Location of Repository

Cognitive development in relation to science education

By Lesley Ann Dunham


Various skills have been considered quintessential to the scientific method. The need for\ud these skills was highlighted by Armstrong at the beginning of the century and continues to be\ud re-iterated to the present day within the criteria of the National Curriculum. Pupils as\ud scientists are expected to make accurate and meaningful observations; record results from\ud experiments formulated to test hypotheses, controlling all the relevant variables except the\ud one under investigation; identify patterns within the results and recognise anomalies; draw\ud valid conclusions from the data collected and extrapolate from the data to predict further\ud results. These criteria were included in the list of thirty-two teacher assessed skills in\ud domains five and six of the Northern Examination Association, NEA, GCSE Biology\ud Syllabus.\ud This research project endeavoured to test the acquisition of these skills in a large sample of\ud students drawn from a variety of schools in an effort to establish the relative difficulty of the\ud individual skills. The corollation of performance of the skills with a range of factors,\ud including IQ, the influence of gender, school type, and associated subjects they studied was\ud explored. In particular the effect of an exposure to the Warwick Process Science Scheme\ud was investigated to establish whether a transferable long term enhancement resulted. The\ud main body of the research was undertaken on Year ten (4th Year) pupils, the sample being\ud drawn from ten schools of varying types. The work was extended to include both younger\ud and older age groups, to identify the progress made with age in skill acquisition and to\ud investigate whether success in the skills is of predictive value for the final GCSE grades of\ud future 'A'Level achievement.\ud The results indicated a wide variability in degrees of difficulty of the individual skills and a\ud wide range of performance by individual candidates. Success in the skills corollated very\ud closely with IQ, so to eliminate this effect samples cross-matched for IQ were investigated to\ud establish the effect of other variables. Only the study of the three separate sciences and\ud tuition within a selective school proved to have a significant effect on the outcome. Only\ud skill 30 devising three separate hypotheses to explain a complex set of results, had predictive\ud value for GCSE and none were of value for predicting capital 'A'Level success

Topics: LB1603
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3701

Suggested articles



  1. (1979). 1857 On teaching Physiology-and its applications
  2. (1970). 6th Edition Reprinted
  3. Arrnstronz and the teaching of
  4. (1987). CASE Coenitive Acceleration throueh Science Prglect. Schools Science Review No. 139. Page 17, Science Develops Logical Thinking?
  5. (1950). Childhood and Society doi
  6. (1980). Cognitive Acceleration through Science Education. Exploratory Study. Paul Black, Michael Shayer at Chelsea College SSRC.
  7. (1980). Conversations with Jean Piaget. doi
  8. (1902). EDUCATION General Reports on Higher EdUcation nnd Appendices, for the Year
  9. (1925). EDUCATION Report on an enquiry into the conditions affecting the teaching of Science in Secondary Schools for Bas.
  10. (1938). EDUCATION Secondary Education. The Report of the Spens Committee
  11. (1913). EDUCATION, Circular 826, The Curricula of Secondary Schools
  12. (1968). Educational Psychology: A Cognitive View doi
  13. (1983). Equal Opportunities Commission. Girls and Girls-only Schools A Review of the Evidence, pamphlet EOC.
  14. (1979). Evidence to Clarendon Commission Vol IV
  15. (1960). Explosion of Sixth Form Numbers HMSO Annual Report Advisory Council on Scientific Policy.
  16. (1977). Good Wives and Little Mothers: Social Anxieties and the Schooleirl's Curriculum in Oxford Review of Education. Vol 3 No. I doi
  17. (1911). L'Etude Experimentale de L'Intelligence, Schleicher Freres, doi
  18. (1973). Mixed or Single Sexed chool? vols 1,2 and 3. Routledge and Kegan Paul,
  19. (1949). Modern School Biology,
  20. (1974). Perception and Understanding in Young Children. doi
  21. (1983). Piaget Critique and Reassessment, doi
  22. (1976). Piaget's theory of cognitive development and individual differences. doi
  23. (1978). Piaget's Theory of Intelligence. doi
  24. (1981). Policy Statement, doi
  25. (1962). Quantity Conception in College Students doi
  26. (1973). quoted in The Technical supplement to the Culture Fair TO Tests page 6, Institute of Personality and Ability Testing Inc.
  27. (1908). Smithells, A. School Training for the Home Duties of
  28. (1916). The Development of Intelligence in Children (Translated by doi
  29. (1993). The National Curriculum and its Assessment An Interim Repor National Curriculum Council NCC.
  30. (1983). The Pupil as a Scientist Open

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.