Location of Repository

Democracy and the media in developing countries : a case study of the Philippines

By Desmond Smith

Abstract

This thesis examines the relationships between the Philippine media, class power and the state. It focusses\ud particularly on the economic and political actors and agencies, including the press, which have promoted\ud or hindered democratisation in the Philippines during the decade 1983-1993. It argues that although the\ud role of the Philippine press has been considerable, it has been inextricably bound to the interests of ruling\ud elites who have disproportionate control over mainstream media agendas.\ud \ud To explain this dominance, the study analyses some of the forces within the Philippine state which historically have shaped this Third World country's economy and polity. The thesis then examines how the role of the Philippine media, in particular the mainstream English-language press, developed through the "liberalisation" phase of the Marcos era and the subsequent periods of "democratic transition" and "consolidation" associated with the Aquino and Ramos administrations. It highlights the pressures on the\ud media that have often promoted sectional class interests, including those of media owners, at the expense of the plurality and accountability required for substantive democracy. However it also considers in detail the conduits within the "public sphere" for oppositional and "alternative" voices which have challenged\ud the status quo, and it examines their role in articulating calls for political change during the Marcos and Aquino administrations.\ud \ud The Manila press is contrasted with regional and "alternative" news sources, in a debate on the need for\ud media strategies to represent agendas of the marginalised sectors of Philippine society. The study analyses press reporting of two indices of "democratic debate" during the Aquino presidency: the issues of land reform and human rights abuses. The role of media practitioners and the tensions caused by conflicting demands of ownership, control and agenda-setting in this period of political turbulence are also examined. "Pluralist", "hegemonic", "gatekeeper" and "propaganda" models of the "Western liberal democratic"\ud media are reviewed and tested in an attempt to refine theory in the context of empirical evidence.\ud \ud The claims for the Philippine media's role in the country's democratisation are finally assessed. The "freest press in Asia" is reevaluated in relation to the economic and political interests it serves within the country's\ud polity. The thesis argues that in particular circumstances -notably those of regime crisis - "spaces" may be created in the media through political contestation and mobilisation. Marginalised voices and agendas may then be heard in the "public sphere", though with difficulty. These articulations are, however, relatively temporary and insecure, and encounter many obstacles from the powerful vested media interests of elite actors and agencies. The thesis questions, moreover, to what extent elites actually act upon these marginalised agendas, even when they can be articulated, in a "developing country" like the Philippines.\ud The media are ultimately never independent of the elites who control them economically and politically: their potential role in democratisation is severely constrained by powerful social forces within the Third World state which seek to manipulate them for narrow class interests

Publisher: School of Media and Communication (Leeds)
Year: 1996
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:733

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1992). (Broad)casting its Spell",
  2. (1972). A Brief Review of American Interest doi
  3. (1992). A Captive Land: the Politics of Agrarian Reform in the Philippines, London, Catholic Institute for International Relations. doi
  4. (1973). A critical review of Barrington Moore's Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy", doi
  5. (1983). A Cruel Deception: government and the mass media after Martial Law',
  6. (1956). A Preface to Democratic Theory, doi
  7. (1992). A Special Issue on the Philippine Left", vol .
  8. (1967). A World of Nations: Problems of Political Modernization, doi
  9. (1971). a), Selections from the Prison Notebooks [1929-351,
  10. (1987). After the Yellow Revolution: Filipino Elite Factions and the Struggle for Power", in Krinks
  11. (1992). All in the Family: a Study of Elites and Power Relations in the Philippines,
  12. (1980). Anne Showstack doi
  13. (1986). Aquino takes charge", doi
  14. (1986). Aquino's Elite Populism: Initial Reflections", Third World Quarterly, doi
  15. (1986). Aquino's First Months", doi
  16. (1993). Asia, an Unacceptable Standard",
  17. (1993). Asia's Different Standard", doi
  18. (1973). Associated Dependent Development: Theoretical and Practical Implications"
  19. (1985). Authoritarian Controls and News Media in the Philippines", doi
  20. (1986). Authoritarianism, Democracy and the Transition to Democracy", Socialist Register 1985-86, doi
  21. (1987). Banking on Telecommunications: the World Bank in the Philippines', doi
  22. (1965). Between Two Empires: the Ordeal of the Philippines 1929-1946, doi
  23. (1987). Bringing the State back in: a polemic",
  24. (1985). Bringing the state back in: strategies of analysis in current research', doi
  25. (1985). Brining the State Back In, Cambridge,
  26. (1990). Britain: the dominant ideology thesis after a decade"
  27. (1988). Cacique Democracy in the Philippines: Origins and Dreams",
  28. (1987). Can the Rest of Asia emulate the NICs? ", doi
  29. (1969). Capitalism and Underdevelopment doi
  30. (1977). Capitalism, communication and class relations" in Curran et al .,
  31. (1947). Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy, (2nd edn. doi
  32. (1982). Capitalist Development and Democracy in South America", doi
  33. (1992). Capitalist Development and Democracy, doi
  34. (1965). Central Intelligence Agency doi
  35. (1995). Chino"
  36. (1986). Church media play a vital role",
  37. (1981). Circulation of News in the Third World: a Study of Asia, Hong Kong, The Chinese
  38. (1992). Citizens, consumers, and public culture" doi
  39. (1983). City, Foundation for Nationalist Studies.
  40. (1987). Class, State and Dependence in East Asia: Lessons for Latin Americanists',
  41. (1982). Class, State, and Revolution: Substitutes and Realities"
  42. (1986). Class. Politics and the doi
  43. (1982). Classes, Power and Conflict,
  44. (1983). Club [of the Philippines]
  45. (1980). Coding and Encoding in the Television Discourse",
  46. (1976). Communication and Cultural Dominance,
  47. (1986). Communication and liberation in the Philippines" [Dedicated Issue].
  48. (1991). Communication and Society: The Philippine Context, Manila, Cacho Publishing House.
  49. (1986). Communication in Social Change: the Philippine Experience"
  50. (1977). Compadrinazgo: Ritual Kinship in the Philippines, De Kalb, doi
  51. (1966). Comparative Politics: a Developmental Approach, doi
  52. (1990). Comparing Democratic Systems", doi
  53. (1985). Conclusion: the Retreat of the Generals",
  54. (1993). Consolidations of Democracy"
  55. (1985). Conspiracy for Empire: Big Business Corruption and the Politics of Imperialism in America 1876-1907, Quezon City, Foundation for Nationalist Studies.
  56. (1991). Constitutional Choices for New Democracies", doi
  57. (1990). Corruption. Development and Underdevelopment, doi
  58. (1987). Cory's Cop-out",
  59. (1977). Counterinsurgency in the Philippines",
  60. (1982). Cultural dependency and the mass media",
  61. (1991). Cultural Imperialism, doi
  62. (1991). Culture, Communications, and Political Economy",
  63. (1977). Culture, the Media and Ideological Effect",
  64. (1991). Dance of the Dunces,
  65. (1979). Deciding What's News, doi
  66. (1984). Democracies: Patterns of Maioritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty-One Countries, doi
  67. (1991). Democracy and Development in Latin America: Pious Hopes and Sombre Expectations",
  68. (1992). Democracy and Development, Cambridge, doi
  69. (1993). Democracy and the Media - without foundations" in Held
  70. (1993). Democracy in Divided Societies", doi
  71. (1989). Democracy Without Citizens, doi
  72. Democracy's Third Wave", doi
  73. (1990). Democratic Transition and Consolidation, doi
  74. (1989). Democratization and stabilization",
  75. (1989). Demystifying Aquino,
  76. (1972). Dependency and Development in Latin America" doi
  77. (1979). Dependent Development: the alliance of multinational, state and local capital in Brazil, doi
  78. (1992). Deterring Democracy, doi
  79. (1982). Development Debacle: the World Bank in the Philippines,
  80. (1987). Dictatorship and Martial Law: Philippine Authoritarianism in 1972,
  81. (1970). Economic Development of Latin America, London, doi
  82. (1992). Elections",
  83. (1990). Elite Politics and the Philippine Left",
  84. (1989). Emerging Economic Issues: Recovery and Democratization" in The Philippines under Aquino: Five Papers,
  85. (1986). Entrepreneurs and the Transition Process: the Brazilian Case",
  86. (1991). Europa Year Book: The Far East and Australasia
  87. (1990). Flowers From the Rubble,
  88. (1980). For ease of reference, this bibliography is divided into three sections: A. Mass Media: B. Political Development and Democracy: C. The Philippines, South East Asia and the Far East.
  89. (1969). For Marx doi
  90. (1989). From production to propaganda? ",
  91. (1986). From the Ashes: the Rebirth of the Philippine Revolution -a review essay", doi
  92. (1986). Gatekeeper versus Propaganda Models: A Critical American Perspective",
  93. (1989). Geographical Inequalities: the Spatial Bias of the New Communications Technologies", doi
  94. (1994). Getting the Right Mix of Feminism and Nationalism". Paper presented to the
  95. (1964). Governments and Politics of Southeast doi
  96. (1975). History of Mass Communication in the Philippines". Unpublished Research Report,
  97. (1986). How Free is the Philippines: Some Impressions and Reflections",
  98. (1993). Identity Crisis: the Military in Changing Times",
  99. (1973). Ideology as a cultural system", in Geertz, doi
  100. (1991). Imagined Communities, (2nd edn.
  101. (1973). Imperialism and Bourgeois Dictatorship in the Philippines", New Left Review,
  102. (1991). In Defence of Objectivity"
  103. (1982). Industrialization, Development, and Dependence",
  104. (1989). Information Poverty and Political Inequality: Citizenship in the Age of Privatized Communications", doi
  105. (1984). International Image Markets, doi
  106. (1986). Inventing Reality: The Politics of the Mass Media, doi
  107. (1992). Jose Maria Sison and the Philippine Revolution: a Critique of an Interface",
  108. (1980). Language and Nationalism: the Philippine Experience Thus Far, Quezon City, Ateneo de doi
  109. (1982). Large corporations and the control of the communications industries",
  110. (1992). Latin America in the Time of Cholera: Electoral Politics Market Economics, and Permanent Crisis, doi
  111. (1988). Lawyers Committee for International Human Rights doi
  112. (1982). Learning to Be... What? Shaping Education in 'Developing Societies'',
  113. (1993). Liberal Democracy and the Limits of Democratization", doi
  114. (1992). Looking Back, the Economy under Aquino",
  115. (1978). Making News, doi
  116. (1991). Malaysian Politics: the Second Generation, Singapore, doi
  117. (1991). Manila's Malaise", doi
  118. (1986). Manila's television, radio and press scene",
  119. (1969). Mass Communication and American Empire, doi
  120. (1991). Mass Media and Democracy: A Reappraisal",
  121. (1988). Mass Media and its Role in Philippine Society",
  122. (1988). Mass Media and the Spiral of Silence: the Philippines from Marcos to Aquino", doi
  123. (1991). Media Analysis Techniques, (2nd edn. doi
  124. (1992). Media Cultures: Reappraising Transnational doi
  125. (1977). Media Imperialism: towards an international framework for the analysis of media systems",
  126. (1986). Media Power and Class Power"
  127. (1977). Media Professionalism in the Third World: the transfer of an ideology", in Curran,
  128. (1990). Media Theory: an Introduction, doi
  129. (1993). Media Versus Clan Politics: A Preliminary Analysis of the 1992 Philippine Elections". Paper presented to Association of Southeast Asian Studies,
  130. (1991). Media, the political order and national identity", doi
  131. (1986). Military Intervention in Philippine Politics",
  132. (1973). Modernisation and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism: Studies in doi
  133. (1972). Modernisation, order and the erosion of a democratic ideal: American political science 1960-1970", doi
  134. (1992). Money and Moguls: Oiling the Campaign Machinery",
  135. (1979). Multinational Corporations and the Control of Culture, doi
  136. (1992). NCCP [National Council of Churches in the Philippines] Report" in [n/a].
  137. (1989). Necessary Illusions: Thought Control in Democratic Societies, doi
  138. (1981). Network television and American society", doi
  139. (1980). Newspapers and Democracy: International Essays in a Changing Medium, doi
  140. (1971). On National Democracy, Quezon City, Aklatang Gising Na.
  141. Paper presented at the First European Association for Southeast Asian Studies Conference,
  142. (1979). Pasyon and Revolution, Quezon City, Ateneo de
  143. (1986). Paths toward Redemocratisation: Theoretical and Comparative Considerations"
  144. (1971). Pedagogy of the Oppressed, doi
  145. (1986). People Power, Popular Culture, and the February Revolt", Pill man Review,
  146. (1994). People power? Non-Governmental Organisations and Philippine Politics since 1986". Paper presented to the
  147. (1988). Philippine Ideologies",
  148. (1990). Philippine Mass Communication: A Mini-History,
  149. (1972). Philippine Mass Communications before 1811. after doi
  150. (1970). Philippine media and Nation-building: an Overview", doi
  151. (1982). Philippine Social History: Global Trade and Local Transformations, Quezon City, Ateneo de doi
  152. (1987). Philippines: Alleged Human Rights Violations by Vigilante Groups,
  153. (1988). Philippines: Unlawful Killings by Military and Paramilitary Fouts,
  154. (1978). Policing the Crisis, doi
  155. (1985). Political Change and Underdevelopment, doi
  156. (1974). Political Change in the Philippines: Studies of Local Politics Preceding Martial Law, doi
  157. (1986). Political Communication and Citizenship: the Media and Democracy in an Inegalitarian Social Order",
  158. (1965). Political Development and Political Decay", doi
  159. (1991). Political Developments in the Philippines" in
  160. (1968). Political Order in Changing Societies, doi
  161. (1973). Political Power and Social Classes, doi
  162. (1977). Politics and Markets: the World's Political-Economic Systems, doi
  163. (1990). Politics and the Press: the Philippines since Marcos", doi
  164. (1971). Polyarchy: participation and opposition, doi
  165. (1985). Power Without Responsibility: the Press and Broadcasting doi
  166. (1977). Power, Class and the Media",
  167. (1976). Press Freedom as a Barometer of Political Democracy",
  168. (1991). Press Freedom in the Philippines: a Legacy of American Colonialism",
  169. (1985). Press Freedom, An Illusion for Writers"
  170. (1992). Press Freedom: the People's Right - Assertion and Repression in the Philippines,
  171. (1984). Processing the News: How People Stem the Information Tide, doi
  172. (1993). Prospects for Democracy: doi
  173. (1990). Provincial Journalists in Third World Development: a Philippine Case Study",
  174. (1989). Public Communication: the New Imperatives,
  175. (1988). Putting "Reality" Together: The BBC and its News,
  176. (1992). Reaffirm our Basic Principles and Rectify Errors",
  177. (1982). Really Bad News, London, Writers and Readers.
  178. (1989). Red Revolution, Boulder, Westview Press. 293 "Ka-Barry" doi
  179. (1987). Rethinking Development: Modernization. Dependency, and Postmodern Politics, doi
  180. (1986). Revolutionary Symbols",
  181. (1987). Right-Wing Vigilantes and US Involvement: Report on a US-Philippine Fact-Finding Mission to the Philippines, May 20-30.1987, Manila, Philippine Alliance of Human Rights Advocates.
  182. (1982). Samuel Huntington and the End of Classical Modernization Theory",
  183. (1990). Seeing, and Believing: The Influence of Television, doi
  184. (1975). Selected Correspondence,
  185. (1974). Sharing in Development: a Programme of Emyloyment.
  186. (1986). Small media, big victory",
  187. (1959). Social Class in a Bikol Town,
  188. (1987). Social Volcano: Sugar Workers in the Philippines,
  189. (1994). Socialism for a Sceptical Age, London, doi
  190. (1959). Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy", doi
  191. (1989). South End Press.
  192. (1971). State and Civil Society" in Gramsci, doi
  193. (1989). State, Regime and the Democratization Muddle", doi
  194. (1979). States and Social Revolutions: a comparative analysis of France. Russia and China, Cambridge, doi
  195. (1962). Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, Cambridge, doi
  196. (1985). Teaching the doi
  197. (1982). Telecommunications technology: transnationalizing the new Philippine information order",
  198. (1995). Television and the Public Sphere,
  199. (1987). Television as a Cultural Forum", doi
  200. (1974). Television: Technology and Cultural Form, doi
  201. (1971). Television: the Business behind the Box,
  202. (1987). Television: the Critical View,
  203. (1988). The 'Brazilianization' of Mexico? ", doi
  204. (1987). The Aquino Watch,
  205. (1992). The Business of Newspapers",
  206. (1990). The Centrality of Political Culture", doi
  207. (1971). The Change to Change", doi
  208. (1989). The Civic Culture Revisited, doi
  209. (1976). The Conjugal Dictatorship,
  210. (1977). The consumption of dependency theory in the United States",
  211. (1987). The Crisis in the Third World",
  212. (1992). The Crisis of the Philippine Progressive Movement: a Preliminary Investigation',
  213. (1992). The Crisis of the Sovereign State",
  214. (1993). The Culture of Contentment, doi
  215. (1995). The culture of the public world of the new middle-classes in the Philippines".
  216. (1972). The Development of Modem Mass Communications in the Philippines: a Case Study of Institutional Growth in a Developing Country", unpublished Ph.
  217. (1852). The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, doi
  218. (1977). The Emergence of American Political Issues: The AgendaSetting Function of the Press,
  219. (1973). The End of the Freest Press in the World", doi
  220. (1986). The February Phenomenon in the Philippines and the Mass and Group Media Coalition",
  221. (1980). The Geopolitics of Information: How Western Culture Dominates the World, doi
  222. (1970). The German Ideology, doi
  223. (1991). The Global and the Local in International Communications",
  224. (1987). The History of the Burgis,
  225. (1993). The Hour of Civil Society",
  226. (1977). The Huk Rebellion, a Study of Peasant Revolt in the Philippines, doi
  227. (1987). The Hunger Crop: Poverty and the Sugar Industry,
  228. (1973). The Interpretation of Cultures, doi
  229. (1986). The long struggle for democracy in the Philippines",
  230. (1986). The Manipulated Press: A History of Philippine Journalism since 1945, (2nd edn. ),
  231. (1989). The Marcos Legacy:
  232. (1980). The Mass Media Election,
  233. (1991). The Media and Democracy, doi
  234. (1985). The Media"
  235. (1973). The Mind Managers, doi
  236. (1970). The Miseducation of the Filipino', doi
  237. (1981). The missing dimensions - News Media and the Management of Social Change',
  238. (1992). The NDF Program and the CPP Program for a People's Democratic Revolution: Umbilical Cord or Lifeline? ",
  239. (1988). The New Perils of the Philippine Press", in Rosario-Braid,
  240. (1987). The origins and development of the Northeast Asian political economy: industrial sectors, product cycles and political consequences", in Deyo doi
  241. (1985). The Past in the Present Crisis",
  242. (1990). The Peasant Movement and the Challenge of Rural Democratisation in the Philippines", doi
  243. (1990). The Perils of Presidential ism",
  244. (1991). The Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism: a Case Study",
  245. (1990). The Philippine News and Features: a Case Study",
  246. (1974). The Philippine press under Martial Law",
  247. (1984). The Philippine Press under Siege: volume 1, Manila, NPC Committee to Protect Writers.
  248. (1987). The Philippine Reader: a History of Colonialism.
  249. (1986). The Philippine revolution and the foreign media",
  250. (1987). The Philippine State and the Marcos Regime: the Politics of Export, doi
  251. (1985). The Philippines after Marcos, doi
  252. (1975). The Philippines: a Past Revisited, doi
  253. (1989). The Philippines: Fire on the Rim,
  254. (1981). The Philippines: from Communal to Societal Pangulo Regime",
  255. (1991). The Philippines: Land of Broken Promises, doi
  256. (1987). The Philippines: People, Poverty and Politics,
  257. (1992). The Philippines: Politics and Military Power,
  258. (1978). The Philippines: the Continuing Past, Quezon City, Foundation for Nationalist Studies.
  259. (1994). The Plausibility of Socialism",
  260. (1988). The Plight of the Provincial Journalists: 1. The Negros Experience",
  261. (1957). The Political Economy of Growth, doi
  262. (1987). The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism, doi
  263. (1979). The Politics of Modernization, doi
  264. (1991). The Problem with PR", doi
  265. (1981). The Quiet Revolt of the Philippine Press,
  266. (1984). The Rise of the Authoritarian State, doi
  267. (1985). The Silencing of Letty Magsanoc"
  268. (1966). The Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, doi
  269. (1951). The Social System, doi
  270. (1992). The Socialist Alternative", doi
  271. (1991). The Sociology of News Production Revisited"
  272. (1974). The Spiral of Silence: a Theory of Public Opinion", doi
  273. (1962). The Stages of Economic Growth: a Non-Communist Manifesto, Cambridge, doi
  274. (1985). The state and economic transformation: towards an analysis of the conditions underlying effective intervention" in Evans et al., doi
  275. (1969). The State in Capitalist Society: the Analysis of the Western System of Power, London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
  276. (1965). The Structure of Foreign News", doi
  277. (1982). The Structure of Peripheral Capitalism",
  278. (1987). The Theory of Democracy Revisited, doi
  279. (1991). The Third Wave: Democratization in the doi
  280. (1982). The Third World on TV news: western ways of seeing the other",
  281. (1994). The Transition to Independence in Namibia, doi
  282. (1985). The Truth about Journalism",
  283. (1984). The Two Revolutions: Gramsci and the Dilemmas of Western Marxism,
  284. (1990). The Urban Mass Movement
  285. (1990). The Virtues of Parliamentarianism",
  286. (1987). The World Order, Cambridge,
  287. (1993). Theoretical perspectives on the Role of State Elites in Southeast Asian Development" doi
  288. (1989). Theories of Development, Cambridge, doi
  289. (1981). There Goes the New Society; Welcome the New Republic",
  290. (1993). Transition and Continuity in the Philippines, doi
  291. (1986). Transitions from Authoritarian Rule; Volume Three: Comparative Perspectives, doi
  292. (1991). Transnational Communications: Wiring the Third World,
  293. (1979). Transnational media and national development" in Nordenstreng and Schiller,
  294. (1961). Two communicators of the news: a study of reporter and source roles", doi
  295. (1992). Unmasking a Giant, doi
  296. (1989). Vigilantes in the Philippines: a Threat to Democracy and Human Rights",
  297. (1987). Waltzing with a Dictator: the Marcoses and the Making of American Policy, doi
  298. (1978). Whose News? Politics. the Press and the Third World, doi
  299. (1984). Will More Countries Become Democratic", doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.