Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Central-local government relations in Pakistan since 1979

By Taj Moharram Khan

Abstract

This thesis explores the pattern of relationship of local government institutions in Pakistan with the higher level of governments, particularly with the provincial governments, under whose jurisdictional purview they fall. Pakistan is a federation where the provinces are empowered to legislate on various aspects of the working of local councils. Despite being a provincial subject, the influence of the central government under both the military and civilian regimes has also been immense. To analyse this, field work was undertaken in two provinces of Pakistan (the Punjab and the N-W. F. P). In each a district was selected (Gujrat and Mardan respectively) and the working of their municipalities and district councils were studied in the context of the impact of party-politics, the administrative control exercised, and the implications of financial decisions taken by the higher levels of government.\ud \ud Part one of the thesis describes the origin and development of local government in the South Asian sub-continent, particularly an analysis of the initiatives taken for\ud their growth by military and civilian regimes during the years preceding independence.\ud \ud Part two consists of the case studies of four local councils and an analysis of the provincial-local government relations under the present Local Government Ordinance of\ud 1979 introduced by General Mohammad Zia-ul Haque.\ud \ud Part three reflects the concerns and recommendations of experts and those involved in the working of local government in Pakistan.\ud \ud The conclusions drawn from the thesis material show that, though local government institutions have been operating in an environment of political expediency and without assistance from the general political cultural background, they have been able to make positive contributions to the development of democracy and to the provision of local services for the general welfare of the people.\ud \ud Local government in Pakistan has suffered from gaps between theory and practice, public statements and practical realities, and a pervasive political context which has neglected the development of services. There has been a tendency to proclaim the virtues of local government in theory and to make promises to support local institutions but in practice to do much less and to continue with practices which do not enable local government and its services to flourish.\ud \ud The clearest exemplification of this is that periods of martial law, where democracy at a national level has been imperilled, have seen the positive encouragement\ud of local government and local democracy as a means of gaining popular support for the regime. In contrast, in periods of democratic central government, local institutions have proved to be obstacles to central authority, and they have been neglected or abused in\ud favour of a more bureaucratic mode of governing. Both military and civilian rulers have manipulated local institutions for their own benefit. The outcome has been that the relationship between centre and provinces and the provinces and the local institutions has never been balanced or fully articulated.\ud \ud At the local level, as illustrated in the case studies, the consequences has been a lower level of civic amenity than is either desirable or what local persons know is\ud practicable with a more stable institutional base. The past record of the cases studied shows that, despite the impact of local and national politics, real progress had been\ud made in services and in developing local democracy\u

Publisher: School of Politics & International Studies (POLIS) (Leeds)
Year: 1996
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:272

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1982). (Unpublished) of the Local Government Commission, vol. I (Chapter on Financial Resources), Islamabad, Government of Pakistan,
  2. (1979). 3 )hahid Javed, Pakistan Under Bhutto 1971-1977,
  3. (1983). 4 Strategy For Management of Resources in the Eighties, National Management Paper
  4. (1983). A and Mohammad Akbar Ali Khan, Theon, of Local Government,
  5. (1979). A Framework for Analysis in Central-Local Government Relations,
  6. A Framework of Local Government Training and Personnel Management for Pakistan, "
  7. (1989). A Mohyuddin, Law and Practice of Local Government in Pakistan,
  8. (1980). A Review of Rural Development Programmes (1857-1980), Study no. 2, Islamabad, Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development,
  9. Abhijit, "Constitutional Status of Local Government in India, "
  10. Administration at the Grassroots: Pakistan's Basic Democracies, " doi
  11. (1966). Administrative Problems in Pakistan, doi
  12. (1979). Alex, "Intergovernmental Relations in Nigeria: Local Government and the doi
  13. (1984). Anwer, Pakistan: Islam, Politics and National Solidarity, doi
  14. (1985). Arshad Syed, Takistan Mein Muqami Hoquinatain' [Urdu (meaning Local Government in Pakistan], Karachi, Rahman Publishers,
  15. (1977). ARTICLES I Ahmad, Aijaz, "Democracy and Dictatorship in Pakistan, "
  16. (1979). Asaf, Elite Politics in an Ideological State: The Case of' Pakistan, doi
  17. (1990). Ashia., Municipal Finances: A Case
  18. (1965). Asok, Federalism in India: A Study of Union-State Relations, doi
  19. (1990). Authoritarianism and Legitimisation of State Power
  20. (1972). Ayub's Fall: A Socio-Economic Explanation, " Asian Survey, doi
  21. Azizuddin, "Local Bodies and National Politics, " The Nation,
  22. (1964). Basic Democracies, District Administration doi
  23. (1989). Bhutto: Opportunities and Challenges,
  24. (1987). Central and Local Government Relations: A Comparative Analysis of Western European Unitary States, doi
  25. (1966). Central Departments and Local Authorities, doi
  26. (1980). Centre for Research in Local Government, doi
  27. Centre-Province Ties: Reviving Old Fears, "
  28. (1990). Changing Image of Local Representatives in the Rural Areas, Peshawar,
  29. (1970). Changing Patterns of Local Government, The Hague,
  30. (1990). Co-ordination Mechanism For Development Administration at District and
  31. (1974). Constitution Making: The Development of Federalism in Pakistan, " doi
  32. (1986). Control and Power in Central-Local Government Relations, Famborough, Gower,
  33. (1964). Control over Municipal Bodies, "
  34. (1992). Decentralization: A Stutl: v into Forms, Structures and Development Processes, Peshawar, Pakistan Academy for Rural Development,
  35. (1963). Democracy on Trail in Pakistan, "
  36. (1963). Democracy, Decentralization and Development, doi
  37. (1964). District Administration in West Pakistan: Its Problems
  38. (1986). Domestic Conflicts in South Asia, doi
  39. (1976). Economic Problems of Pakistan under Bhutto, " doi
  40. (1984). Enhancing Administrative Capability of Local Councils for Rural Development, "
  41. (1992). Fazli Karim, A Comparative Evaluation Study of Developmental Activities of Selected District Councils in
  42. Financing Municipal Services, "
  43. Firozuddin, "Democratic and Accountable District Administration, " The Muslim,
  44. (1972). From Crisis to Crisis: Pakistan 1962-69, doi
  45. (1979). From Jinnah to Zia,
  46. (1970). Government and Politics in a Developing Nation, doi
  47. (1970). Government and Politics in Pakistan, Karachi, doi
  48. Hina Faisal, "Local Bodies Polls, " The Nation, 16.10.1987 70. Inamete, Ufot B., "Federalism in Nigeria: The Crucial Dynamics, "
  49. (1947). Huma, Bureaucratic Elite & Political Development in
  50. (1982). in this connection may be made to the constitution of a Local Government Commission8l in
  51. (1967). India and Pakistan: A Political Analysis, doi
  52. (1977). Integrated Rural Development Programme and Local Government, "
  53. (1990). Issues in Municipal Finance and Management: The Case of Karachi,
  54. Khanum Gauhar, "Resource Distribution between Federation and Provinces, " The Dawn,
  55. (1992). Legislation for Local Government in
  56. (1955). Local Government Finance and its Importance for Local Autonomy, The Hague, International Union of Local Authorities,
  57. (1969). Local Government Finance, doi
  58. (1974). Local Government Finance: Lessons from British Experience, " Nagarlok, (Delhi, Indian Institute of Public Administration),
  59. (1973). Local Government in Pakistan: An Analysis in Retrospect, "
  60. (1963). Local Government in the 20th Century, The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff,
  61. (1965). Local Government in the Modern World, doi
  62. (1976). Local Government Reform and Democracy, " Pakistan Times, 22.1.1972 64. Hassan, Syed Jamshed Nasim, "Development Through Local Government in Pakistan, "
  63. (1984). Local Government, New Delhi, The Indian Institute of Public Administration,
  64. (1990). Local Governmentfor Rural Development in
  65. (1978). Local Self-Government in India,
  66. (1978). Malik Waqar, "Problems of Federalism in Pakistan, "
  67. (1980). Manzooruddin, Contemporary Pakistan: Politics, Economy and Society, Karachi, Royal Book Agency,
  68. (1968). Masudul Hasan, Text Book of Basic Democracy and Local Government in Pakistan, Lahore, All Pakistan Legal Decisions,
  69. (1984). Masudul, Histon, of'Local Governinent in Pakistan, Islamabad, Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development, Government of Pakistan,
  70. (1970). Military Rule or Peoples Power, doi
  71. (1976). Mobilization of local resources for development, " Public Administration Review,
  72. Mobilizing Local Resources in Developing Countries, " doi
  73. (1958). Mohammad (Air Marshal), General in Politics,
  74. (1977). Muzaffar, "Pakistan's Integrated Rural Development Programme, "
  75. (1979). Nation-Building and the Pakistan Army 1947-69, doi
  76. National and Local Government Relationship
  77. (1967). National Development and Local Reform, Political Participation in Morocco, Tunisia and Pakistan, doi
  78. (1992). New Local Government Laws in
  79. Pakistan in 1980: Weathering the Storm, " doi
  80. (1982). Pakistan in 1981: Staying on, " doi
  81. (1987). Pakistan in 1986: Trials of Transition, " doi
  82. (1989). Pakistan in Search of Democracy 1947-77, Lahore, Afrasia Publications,
  83. (1971). Pakistan Votes, " doi
  84. (1947). Pakistan: A Political and Economic Histon, doi
  85. (1963). Pakistan: Emerging DemocracY, doi
  86. (1988). Pakistan: Its Politics and Bureaucracy, doi
  87. (1980). Pakistan: The Enigma of Political Development, doi
  88. (1968). Pakistan: The Formative Phase 1857-1948, doi
  89. (1989). Pakistan: Zia and After,
  90. (1960). Pakistan's Experiment in Basic Democracies, " Pacific Affairs, doi
  91. (1968). Pakstan: A Political Study,
  92. (1983). Parmatma, Government and Politics of Pakistan,
  93. (1986). Performance Evaluation of Local Councils in Pakistan, Peshawar, Pakistan Academy For Rural Development,
  94. (1987). Political and Constitutional Dilemmas, Karachi, Pakistan Law House,
  95. (1965). Political Development in Pakistan, doi
  96. (1968). Political Order in Changing Societies, doi
  97. (1968). Politics and Administration in the Local Councils in East Pakistan, Karachi, doi
  98. (1972). Politics and Peoples Representation
  99. (1980). Politics in Pakistan: The Nature and Direction of Change, doi
  100. (1977). Politics in the Post-Military State: Some Reflections on the Pakistani Experience, " doi
  101. (1973). Politics of National Integration, " The News, 13.9.1993 58. "Charter for Provincial Rights, " ! he Dawn, 5.5.1989 59. Hartley, Owen A., "The Functions of Local Government, " Local Government Studies,
  102. (1975). Power and Privilege: Influence and Decision-Making in Pakistan, doi
  103. (1980). Problems of Local Finance in Pakistan, "
  104. (1974). Problems of Urban Government and Administration, 11 Pakistan Journal-oj'Local Government,
  105. (1969). Raflushan, The Nation of Pakistan,
  106. (1970). Raj: A Study of Rural Local Government in India, doi
  107. (1961). Raj: A Synthesis, doi
  108. (1986). Reports on the Future Role and Organization of Local Government, Birmingham, Institute of Local Government,
  109. (1984). Role of Local Bodies in Rural Development of Pakistan, "
  110. (1972). Rounaq, Pakistan: Failure in National Integration, doi
  111. (1983). Rural Development in India: A MultiDimensional Analysis,
  112. (1964). Saeed Ahmad, A Retrospect on Basic Democracies 1959-1964,
  113. (1971). Shriram, Local Government in India, doi
  114. (1993). Sir Morrice, Pakistan Chronicle, Karachi,
  115. (1957). Sir Olaf, The Pathans 550 BC-AD doi
  116. State Agency for Municipal Supervision in India, " in 47ý
  117. (1927). State and Government in Ancient India,
  118. (1980). State and Society in Pakistan 1971-77,
  119. (1969). State Directorate of Municipal Administration, New Delhi, The Indian Institute of Public Administration,
  120. (1972). State-Municipal Relations: A Functional Anahsis,
  121. (1986). Strategies in the use of Local Resources for Rural Development, "
  122. (1963). Studies in Panchayati Raj, doi
  123. (1970). The Administrative Histot-N, of India 1834-1947,
  124. The Ayub Khan Era: Politics in Pakistan 1958-69, doi
  125. (1964). The Civil Service in PakiStan: Bureaucracy in a New Nation, doi
  126. (1965). The Civil Service under the Revolutionary Government in Pakistan, "
  127. (1986). The Federalist Polity: Experiences and Challenges, " The Dawn,
  128. (1984). The Finance of Local Government, doi
  129. (1954). The Foundations of Local Self-Government in doi
  130. (1989). The Karachi Metropolitan Corporation was dissolved on 12.2.1987 over a controversy over the transferrence of Motor Vehicle Tax from the provincial government. The Zila Council of Lahore was suspended in
  131. (1984). The Pakistan Army, doi
  132. (1956). The Political Stability of Pakistan, " doi
  133. (1988). The Politics of Local Expenditure,
  134. (1960). The Politics of the Developing Areas, doi
  135. (1970). The Politics ol Pakistan: A Constitutional Quest, doi
  136. (1969). The Structure of Local Government Throughout the World, The doi
  137. (1982). This is also evident from the findings of the Local Government Commission
  138. (1962). Thus the national and provincial assemblies elected in May and
  139. (1988). Transition from Military to Civilian Rule, doi
  140. (1976). Unfinished Revolution,
  141. (1984). Urban Finances in Developing Countries, Research Issues and Findings, " The World Bank Research News,
  142. (1974). uthorities and Central Control,
  143. (1915). Village Government in British India, London, doi
  144. (1962). Village Government in India: A Case Study, doi
  145. (1956). Village Panchayats in India, doi
  146. What Federalism Really Demands, " The Dawn,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.