Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

'Tough'-constructions and their derivation

By Glyn Hicks


This article addresses the syntax of the notorious 'tough' (-movement) construction (TC) in English. TCs exhibit a range of apparently contradictory empirical properties suggesting that their derivation involves the application of both A-movement and A'-movement operations. Given that within previous Principles and Parameters models TCs have remained “unexplained and in principle unexplainable” (Holmberg 2000: 839) due to incompatibility with constraints on theta-assignment, locality, and Case, this article argues that the phase-based implementation of the Minimalist program (Chomsky 2000, 2001, 2004) permits a reanalysis of null wh-operators capable of circumventing the previous theoretical difficulties. Essentially, 'tough'-movement consists of A-moving a constituent out of a “complex” null operator which has already undergone A'-movement, a “smuggling” construction in the terms of Collins (2005a,b

Topics: P1
Year: 2009
OAI identifier:
Provided by: e-Prints Soton

Suggested articles


  1. (2002). 33Boˇ skovi´ c, ˇ Zeljko.
  2. (2002). A derivational approach to syntactic relations based on clitics. doi
  3. (1998). A Derivational Approach to Syntactic Relations.
  4. (2003). A derivational approach to the interpretation of scrambling chains. doi
  5. (1993). A minimalist program for linguistic theory. doi
  6. (1960). A multiply ambiguous adjectival construction in English. Language 36:207–221. doi
  7. (2005). A smuggling approach to raising in English. Linguistic Inquiry 36:289–298. doi
  8. (2005). A smuggling approach to the passive in English. Syntax 8:81–120. doi
  9. (1984). Against reanalysis rules. Linguistic Analysis 14:3–30.
  10. (2000). Am I unscientific? a reply to Lappin, Levine, and Johnson. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 18:837–842. doi
  11. Anoteonrightnoderaising, toughconstructionsandreanalysis rules. Linguistic Analysis 13:159–172.
  12. (2004). Beyond explanatory adequacy.
  13. (1987). Binding problems with experiencer verbs. Linguistic Inquiry 18:203–238.
  14. (1986). Chains and Anaphoric Dependence: On Reconstruction and Its Implications. Doctoral Dissertation,
  15. (1999). Chains of arguments.
  16. (1974). Complement object deletion. Linguistic Inquiry 5:535–572. doi
  17. (1971). Cross-over phenomena.
  18. (1964). Current issues in linguistic theory. The Hague: doi
  19. (2001). Derivation by phase. doi
  20. (1995). Easy-adjectives and their ilk. Paper presented at the
  21. (1996). Easy-class adjectives in Old English: a constructional approach.
  22. (2000). Economy and Semantic Interpretation. doi
  23. (2004). Elements of Cyclic Syntax: Agree and Merge. Doctoral Dissertation, doi
  24. (1963). Finitary models of language users. doi
  25. (1982). Grammatical relations and Montague grammar. doi
  26. (1992). Inheritance and complementation: a case study of easy adjectives and related nouns.
  27. (2000). Is the tough-subject thematic? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Linguistic Society of America,
  28. (1981). Lectures on government and binding. doi
  29. (1982). Lexical-functional grammar: a formal system for grammatical representation.
  30. (1981). Lovely to look at. Linguistic Analysis 8:431–448.
  31. (2000). Minimalist inquiries: the framework. In Step by step: essays on minimalist syntax in honor of Howard Lasnik, doi
  32. (2000). Missing-object constructions: lexical and constructional variation.
  33. (2001). Move! a minimalist theory of construal. doi
  34. (1999). Movement and control. Linguistic Inquiry 30:69–96. doi
  35. (2002). Movement types and triggers.
  36. (1986). Null antecedents and proper government.
  37. (1987). Null operator constructions. Doctoral Dissertation,
  38. (1972). Observations on sentential stress. doi
  39. (1993). On null operator structures. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 11:1–30. doi
  40. (1974). On raising. doi
  41. (1966). On so-called ‘pronouns’ in English.
  42. (2004). On the edge. In Peripheries: syntactic edges and their doi
  43. (1977). On wh-movement. doi
  44. (2000). Pragmatics of the English tough-construction.
  45. (1995). Predication in tough constructions.
  46. (1990). Prolegomena to a typology of tough movement. doi
  47. (2002). Pronouns and their antecedents. doi
  48. (1984). Quantifier-pro and the LF representation of PROarb. Linguistic Inquiry 15:499–504.
  49. (1970). Remarks on nominalization. doi
  50. (2003). Representation theory. doi
  51. (1995). Rethinking some empty categories: missing objects and parasitic gaps in HPSG. Doctoral Dissertation,
  52. (2001). Richard returns: Copy raising and its implications.
  53. (2001). Scope reconstruction and A-movement. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 19:503–548. doi
  54. (2001). Sideward movement. Linguistic Inquiry 32:303–344. doi
  55. (2003). So Easy to Look at, So Hard to Define”: Tough Movement in the Minimalist Framework.
  56. (1982). Some concepts and consequences of the theory of government and binding. doi
  57. (1999). Some thoughts on tough movement.
  58. (1979). Syntactic argumentation and the structure of English. doi
  59. (1983). Syntactic vs. semantic categories. doi
  60. (2001). Syntax at the edge: cross-clausal phenomena and the syntax of Passamaquoddy. Doctoral Dissertation,
  61. (2006). The derivation of anaphoric relations. Doctoral Dissertation, doi
  62. (1978). The easy class of adjectives in English. Doctoral Dissertation,
  63. (1967). The grammar of English predicate complement constructions. doi
  64. (1977). The Grammar of Quantification. Doctoral Dissertation,
  65. (1992). The lexical entailment theory of control and the toughconstruction.
  66. (1995). The Minimalist Program. doi
  67. (1993). The recognition and interpretation of idioms.
  68. (1998). The syntax, semantics, and pragmatics of the tough construction. Linguistic Analysis 3:3–32.
  69. (1993). The theory of principles and parameters.
  70. (1982). Three ways to get tough. Papers from the Regional Meetings of the Chicago Linguistic Society 18:348–366.
  71. (1990). Tough movement as function composition.
  72. (1991). Tough movement constructions.
  73. (1971). Tough movement si, tough deletion no! Linguistic Inquiry 2:544–546.
  74. (1992). Tough parasitic gaps.
  75. (1990). Types of ¯ A-dependencies.
  76. (1991). Weakest crossover.
  77. (1998). Where does the binding theory apply? doi
  78. (1979). Why tough movement is impossible with possible. Papers from the Regional Meetings of the Chicago Linguistic Society 15:1–8.
  79. (1993). θ-theory and arguments. Linguistic Inquiry 24:1–23.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.