Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Influence and infection : Georges Bataille and the fate of critique

By Colin Dibben


The thesis argues for the pertinence of the Kantian 'topography' of the mental\ud faculties and the power of critical thought in assessing the philosophical\ud importance of Georges Bataille' s writing. Such an argument runs counter to\ud the received tradition of interpretation of Bataille's work, which has, given\ud the influence of Derrida, construed these texts as works of phenomenological\ud philosophy. The thesis shows that Derrida's interpretation must, by virtue\ud of its exclusivity, be incorrect. Bataille is concerned with the trajectory\ud of thought - that is with the dynamics or energetics of thought - rather than\ud with the articulation of the logic of representation, an articulation which\ud characterises phenomenological thinking. The thesis argues that Bataille's\ud concern with the energetics of thought represents an extension of Kant's\ud critical project. This relation is borne out by the new uses to which he puts\ud the Kantian terminology of continuity, transcendence, subjectivity and\ud communication. Rather than simply exaggerating the power of critique, which\ud Kant countenanced as an influence on the mental processes, Bataille dissolves\ud the critical difference and fuses the status of all thought with its energetic\ud and thermic trajectory. For Bataille, thought is associated with the free\ud contagions or infections of thermic communication. Thus Bataille's relation\ud to Kojeve and Hegel is -only part of a wider move in designating the energetic\ud nature of critique over and above its restricted and conceptual uses.\ud Critique does not survive this definition. The thesis shows the nature of the\ud critical project as it is articulated by Kant in the critiques of pure reason\ud and judgement and how Bataille's major concepts come to inhabit this terrain\ud whilst subjecting themselves and it to the dissolution which is the result of\ud the rational groundlessness of critique. Bataille's treatment of this\ud topography shows that it can be used to infer the attributes of a philosophy\ud of intensities and change

Topics: B1
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1961). 206-Introduction: INFWENCE AND lNFECITON 1. referred to in "A short history of astronomy" by Arthur Berry (Dover,
  2. 3. in 'Critique' doi
  3. (1985). 36 "Qu' I • est ce que a philosophie" p 48 37. see p 97ff 38. see p 120 and "The philosophy of material nature" by Inmanuel Kant
  4. (1981). Beyond the pleasure principle' by Sigmund Freud in "On Metapsychology" Vol 11 Penguin Freud Library (Penguin 1991) -207';' 10. ''Positions'' by Jacques Derrida (Athlone
  5. (1984). Beyond the pleasure principle' by Sigmund Freud in Penguin Freud Library Vol 11 (Penguin doi
  6. (1929). Critique of Pure Reason" by Inmanuel
  7. (1963). Critique' Tome 1 1946 91ff, 325ff, 458ff, 558ff; Tome 2 268ff; Tome 3 1947 259ff, 546ff; Tome 6 1949-50 70ff 9. 'First confrontations with Hegel' in 'Critique'
  8. (1967). Fntretiens avec le professeur yt' by LF Ce1.ine "Oeuvres de LF Ce1.ine" Vol 3 (Andre Ballard
  9. Ko j eve's course broke me, crushed me, killed me ten times over."
  10. (1980). Modem French Philosophy" by Vincent Descanbes (Cambridge Univ Press
  11. (1966). referred to in "Science since 1500" by
  12. (1974). see ''The Gay Science" by Friedrich Nietzsche (Vintage
  13. (1927). The critique of judgement" by Intnanuel Kant (Oxford Clarendon 1952) trans JC Meredith 3. ''TIle critique of pure reason" by Intnanuel
  14. (1977). The Phenanenology of Spirit" by GWF Hegel (Oxford Univ Pres
  15. (1961). Thus spake Zarathustra" by Friedrich Nietzsche (Penguin doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.