Location of Repository

This paper presents and philosophically assesses three types of results on the observational equivalence of continuous-time measure-theoretic deterministic and indeterministic descriptions. The first results establish observational equivalence to abstract mathematical descriptions. The second results are stronger because they show observational equivalence between deterministic and indeterministic descriptions found in science. Here I also discuss Kolmogorov’s contribution. For the third results I introduce two new meanings of ‘observational equivalence at every observation level’. Then I show the even stronger result of observational equivalence at every (and not just some) observation level between deterministic and indeterministic descriptions found in science. These results imply the following. Suppose one wants to find out whether a phenomenon is best modeled as deterministic or indeterministic. Then one cannot appeal to differences in the probability distributions of deterministic and indeterministic descriptions found in science to argue that one of the descriptions is preferable because there is no such difference. Finally, I criticise the extant claims of philosophers and mathematicians on observational equivalence

Topics:
Q Science (General)

Publisher: Springer

Year: 2011

DOI identifier: 10.1007/s13194-010-0011-5

OAI identifier:
oai:eprints.lse.ac.uk:31093

Provided by:
LSE Research Online

- (1982). A Special Family of Ergodic Flows and Their d-Limits",
- (1971). Bernoulli Flows With In Entropy",
- (1974). Billiards and Bernoulli Schemes",
- Charlotte 2009a, \Are Deterministic Descriptions and Indeterministic Descriptions Observationally Equivalent?",
- Charlotte 2009b, \What Are the New Implications of Chaos for Unpredictability?",
- (2007). Compendium to the Foundations of Classical Statistical Physics",
- (2005). Determinism and Indeterminism",
- (1998). Deterministic Chaos and The Nature of Chance",
- (1963). Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow",
- (1985). Ergodic Theory of Chaos and Strange Attractors",
- (1982). Ergodic Theory,
- (1983). Ergodic Theory, Cambridge:
- (1974). Ergodic Theory, Randomness, and Dynamical Systems,
- Ian Melbourne and Frederic Paccaut 2005, \The Lorenz Attractor Is Mixing",
- (1970). Imbedding Bernoulli Shifts in Flows",
- (1944). In General a Measure-preserving Transformation is Mixing",
- (1989). Kolmogorov's Work on Ergodic Theory",
- (1949). Measurable transformations",
- N andor 2003, \Proof of the Boltzmann-Sinai Ergodic Hypothesis for Typical Hard Disk Systems",
- (1994). Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos,
- (2011). On Choosing Between Deterministic and Indeterministic Models: Underdetermination and Indirect Evidence". Forthcoming in:
- (1970). On Entropy and Generators of Measure-preserving Transformations",
- (1996). Photons, Billiards and Chaos",
- (1932). Proof of Gibbs' Hypothesis on the Tendency Toward Statistical Equilibrium",
- (2005). Randomness Is Unpredictability",
- Roman Frigg and Fred Kronz 2006, \The Ergodic Hierarchy, Randomness and Hamiltonian Chaos",
- (1999). Semi-Markov Models and Applications, Dotrecht:
- (1991). Statistical Properties of Chaotic Systems",
- (1953). Stochastic Processes,
- (1999). The Noninvariance of Deterministic Causal Models",

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.