Location of Repository

Recessions lower (some) mortality rates: evidence from Germany

By Eric Neumayer

Abstract

In his article with the provocative title “Are Recessions Good for Your Health?”, Ruhm (J. Health Econ. 21(4) (2000) 659) has found robust and consistent evidence that the total mortality rate, age-specific mortality rates as well as most specific mortality causes are pro-cyclical. His finding that high unemployment rates are associated with lower mortality and vice versa stands in stark contrast to Brenner's earlier work, who found the opposite effect, possibly after a time lag. Ruhm controls for state-specific effects in a panel of US states over the period 1972–1991, whereas Brenner's work is based on time-series analysis. Extending and improving upon Ruhm's original analysis, we analyse the effect of state unemployment and economic growth rates on mortality in the states of Germany over the period 1980–2000, both in a static and a dynamic econometric model. Controlling for state-specific effects, we find evidence that aggregate mortality rates for all age groups taken together as well as most specific age groups are lower in recessions. The same is true for mortality from cardiovascular diseases, pneumonia and influenza, motor vehicle accidents and suicides, but not for necessarily for other specific mortality causes. In particular, there is never a statistically significant effect on homicides, other external effects and malignant neoplasms. There are also few differences apparent between the effect on male and female mortality. If we do not control for state-specific effects, then we often arrive at the opposite result with higher unemployment being associated with higher mortality. This suggests that a failure to control for time-invariant state-specific effects leads to omitted variable bias, which would erroneously suggest that mortality rates move counter-cyclically. Overall, we can confirm Ruhm's main finding for another country: recessions lower some, but not all, mortality rates in the case of Germany

Topics: HV Social pathology. Social and public welfare. Criminology
Publisher: Elsevier
Year: 2004
DOI identifier: 10.1016/S0277-9536(03)00276-4
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.lse.ac.uk:17298
Provided by: LSE Research Online

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1988). A Comparison of Unemployment, Income and Mortality for Five European Countries. doi
  2. (1999). A Note on ‘Economic Conditions and Alcohol Problems’. doi
  3. (2002). An Economic Analysis of Adult Obesity: Results from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. Working Paper 9247. Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research. doi
  4. (2000). Are Recessions Good for Your Health? doi
  5. (2002). Are Recessions Good for Your Health? Further Evidence.
  6. (1954). Distributed Lags and Investment Analysis. doi
  7. (2001). Do High Levels of Unemployment Influence the Health of Those Who are not Unemployed? A Gendered Comparison of Young Men and Women During Boom and Recession. doi
  8. (2002). Does Drinking Really Decrease in Bad Times? doi
  9. (2002). Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. doi
  10. (1995). Econometric Analysis of Panel Data. doi
  11. (2001). Economic Expansions are Unhealthy. doi
  12. (1988). Economic Recession and Mental Health: Some Conceptual Issues. doi
  13. (1981). Estimation of Dynamic Models with Error Components. doi
  14. (2002). Healthy Living in Hard Times. doi
  15. (2002). Income, Income Inequality and Health: What can We Learn from Aggregate Data? doi
  16. (2000). Mental Health and Wellbeing and Unemployment. doi
  17. (1973). Mental Illness and the Economy. Cambridge: doi
  18. (2003). Mortality and Economic Fluctuations in Sweden, 1800-1998. Working Paper. Ann Arbor:
  19. (2002). Mortality and Economic Fluctuations. Theories and Empirical Results from Spain and Sweden. Unpublished PhD thesis.
  20. (1979). Mortality and the National Economy. doi
  21. (1981). Mortality and Unemployment: A Critique of Brenner’s Time Series Analysis. The Lancet, doi
  22. (1996). New Evidence on the Relationship Between Income and Health. doi
  23. (1995). Political economy and health. In
  24. (1985). Recession and Health – A Literature Review.
  25. (1987). Relation of Economic Change to Swedish Health and Social Wellbeing, doi
  26. (1991). Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations. doi
  27. (2002). The Impact of Income on Mortality: Evidence from the Social Security Notch. Working Paper 9197. Cambridge (Mass.): National Bureau of Economic Research. Statistisches Bundesamt (various years). Statistisches Jahrbuch. Wiesbaden: Statistisches Bundesamt.
  28. (1999). The Persisting Effect of Unemployment on Health and Social Well-being in Men Early in Working Life. doi
  29. (1985). Time Series Analysis of the Relationship Between Unemployment and Mortality: A Survey of Econometric Critiques and Replications of Brenner’s Studies. doi
  30. (1975). Trends in Alcohol Consumption and Associated Illnesses: Some Effects of Economic Changes. doi
  31. (1997). Undergraduate Econometrics. doi
  32. (1983). Unemployment and Health in the Context of Economic Change. doi
  33. (1993). Unemployment and Infant Health – Time-Series Evidence from the State of Tennessee, doi
  34. (1984). Unemployment and Mortality in Post-war Scotland. doi
  35. (1996). Unhealthy Societies – The Afflictions of Inequality. London and doi
  36. (1996). Wealthier is Healthier. doi
  37. (1998). Why are the Unemployed so Unhappy? Evidence from Panel Data. doi
  38. (1987). Work, Unemployment and Mental Health. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.