Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The histories and structures of custodial interrogation

By Ian Bryan

Abstract

This thesis is concerned with the centrality of the confession as an item of prosecution\ud evidence. It is also concerned with both the structures and strategies that have evolved in\ud the criminal justice system to legitimate the confession and preserve its vitality as\ud evidence probative of guilt.\ud The socio-legal research evaluates the status of records of police interviews within the\ud context of police custodial interrogations of persons suspected of involvement in crime. To\ud this end the thesis examines the extent to which evidence is "constructed"' within a legal\ud framework rather than elicited; how far the 1984 Police and Criminal Evidence Act\ud (PACE) has affected police-suspect relations in interrogations; the circumstances in which\ud suspects "elect" to cooperate with the police or decline to answer specific questions; and\ud the extent to which records of interrogations can be said to be complete, accurate and\ud reliable.\ud The research comprises a number of different methodologies. The first stage involves a\ud historical and case-based analysis of both the development of the use of confession\ud evidence in criminal cases and of the forms of regulation that have been applied over\ud police access to suspects. The investigation centres upon a structural analysis of the\ud relationship between suspects, the police and the courts and examines the value systems\ud which have conditioned the forms of regulation that have evolved.\ud The next stage of the study involves a comparative analysis of the content and form of\ud police interrogations and of the reporting or recording systems relating thereto in a sample\ud of cases drawn from the period prior to the introduction of the PACE Act and from a\ud sample generated following the implementation of the Act. This aspect of the research\ud builds upon conceptual categories developed by psychologists, sociologists and\ud criminologists.\ud This systematic and comparative examination of the interrogation process of the pre-\ud PACE era and the current PACE era is intended as a contribution to the debate\ud surrounding police interview practices and will help resolve contradictory accounts\ud relating to the police role in the criminal justice process. It is, in addition, also intended as\ud a contribution to questions relating not only to the regulation of police powers over\ud suspects but also to those. concerned with the form, nature and structure of the police suspect dynamic and, finally, to those associated with miscarriages of justice

Topics: KD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:4047

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1877) "Suggestions as to the Reform of the Criminal Law",
  2. (1883) A History of the Criminal Law ofEngland, 3 vols.,
  3. (1886) "Prisoners as Witnesses",
  4. (1990). (193 7) Sources of English Constitutional History,
  5. (1989). (I 979b) "The Practice of Judging",
  6. 1) Police in Urban America, 1860-1920, Cambridge: doi
  7. 1) The English Police: A Political and Social History, Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf
  8. 1) The Right to Silence, Aldershot: Avebury
  9. 5) " Cross-Examination by the Prosecution at Common Law and under the Criminal Evidence Act, 1898", 49 Law Quarterly Review,
  10. 5) "Cross-Examination by the Prosecution at Common Law and Under the Criminal Evidence Act, 1898", Law Quarterly Review,
  11. 8 5) Verdict A ccording to Conscience: Perspectives on the English Jury Trial 1200-1800, doi
  12. 9) The History of the Common Law of England, doi
  13. (1896). A Bill for the Protection of Innocent Prisoners",
  14. (1896). A Bill to Promote the Conviction of Innocent Prisoners",
  15. (1966). A History ofPolice in England and
  16. (1966). A Matter of Conviction",
  17. (1980). A Modern Legal History ofEngland and Wales 1750-1950,
  18. (1964). A Police Officer doi
  19. (1984). A Poor Man's System of Justice: The London Police Courts doi
  20. (1967). A postscript to the Miranda project: Interrogation of draft protesters", doi
  21. (1898). A Preliminary Treatise on Evidence at the Common Law, doi
  22. (1837). A Reading on the Use of Torture in the Criminal Law of England,
  23. (1988). A Retrospective in the Criminal Trial Jury, 1200-1800", doi
  24. (1966). A Social History of English Law, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
  25. (1970). A Theory of Police Reaction to Miranda v.
  26. (1825). A Treatise on Judicial Evidence, 2 vols., extracted from the manuscripts of Jeremy Bentham by Dumount,
  27. (1940). A Treatise on the Anglo-American System of Evidence in Trials at doi
  28. (1973). A Very Wicked Animal Defends the 1 Ith Report of the Criminal Law Revision Committee", Criminal Law Review,
  29. (1981). a) "Balance and clarity: has the Royal Commission achieved them? ",
  30. (1963). Abolition of the Right Not to be Questioned",
  31. (1972). Access to a solicitor in the police station",
  32. (1938). Admissibility of Statements made by Accused Persons",
  33. (1965). Adverse Inferences from Failure of an Accused Person to Testify", Criminal Law Review,
  34. (1989). Advice and Assistance at Police Stations and the 24 Hour Duty Solicitor Scheme,
  35. (1982). Albion's Fatal Flaws", doi
  36. (1972). An Examination of the Judges'
  37. (1964). An Historical Argument for the Right to Counsel During Police Interrogation", 73 Yale Law Journal, doi
  38. (1979). An Introduction to English Legal History, 2nd edn.,
  39. (1990). An Introduction to English Legal History, 3rd edn.,
  40. (1962). Anglo-Saxon England and the Norman Conquest, doi
  41. (1963). Appeal Inquiry
  42. (1936). Attack of the Common Lawyers on the Oath ex officio as Administered in the Ecclesiastical Courts of England",
  43. (1957). Battlefor the Mind,
  44. (1993). Bent Coppers: A Survey ofPolice Corruption,
  45. (1971). Beyond Breaking Point. - A Study of Techniques of Interrogation, doi
  46. (1978). Beyond the Limits of the Law: a comparative study of the police in crisis politics,
  47. (1935). Cautions", 99 Justice of the Peace and Local Government Review,
  48. (1981). Challenging Police Evidence of Interviews and the Second Limb of Section I (f) (ii) - Another View", Criminal Law Review,
  49. (1990). Changes in Custody Practice Since the Introduction of the Police
  50. (1975). Civil Liberties in Britain,
  51. (1989). Coming to terms with policing,
  52. (1765). Commentaries on the Laws ofEngland, 4 vols.
  53. (1962). Commission on the Police, doi
  54. (1991). Common Sense, Legal Advice and the Right of Silence", doi
  55. (1956). Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies", doi
  56. (1979). Confessions and the Doctrine of Oppression ",
  57. (1968). Confessions and the Social Psychology of Coercion", doi
  58. (1980). Confessions in Crown Court Trials, Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure,
  59. (1964). Confessions in the Criminal Law",
  60. (1980). Confessions: The Dubious Fruits of Police Interrogation",
  61. (1987). Constructing the Case for the Prosecution", doi
  62. (1983). Control in the Police Organisation, doi
  63. (1983). Controlling the English prosecutor",
  64. (1993). Corroboration and Confessions. The impact of a rule requiring that no conviction can be sustained on the basis of confession evidence alone,
  65. (1977). Crime and Authority in
  66. (1973). Crime and Public Order
  67. (1987). Crime and Society in
  68. (1986). Crime and the Courts in England 1600-1800, doi
  69. (1990). Crime, authority and the policeman-state", doi
  70. (1977). Criminal Courts and Procedure at Common Law",
  71. (1980). Criminal Due Process, the Pre-Trial Stage and SelfIncrimination",
  72. (1962). Criminal Interrogation and Confessions, 2nd edn., doi
  73. (1978). Criminal Justice and Punishment",
  74. (1965). Criminal Justice in Our Time, doi
  75. (1967). Criminal Justice,
  76. (1984). Criminal Law and Society
  77. (1973). Criminal Law Revision Committee Ilth Report, doi
  78. (1972). Criminal Law Revision Committee's Eleventh Report: Some Comments", Criminal Law Review,
  79. (1990). Cross on Evidence, 7th edn. London: Butterworths.
  80. (1981). Cross-Examination of the Accused on his Record when a Confession is Denied or Retracted", Criminal Law Review,
  81. (1993). Custodial Advice and the Right to Silence,
  82. (1978). Defects in Prosecuting - Professional views in 1845",
  83. (1976). Defendants in the Criminal Process, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. doi
  84. (1973). Defendants Who Fail to Give Evidence", 36 Modern Law Review,
  85. (1989). Detention at the Police Station Under the PACE Act,
  86. (1977). Discipline and Punish: doi
  87. (1973). Domesday Book: A Guide, doi
  88. (1977). Due Process and Slow Process in the Late Elizabethan - Early Stuart Star Charnber" doi
  89. (1979). Due Process ofLaw,
  90. (1924). Early Treatises on the practice of doi
  91. (1972). Enforcing the Law, doi
  92. (1992). Evidence and the Adversarial Process. - The Modern Law, doi
  93. (1955). Evidence Obtained by Illegal Means",
  94. (1973). Evidentlary Barriers to Conviction and Two Models of Criminal Procedure: A Comparative Study",
  95. (1977). Excluding evidence as Protecting Rights", doi
  96. (1979). Eyewitness Accounts of Females and Males", doi
  97. (1956). Fundamentals of Criminal Investigation, 2nd edn.,
  98. (1942). Further problems in the interpretation of the Criminal Evidence Act,
  99. (1980). Fuzzy Thoughts: The Police and Law-and-Order Politics", 28 (2) Sociological Review, doi
  100. (1989). Good Men to Associate and Bad Men to Conspire: Associations for the Prosecution -of Felons in England, 1750-1850",
  101. (1956). Historical Background and Implications of the Privilege Against SelfIncrimination",
  102. (1966). Imputations on the Character of Prosecution Witnesses", doi
  103. (1986). In Defence of a Voluntariness Doctrine for Confessions: The Queen v. Johnston Revisited",
  104. (1983). Inside the British Police: A Force at Work, doi
  105. (1989). Interrogating in a legal framework",
  106. (1976). Interrogation", Police Review (No.
  107. (1988). Introducing Policework, doi
  108. (1963). Involuntary Confessions and Illegally Obtained Evidence in Criminal Cases - 2".
  109. (1963). Involuntary Confessions and Illegally Obtained Evidence in Criminal Cases -I",
  110. (1983). Judicial Discretion in Relation to Confessions", 3 doi
  111. (1988). Juries and the Middling Sort: Recruitment and Performance at Devon Quarter Sessions, 1649-4670", doi
  112. (1988). Juror Attitudes toward Local Disorder: The Evidence of the 1328 Trailbaston Proceedings", doi
  113. (1988). Lawless Juries? The Composition and Behaviour of Hertfordshire Juries, 1573-162411, doi
  114. (1986). Leading questions and the police interview",
  115. (1934). Legal Interrogation of Persons Accused or Suspected of Crime", doi
  116. (1959). Letters to the Editor", Criminal Law Review,
  117. (1973). Minority Verdict, the 1973 Dimbleby Lecture,
  118. (1987). Miscarriages ofJustice,
  119. (1977). Negotiated Justice: Pressures to Plead Guilty, doi
  120. (1994). Normalising Justice: The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice", doi
  121. (1977). On the psychology of eyewitness testimony", doi
  122. (1911). Origin of the petty jury", 27 Law Quarterly Review,
  123. (1968). Origins of the Fifth Amendment: the Right Against Self-Incrimination, doi
  124. (1979). Police and People: The Birth of Mr Peel's 'Blue Locusts"',
  125. (1994). Police Interrogation and Social Control", 3 (1) Social and Legal Studies, doi
  126. (1966). Police Interrogation and the Privilege Against Self-Incrimination", doi
  127. (1979). Police Interrogation and the Right to see a Solicitor", Criminal Law Review,,
  128. (1985). Police Interrogation and the Right to Silence",
  129. (1961). Police Interrogation in England"
  130. (1987). Police Interrogation, a handbookfor investigators, London: Police Review,
  131. (1987). Police Interrogation; the effects of PACE",
  132. (1980). Police Interrogation: An Observational Study in Four Police Stations, doi
  133. (1980). Police Interrogation: Review of Literature,
  134. (1989). Police Interrogation: The Effects of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act
  135. (1980). Police Interrogation: The Ps hological Approach,
  136. (1970). Police Interrogation"
  137. (1965). Police Interrogation" 5 Sydney Law Review,
  138. (1967). Police Powers - IV. Questioning: A General View",
  139. (1982). Police Powers and Politics, doi
  140. (1988). Police Powers and Public Prosecutions: Winning By Appearing To Lose?
  141. (1975). Police Powers in England and doi
  142. (1977). Police Work The Social Organisation of Policing, doi
  143. (1978). Police",
  144. (1977). Policing a Perplexed Society, doi
  145. (1979). Policing in Modem Britain",
  146. (1979). Policing the Working Class City",
  147. (1991). Politics, Research and Symbolism in Criminal Justice: The Right of Silence and the Police and Criminal Evidence Act",
  148. (1816). Practical Treatise on the Criminal Law, 4 vols, London: Valpy.
  149. (1985). Pre-Trial Justice: A Study of Case Settlement in Magistrates' Courts,, doi
  150. (1976). Pre-trial Procedures and the Construction of Conviction",
  151. (1956). Privilege Against Self-Incrimination", doi
  152. (1975). Property, authority and the criminal law", in
  153. (1984). Prosecuting Criminal Cases in England and Wales: Reflections of an Inquisitorial Adversary", doi
  154. (1957). Protectionftom Power Under English Law,
  155. (1974). Public Prosecutions in England and Wales", Criminal Law Review,
  156. (1960). Questioning by the Police: Some Further Points - 2", Criminal Law Review,
  157. (1960). Questioning by the Police: Some Practical Considerations", Criminal Law Review, 325. r1-,
  158. (1982). Questioning Freedom: Detention for Questioning in France, Scotland and England", doi
  159. (1967). Questioning: A Comment",
  160. (1827). Rationale ofJudicial Evidence, published under the superintendence of John Bowring in The Works ofJeremy
  161. (1982). Recent Developments in English Criminal Justice and the Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure",
  162. (1983). Recording the Interrogation: Have the Police got it Taped? ",
  163. (1988). Regulating Custodial Interviews, London: Police Foundation.
  164. Report of an Inquiry by the Bon. Henry Fisher into the circumstances leading to the trial of three persons on charges arising out of the death of Maxwell Confait and the Fire at 27 Doggett Road, London SE6,1977,
  165. Report of an Inquiry by the Hon. Mr Justice Brabin into the case of Timothy John
  166. Report of the Royal Commission on doi
  167. Report of the Royal Commission upon the Duties of the Metropolitan Police,
  168. (1976). Report to the Secretary of State for the Home Department of the Departmental Committee on Evidence on Identification in Criminal Cases,
  169. (1988). Retracted Confessions: legal, psychological and psychiatric aspects",
  170. (1972). Revision Committee, Eleventh Report, Evidence (Generao Cmnd. doi
  171. (1993). Royal Commission on Criminal Justice, doi
  172. (1981). Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure, doi
  173. (1990). Safeguarding the rights of suspects in police custody", 1 (2) Policing and Society, doi
  174. (1979). Seýf-Incrimination in the Canadian Criminal Process,
  175. (1983). Shaping the Eighteenth-Century Criminal Trial, A View from the Ryder Sources", doi
  176. (1973). Silence and Confessions - What are they worth? ",
  177. (1973). Society and the Policeman's Role, doi
  178. (1986). Some Observations on the Parliamentary History of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act
  179. Sott Henderson QC, of an Inquiry into Certain Matters arising out of the Deaths ofMrs Beryl Evans and of Geraldine Evans and out of the Conviction of Timothy John Evans of the Murder of Geraldine Evans,
  180. (1994). Standing A ccused: The Organisation of Criminal Defence Lawyers in Britain, doi
  181. (1980). Taking the Fifth,
  182. (1972). Testimonial validity as a function of question form, atmosphere, and item difficulty", doi
  183. (1964). The doi
  184. (1947). The Admissibility of Confessions in Criminal Cases", 25 Canadian Bar Review,
  185. (1985). The Admissibility of Defence Counsel in English Criminal Procedure", doi
  186. (1979). The Authentication of Statements to the Police",
  187. (1973). The Birth of the English Common Law, 2nd edn., 1988, Cambridge: doi
  188. (1993). The Changing Face of Police Interrogation", doi
  189. (1979). The Changing Image of the Magistracy,
  190. (1988). The Class Composition of the Palladium of Liberty: doi
  191. (1974). The CLRC Evidence Report -A Survey of Reactions", 71 Law Society's Gazette,
  192. (1939). The Colonial and Constitutional History of the Privilege against SelfIncrimination in America", 21 Virginia Law Review, doi
  193. (1974). The Compulsory Process Clause", doi
  194. (1992). The Conduct and Supervision of Criminal Investigations,
  195. (1993). The Conduct ofPolice Interviews with Juveniles,
  196. (1987). The Confait Confessions",
  197. (1983). The Confait Inheritance -
  198. (1908). The Constitutional History of England, doi
  199. (1913). The Court of Star Charnber",
  200. (1985). The Court ofStar Chamber and its Records to the Reign ofElizabeth 1,
  201. (1960). The Criminal Prosecution in doi
  202. (1968). The Criminal Suspect's Illusory Right
  203. (1973). The Criminal Suspect's Right to Silence: A Hallowed Shibboleth",
  204. (1983). The Criminal Twilight Zone: Pre-Trial Procedures in the 1840s", 21 (1) Alberta Law Review,
  205. (1966). The Defendant's Rights Under English Law, doi
  206. (1967). The Demand for Order in Civil Society: A Review of Some Themes in the History of Urban Crime, Police and Riot",
  207. (1935). The Development of Present-Day Criminal doi
  208. (1983). The Early Development of the Pein Forte et Dure",
  209. (1990). The Early Development of the Privilege against SelfIncrimination", 10 doi
  210. (1988). The Early-Thirteenth-Century Criminal Jury", doi
  211. (1992). The Effects of Case Characteristics on Suspect Behaviour During Police Questioning", 32 doi
  212. (1988). The Effects of the PACE Provisions in Detention and Questioning",
  213. (1987). The emergence of the police: the colonial dimension",
  214. (1976). The English Legal System, 4th edn.
  215. (1967). The English Magistracy, London:
  216. (1978). The Fisher Report on the Confait Case: Four Issues", 41 Modern Law Review,
  217. (1986). The Governance of the doi
  218. (1977). The History and Practice of the Political Police in doi
  219. (1898). The History ofEnglish Law Before the Time of Edward 1,2 vols., (2nd edn., 1911) Cambridge:
  220. (1970). The Interrogation of Suspects" 48 Canadian Bar Review,
  221. (1979). The investigation of crime: a study of cases tried at the Old Bailey", Criminal Law Review,
  222. (1982). The Judge, Discretion and the Criminal Trial,
  223. (1966). The Judges' Rules and Police Interrogation in England and Wales", doi
  224. (1964). The Judges' Rules"
  225. (1964). The JudgesRules",
  226. (1897). The Judicial Use of Torture", parts I and 11,11 Harvard Law Review, doi
  227. (1941). The Jury of Presentment and the Assize of Clarendon", doi
  228. (1968). The JurY, London:
  229. (1823). The Justice of the Peace and Parish Officer, 23rd edn., with "Supplement" by Chetwynd,
  230. (1969). The Justice of the Peace, doi
  231. (1760). The Law ofEvidence by a Late Learned Judge, 2nd edn.
  232. (1948). The Legal Limitation of the Interrogation of Suspects and Prisoners in ng and and Wales", doi
  233. (1968). The Limits of the Criminal Sanction, Stanford: doi
  234. (1988). The Limits to Diversion From Prosecution",
  235. (1967). The Machinery ofJustice in England, 5th edn., Cambridge:
  236. (1977). The Making of English Law: (3) The Reign of Mary Tudor",
  237. (1979). The Metropolitan Police and the News Media",
  238. (1914). The Modem View of Confessions",
  239. (1977). The Nature and Incidence of Crime in England 1559-1625: A Preliminary Survey",
  240. (1964). The New Judges'Rules -A Lawyer's View", Criminal Law Review,
  241. (1966). The Normans, doi
  242. (1975). The Plague of Blue Locusts: Police Reform and Popular Resistance
  243. (1985). The Police and Criminal Evidence Act doi
  244. (1990). The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984,2nd edn.,
  245. (1966). The Police in a Changing Society", doi
  246. (1979). The Police in Society, London: Eyre Methuen. 460 Wigmore,
  247. (1985). The Police ofBritain,
  248. (1986). The Police, doi
  249. (1982). The Police: Autonomy and Consent, doi
  250. (1976). The Policeman as Domestic Missionary: Urban Discipline and Popular Culture in doi
  251. (1983). The Politicization of the Police in Britain",
  252. (1985). The Politics of the Police, doi
  253. (1977). The Principle of Utility and the law of procedure: Bentham's theory of adjudication",
  254. (1989). The Principles of Criminal Evidence, doi
  255. (1902). The Privilege Against Self-Incrimination; Its History", 15 Harvard Law Review, doi
  256. (1958). The Privilege against Self-Incrimination: How Did It Originate", 31 Temple Law Quarterly,
  257. (1949). The privilege against self-incrimination", doi
  258. (1992). The Psychology ofInterrogations, Confessions and Testimony, doi
  259. (1984). The Purpose Behind an Arrest",
  260. (1981). The Purpose of Cross-Examination Under Section I (f) of the Criminal Evidence Act 1898", Criminal Law Review, doi
  261. (1953). The Queen's Peace,
  262. (1979). The Queen's Peace: The origins and development of the Metropolitan Police 1829-1979,
  263. (1991). The questioning code revamped",
  264. (1964). The Revised Judges' Rules",
  265. (1955). The Right to Counsel in American Courts, doi
  266. (1977). The Right to Remain Silent",
  267. (1970). The Right to Silence and the Presumption of Innocence - Sacred Cows or Safeguards of Liberty? ",
  268. (1994). The Right to Silence, Defence Disclosure, and Confession Evidence", doi
  269. (1969). The Rights of the Accused and the
  270. (1913). The Rise and Fall of the High Commission, doi
  271. (1992). The role of legal representatives at the police station,
  272. (1938). The Scope of Privilege in the Law of Evidence",
  273. (1979). The Self-Incrimination Debate in Great Britain", doi
  274. (1960). The State and the Accused: Balanceof Advantage in Criminal Procedure". doi
  275. (1985). The State of the Police, doi
  276. (1970). The Struggle to Make the Accused Competent in England and Canada",
  277. (1975). To Combat Verbals",
  278. (1985). Torture, doi
  279. (1985). Trial by Jury: Social and Psychological Dynamics,
  280. (1979). Trial by Jury: the Thirteenth-Century Crisis in Criminal Procedure",
  281. (1978). Trial by the Book? Fact and Theory in the Criminal Process, 1558-1625".
  282. (1928). Tribunal ofInquiry in Regard to the Interrogation by the Police ofMiss Savidge
  283. (1964). Two Models of the Criminal Process", doi
  284. (1980). Uncovering Crime: The Police Role,
  285. (1953). Unsworn Statements by Accused Persons",
  286. (1989). Using the Criminal Law, 1750-1850: Policing, Private Prosecution, and the State", doi
  287. (1992). Videotaping interrogations: Police behaviour on and off camera",
  288. (1903). vols. London :
  289. (1979). Voluntariness, Free Will and the Law of Confessions", 65 Virginia Law Review, doi
  290. (1983). White Law: Racism in the Police, Courts and Prisons,
  291. (1975). Wigs and Hunters: The Origin of the Black Act,
  292. (1964). William the Conqueror: The Norman Impact Upon doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.