Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

From plural society to Bangsa Malaysia : ethnicity and nationalism in the politics of nation-building in Malaysia

By Mohamed Mustafa Bin Ishak

Abstract

The question of nation-building has always been a central issue in Malaysian politics. Whilst the country has been able to sustain a relatively stable politics since the 1969\ud tragedy, and hence spawn a rapid economic development (at least until the 1997 Asian economic crisis), the project of nation-building remained a basic national agenda yet\ud to be fully resolved. This study investigates the delicate process of nation-building in Malaysia in the post 1970s, especially in the context of the vision of constructing the\ud Bangsa Malaysia or 'a united Malaysian nation' enshrined in Mahathir's Vision 2020 project which was introduced in 1991. The aim of the study is firstly, to examine the\ud underlying socio-political parameters that shaped and influenced the politics of nation-building in the country, and secondly, to explore the viability of the project of\ud Bangsa Malaysia in the context of the daunting challenges involved in the process of nation-building. Drawing from a range of theoretical frameworks as well as from\ud both primary and secondary data, the study contends that, based on the Malaysian experience, the potent interplay between the forces of ethnicity and nationalism\ud constitute the crux of the problems in the politics of nation-building in Malaysia. This dialectic it is argued, stems from the prevalence of the varying perceptions of 'nation-of-intent' within and across ethnic groups. These phenomena have not only shaped the pattern of ethnic political mobilisation in the country, but above all, laid the most complex set of obstacles in the path of the project of nation-building. This study argues that the project of constructing the Bangsa Malaysia therefore, can be seen as a significant attempt by the state to reconcile the varying ethnic ideologies of nation-of-intent.\ud It can also be considered as an attempt to consolidate Malay nationalism and cultural pluralism, thus, depicting 'the nation' as a 'mosaic of cultures', or reflecting a creation of 'a supra-ethnic' national identity. However, the viability of the envisaged\ud project is yet to be tested. The concept itself is still vague to many people and the challenges ahead are enormous, involving political, economic, socio-cultural and\ud religious issues. Indeed, the project risks becoming the 'latest' in the series of competing notions of nation-of-intent circulating in Malaysia. This study contends\ud that whilst, to some extent, the socio-political landscape of Malaysian society has been rapidly changing, especially under the eighteen years of Mahathir's reign,ethnicity still pervades Malaysian political life. This study differs from many previous studies on nation-building in Malaysia which have mainly focused on either the historical dimensions or those which have examined the impact of key national policies. As such, it is hoped that this study would be able to provide an alternative perspective in the analysis of ethnic relations and nation-building in Malaysia, thus broadening the understanding of Malaysian politics and society

Publisher: School of Sociology and Social Policy (Leeds)
Year: 1999
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:504

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1948) Colonial Policy and Practice, doi
  2. (1959) 'The school as a Social System- doi
  3. (1967) doi
  4. (1971) 'Problems of Democratic doi
  5. (1972), doi
  6. (1978) 'Ethnicity and the ethnic group: a doi
  7. (1979) doi
  8. (1980b) Ownership and Control
  9. (1981) The Ethnic Phenomenon. doi
  10. (1983)
  11. (1985)
  12. (1985) 'Contradiction in the Development of Malay Capital: State,
  13. (1986) The Challenge. Petaling Jaya: Pelanduk Publications. doi
  14. (1987) Malay Dominance? The
  15. (1987) Polarization in Malaysia : The Root Causes. Petaling Jaya: K. Das Ink.
  16. (1989) 'The End of History?', The National Interest, Summer.
  17. (1989) 'The origins of nations'. Ethnic and doi
  18. (1989) Ethnicity and Nation-building in South Asia, New Delhi: doi
  19. (1989) Nationalism and National Integration. London: Unwin Hyman Ltd. doi
  20. (1989) Racial Politics in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur:
  21. (1990)
  22. (1990) 'The state, religious nationalism, and ethnic rationalization in doi
  23. (1991)
  24. (1991) `Ke arah Pembentukan Satu Bangsa Malaysia' [Towards
  25. (1993) Melayu Baru: Mengisi Wawasan Perdana Menteri[The New Malay: Fulfilling the Prime Minister's Vision]. Kuala Lumpur: Intisari
  26. (1994)
  27. (1994) The state doi
  28. (1994), (eds.) Nationalism. Oxford: Oxford doi
  29. (1996)
  30. (1996a)'Nation-of-Intent in Malaysia', in
  31. (1996b) 'Memory
  32. (1996d)
  33. (1998)
  34. 11 September, 1995 , 31 August 1998. doi
  35. 12
  36. 1991.
  37. 1997.
  38. 20
  39. 23 June 1990 Ramasamy, P. (1994) Identiti
  40. 27 Mac, 1998. doi
  41. 27 October 1998. doi
  42. 4 December 1998. doi
  43. 5 November, 1998. doi
  44. 7 July 1982.319 , 2 June, 1990. doi
  45. 7. No. 3 July 1984. pp. 413-420. .
  46. A doi
  47. (1990). A Protean Saga: The Chinese
  48. (1988). A.B.
  49. A.L. (1978) Ethos doi
  50. Ahmat Adam (1997) 'Comments on 'Malaysian Chinese:
  51. (1996). Akta-Akta Pendidikan 1995 dan 1996 Terhadap Pendidikan Aliran Melayu dan Kedudukan Ekonomi Bangsa Melayu serta Kebudayaan Kebangsaan' [What
  52. Albert (1991) The Malayan Union Controversies 1942-1948. Singapore: Oxford University Press. doi
  53. Alias Mohamed (1994) PAS' Platform: Development
  54. Aliran, Vol. 10. No. 4, 1990. Penang: Aliran. doi
  55. and doi
  56. Anderson, Benedict (1996a) Imagined
  57. (1993). Ariffin Omar doi
  58. (1997). at his office in Kuala Lumpur,
  59. (1993). at his office in UKM,
  60. August
  61. August 1995.
  62. Ave, Jan B. and Victor T. King (1986) Borneo: The People of the Weeping ForestTradition and Change
  63. Awang Had Salleh (1994) Nasionalisme Melayu:
  64. Aziz
  65. Background to Malaysia, London: Oxford University Press Smock,
  66. Barraclough, Simon (1984) 'Communalism and confusion: towards a clarification doi
  67. Basri and Idris
  68. Basu, T. et.al. (1993)
  69. (1978). Bedlington, doi
  70. before doi
  71. Bell, Daniel (1975) doi
  72. Belonging: doi
  73. Binder, Leonard, ed.
  74. Bogdan, R. & doi
  75. Breuilly, John (1993) Nationalism and the State. Manchester: Manchester University Press Brown, David doi
  76. Bruce (1981) Politics and Public Enterprise in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Eastern University Press.
  77. (1988). Building a Malaysian Nation, Speech presented at the launching of
  78. Catherine doi
  79. Chandra Muzaffar (1979) Protector? An Analysis of
  80. Chang,
  81. Changing
  82. Changing Values and Political Styles among Western Publics. Princeton: Princeton University Press Jayum A. Jawan doi
  83. Charles
  84. Chatterjee, P. (1996) 'Whose imagined community', in G. Balakrishnan
  85. Cheng
  86. Chinese
  87. Chua Jul Meng (1988) 'The Malaysian Chinese -The Way Ahead'
  88. Chua, David (1988) ' The Chinese Education and Cultural Vision'
  89. Class
  90. Clive J. (1998a) Race and Nation: A Reader.
  91. Coalition Government in Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur: Marican and Sons.
  92. Comber,
  93. Conflict'. doi
  94. Crouch,
  95. Crouch, H. (1996) Government and Society in Malaysia, Ithaca and London: doi
  96. Dalam
  97. dan Politik. Kuala Lumpur: K. Publishing &
  98. Daniel.
  99. (1997). Datuk Ahmad Nazri Abdullah, Editor-in-Chief, Berita Harian Press.306 Formal interview at his office in Kuala Lumpur,
  100. Daud (1997) `Himpunan Bukti (Isu Semasa) Dahulu Dan Sekarang' [The Collection of Evidents (Current
  101. der doi
  102. (1997). Divide And Rule. The Roots of Race Relations in Malaysia, Insan: Kuala Lumpur. doi
  103. Durkheim, Emile (1961) Moral Education. Glencoe: The doi
  104. (1997). E. doi
  105. Eriksen, Thomas Hylland (1993) doi
  106. Esman, Milton J. (1973) The Management of Communal Conflict', Public
  107. Ethnic doi
  108. Ethnicity. Oxford: Oxford University Press. doi
  109. (1997). Faces of Nationalism, doi
  110. (1986). Fifth Malaysia Plan 1986-1990. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  111. for a Fight', in PEER, May, 27, 1999.
  112. (1997). Formal interview at his clinic in Petaling Jaya,
  113. (1997). Formal Interview at his house in Kuala Lumpur,
  114. (1997). Formal interview at his house in Petaling Jaya,
  115. (1997). Formal interview at his office in Alor Star,
  116. (1997). Formal interview at his office in Federal Parliament,
  117. (1997). Formal interview at his office in Kuala Lumpur,
  118. (1997). Formal interview at his office in UKM, 31
  119. (1997). Formal interview at PAS Headquarters, Kuala Lumpur, 13 Match
  120. (1997). Formal interview at the Penang State's Guest House,
  121. (1997). Formal interview at UICM,
  122. (1997). Formal interview at University of Malaya,
  123. (1981). Fourth Malaysia Plan 1981-1985. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  124. Fukuyama, Francis (1992) doi
  125. Funston, N.J. (1980) Malay doi
  126. G. doi
  127. Geertz, Clifford (1973[1963]) 'The integrative revolution: primordial sentiments and civil politics
  128. Gellner, Ernest (1996) doi
  129. Ghazali
  130. good and bad nationalism', Nations And Nationalism. doi
  131. (1971). Government Printing Malaysia
  132. H.
  133. Habermas, Jurgen (1996) 'The European doi
  134. Hiebert, Murray (1998) 'Call of the Imams', Far
  135. Hirsch Jr., E.D. (1987) Cultural Literacy. Boston: doi
  136. Hobsbawm, doi
  137. Hong doi
  138. Hoover.
  139. Idhayam, January 1, 1996.
  140. Iftikhar doi
  141. in doi
  142. (1992). in 2020, One State Many Nations?' The Seventh James C.
  143. Indonesia', doi
  144. James
  145. Januari
  146. (1968). Joel doi
  147. (1969). John
  148. John (1993) 'Disgusted of Malaysia Aggravates the Anglos', The Sunday Times, London,
  149. John A. (1998) doi
  150. Joint Memorandum On doi
  151. Jr. (1965) Public Opinion and American Democracy. New York: Alfred.A. Knopf. doi
  152. Kamarudin Jaafar (1980) Dr. Burhanuddin al-Helmi: Politik
  153. Kanapathy, V.
  154. (1993). Karthigesu R. (1993) 'Malaysian Economy and the Future of Malaysian Indians' [translated from Tamil ], in Weekly Mayil,
  155. Khoo Kay Kim (1994) Nasionalisme Melayu 1919-1941: Suatu
  156. Kia Soong (ed.) (1985) National Culture and Democracy, Subang Jaya: Kersani Penerbit Sdn.
  157. (1997). Kia Soong, Director of the Dong Jiao Zhong (Chinese Education Association), at his office in Kajang,
  158. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa Dan Pustaka Morais, doi
  159. L.
  160. Laponce, J.A (1987) Languages and Their doi
  161. Lawrence A. (1962) Transformation of doi
  162. Lee, Kam doi
  163. Lim doi
  164. Lim Kit
  165. Lim Mah Hui (1980a) 'Ethnic and class relations doi
  166. Lipjhart, Arendt (1977) Democracy in
  167. Lumpur:
  168. M. (1992) 'The emergence of modern European nationalism', in J. Hall and doi
  169. M.G. (1969) Pluralism in Africa (eds.), Berkeley: University doi
  170. Mahathir doi
  171. Malay Dilemma: Recessions hits state-aided entrepreneurs hard', in FEER, May
  172. Malay Politics: Its Origins
  173. (1983). Malaya: doi
  174. Malays
  175. (1991). Malaysia: The Way Forward, Working Paper presented at the Inaugural Meeting of the
  176. Malaysian doi
  177. (1997). Malaysian Chinese: Seeking Identity in Wawasan 2020', in Leo
  178. Malaysian Nation Towards 2020],
  179. Masked
  180. Mauzy, doi
  181. McCrone, David (1998) The doi
  182. Mehmet, doi
  183. Milne,
  184. Milner, A.C. (1982) Kerajaan: Malay Political Culture on the Eve of Colonial doi
  185. (1988). Mohamad Abdad Mohamad Zain
  186. Mohamed Aris Othman (1977) Ethnic
  187. Mohamed Mustafa Ishak (1987) 'The Politics of Development in Penang State,
  188. Movement
  189. Muhamad doi
  190. (1974). Mukhtar Che Ali (1985)'Kepimpinan
  191. Muslim State: The doi
  192. Myth or Reality?', Ethnic and Racial Studies. Vol.1 doi
  193. Naomi
  194. Nascent
  195. nation'.
  196. National Culture Submitted By The 10 Major Indian Associations Of
  197. (1969). National Operation Council Report,
  198. (1986). Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World: A Derivative Discourse. London: Zed. doi
  199. Nations: doi
  200. Netherlands
  201. New Straits Times, 10 November 1993.
  202. Newspapers,
  203. Noordin Sopiee
  204. Nordlinger, Eric doi
  205. November
  206. October,
  207. of Mahathirism: An Intellectual Biography doi
  208. old doi
  209. Oxford doi
  210. Parekh, Bilchu (1995) ' The
  211. Parlimen Tuaran 1990 Dan 1995' [The
  212. Peh
  213. (1986). Peristiwa Memali' (The Memali Incident), Kertas Perintah 21. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  214. Perpaduan
  215. Plattner, doi
  216. (1960). Pluralism',
  217. Plurality doi
  218. Politics
  219. (1990). Politics in Business: UMNO's Corporate Investments. Kuala Lumpur: doi
  220. (1994). Press.314
  221. Publishers.
  222. Quarterly
  223. Rabushka, A. and doi
  224. Ratnam,
  225. Ratnam, K.J. (1965)
  226. Regarding doi
  227. Review doi
  228. Robison R. and Goodman D. (eds.) (1996) doi
  229. Roff, Margaret Clarke (1969) ' The Rise and Demise doi
  230. Roff, W.R. (1994[1967 doi
  231. Rose, P. doi
  232. Rotberg, doi
  233. (1982). Royce,
  234. Rupert,
  235. Sangwon and Ooorjitham, Santha (1998) 'The New Opposition Consists
  236. Schwarzmantel, J.J.
  237. Seaward, N. (1986) 'Balancing the Redress', Far Eastern Economic Review (FEER), 25 September
  238. (1997). Series of informal discussion with Malaysian students in Leeds from
  239. (1997). Series of informal discussions, at his office
  240. (1997). Series of informal interviews with 6 private sector respondents of different ethnic background, gender, and age, from 1
  241. (1997). Series of informal interviews with 7 public sector respondents of different ethnic background, gender, and age, from 1
  242. Shafruddin, B.H. and Iftikhar
  243. Shari
  244. (1995). Sik
  245. Singapore, 12 July, 1998.
  246. Smith,
  247. Societies: doi
  248. (1998). Southeast Asia in the Twentienth Century: A Reader. London: I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd.
  249. (1991). Speech at the UMNO General Assembly,
  250. Stein
  251. Steinberg, Stephen (1981) doi
  252. Stockwell, doi
  253. Stryker, S. (1973) 'Fundamental Principles of
  254. Studies,
  255. Syed Hussin Ali
  256. Syed Naguib al-Attas (1972) doi
  257. T.K.
  258. Tan doi
  259. Terence
  260. the doi
  261. (1997). The Community 27. Series of informal interviews with 13 University Utara Malaysia (UUM) students of various ethnic background and gender from 1
  262. (1957). The Federation of Malaya Constitutional Commission Report,
  263. (1969). The May 13th Tragedy, A Report. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  264. The Role of Race, Religion and doi
  265. (1976). Third Malaysia Plan 1976-1980. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  266. Times
  267. (1992). Towards A United Malaysian Nation, Speech at the 'United Malaysian Nation by the year 2020' dinner, doi
  268. (1988). Towards Preserving National Security, Kertas Perintah 14. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing.
  269. (1976). Tun Mustapha: Bapa Kemerdekaan Sabah [Tun Mustapha: Father of Sabah Independence]. Kuala Lumpur: M.F.I. Abdul Rahman Embong
  270. Untuk Malaysia', in Kajian Malaysia, VII, 1&2 Jun/Dis. 1989. pp. 58-81.
  271. (1980). Value-Consensus: An Approach to National Unity', in Jurnal Negara. Vol. 4.
  272. Van doi
  273. Verso.311 Hua Wu Yin (1983) Class and
  274. (1997). Vision 2020: The Way Forward, Keynote address at the Vision doi
  275. Vol. 5, April doi
  276. (1975). von doi
  277. W. (1985) Asian Power and Politics: The Cultural Process doi
  278. Wan Hashim (1983) Race doi
  279. Williams, R. (1976) Keywords, London: Flamingo.
  280. Wong Chun Wai (1998) 'On the Beat',
  281. World: doi
  282. Worsley, P. (1984) doi
  283. (1996). Year Book of Statistics. Kuala Lumpur: Government Printing. List of Interviews I. Leading politicians and bureaucrats 1.Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, The Minister of Youth and Sports.
  284. YN (1981) `The Role of Chinese Organisations in Malayan Politics, 1945-57: Special Reference to
  285. York: John Wiley and Sons.307 Barth, Frederik, ed., (1969) Ethnic
  286. Zainah Anwar ( 1987) Islamic revivalism in Malaysia: Dakwah amongst the students. Petaling doi
  287. Zainal Abidin
  288. Zainal Kling (1988) 'Antara Nasional Dan Etnik' [Between
  289. Zawawi Ibrahim (1985) 'Rich Man, Poor Man - The NEP Equation', Far Eastern Economic Review, June 20 1985.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.