Location of Repository

Physician Assistants in NHS Scotland: Reviewing the Issues. Report for the Scottish Executive Health Department.

By James Buchan, Jane Ball and Fiona O'May


This paper was commissioned by the Scottish Executive Health Department (SEHD). It provides background information on the role of physician assistants (PAs), and on their deployment in the United States and in England. The SEHD is planning to recruit and deploy a small number of US educated PAs in the NHS in Scotland in 2006.\ud \ud The primary focus of the paper is to identify lessons for consideration during planning and implementation of the planned “pilot”. This paper highlights key lessons from\ud the literature, and from key informants, on the employment of PAs.\ud \ud Readers who wish a comprehensive assessment and description of the development of the PA role in the USA, should consult the American Academy of Physician Assistants (AAPA) website (www.aapa.org) and also the core book by Hooker and\ud Cawley (2003).\ud \ud Given constraints of time and resources the focus of the review was on identifying key messages for Scotland; it was not structured as a systematic review (no systematic\ud review of physicians assistants was identified during the search). The review was supported by follow up contact with key individuals and representatives of organisations in the US and with UK organisations working with PAs. The purpose was to identify the issues that need be considered in the lead up to the recruitment and deployment of PAs in the NHS in Scotland.\ud \ud The remainder of the paper is in two sections: Section 2 reports key findings from the literature review; and Section 3 reports of follow up findings, and focuses on key\ud messages for Scotland

Publisher: Queen Margaret University College
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:eresearch.qmu.ac.uk:504

Suggested articles



  1. (2004a) Patien t satis fa ct i o n with prima r y care: does type of pract i t i o ne r matter?
  2. (2002). A cost analysis of physici a n assist a n t s in primary care.
  3. (2002). A cost analysis of physician assistants in primary care.
  4. AAPA (2004a) Trends in the physician a ssistan t professi o n 1991-200 3 . Alexandr i a , Virgin i a :
  5. AAPA (2004a) Trends in the physician assistant profession 1991-2003.
  6. AAPA (2004b) Issue brief: Physician Assi st a n t Scope of Prac tic e . Alexan d r i a , Virgin i a :
  7. AAPA (2004b) Issue brief: Physician Assistant Scope of Practice.
  8. AAPA (2005a ) Compet e n c i e s for th e physici a n assista n t profess i o n .
  9. AAPA (2005a) Competencies for the physician assistant profession. doi
  10. AAPA (2005b) Physician assist a n t census report 2005. Alex andria,
  11. (1999). AAPA (2005b) Physician assistant census report 2005.
  12. (2005). Accommo d a t i n g a new medical profess i o n : the history of physicia n assistan t regulato r y legislat i o n in North Carolina .
  13. (2005). Accommodating a new medical profession: the history of physician assistant regulatory legislation in North Carolina.
  14. (2001). Advance d nurse practit i o n e r s and physici a n assist a n t s : what is the difference? Comparing the USA and UK.
  15. (2001). Advanced nurse practitioners and physician assistants: what is the difference? doi
  16. (1997). Allied health and physician assistants: a progressive partnership.
  17. (2002). Americ a n idea of physic i a n as sista n t s can be anglici s e d . Letter to edit or .
  18. (2002). American idea of physician assistants can be anglicised. Letter to editor.
  19. (2005). APAP National Recruitment Strategies Taskforce Report.
  20. (2005). APAP National Recruitment Strategies Taskforce Report. Alexand r i a , Virgin i a :
  21. (2005). Can physician assistants be effective in the UK?
  22. (2005). Cantanz a r o R &
  23. (2005). Commentary from the front lines: American physician assistants working in a United Kingdom emergency department. doi
  24. (1978). Cost effecti v e ne s s of physic i a n assist a nt s : a review of recent evide n c e .
  25. (1978). Cost effectiveness of physician assistants: a review of recent evidence.
  26. (1998). Decis i o n makin g : the context of nurse prescrib i n g .
  27. (1998). Decision making: the context of nurse prescribing. doi
  28. (2002). Departme n t of Health
  29. (2005). Departme nt of Health
  30. (1996). Do we need physician assistants in the UK?
  31. (2002). Esmail A doi
  32. (2002). Fightin g Hand to Hand over Physici a n Workfor c e Policy. Health Affairs 21 (5) 13-27 Gryzb i c k i DM, Sulliva n PJ,
  33. (2002). Fighting Hand to Hand over Physician Workforce Policy. doi
  34. (2005). From physician assistant to medical care practitioner. Work Based Learning in Primary Care,
  35. (2002). Future Practice: Proposals of an Advisory Group. Commissioned by the Scottish Executive to Review the Scottish Medical Workforce. Edinburgh Scott S
  36. (2002). G a v i n M & Esmail A doi
  37. (2003). H o o k e r RS (2003) Interna t i o n a l Medical Workfor c e Conferen c e . Nonphysician clinicians: the US experience.
  38. (2001). H u t c h i n s o n L, doi
  39. Howard DH & Roberts MH (2004a) Patient satisfaction with primary care: does type of practitioner matter? doi
  40. L a B a r b e r a DM (2004) Physic i a n as sist a n t vocati o n a l satisf a c t i o n .
  41. (2000). Looking into tomorro w . Health workfor c e issues confro n t i n g physic i a n assist a n t s
  42. (2000). Looking into tomorrow. Health workforce issues confronting physician assistants,
  43. (2005). Maxi Nurses. Advanced and specialist nursing roles. RCN: London. (accessed 1 st
  44. (2005). Maxi Nurses. Advanced and specialist nursing roles. RCN: London. < http: / / w ww. r c n . o r g . u k/ p u b l i c a t i o ns / p d f / ma x i _ n u r s e s _ a d v a n c e d . p d f > (acce s s e d 1 st
  45. (1997). Medica l Wo rkfo r c e Standi n g Adviso r y Commit t e e .
  46. MH (2004b) Use of midlevel practitioners to achieve labor cost savings in the primary care practice of an MCO. doi
  47. (2001). Na tiona l Estimat e s of Physi c i a n Assis t a nt Producti v i t y .
  48. (2001). National Estimates of Physician Assistant Productivity.
  49. (2006). NES Explor i n g new solutions to Scotland’s Healthcare workforce pressu r e s . Physician Assistants in the US: History, Background & Evidence Base.
  50. (2006). NES Exploring new solutions to Scotland’s Healthcare workforce pressures.
  51. (2005). Office of the Chief Medical Officer doi
  52. (2006). Office of the Chief Medical Officer (2005) Report on research into recruitment and retention of GPs in Wales. Cardiff: CMO. Available from (accessed 1 st
  53. (2002). PA educati o n in an evolvin g health care system.
  54. (2002). PA education in an evolving health care system.
  55. (2005). Patient satisfaction with physician assistant, nurse practitioner, and physician care: a national survey of Medicare beneficiaries.
  56. (2002). Phys ic i a n assist a n t s in the United States ,
  57. (2005). Physic i a n assi st a n t and nurse practi t i o n e r prescr i b i n g : 1997-20 0 2 .
  58. (2003). Physic i an assist a n t s: f illi n g the gap in patie n t care in acade mi c hospit a l s .
  59. (2004). Physicia n assistan t s in occupat i o n a l medicin e : how do they compare to occupat i o n a l physici a n s ?
  60. (2004). Physician assist ant – manageme nt perspective.
  61. (2004). Physician assistant – management perspective. doi
  62. (2005). Physician assistant and nurse practitioner prescribing: 1997-2002. doi
  63. (2005). Physician assistant supply and demand. doi
  64. (2004). Physician assistant vocational satisfaction.
  65. (2003). Physician Assistants doi
  66. (2005). Physician assistants as physician extenders in the pediatric intensive care unit setting-A 5-year experience. Pediatric Critical Care Medicine, doi
  67. (2004). Physician assistants in occupational medicine: how do they compare to occupational physicians? doi
  68. (2002). Physician assistants in the United States, doi
  69. (2003). Physician assistants: filling the gap in patient care in academic hospitals.
  70. (2005). Ra mpers a d A, Howard K & Gold man GM
  71. (1999). Replace the ‘assistant’ in “physician assistant”? Roundta b l e debate .
  72. (1999). Replace the ‘assistant’ in “physician assistant”? Roundtable debate.
  73. (1994). Role differen t i a t i o n of the nurse pract i t i on e r and physic i a n assist a n t , withi n the real i z a t i o n of healt h care refor m.
  74. (1994). Role differentiation of the nurse practitioner and physician assistant, within the realization of health care reform. The Nurse Practitioner, doi
  75. (2003). Rural and urban physi c i a n s ’ perce p t i o n s regar d i n g the role and practic e of the nurse practitioner, physic i a n assist a n t , and cer tified nurse midwife.
  76. (2003). Rural and urban physicians’ perceptions regarding the role and practice of the nurse practitioner, physician assistant, and certified nurse midwife. doi
  77. (2002). Schemes will help boost GP numbers and improve working lives. DoH: London. Available from s/fs/en?CONTENT_ID=4014312&chk=OdiFJw> (accessed 1 st
  78. (2005). Sekscen s k i E
  79. (2005). The competence and curriculum framework for the medical care practitioner: A consultation document.
  80. (2000). The economi c basis of physici a n assist a n t practi c e .
  81. (2000). The economic basis of physician assistant practice.
  82. (2001). The physician assistant: would the US model meet the needs of the NHS? doi
  83. (1996). The productivity of physician assistants and nurse practitioners and health work force policy in the era of managed health care.
  84. (2002). Trends in the supply of physician assistants and nurse practit i o n e r s in the United States. doi
  85. (2002). Trends in the supply of physician assistants and nurse practitioners in the United States. Health Affairs, doi
  86. (1997). Vetrosky DT & Cove y PC
  87. (2006). w ww. a a p a . o r g / r e s e a r c h / 0 5 c e n s u s - c o nt e n t . h t ml
  88. (2006). w ww. d h . g o v . u k / a s s e t R o o t doi
  89. (2006). w ww. j a a p a . c o m / i s s u e s doi
  90. (2004). Weighin g the Evidenc e for Expandi n g Physici a n Supply.
  91. (2004). Weighing the Evidence for Expanding Physician Supply. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.