Location of Repository

The role of state and society in response to change in the fishing industry : a comparative study of Britain and France, 1975-1983

By Michael Shackleton


The last decade has seen dramatic changes in the environment facing the\ud fishing industries of Western Europe. This study looks at Britain and\ud France and compares the response of government and industry to those\ud changes between 1975 and 1983. It argues in the opening chapter that\ud that response can be best understood in terms of the nature of the\ud general relations which link state and society in the two countries.\ud Thus France can be characterised as a state-led society, which has\ud generated protectionist forms of economic policy and a 'dirigiste'\ud style of policy making, where the institutions of the state seek\ud actively to determine the way in which an economic sector develops. By\ud contrast, Britain can be seen as a society-led state, in which a\ud liberal conception of economic policy has been matched by a more\ud consensual style of policy-making, where the agents within a sector are\ud left to develop their own individual responses to change. Chapters two\ud to four consider in turn the impact of political and economic change\ud upon the structure of the two industries, the transformation of the\ud international framework of negotiation within which the two governments\ud dealt with the issue and the development of the institutional links\ud between government and the fishing interest. The chapters that follow\ud (five to eight) are organised around four perspectives on the relations\ud between an interest group and government. These are entitled\ud interventionist, mediatory, direct-action and self-help and each\ud stresses a different aspect of the behaviour of state institutions and\ud a societal interest. In all four chapters, the available evidence is\ud assessed in terms of what we might expect that behaviour to be, given\ud the extent of the change that overtook the industry and the political\ud and economic character of the two countries. The final chapter reviews\ud the distinction between a state-led society and a society-led state and\ud suggests two conclusions: firstly, that the pattern of relations\ud between industry and government retained its distinctive shape in the\ud two countries, despite severe pressures and secondly, that any\ud judgement of the relative success of the two states and their\ud respective industries in developing a response to change depends on\ud one's appreciation of the merits of two contrasting political and\ud economic philosophies

Topics: HD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:4036

Suggested articles



  1. (1978). A Case for Aid for Restructuring the Catching Sector,
  2. (1983). A Crime Against the World: Memoirs of a
  3. (1983). A LA MER
  4. (1978). A sea of troubles?: sources of dispute in the new ocean regime, doi
  5. (1980). A selection of debates from the European Parliament, to be found in the Annexes of the Official Journal of the European Communities (OJEC) was also read.
  6. Annuels (for the years 1976-1982). MINISTERE DES TRANSPORTS, Voies - magazine of the ministry.
  7. (1982). Artisanat et Capitalisme, l'Envers de la Roue de l'Histoire, doi
  8. (1974). Big Business and the State, Cambridge, doi
  9. (1981). Big Government in Hard Times, doi
  10. (1976). Blockade '75: the Story of the Fishermen's Blockade of the Ports,
  11. (1976). Britain's Economic Problem: Too Few Producers?, doi
  12. (1973). British fishing and the Iceland saga'
  13. (1984). British Politics in Perspective, Leicester,
  14. (1965). British Politics in the Collectivist Age, doi
  15. (1974). Campaigning for the Environment, doi
  16. (1975). Centripetal Politics,
  17. (1978). Cod Wars and How to Lose them, doi
  18. (1978). Collective arrangements for managing ocean fisheries' doi
  19. (1972). Collective goods and future international collaboration' doi
  20. (1975). Common Property" as a concept in natural resources policy'
  21. (1978). Contribution ä l'Analyse de la
  22. (1981). Crowds and Power, doi
  23. (1972). Direct Action and Democratic Politics, London, George Allen and Unwin.
  24. (1978). Dissentient France: the counter political culture' doi
  25. (1983). Do we really have a Common Fisheries Policy? '
  26. (1983). Domestic politics and European Community policy-making'
  27. (1962). Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective: A book of Essays, doi
  28. (1972). Economic interdependence and foreign policy in the seventies' doi
  29. (1979). Elites in French Society, the Politics of Survival, doi
  30. (1981). Etat de la Flotte des Chalutiers Hauturiers du Sud-Bretagne au Ier Janvier
  31. (1975). Eurogroups, clientela and the European Community' doi
  32. (1972). European Integration,
  33. (1982). Falkland Islands Economic Study
  34. (1977). Federal Solutions to European Issues, doi
  35. (1980). Financial Support to the Fishing Industry, Paris, OECD OECD doi
  36. (1977). Fisheries of the European Community, Fishery Economics Research Unit,
  37. (1975). Fisheries Resources of the Sea and their Management, doi
  38. (1983). Fishing for a policy? The common fisheries policy of the Community'
  39. (1978). Fishing into the 80s -A Discussion Document, prepared by group chaired by J. PRESCOTT and including
  40. (1975). Food From Our Own Resources, Cmnd 6020.
  41. (1973). Foreign Policy and Interdependence in Gaullist France, doi
  42. (1972). Four systems of policy, politics and choice' in Public Administration Review, doi
  43. (1968). France in the Age of the Scientific State, doi
  44. (1982). France in the Troubled World doi
  45. (1979). French administration: sanctified or demystified? ' in doi
  46. (1980). French Politics and Public Policy, doi
  47. (1982). Gerer La Mer', in Les Cahiers Francais, October-December
  48. (1983). Governing France: The One and Indivisible
  49. (1977). How common a fisheries policy? '
  50. (1979). Impact Regional de la Politique de la Peche de la CEE - Bretagne, Informations internes sur la peche.
  51. (1984). In Search of a Common Fisheries Policy,
  52. (1963). In Search of France, doi
  53. (1978). Individualism versus collectivism: economic choices in France' in doi
  54. (1972). Industry Participation in the Administration of the Fishing Industry in France,
  55. (1976). Institutional inertia and political impetus in France and Britain' doi
  56. (1983). Institutions and Policies of the European Community, doi
  57. (1974). Interest groups and political integration' doi
  58. (1961). Interest groups in comparative analysis' doi
  59. (1982). International regimes, transactiots and change: embedded liberalism in the postwar economic order' doi
  60. (1976). International relations and domestic structures: foreign economic policies of advanced industrial states' doi
  61. (1975). International responses to technology' doi
  62. (1976). L'Avenir des Peches Maritimes, presented by
  63. (1981). L'Election Presidentielle 26 avril-10 mai 1981', Supplement aux Dossiers et Documents du Monde,
  64. (1970). L'Etat, doi
  65. (1983). L'Europe bleue' in Regards sur l'Actualite,
  66. (1970). L'industrie des peches brittaniques' in 'Les'activites maritimes du Royaume Uni, de Grande Bretagne et d'Irlande du Nord', doi
  67. (1976). La Crise de l'Industrie des Peches Maritimes en 1975, CCPM, Ecole Nationale Superieur Agronomique de Rennes, Memoire de fin d'etudes.
  68. (1978). La crise des peches maritimes brittaniques' in La Peche
  69. (1975). La crise' in Germes, No. 19, pp 1-27, (review of the French fishing boat owners
  70. (1981). La Droite Absolue,
  71. (1982). La Filiere des Produits de la Mer daps l'Ouest (prepared by M. Bru and B. Simon for DATAR, the regional planning agency.
  72. (1977). La grande peche morutiere francaise' in La Peche doi
  73. (1982). La Logique de 1'Etat, doi
  74. (1976). La peche dans les perspectives economiques de la France' in La Peche Maritime, doi
  75. (1980). La Peche'
  76. (1981). La Peche', doi
  77. (1983). La place de l'artisanat dans la societe francaise: 1'exemple de la peche maritime'in Dossier pour notre temps, Nos.
  78. (1972). La Politique Commune Des Peches, These de Doctorat,
  79. (1981). La situation de la peche aux Iles Kerguelen en 1981' in La Peche Maritime, doi
  80. (1977). Le Grand Metier, journal d'un capitaine de peche ä Fecamp,
  81. (1976). Le Mal Francais, doi
  82. (1977). Le nouveau droit de la mer et ses incidences sur les peches maritimes francaises'
  83. (1976). Legitimation Crisis, doi
  84. (1978). Les Etats et la '. vier-le nationalisme maritimes, Notes et Etudes Documentaires, Nos. 4451-4452, (prepared by L.
  85. (1983). Les groupes d'interet sous la cinquieme republique' doi
  86. (1972). Les Institutions de la Peche Maritime, These pour le Doctorat en Droit,
  87. (1977). Les Peches Maritimes Francaises en
  88. (1967). Les Peches Maritimes, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France Que Sais-Je? doi
  89. (1983). Les pecheurs d'Houat,
  90. (1983). Less than a federation, more than a regime: the Community as a political system' in
  91. (1978). Marine resources and environment'
  92. (1982). Mobilising private interests in the service of public ambitions: the salient element in the dual French policy style? '
  93. (1965). Modern Capitalism, doi
  94. (1977). Modern Capitalist Planning: The French Model, doi
  95. (1969). Nation-states and state-nations' doi
  96. (1974). National aptitudes for planning in Britain, France and Italy' doi
  97. (1966). National economic interest groups and policy formation in the European Economic Community' doi
  98. (1978). New departures in the North Sea' doi
  99. (1981). Note d'Information sur le FIOM.
  100. (1962). Nouvelles Etudes sur les Groupes de Pression, doi
  101. (1977). Oceanic Management: Conflicting Uses of the Celtic Sea and Other doi
  102. (1975). On systems and international regimes' doi
  103. (1977). Organisations de Producteurs des Peches Maritimes en France et Droit Communautaire,
  104. (1981). Organising interaction in Western Europe, Cambridge,
  105. (1970). Overinstitutionalisation and political constraint. The case of France' doi
  106. (1975). Overload: problems of governing in the 1970s' doi
  107. (1975). Pecheurs du Cotentin,
  108. (1981). Perspectives on World Politics, doi
  109. (1980). Pluralism and Corporatism, doi
  110. (1978). Pluralism, corporatism and the role of the state' doi
  111. (1982). Policy Styles in doi
  112. (1979). Political Action : Mass Participation in Five Western Democracies, doi
  113. (1977). Political Strategies for Industrial Order: State, Market, and Industry in France, doi
  114. (1979). Politics in Industrial Society, doi
  115. (1982). Politics, Policy and the European Recession, doi
  116. (1974). Politics, Power and Bureaucracy, doi
  117. (1977). Power and Interdependence, doi
  118. (1972). Pressure groups and the European Economic Community' doi
  119. (1976). Proposals for a United Kingdom Fisheries Policy,
  120. (1911). Rapports d'Activites and Rapports sur la Production (an invaluable source for the years
  121. (1964). Representative and Responsible Government, doi
  122. (1982). Representative Government and Economic Power, doi
  123. (1977). Resource Management at the International Level: The Case of the North doi
  124. (1980). Revision of the EEC's Common Fisheries Policy, ' -
  125. (1980). Revision of the EEC's Common Fisheries Policy' - Part II,
  126. (1970). Revolutionary Syndicalism in France, Cambridge, doi
  127. (1965). sation of the Fish Englands A Researc at Hull College
  128. (1976). Sea Power and the Law of the Sea, doi
  129. (1975). Sea Use Planning, Fabian Tract 437.
  130. (1977). So UNCLOS failed - or did it? "
  131. (1975). Social rules and the state as a social actor' doi
  132. (1972). State intervention in France: the changing style of government-industry relations' doi
  133. (1980). State structure and the assymetrical society'
  134. (1982). Statuts de l'Organisation Professionelle des Peches Maritimes,
  135. (1974). Still the century of corporatism? ' doi
  136. (1974). Sur les rapports d'etre de l'ideologie, les rapports sociaux daps le secteur de la peeche'
  137. (1973). Terms of Entry: Britain's Negotiation with the European Community,
  138. (1983). The Administration of the Fishing Industry in France at Central and Local Level,
  139. (1979). The ambiguous politics of Western Germany' doi
  140. (1982). The British policy style or the logic of negotiation'
  141. (1974). The Challenge of New Territories,
  142. (1979). The changing regime of North Sea fisheries' in
  143. (1971). The Common Fisheries Policy of the Six'
  144. (1983). The Common Fisheries Policy'
  145. (1983). The Common Fisheries Policy'in LODGE,
  146. (1977). The EEC and fishing: new venture into unknown seas' doi
  147. (1977). The EEC fisheries policy - towards a revision' doi
  148. (1979). The Effective Management of Resources,
  149. (1983). The European Community: Bibliographical Excursions,
  150. (1980). The Fifth Republic at Twenty,
  151. (1972). The Fisheries of Europe, doi
  152. (1962). The Fishermen, London, MacGibbon and Kee.
  153. (1973). The Fishing Industry,
  154. (1969). The French experience of modernisation'
  155. (1977). The French state in the international economy' doi
  156. (1978). The Government and Politics of France, doi
  157. (1976). The Humberside Fishing Industry, Report for HM Government,
  158. (1983). The inapplicability of the corporatist model in Britain and France' doi
  159. (1982). The Management and Orga Catching Industry on the North East Coast o Report from the Centre for Fisheries Studie Higher Education.
  160. (1977). The myth of technical expertise: selection, organisation, and leadership' doi
  161. (1977). The New France,
  162. (1975). The new mercantilism in international relations: the case of France's external monetary policy' doi
  163. (1980). The North Sea: A New International Regime? Greenwich Forum V, Records doi
  164. (1975). The North Sea: Challenge and opportunity, Europa for the David Davies Memorial Institute of International Studies. doi
  165. (1974). The North Ships: The Life of a Trawlerman,
  166. (1983). The Parti Communiste Francais And the Confederation G6n6rale du Travail in Contemporary French Politics: A Study of Some Aspects of the Organizations And Their Relationship, D. Phil Thesis, Hilary Term
  167. (1975). The political economy of international marine resources management' doi
  168. (1975). The political geography of the oceans, London, David and Charles.
  169. (1974). The politics of fisheries in the Community'
  170. (1977). The Politics of International Economic Relations, London, George Allen and Unwin.
  171. (1978). The politics of the biosphere: the dynamics of fishing policy'
  172. (1981). The politics of the green pound' doi
  173. (1979). The revitalization of French parties'
  174. (1981). The Role of Interest Groups in the European Community,
  175. (1976). The small maritime community and its resource management problems: a Newfoundland example' in
  176. (1980). The State in doi
  177. (1973). The State in Capitalist Society,
  178. (1980). The State Tradition in
  179. (1973). The World in Depression, doi
  180. (1975). Three models of the future' doi
  181. (1977). Transition in the management and distribution of international fisheries' doi
  182. (1976). Une region dont la population depend etroitement des richesses de la mer: la Bretagne'
  183. (1980). Vers un marche commun de la peche' in Regards sur'l'Actualite,
  184. (1980). Vers une Politique Commune de la Peche dans la Communaute: Fondements Juridiques et Problemes d 'Elaboration, These pour le Doctorat du 3e cycle, Universite de Bordeaux, Faculte de Droit et des Sciences Economiques.
  185. (1980). VIIIe Plan: le dossier de la peche franyaise, in Regards sur l'Actualite,
  186. (1976). Who makes British foreign policy? doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.