Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Correlation of subjective and objective handling of vehicle behaviour

By Howard Alan Simon Ash


This thesis presents the results of a research project which sought to find links between driver subjective ratings and objective measures of vehicle handling. The\ud experimental data used in this project has been made available from a previous research project. The experimental data was collected using a prototype vehicle which was used in 16 different configurations. Objective data was collected based around the ISO defined steady state, step input, and frequency response tests. Subjective\ud assessments were collected from eight trained test drivers using a numerical rating scale to a questionnaire covering various aspects of vehicle handling.\ud \ud Analysis of the subjective assessments has been done to identify any shortcomings that may affect any subsequent analysis.\ud \ud From the literature review, an approach that claims to relate four simple objective metrics to subjective measures of vehicle handling has been developed in two new ways. Firstly, the proposal was tested [1] with the large amount of subjective data available to see if good levels of correlation could be found between the proposed metrics and driver subjective ratings to specific handling questions. Secondly, the method was extended to include further simple metrics to try and improve links between the subjective and objective data [2].\ud \ud Non-linear relationships in the correlation of subjective vs. objective data have been investigated for the first time [3] using non-linear genetic algorithms, which, in\ud addition have not previously been used to correlate driver subjective ratings with objective measures that describe vehicle handling.\ud \ud From the results, it has been possible to specify ranges of preferred values of objective metrics in order to produce a subjectively satisfying vehicle.\ud \ud Finally, the work discusses how the results obtained can be used by engineers to aid the vehicle design and development process

Publisher: School of Mechanical Engineering (Leeds)
Year: 2002
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1999). A Course in Analysis of Variance",
  2. (1991). A Simplified Method For The Measurement of Composite Suspension Parameters", doi
  3. (1993). Advanced methods in neural computing",
  4. An Introduction to Vehicle Dynamics", doi
  5. (1999). Consideration of the Age Related Hearing Ability (Presbycusis) in the Definition of Vehicle Interior Noise Targets", SAE paper 1999-01-1820, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  6. (1991). Correlation Analysis of Open/ Closed Loop Data for Objective Assessment of Handling Characteristics of Cars", doi
  7. (1978). Correlation and Evaluation of Driver/ Vehicle Directional Handling Data", SAE paper 780010, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  8. Correlation Between Objective Handling Characteristics and Subjective Perception of Handling Qualities of Heavy Vehicles",
  9. (2001). Correlation of Objective Handling Characteristics and Subjective Perception of Vehicle Handling", doi
  10. (1987). Correlation of Subjective Evaluation and Objective Measurement of Vehicle Handling",
  11. (1999). Customer-oriented Development of Driving Dynamics: The Ford Focus Example", Vehicle Dynamics Seminar & MIRA Open Day,
  12. (1994). Data sheet provided by Michelin plc., " Caracterisation Du Fonctionnement Pneu En Transversal Pur- Mesures Pneu Demandees par:
  13. (1989). Design and Use of the Two-Level Sequential Judgement Scale in the Identification of Vehicle Handling Criteria: 1. Instrumented Car Experiments on Straight Lane Driving",
  14. Development of Simulator Vehicle for Conducting Vehicle Dynamics Research",
  15. (1974). Driving Simulator Studies: The Influence of Vehicle Parameters on Safety in Critical Situations", doi
  16. (1980). Effects of Vehicle Response Characteristics and Driver's Skill Level on Task Performance and Subjective Rating",
  17. Electric power steering - the first step on the way to steer-by-wire", doi
  18. (1997). Evaluation of Neural Networks as a Technique for Correlating Vehicle Noise with Subjective Response", doi
  19. (1990). Feedback stabilization using two hidden layer nets", report SYCON-90-1 1, Rutgers Center for Systems and Control,
  20. Flight Evaluations of Various Longitudinal Handling Qualities in a Variable-Stability Jet Fighter",
  21. (1990). Four Parameter Evaluation Method of Lateral Transient Response", SAE paper 901734, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  22. (1995). Fuzzy Logic Toolbox User's Guide",
  23. Identification of Subjective-Objective Vehicle Handling Links Using Neural Networks for the Foresight Vehicle", doi
  24. (1992). Identification of Vehicle Handling Predictors: 2: All-terrain Vehicles in a Severe Lane-Change",
  25. International Organaisation for Standardisation technical Committee ISO/TC22,: Road vehicles- Test procedure for a severe lane-change manoeuvre, ISO
  26. Learning Internal Representations by Error Propagation", Parallel Distributed Processing,
  27. (1973). Measurement and Subjective Evaluation of Vehicle Handling", doi
  28. (1992). Methodology For Predicting Car and Truck Handling Assessments",
  29. Multi-layer feed-forward neural networks are universal approximators",
  30. (1993). Neural Networks for statistical modelling",
  31. (1998). Objective Evaluation of Vehicle Driveability", doi
  32. (1988). Organisation " Road Vehicles- Lateral Transient Response Test Methods", doi
  33. (1982). Organisation " Road Vehicles- Steady State Circular Test Procedure",
  34. Outline of a new approach to the analysis of complex systems and decision processes", doi
  35. (1969). Perceptrons", doi
  36. (1996). Potential functions and benefits of electronic steering assistance",
  37. Principal components and factor analysis". [On-line] Available URL:
  38. (1991). Regression Analysis by Example", doi
  39. Requirements for Vehicle Dynamics Simulation Models", SAE paper 940175, Society of Automotive Engineers,
  40. (1999). Road Testing by Numbers", Autocar,
  41. (1973). Simulation and Measurement of Driver Vehicle Handling Performance", SAE paper 730489, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  42. Study of the Human Pilot as a Servo-Element",
  43. Subjective and Objective Assessment of Vehicle Handling Performance", doi
  44. (1997). Subjective and Objective Handling Behaviour",
  45. (1980). Subjective Evaluation and Vehicle Behaviour in Lane-change Manoeuvres", doi
  46. The Correlation Between Subjective Assessments and Physical Measurements of The Vibratory Motion In a Saloon Car", doi
  47. (1964). The Correlation Between Subjective Assessments of Vehicle Ride and Physical Measurements of Vehicle Motion",
  48. The Handling and Stability of Motor Vehicles, Part7, Frequency Response Measurements and their
  49. (1969). The use of pilot rating in the evaluation of aircraft handling properties",
  50. (1987). Tyre Modelling For Use In Vehicle Dynamics Studies", SAE paper 870421, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  51. (2000). Vehicle Driveability Assessment using Neural Networks for Development, Calibration and Quality Tests", SAE paper 2000-01-0702, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  52. (1998). Vehicle Handling Assessment Using a Combined Subjective-Objective Approach", SAE paper 980226, Society of Automotive Engineers, doi
  53. (1994). Vehicle Model Complexity, How Much is Too Much", doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.