublished MA Dissertation.
  23. (1999). An Exploratory Study of Communication Competence in Thai Organizations'. doi
  24. (1985). An Introduction to Discourse Analysis. doi
  25. (1993). Analysing Genre: Language use in Professional Settings. doi
  26. (1997). Analyzing Casual Conversation.
  27. (1983). Annual Review ofApplied Linguistics Iff. Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
  28. (1999). APEC: The Road to Prosperity (Conference Fact Sheet).
  29. (1991). Aristotle on Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse. doi
  30. (1999). British Embassy's List of British Companies in Thailand.
  31. (2000). Building Knowledge Structures in Teaching Cross-Cultural Sales Genres'. doi
  32. (1999). Business English Communication.
  33. (1990). Business English: An International Survey'. English for Specific Purposes. doi
  34. (1996). Business is Booming: Business English in the 1990s'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  35. (1987). Business Letter Writing: English, French and Japanese'. doi
  36. (1996). Business Negotiations: Interdependence Between Discourse and the Business Relationship'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  37. (1975). Byinesu Bunsho: Bunreishuu (Business Writing: Collection of Sample Sentences).
  38. (1984). Characteristics of Rejection Letters and Their Effects on Job Applicants'. doi
  39. (1996). Chom Naa Kam Suksa Thai Nai Anakod: Naew Kit Lae Bod Vikrao' (The Future Education in Thailan& Trends and Analysis).
  40. (1989). Closings in Business Letters. Unpublished academic exercise submitted to the Department of English Language and Literature,
  41. (1976). Cohesion in English. doi
  42. (1980). Cohesion in Written Business Discourse: Some Contrasts'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  43. (2000). com/Business and Eggqom / Yahoo Inc.
  44. (1997). Communication Across Cultures: Translation Theory and Contrastive Text Linguistics. doi
  45. (1993). Context and Culture in Language Teaching. doi
  46. (1993). Contrastive ESP Rhetoric: Metatext in Finnish-English Economic Texts'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  47. (1987). Contrastive Rhetoric and Developing Discourse Strategies'. Paper presented at the 21'International TESOL Conference,
  48. (1985). Contrastive Rhetoric: An American Writing Teacher in China'. doi
  49. (1996). Contrastive Rhetoric: Cross-Cultural Aspects ofSecond Language Writing. doi
  50. (1983). Contrastive Rhetoric: Japanese and English'. doi
  51. (1983). Cross-Cultural Differences and Perceived Quality in Written Paraphrases of English Expository Prose'. doi
  52. (1989). Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Requests andApologies. doi
  53. (1998). Cross-Cultural Strategies and the Use of English in International Business Correspondence'.
  54. (1996). Cross-Cultural Strategies and the Use ofEnglish in
  55. (1966). Cultural Thought Patterns in Intercultural Education'. doi
  56. (1988). Cultural Variation in Reflective Writing'.
  57. (1980). Culture's Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values. doi
  58. (1998). Dear ???: Understanding British Forms of Address'. doi
  59. (1996). Developing Pragmatic Competence for Cross-Cultural Comminication'.
  60. (1983). Discourse Analysis. Cambridge: doi
  61. (1987). Discourse Strategies for Foreign Business Students: Preliminary Research Findings'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  62. (1995). Drop Me a Fax, Will You?: doi
  63. (1972). Einfuhrung in Die Textlinguistik (Introduction to Text Linguistics). doi
  64. (1997). English as a Global Language. Cambridge: doi
  65. (1982). English as an International Language 1: What Do We mean by "English"T.
  66. (1998). English for Specific Purposes: The Preservation of Species (Some Notes on a Recently Evolved Species and on the Contribution of John Swales to its Preservation and Protection)'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  67. (1987). English in Parallels: A Comparison of English and Arabic Prose'.
  68. (1988). Englishfor Business.
  69. (1980). ESP (Englishfor Specific Purposes). Oxford: Pergamon Press. . 199 1. ESP Today: A Practitioner's Guide. Hemel Hempstead:
  70. (1973). Explorations in the Functions ofLanguage. London: Edward Arnold.
  71. (1998). Exploring Corporate Rhetoric: Metadiscourse in the CEO's Letter'. doi
  72. (1989). Factual Writing: Exploring and Challenging Social Reality. Oxford:
  73. (1986). Features of Word Omission and Abbreviation in Telexes'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  74. (1987). Finland-Swedish Paragraph Patterns in EFL Compositions'.
  75. (1984). Francais Commercial: Theorie el Correspondance. doi
  76. (1994). Genre Analysis and the Identification of Textual Boundaries'. doi
  77. (1986). Genre Analysis: An Investigation of the Introduction and Discussion Sections of MSc Thesis'.
  78. (1984). Genre as Social Action'. doi
  79. (1993). Genre as Social Process'.
  80. (1962). How to Do Things with Words. doi
  81. (1911). How to Write the Business Letter.
  82. (1984). How Writers Orient Their Readers in Expository Essays: A Comparative Study of Native and Non-Native English Writers'. doi
  83. (1975). Indirect Speech Acts'. doi
  84. (1987). Indirectness and Politeness in Requests: Same or Different'. doi
  85. (1990). Inductive, Deductive, Quasi-Inductive: Expository Writing in Japanese, Korean, Chinese and Thai'.
  86. (1993). Information Sequencing in Modem Standard Chinese'.
  87. (1994). Inter-cultural Communication at Work Cultural Values in Discourse. Cambridge: doi
  88. (1967). Interaction Ritual: Essays on Face to Face Behaviour. doi
  89. (1993). Intercultural Business Telephone Conversations: a Case of Finns VS Anglo-Americans'. doi
  90. (2000). Internet-based Resources (Additional web-sites Presented in Chapter 1) http: //www. business-in-thailand. com
  91. (2000). Interpreting Literature: The Role of APPRAISAL'.
  92. (1983). Interpreting the Thai Variety of English: A Functional Approach'.
  93. (1998). Kaan Kaen Nangsue Tidtoh Rachakorn Lae Duraky. (Letter and Report Writing for Government and Business Contacts). Bangkok: Office of the Civil Service Commission.
  94. (1997). Kaan Kean Pua Kaan Suesaan (Writing for Communication).
  95. (1985). Language and Cross-Cultural Training in American Multinational Corporations. doi
  96. Language and Writing. - Applications ofLinguistics to Rhetoric and Composition. doi
  97. (1994). Language as Discourse: Perspectivesfor Language Teaching. doi
  98. (1985). Language Process in Sociocultural Practice.
  99. (1988). Language Taught in Meetings and Language Used in Meetings: Is There Anything in Common? '. doi
  100. (1993). Language Teaching and Leaming in Australia.
  101. (1982). Language Transfer and Conversational CompetenceĆ½. doi
  102. (1979). Languages of Thailand'.
  103. (2000). Lingua Future'. Far Eastern Economic Review.
  104. (1971). Linguistic Function and Literary Style: An Inquiry into the Language of William Golding's The Inheritors'.
  105. (1992). Linguistic Imperialism. doi
  106. (1989). Linguistic Politeness in Professional Prose: A Discourse Analysis of Auditors' Suggestion Letters, with Implications for Business Communication Pedagogy'. doi
  107. (1999). Meeting Talk: A Stylistic Approach to Teaching Meeting Skills'.
  108. (1993). Metadiscourse in Persuasive Writing: doi
  109. Narrative Styles in the Writing of Thai and American Students'.
  110. (1999). Negotiating Organizational Communication Cultures in American Subsidiaries Doing Business in Thailand'. doi
  111. (2000). net ThaiMarket Co.,
  112. (1997). Office of the National Education Commission.
  113. (1993). On the Nature of Written Business Communication'.
  114. (1981). On the Use of the Passive in Two Astrophysics Journal Papers'. doi
  115. (1979). On Whimperatives and Related Questions'. doi
  116. (1998). Pasaa Thai DurakU. (Business Thai).
  117. (1998). Phecht Pasaa Thai. (The Diamond of the Thai Language). Bangkok: Phecht Pasa Foundation.
  118. (1997). Polite Requests in English and Chinese Business Correspondence in Hong Kong'. doi
  119. (1997). Politeness in Written Business Discourse: A Textlinguistic Perspective on Requests'. doi
  120. (1992). Politeness Strategies in Business Letters by Native and Non-native English Speakers'. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  121. (1987). Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage. doi
  122. (1983). Pragmatics. Cambridge:
  123. (1995). Programs Offered by Thai Universities. Retrived February 24,2000, from http: //www.
  124. (1987). Reader Versus Writer responsibility: A New Typology'.
  125. (1999). Reflection and Projection on Thailand's Language Education Policy for the New Millennium'.
  126. (1996). Report on Business English: A Review ofResearch and Published Teaching Materials.
  127. (1996). Requests and Status in Business Correspondence'. doi
  128. Requests in German-Norwegian Business Discourse: Differences in Directness'.
  129. (1994). Requests in Professional Discourse: A Cross-Cultural Study ofBritish, American and Finnish Business Writing. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. doi
  130. (1966). Resourceful Business Communication. doi
  131. (1998). Rhetorical Ethos: A Bridge between High-Context and Low-Context Cultures? '. doi
  132. (2000). Rhetorical Moves in Chinese Sales Genres, doi
  133. (1992). Schemas, Authentic Texts and Cross-Cultural Communication'.
  134. (1972). Some Aspects of Text Grammars. The Hague: Mouton de Gruyter. doi
  135. (1969). Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy ofLanguage. Cambridge: doi
  136. Statistics and Data (Fact Sheet). February 16,2000. Internal Documents. Bangkok: Office of the Board of Investment
  137. (1986). Studying Writing: Linguistic Approaches.
  138. (1997). Survey Review: doi
  139. (1998). Survey Review: Recent Materials for the Teaching of ESP'. doi
  140. (1984). Syllabus Design for CULI's English for Academic Purposes Program'.
  141. (1986). Talking about Text: doi
  142. (1994). Teaching Business English. doi
  143. (1978). Teaching Language as Communication. Oxford: doi
  144. (1974). Tekstilingvisffikan Peruskasitteita (Basic Principles of Text Linguistics).
  145. (1986). Text and Context: How Writers Come to Mean'. In Couture, B. Functional Approaches to Writing: Research Perspectives.
  146. (1977). Text in the Systemic-Functional Model'. doi
  147. (1987). Thai Speakers'. doi
  148. (2000). thaiexporterguide. com Thailand Exporter Guide (TEG)
  149. (1999). The Academy Meets the Real World: Response to Audience in Academic Business Writing'.
  150. (1997). The Asian Connection: Business Requests and Acknowledgements'.
  151. (1996). The Business Communication Classroom vs. Reality: What Should We Teach Today? '. Englishfor Specific Purposes. doi
  152. (1987). The Cambridge Encyclopedia ofLanguage. Cambridge:
  153. (1983). The Center for Curriculum Development 327
  154. (1994). The Cultural Politics ofEnglish as an International Language.
  155. (1982). The Ethnography of Communication: An Introduction. doi
  156. (1995). The Functional Analysis of English. doi
  157. (1997). The Future ofEnglish. London: British Council.
  158. (1997). The Language of Administration: Organizing Human Activity in Formal Institutions'.
  159. The Language of Buying and Selling in Cyrenaica: A Situational Statement'.
  160. (1991). The Language of Letters: A History of Persuasive and doi
  161. (1984). The New Englishes. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. doi
  162. (1986). The Problem of Speech Genres'.
  163. (1988). The Second Language Learner and Cultural Transfer in Narration'.
  164. (1986). The Story ofEnglish. doi
  165. (1983). The Syntax of Persuasion: Two Business Letters of Request'. doi
  166. (1974). The Use of Error Analysis and Contrastive Analysis in Foreign Language Teaching'.
  167. (1977). Therapeutic Discourse. doi
  168. (1975). Towards an Analysis ofDiscourse.
  169. (1985). Understanding Persuasive Essay Writing: Linguistic/ Rhetorical Approach'. doi
  170. (2000). Verb-Tense Errors in English Writing Made by Thai Students: A Comparative Analysis'. Pasaa Lae Wattanatham (A Thai journal of language and culture).
  171. VIII-in ff m6uml I'li MI cub fli Iva luf 11""n I sp 14 V04 ift gmk As IIIJU q3JIMASIMM-11 CLO -a 41444 m 1,14 so -a-aluto 0 ofil I lvpl fil 5500 IPI.
  172. (1983). What a Functional Approach to the Writing Task can Show Teachers about 'Good Writing'. In Couture, B. Functional Approaches to Writing: Research Perspectives.
  173. (1997). Why We Need Contrastive Rhetoric'. doi
  174. (1995). Working with the Thais.
  175. (1997). World Englishes and English-Using Communities'. Annual Review ofApplied Linguistics. doi
  176. (1987). Written Academic Discourse in Korean: Implications for Effective Communication'.
  177. (1999). Year-End Economic Review.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.