Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The role of insurance and its regulation in development : Sudan and Tanzania

By Mirghani Mohmed El-Hassan

Abstract

This thesis examines the experiences of Sudan and Tanzania in attempting\ud to control their respective insurance industries to serve their economic\ud development. The socio-political chemistry in each country has produced a\ud certain policy towards the insurance institution. The Sudan opted to control\ud its industry through a regulation code; Tanzania adopted nationalization as\ud an ultimate form of control. The thesis examines the respective roles of the\ud two regulation models in the development process, and argues that, on balance,\ud a direct model of insurance control such as in Tanzania is more appropriate to\ud the needs of underdeveloped countries than a regulatory model of the Sudanese\ud type. This conclusion derives from insurance theory itself, and from the need\ud to avoid the problems which afflict the regulatory model such as the technical\ud difficulties which regulation involves, the weakness of the regulation agency\ud vis-a-vis the industry, the influence of the latter upon the agency, the\ud difficulty of monitoring solvency, and of enforcing investment regulations.\ud In theory, the state is also more capable of protecting the public which seeks\ud insurance cover from its own institution than when cover is purchased from\ud private insurers.\ud Most information relates to the period 1970-1977, and the thesis is\ud largely based on fieldwork research in the Sudan and Tanzania and on secondary\ud resources. Although the methods of control examined are largely legal methods\ud an attempt is made to transcend law for a better understanding of the problems\ud which afflict the institution. A legal doctrinal study preoccupied with the\ud analysis of rules and procedures is unlikely to provide an insight into how\ud the institution operates. Even less is it likely to be of value when legal\ud rules are not truly reflective of practice. It is for this reason that the\ud institution is studied in the wider political economy of the two countries

Topics: HG
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3950

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (Minister of Finance) to the Council of Ministers,
  2. (of the Attorney-General) to the controller of insurance,
  3. (of the Attorney-General) to the controller of insurance, dated 8.10.1978. -376-Memo. by Mr. Glassborrow dated 20.5.1956.
  4. (of the Ministry of-Justice) to the controller of insurance,
  5. (1979). 382-Interviews: Interview with Ahmed Mohmed E.
  6. (1976). 9 "Traditional Sector and the National Democratic Revolution",
  7. (1948). A Century of Service: The Story of The Prudential, (London: Wi. therby Ltd.,
  8. A History of British Insurance,
  9. (1974). Accumulation on A World Scale, (_New York and London: Monthly Review Press,
  10. (1976). African Insurance Markets: Structure and Development", a paper published by the Economic and Social Research Council,
  11. (1972). After The V&G Crash: Reflections on Motor Insurance in
  12. (1974). Aid as Imperialism, doi
  13. (1980). An Introduction to the Sudan Economy, Supra. -355-Ellis, T. H., European Integration and Insurance: Creating a Common Insurance Market,
  14. (1977). Annual Report of the Controller of Insurance (Sudan) to the Minister of Finance, "Performance of Insurance Companies", unpublished,
  15. (1956). Approved Enterprises (Concessions) Act,
  16. (1968). Asian Drama: An Inquiry Into the Poverty of Nations, doi
  17. (1977). Banking and Foreign Trade",
  18. (1979). Barriers to Trade in Insurance", (Trade Policy Research Centre,
  19. (1975). Beyond the Sociology of Development, doi
  20. by Lloyds to Mr. Glassborrow,
  21. (1967). by the Attorney-General to the Acting controller of insurance,
  22. by the controller of insurance to the Deputy Minister of Finance,
  23. by the controller of insurance to the Minister of Finance on "Investment of insurance companies",
  24. by the controller of insurance to the Minister of Finance on "Valuation of Insurance Companies' Real Estate Assets",
  25. by the controller of insurance to the Minister of Finance on the "Re-organization of the Sudanese Insurance Market"
  26. (1970). by the controller of insurance to the Minister of Finance,
  27. by the controller of insurance to the Minister of Finance, dated 18.8.1971. Memo. by the, Sudanese Insurance Association to the controller of insurance,
  28. by the Sudanese Insurance Association to the Minister of Finance,
  29. (1964). Capital Formation and Economic Development, doi
  30. Capitalism and Slavery, LLondon:
  31. (1967). Capitalism and Underdevelopment in Latin America, doi
  32. Circular Letter by the State Minister of Commerce (Khartoum),
  33. (1975). Class Struggles in Tanzania, (Dar es Salaam: Tanzania Publishing House, doi
  34. (1979). Co-Insurance in the Sudan", unpublished paper written for the Insurance Section of the Ministry of Finance,
  35. (1973). Colonialism and Underdevelopment in East Africa, doi
  36. (1979). Committee to Review the Functioning of Financial Institutions, "Second Stage Evidence",
  37. (1979). Condominium and Sudanese Nationalism, doi
  38. (1973). Contracts and Power in America"
  39. (1980). Contribution of Agricultural Insurance Towards Economic Development", The Platform,
  40. (1973). Crises and Coups: Themes in the Sociology of Developing Countries, doi
  41. (1968). Democratic Values, Social Change, and Legal Institutions in the Development Process"
  42. (1979). Development and Underdevelopment: A Marxist Analysis, doi
  43. (1978). Development Planning in the Sudan",
  44. (1950). Domestic Financing of Economic Development",
  45. (1971). East Africa: A Centur of Change, 1870-1970, (London: Allen and Unwin,
  46. (1977). Economic Effects of Restrictions on International Trade in Reinsurance", a paper presented to the Third International Reinsurance Seminar,
  47. El-Tuhami, 0. (of the Attorney-General) to the controller of insurance,
  48. Empire and Commerce doi
  49. (1977). Faisal Islamic Bank Act,
  50. (1971). Final Report to the Government of the Democratic Republic of the Sudan", by M. Sadiq, (UNCTAD expert), unpublished,
  51. (1966). Financial Intermediaries and their Role in East Africa", a paper presented to the University of East Africa Social Science Conference,
  52. (1972). Financial Planning and Control in Tanzania" doi
  53. (1968). Freedom and Socialism, doi
  54. (1969). From Independence To Self-Reliance"
  55. (1959). Gezira: A Story of Development in the Sudan, (Faber and Faber Ltd., doi
  56. (1958). Glassborrow dated 26
  57. (1958). Glassborrow to the Attorney-General,
  58. (1967). Government and Politics in Tanzania,
  59. Government Control of Operations of Insurance in Developing Countries",
  60. (1964). History of Accident Insurance in doi
  61. (1972). History of the Sudan, (London: Weidenfield and Nicolson,
  62. How Europe Underdeveloped Africa, doi
  63. (1969). Imperialism and Nationalism in the Sudan, doi
  64. (1970). Imperialism and Underdevelopment: A Reader, doi
  65. (1970). Imperialism: The highest stage of Capitalism, doi
  66. (1975). Inflation, Insurance and Reinsurance",
  67. (1971). Insurance As A Cybernetic Institution of Self-Regulation of the National Economy",
  68. (1963). Insurance Co. v.
  69. (1977). Insurance Companies",
  70. (1975). Insurance Education for Developing Countries",
  71. Insurance in the Economy",
  72. (1977). Insurance Management in Africa, doi
  73. (1964). Insurance Markets of the World, (Zurich: Swiss Reinsurance Co., doi
  74. (1980). Insurance of Public Sector Corporations in the Sudan", a paper published by the Economic and Social Research Council,
  75. (1966). Insurance Principles and Practices, (PrenticeHall Inc. Englewood Cliffs,
  76. Insurance, doi
  77. (1977). Insurance: A Commercial Venture", a research paper presented to the Faculty of Law, University of Dar es Salaam,
  78. (1969). Inter-Regional Seminar on Insurance and Reinsurance -Prague,
  79. (1953). International Insurance Transactions,
  80. (1979). Interview with the controller of insurance,
  81. (1979). Interview with the Deputy General Manager of United Insurance Co.
  82. (1979). Interview with Yahya Mutwali of the insurance section,
  83. (1962). Introduction To Insurance, doi
  84. (1971). Investment of Technical Reserves of Insurance Concerns in the Country Where the Premium Income Arises",
  85. (1975). Issues in the Economic Development of the Sudan,
  86. (1980). Law and Development in the Light of Dependency Theory", doi
  87. (1980). Law and State i. n doi
  88. (1972). Law as Symbolism"
  89. (1977). Law in The Political Economy of The Public Enterprise, (Uppsala: Scandinavian Institute of African Studies and New York: International Legal Centre, doi
  90. (1967). Legal Aspects of Nationalization in
  91. Letter by Attorney-General to the Council of Ministers,
  92. (1968). Letter by the Acting controller to the Attorney-General,
  93. Letter by the Acting controller to the Attorney-General, dated 19.11.1963.
  94. Letter by the Alliance Marine Insurance Co. to the Commercial Registrar, dated 2.10.1962. -374-Letter by Mr. Porteous,
  95. Letter by the Attorney-General to acting controller,
  96. (1962). Letter by the Attorney-General to acting controller, dated 15
  97. Letter by the Attorney-General to the controller, dated 8.11.1978.
  98. Letter by the Attorney-General to the Director. of Establishments,
  99. Letter by the Blue Nile Insurance Co. to the controller of insurance,
  100. Letter by the Business Profit Tax (of the Department of Taxation) to the controller of insurance,
  101. Letter by the controller of insurance to the Attorney-General, dated 15.11.1959.
  102. Letter by the controller of Insurance to the Minister of Finance,
  103. Letter by the controller to the Commissioner of the Police, dated 11.3.1975. -375-Letter by the controller to the Fire Brigade, dated 18.8.1973.
  104. Letter by the Financial Manager of the Sudanese Tractors Corporation to the controller, dated 12.5.1975.
  105. Letter by the Governor of the Bank of Sudan to the controller, dated 22.12.1961.
  106. Letter by the Minister of Economics and Trade to the Minister of Local Governments, dated 23.5.1972. "The Sudanese Insurance Market", a memo. by
  107. Letter by the Minister of Finance to the controller, dated 17.8.1975.
  108. Letter by the Minister of Finance to the Governor of the Bank of Sudan,
  109. (1958). Letter by the Minister of Industry, Commerce and Supply to the AttorneyGeneral,
  110. Letter by the National Trading Co. to the Minister of Finance and Commerce,
  111. (1975). Letter by the Sudanese Insurance and Reinsurance Co. to the Minister of Finance,
  112. Letter by the Sudanese-Kuwaiti Road Transport to the controller of insurance,
  113. Letter by thePttorney-General to the Permanent Undersecretary of the Ministry of Finance,
  114. Life Insurance Corporation of India [1974], Lloyds
  115. (1980). Ltd., "Sudan - Economic Report", published by Lloyds Bank, Overseas Division,
  116. Management and Control of Parastatal Organizations", doi
  117. (1975). Minerals in African Underdevelopment,
  118. (1966). Modernization: The Dynamics of Growth, doi
  119. (1979). Mshuza (editor of Ngao), Dar es Salaam,
  120. (1975). Multinational Insurance Companies", discussion papers in industrial economics,
  121. (1978). Nationalism and Communism in a Traditional Society: The Case of Sudan, doi
  122. (1979). Nationalization of Companies in Tanzania"
  123. (1975). Nationalization of Insurance in Developing Countries",
  124. (1965). Neo-Colonialism: The Last Stage of Imperialism. doi
  125. Notes Towards a Theory of Law and Ideology: Tanzanian Perspectives", doi
  126. Omari v. Tanganyika Farmers' Association, (unreported), Workmen's Compensation
  127. Organizational Relationship and The Control of Parastatals in
  128. (1979). Perspectives, doi
  129. (1978). Planning in the Sudan 'in Arabic',
  130. (1968). Political Order in Changing Societies, doi
  131. (1976). Principles of Insurance,
  132. (1979). Problems of Management in a Developing Environment, (Elsevir:
  133. Project Implementation and Control: A Critical Problem in Public Enterprises in Tanzania",
  134. Reflections on the Pertinence of a Theory of Exchange'. doi
  135. Reinsurance For the Beginner,
  136. (1975). Reinsurance Problems in Developing Countries",
  137. (1973). Report of "The Ministerial Committee for the Evaluation of the Assets of Sudanese Insurers",
  138. (1970). Report of the Economic Committee on the Insurance Sector", unpublished report, submitted to the Minister of Finance,
  139. (1957). Report of the Interdepartmental Committee, doi
  140. (1975). Review of African Political doi
  141. (1974). Rural Development and Bureaucracy in Tanzania: The Case of Mwanza Region, doi
  142. (1962). Selected Works, (Moscow: Foreign Language Publishing House,
  143. (1971). Slavery and Muslim Society in Africa, doi
  144. (1974). Social Security in Tanzania", a research paper presented to the Faculty of Law, University of Dar es Salaam,
  145. (1978). Socialist Development and Public Investment in Tanzania 1964-1973, doi
  146. (1979). Sociology of Underdevelopment v. Sociology of Development? "
  147. (1974). Some Preliminary Notes on the Political Economy of Rural Tanzania Based on a case study in Western Usambaras", mimeo., University of Dar es Salaam,
  148. (1976). Some Thoughts on Insurance and Development", Best's Review,
  149. (1963). Studies in the Development of Capitalism, (London and Henley: Routledge Paperback,
  150. Studies in- the Theory of Imperialism, doi
  151. (1968). Sudan : Background to Conflict, doi
  152. (1976). Sudanese Financial Institutions and Their Functioning",
  153. (1960). Sudanese Motor Insurance Co.
  154. (1969). Tanganyika Under German Rule, (London: doi
  155. (1974). Tanu, The Party of Independence and National Consolidation"
  156. (1979). Tanzania: From Ujamaa to Villagization" doi
  157. Tarawia v. Tinga Tinga Estate Ltd., (unreported), Workmen's Compensation
  158. (1976). The Agricultural Investment Act,
  159. (1969). The Arusha Declaration: Ten Years After"
  160. (1948). The Assurance Companies Act, doi
  161. (1970). The Auditor-General's Act,
  162. (1959). The Bank of Sudan Act,
  163. (1972). The Barrel of Gun,
  164. (1933). The British Anti-Slavery Movement,
  165. (1973). The British Financial System,
  166. (1969). The Co-operative Movement and its Growing Pains",
  167. (1932). The Co-operative Societies Ordinance,
  168. (1925). The Companies Ordinance, doi
  169. The Control of Insurance Business in Great Britain",
  170. (1976). The Critical Phase in Tanzania: 1945-1968 (London: doi
  171. (1964). The Development of Capitalism in
  172. (1980). The Development of Corporate Capitalism in Kenya: 1918-1977, doi
  173. (1969). The Doctrine of Uberrima Fides in Insurance Law -A Critical Evaluation", doi
  174. (1968). The Economy of Tanganyika, doi
  175. (1979). The Effect of Legislation in Latin America Limiting the Freedom to Reinsure Internationally",
  176. (1880). The Employers' Liability Act, doi
  177. (1955). The Establishment of Workers' Councils, Executive Committees and Boards of Directors. " Letter by Mr. Glassborrow to the Attorney-General,
  178. (1974). The Finance Act, doi
  179. (1977). The Financial Accounting and Procedures Act,
  180. The Financial Times, doi
  181. (1977). The Gezira Scheme: An Illusion of Development, doi
  182. The History of Lloyds and of Marine Insurance
  183. (1961). The Industrial Bank Act, doi
  184. (1967). The Insurance (Vesting of Interest and Regulation) Act,
  185. (1974). The Insurance Companies Act, doi
  186. (1971). The Insurance Industry in Tanzania: 10th Year Independence Anniversary",
  187. (1960). The Insurers (Control) Act,
  188. (1962). The Insurers (Control) Regulations,
  189. (1965). The Interim Constitution of Tanzania,
  190. (1974). The International Activity of Swiss Insurers and Reinsurers",
  191. (1980). The Investment Act,
  192. (1957). The Labour Movement in the Sudan : 1946-1955, doi
  193. (1905). The Land Settlement Ordinance, doi
  194. The Law of Insurance, doi
  195. (1971). The Liberation of Sudanese Economy('in Arabic'),
  196. (1945). The Life Assurance Ordinance,
  197. (1958). The Mahdist State in the Sudan, doi
  198. (1969). The Mechanized Farming Corporation Act,
  199. (1979). The Monetary System of Tanzania Since 1967: Progress, Problems and Prospects",
  200. (1970). The Nationalization of Companies Act,
  201. (1973). The Nature of Reinsurance",
  202. (1967). The Permanent Commission of Inquiry Act,
  203. (1967). The Permanent Labour Tribunal Act,
  204. (1973). The Political Economy of Growth, doi
  205. The Political Economy of Imperialism, (Dar es Salaam: doi
  206. The Political Economy of the Parastatals", doi
  207. (1965). The Politics of Modernization, doi
  208. (1977). The Post-Colonial State and its Tanzanian Version", doi
  209. (1971). The Prevention of Corruption Act,
  210. (1953). The Problems of Capital Formation in Underdeveloped Countries, doi
  211. (1969). The Public Corporations Act, doi
  212. (1961). The Purpose of Insurance Regulation: An Inquiry in the Theory of Insurance Law",
  213. (1980). The Purpose of Reinsurance"
  214. (1974). The Regulation of Prices Act, doi
  215. (1977). The Responsibility of the Reinsurance Dictorate",
  216. (1945). The Road Traffic Act, doi
  217. (1979). The Role of Insurance in the Development of Sudanese Economy", a dissertation paper submitted to the Faculty of Economics and Social Studies,
  218. (1974). The Role of the National Provident Fund as a Social Security Institution in Tanzania", a research paper presented to the Faculty of Law, University of Dar es Salaam,
  219. (1970). The Royal Exchange Assurance : 1720-1970, (London: doi
  220. (1969). The Search for Countervailing Power",
  221. (1977). The Secretary of State for Trade doi
  222. (1964). The Security of Employment Act, doi
  223. (1974). The Social Insurance Act, doi
  224. The Soft State in Underdeveloped Countries",
  225. (1960). The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto, (London: doi
  226. (1973). The Stages of Economic Growth: A Review"
  227. (1978). The State, Law and Development, doi
  228. (1977). The Structural Malformation of the Sudanese Economy", a paper published by the Economic and Social Research Council,
  229. The Sudanese Communisty Party, "Mechanized Farming and the Development of Capitalism in The Traditional Sector",
  230. (1978). The Sudanese Insurance Association, "Treaty Limi-±s of Sudanese Insurers", unpublished paper presented to the Ministry of Finance by the Sudanese Insurance Association,
  231. (1960). The Sun Fire Office, 1710-1960, doi
  232. (1968). The Tanzania Audit Corporation Act,
  233. The Times, 8.2.1971,8.8.1971. -378-Statutes and Regulations Cited: The Sudan.
  234. (1971). The Trade Union Act, doi
  235. (1959). The Treasury Registrar Ordinance,
  236. (1967). The Tying of Aid: Progress Report",
  237. (1980). Third World Insurance at the End of the 1970s", TD/B/C.
  238. Title to Lands Ordinance,
  239. (1977). Ujamaa - Socialism From Above, (-Uppsala: Scandinavian Institute of African Studies, doi
  240. (1973). Ujamaa Vijijini and Rural Development", mimeo., University of Dar es Salaam,
  241. (1974). UNCTAD and Insurance",
  242. (1971). Underdevelopment and Dependence in Black Africa", a paper presented for the U. N. African Institute for Economic Development and Planning,
  243. (1973). Underdevelopment and Industrialization in Tanzania, (Nairobi: doi
  244. (1975). Underdevelopment in Kenya: The Political Economy of Neo-Colonialism, doi
  245. (1970). Underdevelopment or Revolution, doi
  246. (1979). unpublished paper written for the Insurance Section of the Ministry of Finance,
  247. v. Phoenix Assurance [1964.1,
  248. (1972). Workers Participation in Management in Tanzania", mimeo., University of Dar es Salaam,
  249. (1967). Workmen's Compensation Act, doi
  250. (1975). Workmen's Compensation: Law and Practice", a paper presented to the Faculty of Law, University of Dar es Salaam,
  251. (1975). World Trends in Life Insurance (London: Associated Business Programmes, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.