Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Access to justice within the sustainable self-governance model

By Stephen Tully


Little attention has been given to the development and operation of non-state models of global governance and the extent to which they conform to principles of good governance. Focusing primarily on issues of access to justice and secondarily on the independence of such bodies from the industries which they purport to regulate, this paper argues that adjudicative mechanisms established by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and firms may not produce outcomes which are considered 'just' by them. Part one locates dispute resolution as a narrower aspect of participation in decision-making, identifies several deficiencies of the state-centric model in the provision of justice and outlines collaborative NGO-corporate arrangements. Part two provides an account of one NGO-corporate arrangement, portrays its principal function and governance structure and identifies the relevant procedural aspects for initiating its private adjudicative arm. The case study considered in part three involves recourse by the Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society to the objections procedure of the Marine Stewardship Council with a view to challenging the certification of the New Zealand hoki fishery as well-managed and sustainable. Finally, it is argued in part four that the lack of independence and limited remedies available to such arrangements does not merely fail to realise justice but has wider ramifications for the continued governance of corporate-NGO arrangements

Topics: HG Finance, K Law (General)
Publisher: Centre for Analysis of Risk and Regulation, London School of Economics and Political Science
Year: 2004
OAI identifier:
Provided by: LSE Research Online
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • (external link)
  • (external link)
  • (external link)
  • Suggested articles


    1. (1972). A Theory of Justice, doi
    2. (1981). Access to Justice and the Welfare State, Martinus Sijthoff Publishers,
    3. (1992). Business Strategy for Sustainable Development: leadership and accountability for the 90s, doi
    4. (2001). Code of Practice for Mitigating Seal and Sea Lion By-Catch.
    5. (1999). Codes of Conduct for Partnership in Governance: Texts and Commentaries,
    6. (2001). Economic Commission for Europe, doi
    7. (2001). European Governance: A White Paper, doi
    8. (2002). Final Report on International Sustainable Development Governance: the question of reform: key issues and proposals,
    9. (2002). Fishery Surveillance Audit Reports
    10. (1948). General Assembly Resolution 217A(III)
    11. (2001). Handbook on Access to Justice under the Aarhus Convention, Draft, Regional Environmental Center for Central and
    12. (2002). Hoki Certification confirmed by Independent Review’, Press Release,
    13. (1998). Hoki Sector Foresight Strategy-Our Vision to 2010 and Beyond.
    14. (2001). Human Development Report, Deepening Democracy,
    15. (2002). Independent Panel Decision on the New Zealand Hoki Fishery.
    16. (2002). Industry Agreed Code of Practice for Hoki Target Trawling,
    17. (1996). International Organisation for Standardisation, Environmental Management Systems
    18. (1999). Just Lawyers: regulation and access to justice, doi
    19. (2000). Network for the Implementation and Enforcement of Environmental Law, Complaint Procedures and Access to Justice for Citizens and NGOs in the field of the Environment within the European Union, Final Report, The Hague,
    20. (2002). New Zealand Hoki Dispute Panel Releases its
    21. (2002). New Zealand Hoki Dispute Panel Releases Its Findings on Certification of the Fishery to the MSC Standard’, Press Release.
    22. (1999). Organised Interests and Self-Regulation: an economic approach,
    23. (1999). Position Paper submitted to the Seventh Session of the UN Commission on Sustainable Development,
    24. (1998). Principles and Criteria for Sustainable Fishing, Airlie House Draft, doi
    25. (2002). Protection Society
    26. (1995). Public Sector Management, Governance and Sustainable Human Development, doi
    27. (2001). Public Summary Report.
    28. (1997). Republicanism: a theory of freedom and government, doi
    29. (1995). Resolution on a Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries, doi
    30. (2003). Some Reflections on Justice in a Globalising World’, Remarks made at the
    31. (2000). Terms for Endearment: Business, NGO’s and Sustainable Development, doi
    32. (1999). The Audit Society: rituals of verification, doi
    33. (2002). The Open Corporation: effective self-regulation and democracy, doi
    34. (1981). The Principles of Social Order: selected essays of doi
    35. (1987). World Commission on Environment and Development, doi

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.