Location of Repository

Economic evaluation of alcohol treatments: linking drinking patterns, alcohol consequences and cost effectiveness of alcohol treatments\ud \ud

By Carolina Pinto Pereira Barbosa


The negative individual and social impacts of alcohol consumption raise a considerable policy interest surrounding alcohol treatment. Economic evaluations help on the allocation of scarce health care resources, but these have been inadequately conducted in the alcohol field. \ud This thesis builds up a taxonomy of alcohol-related consequences that should be included in economic evaluations of alcohol treatment and uses this taxonomy to critically review the published evidence around the cost effectiveness of alcohol treatments. The review provides a set of recommendations and most of them are pursued throughout the thesis. \ud An economic model for the cost effectiveness of alcohol treatments is developed. The framework provides the means to conduct economic evaluation while bearing the complexity and challenges of decision making in the field of human behaviour. A link between drinking patterns, health consequences and alcohol treatment effectiveness and cost effectiveness is created. This is a probabilistic lifetime model that uses the cohort simulation approach. The model can be applied to any setting and this is exemplified for a UK-scenario. The methods and data for the generation of UK-specific model inputs are described and used in two model applications. A first application of the model extrapolates the results of a short term randomized controlled trial and provides the expected lifetime costs and outcomes of the treatments compared, by age and gender. A second application compares two alcohol treatments delivered in different countries and to populations very different at baseline. Both case-studies show the importance of time and that only a long-term analysis can capture both short-term alcohol consequences, such as injuries, and long-term consequences, such as most forms of alcohol-related chronic diseases. \ud Assumptions and implications of the methods and analyses are discussed and recommendations for future research are presented.\u

Publisher: Health Sciences (York)
Year: 2010
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:815

Suggested articles



  1. (2001a) Average volume of alcohol consumption, patterns of drinking, and all-cause mortality: results from the US national alcohol survey. doi
  2. (2008). (2005a) Alcohol Needs Assessment Research Project (ANARP) Department of Health,
  3. (2005). (2005b) Basic types of economic evaluation. Methods for the economic evaluation of health care programmes, p 7-26.
  4. (2007a) Comparative quantification of alcohol exposure as risk factor for global burden of disease. doi
  5. (2001). A
  6. (1996). A 12-item short-form health survey - construction of scales and preliminary tests of reliability and validity. doi
  7. (1999). A cluster analysis of alcohol-related attitudes and behaviors in the general population.
  8. (2004). A comparison of the EQ-5D and SF-6D across seven patient groups. doi
  9. (2004). A meta-analysis of alcohol consumption and the risk of 15 diseases. doi
  10. (2000). A Note on the Common Support Problem in Applied Evaluation Studies. doi
  11. (1995). A note on the depreciation of the societal perspective in economic evaluation of health care. doi
  12. (2006). A taxonomy of model structures for economic evaluation of health technologies. doi
  13. (1988). A theory of rational addiction.
  14. (2006). Abstaining from alcohol and labour market underperformance. Have we forgotten the 'dry' alcoholics? doi
  15. (2002). Alcohol abuse and employment: a second look. doi
  16. (1998). Alcohol advice in primary health care: is it a wise use of resources? doi
  17. (1997). Alcohol alert: alcohol metabolism, Report 35. National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism Bethseda, doi
  18. (1994). Alcohol and casualties- a comparison of emergency room and coroner data. doi
  19. (2000). Alcohol and coronary heart disease: a meta-analysis. doi
  20. (2001). Alcohol and crime: examining the Link.
  21. (1993). Alcohol and injuries- a review of international emergency room studies. doi
  22. (2005). Alcohol and public health. doi
  23. (1999). Alcohol and the marriage effect.
  24. (1982). Alcohol Dependence Syndrome- measurement and validation. doi
  25. (2007). Alcohol drinking and total mortality risk. doi
  26. (2006). Alcohol in Europe, A Public Health Perspective. Institute of Alcohol Studies, doi
  27. (1996). Alcohol in fatal and nonfatal injuries: a comparison of coroner and emergency room data from the same county. doi
  28. (2005). Alcohol interventions for trauma patients treated in emergency departments and hospitals: a cost benefit analysis. doi
  29. (2003). Alcohol misuse: how much does it cost? Cabinet Office, London [Accessed 16
  30. (1994). Alcohol policy. Evaluating the options.
  31. (1994). Alcohol problems in employment - epidemiology and responses.
  32. (1993). Alcohol related mortality in the United States, doi
  33. (1987). Alcohol use by violent and property offenders. doi
  34. (1997). Alcohol use disorders, consumption patterns, and health-related quality of life of primary care patients. doi
  35. (2004). Alcohol use. In doi
  36. (2003). Alcohol: No Ordinary Commodity: Research and Public Policy. doi
  37. (2000). Alcohol.
  38. (1987). Alcoholism treatment and potential health care cost saving. doi
  39. (2006). Alqol 9 for measuring quality of life in alcohol dependence. doi
  40. (2003). Alternative decision modelling techniques for the evaluation of health care technologies: Markov processes versus discrete event simulation. doi
  41. (1998). An introduction to Markov modelling for economic evaluation. doi
  42. (2010). Appropriate perspectives for health care decisions. CHE Research Paper 54. Centre for Health Economics,
  43. (2000). Assessing quality in decision analytic cost effectiveness models. A suggested framework and example of application. doi
  44. (1993). Assessing the cost effectiveness of alcoholism treatments: a comment on Holder, Longabaugh, Miller and Rubonis.
  45. (1995). Assessment of health producing measures across different sectors. doi
  46. (2001). Association of outpatient alcohol and drug treatment with health care utilization and cost: Revisiting the offset hypothesis.
  47. (2001). AUDIT: The Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test: Guidelines for Use in Primary Health Care. World Health Organization,
  48. (2010). Available at http://www.who.int/healthinfo/global_burden_disease/GlobalHealthRisks_report_Front.pdf270
  49. (2008). Available at http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/che/publications/publicationsbyyear.htm
  50. (2000). Behavioural self-control training for problem drinkers: a meta-analysis of randomized control studies. doi
  51. (2006). Brief interventions for at-risk drinking: patient outcomes and cost effectiveness in managed care organizations. doi
  52. (2009). Brief interventions for heavy alcohol users admitted to general hospital wards. doi
  53. (2002). Brief physician advice for problem drinkers: long-term efficacy and benefit-cost analysis. doi
  54. (2005). Brief relationship therapy for alcoholism: A randomized clinical trial examining clinical efficacy and cost effectiveness. doi
  55. (2002). British Crime Survey. Home Office, doi
  56. (2004). Can the value choices in DALYs influence global priority-setting? doi
  57. (1999). Causal effects in non-experimental studies: re-evaluating the evaluation of training programmes. doi
  58. (2008). Causation and causal inference. Modern Epidemiology, doi
  59. (1980). Clinical decision analysis.
  60. (2002). Community-based alcohol counselling: a randomized clinical trial. doi
  61. (2004). Comparative quantification of health risks. Global and regional burden of disease attributable to selected major risk factors. Geneva: World Health Organization.
  62. (1985). Constructing a control group using multivariate matched sampling methods that incorporate the propensity score. doi
  63. (2008). Cost and cost effectiveness of the COMBINE study in alcohol dependent patients.
  64. (2006). Cost and outcome analysis of two alcohol detoxification services. doi
  65. (2000). Cost benefit analysis of drug treatment services: review of the literature. doi
  66. (1996). Cost benefit and cost effectiveness analyses of behavioral marital therapy as an addition to outpatient alcoholism treatment. doi
  67. (2004). Cost effectiveness analysis of a brief intervention delivered to problem drinkers presenting at an inner-city hospital emergency department.
  68. (2004). Cost effectiveness analysis of addiction treatment: paradoxes of multiple outcomes. doi
  69. (1996). Cost effectiveness in health and medicine.
  70. (2003). Cost effectiveness of adjuvant treatment with acamprosate in maintaining abstinence in alcohol dependent patients. doi
  71. (1994). Cost effectiveness of alcohol service provision.
  72. (2001). Cost effectiveness of brief interventions for reducing alcohol consumption. doi
  73. (2006). Cost effectiveness of screening and referral to an alcohol health worker in alcohol misusing patients attending an accident and emergency department: a decision-making approach. doi
  74. (1978). Cost of disease and illness in the United States in the year
  75. (2000). Cost of illness studies: what is good about them? doi
  76. (2006). Decision modelling for health economic evaluation: doi
  77. (2007). Decision models need to be "fit for purpose" for decision-making: response to Caro et al. doi
  78. (2008). Designing randomized trials in health, education and the social sciences: an introduction. Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. doi
  79. (2008). Determination of lifetime injury mortality risk in Canada in doi
  80. (1994). Determining transition probabilities- confusion and suggestions. doi
  81. (1995). Development of a self-administered Quality of Well-Being Scale (QWB-SA): initial studies. doi
  82. (1994). Development of the Leeds dependence questionnaire (LDQ) to measure alcohol and opiate dependence in the context of a treatment evaluation package. doi
  83. (1994). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. doi
  84. (2004). Does problem drinking affect employment? Evidence from England. doi
  85. (1997). Drug abuse, crime costs, and the economic benefits of treatment. doi
  86. (2000). Drugs and crime: the results of the second developmental stage of the NEWADAM programme. Home Office,
  87. (1999). Dutch guidelines for pharmacoeconomic research. College Voor Zorgverzekeringen,
  88. (2000). Economic evaluation of alcohol treatment services. doi
  89. (2008). Economic evaluation of continuing care interventions in the treatment of substance abuse: recommendations for future research. doi
  90. (2000). Economics notes - costing in economic evaluation. doi
  91. (2004). Effective and cost effective measures to reduce alcohol misuse in Scotland: an update to the literature review Scottish Executive Health Department,
  92. (2009). Effectiveness and cost effectiveness of a stepped care intervention for alcohol use disorders in primary care: pilot study. doi
  93. (2007). Effectiveness of brief alcohol interventions in primary care populations. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews doi
  94. (2006). Effectiveness of nurse-led brief alcohol intervention: a cluster randomized controlled trial. doi
  95. (1978). Egonomics, or art of self-management.
  96. (2001). Elstein A doi
  97. (1991). Emergency room evidence on the role of alcohol intoxication in injury at work in the United States. doi
  98. (1993). Employee accidents - influences of personal characteristics, job characteristics, and substance use in jobs differing in accident potential. doi
  99. (1996). Employment, unemployment, and problem drinking. doi
  100. (1994). Empowering family and friends: a new approach to the secondary prevention of addiction. doi
  101. (2009). Epidemiology. doi
  102. (2005). Establishing the cost effectiveness of new pharmaceuticals under conditions of uncertainty. When is there sufficient evidence? Value in doi
  103. (1997). Estimating CE ratios under second-order uncertainty. The mean ratio versus the ratio of means. doi
  104. (1996). Estimating costs in cost effectiveness analysis.
  105. (2007). Estimating the economic and social costs of the fear of crime. doi
  106. (1990). Euroqol - a new facility for the measurement of Health-Related Quality-of-Life. doi
  107. (1995). Evaluating multiple outcomes and gender differences in alcoholism treatment. doi
  108. (2006). Evidence based illicit drug policy: the potential contribution of economic evaluation techniques doi
  109. (2004). Evidence-based care for alcohol use disorders is affordable. doi
  110. (1987). Expenditure effects of changes in Medicaid benefit coverage: an alcohol and substance abuse example. doi
  111. (1999). Exploring the dose-response relationship between alcohol consumption and the risk of several alcohol-related conditions: a meta-analysis. doi
  112. (2003). Financial costs of alcoholism treatment programs: a longitudinal and comparative evaluation among four specialized centers. doi
  113. (1997). Flows and costs in the criminal process. Unpublished document. Home Office.
  114. (1998). Formulating the questions and locating the studies for inclusion in systematic reviews. In Mulrow C and Cook D (eds), Systematic reviews- synthesis of best evidence for health care decisions, p 67-79. Philadelphia: American College of Physicians.
  115. (1991). Gafni A doi
  116. (1992). Gender disparities in treatment for alcohol problems. doi
  117. (2004). General practitioners' role in preventive medicine: scenario analysis using alcohol as a case study. doi
  118. (1997). Generalisation from phase III clinical trials: survival, quality of life, and health economics. doi
  119. (2009). Global burden of disease and injury and economic cost attributable to alcohol use and alcohol-use disorders. doi
  120. (1997). Global mortality, disability, and the contribution of risk factors: Global Burden of Disease study. doi
  121. Gmel G (2001b) Alcohol and all-cause mortality: a pooled analysis. doi
  122. (2006). Good practice guidelines for decisionanalytic modelling in health technology assessment - a review and consolidation of quality assessment. doi
  123. (1990). Health and Daily Living Form Manual.
  124. (2008). Health, Home Office, London [Accessed 5
  125. (1994). Heavy drinking and the risk of occupational injury. doi
  126. (2000). Heavy drinking, alcohol dependence, and injuries at work among young workers in the United States labor force. doi
  127. (2000). How can policy makers use available evidence on the cost benefits of drug treatment? doi
  128. (2009). How to perform a critical analysis of a randomised controlled trial. doi
  129. (2002). Ichino A
  130. (1996). Identifying and valuing outcomes.
  131. (2004). Inclusion of cost effectiveness in licensing requirements of new drugs: the fourth hurdle. doi
  132. (2005). Indurkhya A doi
  133. (1999). Influence of pattern of drinking on cardiovascular disease and cardiovascular risk factors - a review. doi
  134. (2005). Injury places and alcohol use. Emergency room study.
  135. (1999). Inpatient alcohol treatment in a private healthcare setting: which patients benefit and at what cost?
  136. (2001). International Guidelines for Estimating the Costs of Substance Abuse-
  137. (2000). Interpreting the rational addiction model. doi
  138. (1995). Is moderate alcohol use related to wages - evidence from 4 worksites. doi
  139. (1992). Is there a safe level of daily consumption of alcohol for men and women? Camberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
  140. (2001). Kilburg A doi
  141. (1997). Lifelong teetotallers, ex-drinkers and drinkers: mortality and the incidence of major coronary heart disease events in middle-aged British men. doi
  142. (2004). Manca A doi
  143. (2007). Mark versus Luke? Appropriate methods for the evaluation of public health interventions. CHE Research Paper 31. Centre for Health Economics,
  144. (1993). Markov models in medical decision making - a practical guide. doi
  145. (2007). Matching estimators of average treatment effects: a review applied to the evaluation of health care programmes. HEDG Working Paper 07/02,
  146. (2000). Measurement of quality of life in alcoholdependent subjects by a cancer symptoms checklist.
  147. (2007). Measuring and valuing health benefits for economic evaluation.
  148. (2002). Mesa Grande: a methodological analysis of clinical trials of treatments for alcohol use disorders. doi
  149. (2008). Methods for moderation: measuring lifetime risk of alcoholattributable mortality as a basis for drinking guidelines doi
  150. (2006). Mid-2006 population estimates: England; estimated resident population by single year of age and sex
  151. (1997). Modelling in economic evaluation: an unavoidable fact of life. doi
  152. (2004). Modelling in the economic evaluation of health care: selecting the appropriate approach. doi
  153. (1993). Modelling the interactions between alcohol, crime and the criminal justice system. doi
  154. (2001). Mortality in England and Wales attributable to current alcohol consumption. doi
  155. (1992). Motivational enhancement therapy: a clinical research guide for therapists treating individuals with alcohol abuse and dependence.
  156. (2002). Motivational interviewing: preparing people for change. doi
  157. (1995). Multiattribute preference functions- Health Utility Index. doi
  158. (2006). NHS Reference Costs 2005-06. Department of Health,
  159. (2004). Nonparametric estimation of average treatment effects under exogeneity: a review. doi
  160. (1984). Occupational accidents and alcohol. doi
  161. on behalf of the UKATT research team (2002) Social behaviour and network therapy - basic principles and early experiences. doi
  162. (2005). Opioid antagonists for alcohol dependence. doi
  163. (1996). Patient preferences in randomised trials: threat or opportunity?
  164. (2008). Patients' preferences within randomised trials: systematic review and patient level meta-analysis. doi
  165. (1985). Patterns of outcome: drinking histories over ten years among a group of alcoholics. doi
  166. (1998). Perspectives in economic evaluation. doi
  167. Popova S (2006b) Alcohol-attributable mortality and potential years of life lost in Canada 2001: implications for prevention and policy. doi
  168. Popova S (2007b) Alcohol drinking cessation and its effect on esophageal and head and neck cancers: a pooled analysis. doi
  169. (1998). Predictors of relapse to heavy drinking in alcohol dependent subjects following alcohol detoxification- the role of quality of life measures, ethnicity, social class, cigarette and drug use. doi
  170. (2003). Prevention of relapse in alcohol dependence. Health Technology Board for Scotland,
  171. (2006). Probabilistic analysis and computationally expensive models: necessary and required? doi
  172. (2003). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis for decision trees with multiple branches: use of the Dirichlet distribution in a Bayesian framework. doi
  173. (2005). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis for NICE technology assessment: not an optional extra. doi
  174. (1985). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis using Monte Carlo simulation. A practical approach. doi
  175. (2002). Promoting self-change with alcohol abusers: a community-level mail intervention based on natural recovery studies. doi
  176. (2000). Public expenditure statistical analysis 2000-1. Command 4601. London: Stationery Office.
  177. (1999). Quality of Life in alcohol-dependent subjectsa review.
  178. (1986). Randomised trial of community-based versus conventional hospital management in the treatment of alcoholism. doi
  179. (1996). Reduced substance-abuse-related health care costs among voluntary participants in Alcoholics Anonymous.
  180. (2004). Reducing the global burden of hazardous alcohol use: a comparative cost effectiveness analysis. doi
  181. (2006). Review of the effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems. The National Treatment Agency for Substance Misuse,
  182. Sempos CT (2003b) The relationship of average volume of alcohol consumption and patterns of drinking to burden of disease: an overview. doi
  183. (2003). Source and accuracy statement for wave 1 of the 2001-2002
  184. (2009). Sowden A doi
  185. (2005). Spending on substance abuse treatment: how much is enough? doi
  186. SPSS 15 for Windows, Release
  187. (2009). Stata statistical software version 10.1. College Station,
  188. (1998). Statistics on race and the criminal justice system. Home Office, doi
  189. (2002). Taylor B (2006a) The costs of substance abuse in Canada
  190. Team (2005a) Cost effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems: findings of the randomised UK Alcohol Treatment Trial (UKATT). doi
  191. (1998). Team (2005b) Effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems: findings of the randomised UK Alcohol Treatment Trial (UKATT). doi
  192. (2004). The addition of a psychological intervention to a home detoxification programme. doi
  193. (1999). The Assessment of Quality of Life (AQoL) instrument: a psychometric measure of health-related quality of life. doi
  194. (2000). The association between health-related behaviours and the risk of divorce in the USA. doi
  195. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. doi
  196. (1998). The cost effectiveness of acamprosate in the treatment of alcoholism in Germany: doi
  197. (1991). The cost effectiveness of treatment for alcoholism - a 1st approximation.
  198. (1999). The cost of criminal justice, Report 103. Home office,
  199. (2001). The design and analysis of stochastic cost effectiveness studies for the evaluation of health care interventions. doi
  200. (2005). The Dictionary of Health Economics. doi
  201. (1982). The distinction between costs and charges. doi
  202. (2005). The economic and social costs of crime against individuals and households 2003/04. Home Office,
  203. (2000). The economic costs of crime. Home Office Research Study 217. Home Office.
  204. (1967). The economic value of human life.
  205. (2009). The economics of alcohol. doi
  206. (2002). The effect of alcohol consumption on earnings. doi
  207. (2004). The efficacy of acamprosate in the maintenance of abstinence in alcohol-dependent individuals: results of a meta-analysis. doi
  208. (2003). The efficacy of motivational interviewing: a metaanalysis of controlled clinical trials. doi
  209. (2007). The EQ-5D in alcohol dependent patients: relationships among health-related quality of life, psychopathology and social functioning. doi
  210. (2002). The estimation of a preference-based measure of health from the SF-36. doi
  211. (1995). The friction cost method for measuring indirect costs of disease.
  212. (1992). The ICD-10 classification of mental and behavioural disorders: clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines. World Health Organization, doi
  213. (2001). The impact of problem drinking on employment. doi
  214. (1999). The impact of sociodemographics, comorbidity and symptom recency on health-related quality of life in alcoholics.
  215. (1999). The irrelevance of inference: a decision-making approach to the stochastic evaluation of health care technologies. doi
  216. (2000). The long-term cost effectiveness of improving alcohol abstinence with adjuvant acamprosate. doi
  217. (1992). The Medical Outcomes Study 36-item Short-Form health survey (SF-36). Conceptual framework and item selection. doi
  218. (2003). The National Coroners Information System as an information tool for injury survaillence.
  219. (2007). The NHS Information Centre (2007a). Health Care Resource Groups. The NHS Information Centre [Accessed 12
  220. (2001). The quantification of drug-caused mortality and morbidity in Australia
  221. (1995). The quantification of morbidity and mortality caused by substance abuse. Camberra: Commonwealth Department of Human Services and Health.
  222. (1992). The reduction of health care costs associated with alcoholism treatment: a 14-year longitudinal study.
  223. (1997). The relationship of drinking and hangovers to workplace problems: an empirical study.
  224. (2003). The relative contribution of outcome domains in the total economic benefit of addiction interventions: a review of first findings. doi
  225. (2009). The relative efficacy of two levels of a primary care intervention for family members affected by the addiction problem of a close relative: a randomized trial. doi
  226. (1993). The role of alcohol in work-related fatal accidents in Australia 1982-1984. doi
  227. (1996). The SECCAT survey 1. The costs and consequences of alcoholism. doi
  228. (1983). The Severity of Alcohol Dependence Questionnaire. Its use, reliability and validity. doi
  229. (1985). The value of safety: results of a national sample survey. doi
  230. (1994). Toward a peer-review process for medical decision-analysis models. doi
  231. (1998). Treating alcohol problems: a study of programme effectiveness and cost effectiveness according to length and delivery of treatment. doi
  232. (2000). Treno AJ, Zweben A doi
  233. (2001). Undertaking Systematic Reviews of Research on Effectiveness CRD's Guidance for those Carrying Out or Commissioning Reviews.
  234. (2002). Unit costs of health and social care
  235. (2007). Unit costs of health and social care 2007. Personal Social Services Research Unit,
  236. (2001). United Kingdom Alcohol Treatment Trial (UKATT): hypotheses, design and methods. doi
  237. (2003). Validity of indirect comparison for estimating efficacy of competing interventions: empirical evidence from published meta-analyses. doi
  238. (1996). Victim costs and consequences: a new look.
  239. (1999). What is meant by intention to treat analysis? Survey of published randomised controlled trials. doi
  240. (2006). Whither trial-based economic evaluation for health care decision making? doi
  241. (2002). Work environment, alcohol consumption and health: the Whitehall II study. Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, University College London, London. Available at http://www.hse.gov.uk/research/crr_pdf/2002/crr02422.pdf260 Health and Safety Executive
  242. (1997). Work-place alcohol and other drug testing: a review of the scientific evidence. doi
  243. (2003). Worker substance use, workplace problems and the risk of occupational injury. A matched case-control study.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.