Location of Repository

Regionalism and foreign policy:China-Vietnam relations and institution-building in the Greater Mekong Subregion

By Oliver Michael Hensengerth

Abstract

This study is concerned with the institution-building and capacity-building of the Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) and its interactions with the foreign policies of member states, exemplified by the foreign policies of China and Vietnam.\ud \ud The structure of the GMS includes not only central governments, but also subnational units (provincial governments) and non-state actors (NGOs, firms). The\ud involvement of actors other than the central government is due to the transnationalisation of issues such as poverty and environmental degradation. This also put central government departments other than the foreign ministry on the foreign policy scene, such as the ministries of trade, environment or public security. As transnational problems cannot be solved within the domestic context only, domestic policy demands have come to inform foreign policy decisions, which relate directly to transnational subregional concerns, such as integrating the local economies of China's west and Vietnam's north into the subregion in order to tackle widespread poverty in these regions.\ud \ud A result of this diversification and proliferation of actors in the GMS is a system of committee governance, which is not based on rules but on norins. Although still dominated by central governments, it is nevertheless stable as it has led to a regular exchange of information and enhanced transparency and predictability of policies and priorities of member states. This contradicts the premise of international regimes, namely that cooperation can only be stable if legally-binding rules are introduced.\ud \ud However, for central governments - exemplified by China and Vietnam - GMS cooperation also has a global dimension. Central governments aim at using the institution of the GMS in order to attain foreign policy goals, which go beyond the\ud specific transnational concerns of subregional cooperation. Here, Vietnam and China have devised foreign policies, which - due to the traditional antagonism - have\ud resulted in opposed aims towards the GMS, leaving the institution little space for the development of an independent capacity, which could in turn structure the bilateral relations between China and Vietnam.\ud \ud As a result, we can observe in the GMS in general and in the Chinese-Vietnamese border regions in particular a mix between the Westphalian and the post-Westphalian international system: although central governments are the\ud dominant decision-making authorities and set the framework for actions of provincial governments and NGOs, subnational units and non-state actors are increasingly active in forming a transnational substructure in the GMS. In the\ud Chinese-Vietnamese border regions this is manifested by, for instance, locally implemented central agreements (provincial governments), cross-border financed\ud infrastructure projects (firms) and youth exchanges of provincial party committees. The fact, however, that central governments dominate the cooperation structure\ud gives the GMS no independent institutional capacity with which it could soften the antagonism between China and Vietnam. As a result, the asymmetry between China and Vietnam remains essentially unaffected by the GMS, a situation, which thwarts hopes of Vietnam to make China's foreign policy less assertive through cooperation\ud in the GMS

Publisher: East Asian Studies (Leeds)
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:224

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2003b), 'Sub-regional Co-operation in the Mekong Valley: Implications for Regional Security, '
  2. (2006). 13 Ih Ministerial Meeting Greater Mekong Subregion Program of Economic Cooperation (GMSProgranz), online at http: //w, vv%v. adb. org/Documents/Events/2004/1 3th-MinisterialMeeting/default. asp (last accessed 17
  3. (1965). 77ie Coi)nnunist Conquest of China: A History of the Civil War 1945-1949. Translated from the French by Timothy Osato and Louis Gelas doi
  4. (1967). 7he ASEAN Declaration (Bangkok Declaration), concluded in Thailand, doi
  5. (2000). A New Course for Water Policy, '
  6. (2003). A Vietnamese Leader's Vision, ' interview with Vietnam's Prime Minister Phan Van Khai
  7. (1985). Achieving Cooperation under Anarchy: Strategies and Institutions, ' doi
  8. (2002). Against Ballistic Missile Proliferation (or Hague International Code of Conduct Against Ballistic Missile Proliferation), concluded in
  9. (1966). Agreement Establishing the Asian Development Bank (ADB Charter, in effect since 22
  10. (2003). AKP/01), 'Premier Hun Sen leaves for fourcountry summit in Myanmar' (contains Bagan Declaration).
  11. (2004). AKP/03), 'Cambodia Display Products At ASEAN Trade Fair in Hanoi. '
  12. (1992). An Agenda for Peace: Preventive diplomacy, peacemaking and peace-keeping. Report of the Secretary-General purstiant to the statement adopted by the doi
  13. (2004). An unquenchable thirst, doi
  14. (2002). ASEAN-United States of America Joint Declaration for Cooperation to Conibat International Terrorisin, Bandar Seri Begawan,
  15. (2003). ASEAN's Diplomatic and Security Culture: Origins, developments andprospects (London: RoutledgeCurzon,
  16. (2002). Aus Bombenkratern aufgebaut, ' interview with Vietnam's Prime Minister Phan Van Khai in Der Spiegel,
  17. Ausw5rtiges Amt (2004), Ubersicht fiber die Infrastrukturprojekte in der Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) (no place)
  18. (1995). Bangkok Summit Declaration of doi
  19. (1996). Basic Framework of 4SE. 4N-Mekong Basin Development Cooperation, concluded in Kuala Lumpur,
  20. (1979). BBC Staninary of World Broadcasts, Far East (17 February 1979b), TRC Foreign Ministry Note of Vietnamese Encroachments, ' quoted from Xinhua (New China News Agency,
  21. (1992). BBC Sununary of World Broadcasts,
  22. (1997). Beijing, Hanoi to Boost Transport Cooperation, ' quoted from Xinhua (in
  23. (1995). Cainbodia: The Legacy and Lessons of UNTAC (Oxford: doi
  24. Cam Ranh Bay Manoeuvres, '
  25. (1996). Chairman's Statement of the Asia-Europe Meeting, Bangkok, 2 March, online at http: //europa. eu. int/comm/extemal relations/asem/asern summits/aseml. htm (last accessed 17
  26. (1990). Charter of Parisfor a Neiv Europe, concluded
  27. (2005). China accused of inciting gas row', online at http: //neWs.
  28. (1986). China and Vietnam: The Roots of Conflict (Berkeley: doi
  29. (2005). China apologises for river spill, ' online at http: //news.
  30. (2005). China dam firm to stop some work, ' online at http: //news.
  31. (2005). China Passes U. S. in Trade with Japan:
  32. (2005). China suspends 26 power projects, ' online at http: //news.
  33. (2004). China-Vietnam Relations Moving Towards Pragmatism.
  34. (2005). China, America and Southeast Asia, ' doi
  35. (2000). China's National Defense in 2000, white paper, Beijing: Infonnation Office of the State Council of the People's Republic of China, doi
  36. (2002). China's National Defense in 2002, white paper, Beijing: Information Office of the State Council of the People's Republic of China, doi
  37. (2005). Chinese dam finn "defies Beijing", ' online at http: //news.
  38. (1979). Chinese Government Authorizes Statement on Counter-Attack, ' quoted from Xinhua (New China News Agency,
  39. (2000). Chronology of Key Events, ' 3d Quarter 2000. -302-Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, The Foreign Affairs and National Defense Division
  40. (1990). Cooperation among Nations: Europe, America, and the Non-tariffBarriers to Trade (Ithaca and London: doi
  41. (2002). Create Together a Fine Future for Sino-Vietnamese Relations. ' Jiang Zemin's speech at Hanoi National University,
  42. (2002). Cross-Border Regionalism through a Southeast Asian Looking-Glass, ' doi
  43. (1995). Crossing the Boundaries between Public and
  44. (2005). Dams back in fashion,
  45. (2001). Declaration on Joint Action to Combat International Terrorisin,
  46. (2002). Declaration on Terrorism by the 8
  47. (1995). Defining the "Asia Pacific Region", '
  48. (1997). Die ASEAN: Bilanz eines Erfolges: Aktetire, Interessenlagen,
  49. (1997). Die Gruppe von Lissabon doi
  50. (2002). Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook, doi
  51. (1989). Do Regimes Matter? doi
  52. (1996). Economic Cooperation in the Greater Mekong Subregion: Facing the Challenges, doi
  53. (1994). Economic Cooperation in the Greater Mekong Subregion: TowardImplementation, doi
  54. (1992). Economic Revieiv
  55. (1958). Econondc Review
  56. (2001). Eigene Dolmetscher sind mehr als Übersetzer, '
  57. (2005). Embassy of the People's Republic of China in doi
  58. (2004). Erzwungene Umarmung, ` in Die Zeit, online version at httl2: //zeus. zeit. de/text/2004/49/asean (last accessed 17
  59. (2000). Experiences in the establishment and Operation of the Brunei Darussalam-Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines-East ASEAN growth -304-area (BIMP-EAGA) initiative, '
  60. (1998). Force and Diplomacy: China prepares for the TwentyFirst Century, '
  61. (1995). Foreign Direct Investment, Institutional Change, and Vietnam's Gradualist Approach to Reform, ' doi
  62. (1999). Fragmented Integration in the Singapore-Indonesian Border Zone: Southeast Asia's "Growth -306-Triangle" Against the Global Economy, ' doi
  63. (1992). Framework Agreement On Enhancing doi
  64. (2000). Friend or Foe?, '
  65. (2005). Global Intelligence Challenges 2005: Meeting Long-Term Challenges with a Long-Terin Strategy.
  66. (1999). Globalization and the New Regionalism: The Second Great Transfonnation, '
  67. (2006). GMS Summit: Making It Happen: A Common Strategy on Cooperation for Growth, Equity and Prosperity for the Greater Mekong Subregion, online at http: //, %vNV%v. adb. org/Documents/Events/Mekong/2002/summit. asp (last accessed 17
  68. (2006). Greater Mekong Subregion: Eleventh Ministerial Conference on Subregional Cooperation, online at i, "vw. adb. org/Documents/Events/MekonWProceedings/minl Lasp (last accessed 17
  69. (2001). Greater Mekong Subregion: Tenth Ministerial Conference on Subregional Cooperation, online at Nv-, vw. adb. org/Documents/Events/Mekonv--/Proceedings/minI0. asp (last accessed 17
  70. (2003). Greater Mekong Subregion: Tivel(th Ministerial Conference on Subregional Economic Cooperation, online at www. adb. org/Documents/Events/Mekong/Proceedings/min 12. asp (last accessed 17
  71. (2000). Growth Zones: An Overview, Examples and Conceptual Framework, '
  72. (1997). Guangxi: Towards Southwest China and Southeast Asia, '
  73. (2005). Hu says China's rise "peacefal", ' online at http: //news.
  74. (2004). India, Asean ready to reap early harvest, ' online at http: //economictimes. indiatimes. com/articleshoNv/841684. cms (last accessed 17
  75. (1995). Introduction, '
  76. (1995). Introduction: Reading the Chinese Tea Leaves, ' in Stuart Harris and Gary Klintworth, China as a Great Power: Myths, Realities and Challenges in the Asia-Pacific Region (Melbourne: doi
  77. (2005). Japan history texts anger E Asia, ' online at http: //news.
  78. (2005). Japan presses China on gas fields, ' online at http: //news.
  79. (2005). Japan protests at China gas move', online at http: //neWs.
  80. (2005). Last-ditch attempt to stop Laos dam project, ' in Ae Straits Times,
  81. (1993). Localizing Foreign Policy: Non-Central Governinents and MultilayeredDiplontacy doi
  82. (2000). National Interests and Multilateral Cooperation:
  83. (2005). One Chapter Ends, doi
  84. (2002). online at bttp: H-vv%vw. aseansee. org/13163. htm (last accessed 17
  85. (1998). Opening the Lancang (Mekong) River in Yunnan: Problems and Prospects for Xishuangbanna, MA thesis presented to the
  86. (2004). Paper prepared for the Vietnam Update Conference
  87. (1987). Protocol Amending the Treaty of Amity and Cooperation
  88. (1999). Pulled Two Ways, '
  89. (2004). Re-building the Ancient Silk Road, ' in Zhonggito Ribao (China Daily),
  90. (2005). Regional Cooperation Strategy and Program Update, 2006-2008: The Greater Mekong Subregion: Beyond Borders.
  91. (1993). River of Promise, '
  92. (2006). Second GMS Summit, online at http: //v; w%v. adb. org/Documents/Events/2005/2nd-GMS-Summit/default. asp (last accessed 17
  93. (2000). Sensitive Political and Security Implications of the Greater Mekong Subregion in Southeast Asia, '
  94. (1993). Shadow Play, ' in Far Eastenz Economic Revieiv,
  95. (2004). Shame on the summiteers,
  96. (2003). Sino-Vietnamese Relations in the Early 21st Century. Paper prepared for the I" Annual Conference of the Asian Scholarship Foundation,
  97. (1999). Sino-Vietnamese Relations: Past, Present and Future, '
  98. (1997). SinoVietnamese Border Control Talks Reported, ' quoted from Voice of Vietnain external service of 19
  99. (2005). Soft touch at the helm to check nationalism, ' in The Straits Times,
  100. (1994). Subregional Econoinic Cooperation Aniong Cainbodia, People's Republic of China, Lao People's Democratic
  101. (1993). Subregional Economic Cooperation: Initial Possibilities for Cambodia,
  102. (1993). Subregional Economic Zones: A New Motive Force in Asia-Pacific Development, '
  103. (1969). Symbolic Interactiollisl)j: Perspective and Method (Englewood Cliffs, doi
  104. (1995). Ter Beitrag regionaler Ansätze zur internationalen Ordnung nach dem Ende des Ost-West-Konflikts,
  105. (2003). Thailand, US to announce plans for freetrade agreement: PM. ' Agence France-Press
  106. (1989). The End of History? ' doi
  107. (2001). The External Relations of China's Provinces, '
  108. (2004). The Foreign Investment Department - The Ministry of Planning and
  109. (2003). The Governance of Increasing Mekong Regionalisill. Paper prepared for the conference of the Regional Centre for Social and Sustainable Development (RCSD),
  110. (2000). The Greater Mekong Subregion: Working Together With ASEAN, ' in Kao Kim Houm and
  111. (2002). The lessons of Le Kba Pbieu: Changing rules in Vietnamese politics, doi
  112. (1969). The Mekong River: A Challenge in Peaceful Developmentfor Southeast
  113. (1999). The New Regionalism: A Prologue, ' doi
  114. (2002). The Relevance of Reginies. Presentation held at the Carnegie International Non-Proliferation Conference, Ronal Reagan International Trade
  115. (2004). The River Runs Black., 77ie Environniental Challenge to China'S Future (Ithaca and London:
  116. (1997). Theories of International Reginies (Cambridge: doi
  117. (2005). Toxic leak reaches Russian river, ' online at http: //news.
  118. (2005). Toxic leak set to hit Russia city, ' online at http: //news. bbc. co. uk/l/hi/,, vorld/europe/4545502. stm (last accessed 17
  119. (1976). Treaty of Amity and Cooperation in Southeast Asia, concluded in Indonesia, doi
  120. (1993). UNO-Friedenssichening: Neueste Entivicklungen in Theorie und Praxis (St. Gallen: Institut für Politikwissenschaft).
  121. (2002). Vietnain: Selected Issues and Statistical
  122. (1996). Vietnam and ASEAN: Who Would Have Thought It Possible?, ' doi
  123. (2003). Vietnam Country Report,
  124. (1998). Vietnam-China Relations since the End of the Cold War, ' doi
  125. (1997). Vietnam, China Sign Road Transport Agreement, ' quoted from the Vietizanzese News Agency (in
  126. (1994). Vietnam's Membership in ASEAN: Economic, Political and Security huplications, '
  127. (1979). Vietnamese "Indictment" doi
  128. (1979). Vietnamese Atrocities" on Beibu Gulf, ' quoted from Xinhua (New China News Agency,
  129. (1979). Vietnamese Government Statement On China's "War of Aggression", ' quoted from the Vietnamese News Agency (English version)
  130. (1997). Vietnamese, Chinese Deputy Premiers Hold Talks, ' quoted from the Vietnainese News Agency (in
  131. (2000). Water and international conflict, '
  132. (1993). Way of Future, '
  133. (2004). Who will gain from the India-Thailand trade pact?, ' online at http: //economictimes. indiatimes. com/articleshoNv/856484. cms (last accessed 17
  134. (1980). Why Collaborate? Issue-Linkage and International Regimes, ' doi
  135. (2004). WMD Disarmament in Transition: But Where To?, '
  136. (2004). Yankee stay home,
  137. (1972). Yhe Mekong Project: Opportunities and Problenis of Regionalism. Prepared for the Subcommittee on
  138. (1997). Yunnan Rising, ' in Far Eastern Economic Review,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.