Location of Repository

Henry Fielding and the language of morals: An Experiment in Contextual Reading

By Roger J. Fallon

Abstract

This historical study attempts a thorough revision of some current\ud assumptions about Fielding's moral 'philosophy'. It endorses the\ud orthodox view that Latitudinarian Anglicanism was a decisive influence,\ud but questions whether the Anglican moralists can usefully be described\ud as exponents of 'benevolism' - their sermons are distinguished most\ud notably by an overriding concern with the inculcation of prudence, and\ud by persistent hortatory appeals to self-interest. 'Prudentialism' is\ud arguably a better term for Latitudinarian ethics, and indeed for that\ud dimension of Fielding's work which is attributable to Anglican\ud influence - above all, the reiterated emphasis on the coincidence of\ud virtue and interest.\ud The Latitudinarian connexion is important. But there were other\ud formative influences, including the 'negative' influence of\ud philosophies with which Fielding disagreed, such as ethical rationalism\ud and psychological egoism. The moral 'philosophy' of Tom Jones is not\ud a rigid conceptual structure: it is a dynamic, and sometimes polemical,\ud response to contemporary ethical debate. This study therefore analyzes\ud Fielding's moral vocabulary by relating it to various other\ud contemporary moral vocabularies. Making constant, detailed reference\ud to chosen contextual sources, it explores Fielding's views on a range\ud of 'live' moral and moral-psychological issues: on the functions of\ud prudence and the grounds of prudential obligation; on the relations\ud between prudential obligation and other moral duties; on benevolence,\ud self-love, and 'disinterestedness'; on the relative status of 'private'\ud and 'public' virtues; on the moral functions of reason and the\ud passions; and on the psychology of moral judgment.\ud This study suggests that Fielding's writings embody a complex and\ud uneasy synthesis of two historically divergent ethical traditions: in\ud his didactic emphasis on interest and his concern with the\ud enlightenment of self-love, Fielding is a literary heir of Anglican\ud prudentialism; in his esteem for the 'heart', he can be seen as an\ud ally of the newer 'sentimental' school of Shaftesbury, Hutcheson and\ud Hume

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1988
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/9985

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1946). 13-26, and Sermons II ! gorical" in their Kantian Metaphysic of Morals,
  2. 2. (First German edition,
  3. (1963). A Brief Account of the New Sect of Latitude-Men (1662).
  4. (1968). A Dictionary of the English Language (1755). Facsimile reprint. 2 vols.
  5. A Discourse concerning the Unchangeable Obligations of Natural Religion. doi
  6. (1975). A Reader's Guide to the Development of the English Novel in the Eighteenth Century*
  7. A Sermon Preached before the Honourable House of Commons, at Westminster, March 31.1647- Cambridge, 1647-,A Treatise concerning Eternal and Immutable Morality. With a Preface by Edward Chandler , Bishop of Durham. 1731-A Treatise of Freewill.
  8. (1978). A Treatise of
  9. (1964). Action and Morality. doi
  10. (1972). Allworthy and Barrow: The Standards of Good Judgment".
  11. (1973). Amelia and Booth's Doctrine of the Passions". doi
  12. An Inquiry into the Original of Our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue. doi
  13. (1967). An Introduction to the English Novel. 2nd edition. 2 vols.
  14. (1972). and the Augustan Ideal Under Stress: "Nature's Dance of Death" and Other Studies. doi
  15. (1982). and the Ends of the Novel". doi
  16. (1975). Aristotle and the 'Prudence' Theme of Tom Jones".
  17. (1980). Aristotle's Ethical Theory. 2nd edition. doi
  18. (1984). Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics and Tom Jones". doi
  19. Augustinianism and Empiricism: A Note on EighteenthCentury English Intellectual History". doi
  20. Bishop Burnet's History of His Own Time.
  21. (1971). Bishop Butler and the Age of Reason: A Study in the History of Thought. doi
  22. (1975). Booth's Conversion in Amelia". doi
  23. (1969). British Moralists 1650-1800. Volume I: Hobbes-Gay.
  24. (1952). Butler's Moral Philosophy. doi
  25. (1949). Christian Censor". In The Age of Johnson: Essays Presented to Chauncey Brewster Tinker.
  26. (1969). Conduct: An Introduction to Moral Philosophy. doi
  27. (1948). Dr. Johnson on Fielding and Richardson". doi
  28. (1972). Elements of Pulpit Oratory doi
  29. (1962). English Literature of the Eighteenth Century. doi
  30. (1961). Essays on Fielding's Miscellanies: A Commentary on Volume One. doi
  31. (1947). Euthyphro - Apology - Crito - Phaedo - Phaedrus. Trans. Harold North Fowler. Loeb Classical Library, doi
  32. (1928). Familiar Letters on Important Occasions. Routledge English Library,
  33. (1959). Fielding and 'Conservation of Character"'. doi
  34. (1966). Fielding and Richardson". doi
  35. (1985). Fielding and the Whores of London".
  36. (1972). Fielding as Novelist: Tom Jones", in his The Rise of the Novel: Studies in Defoe,
  37. (1980). Fielding, Lord Chancellor Hardwicke and the 'Court of Conscience' in Tom Jones".
  38. Fielding: "Tom Jones".
  39. (1980). Fielding: A Reference Guide.
  40. (1962). Fielding's Amelia and the Materials of Romance".
  41. (1962). Fielding's Amelia: An Interpretation". In Fielding: A Collection of Critical Essays, doi
  42. (1968). Fielding's Definition of Wisdom: Some Functions of Ambiguity and Emblem in Tom Jones". doi
  43. (1966). Fielding's Social Pamphlets.
  44. (1966). Fielding's social philosophy is of course essentially conservative, and certainly non-egalitarian: see Sherburn, "Fielding's Social Outlook", Passim; Miller, Essays,
  45. (1953). First German edition,
  46. (1930). Five TyDes of Ethical Theory.. doi
  47. (1965). Fortune and the Passions in Fielding's Amelia". doi
  48. (1960). From Puritanism to the Age of Reason: A Study of Changes doi
  49. (1978). Happiness - 'A Great, Useful, and Uncommon Doctrine"',
  50. (1959). Henry Fielding and the 'Trunk-Maker"'.
  51. (1968). Henry Fielding and the Language of Irony. doi
  52. (1967). Henry Fielding The Tentative Realist. doi
  53. (1987). Henry Fielding: "Joseph Andrews". Penguin Masterstudies,
  54. (1975). Henry Fielding: A Biography. 1979" R6stvig, Maren-Sofie. "Tom Jones and the Choice of Hercules",
  55. (1973). Henry Fielding: A Critical Anthology. Harmondsworth,
  56. (1975). Henry Fielding's "Tom Jones": The Novelist as Moral Philosopher. doi
  57. (1966). Henry Fielding's Theory of the Comic Prose Epic. doi
  58. (1986). His Virtue Square: A Note on Tom Jones".
  59. (1961). History of Western Philosophy and its Connection with Political and Social Circumstances from the Earliest Times to the Present Day. 2nd edition. doi
  60. (1965). Hogarth's Graphic Works. Ed. Ronald Paulson. doi
  61. (1974). Hume's Critique of Ethical Rationalism".
  62. (1980). Hume's Moral Theory. doi
  63. (1976). Imagining a Self: Autobiography and Novel in Eighteenth-Century England. doi
  64. (1956). In Defence of Fielding", in his Unprofessional Essays.
  65. (1971). Interpositions of Providence and the Design of Fielding's Novels".
  66. (1977). Latitudinarianism and Sensibility: The Genealogy of the 'Man of Feeling' Reconsidered". doi
  67. (1977). Lessons in Evil: Fielding's Ethics in The Champion Essays".
  68. (1970). Making an Effectual Provision for the Poor (published in 1753, two years after Amelia). Among his suggestions for a workhouse regime is the 18 "The Debate on Eternal Punishment in Late Seventeenth- and Eighteenth-Century English Literature",
  69. (1974). Meaning: Implicit and Explicit".
  70. (1985). Moral Sense and the Narrator of Tom Jones". doi
  71. (1970). Narrative Form in History and Fiction: Hume, Fielding, and Gibbon. doi
  72. (1953). Nature Moralized: The Divine Analogy in the Eighteenth Century". doi
  73. (1976). Nerves, Spirits, and Fibres: Towards Defining the Origins of Sensibility". In doi
  74. nuel. A Demonstration of the Being and Attributes of God. doi
  75. Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity. doi
  76. (1953). On Tom Jones", in her The English Novel: Form and Function.
  77. (1980). Out of the Thicket in Tom Jones". doi
  78. (1980). Out of the Thicket in Tomes nes",
  79. Pope's Theory of the Passions: The Background of Epistle
  80. (1959). Professor Empson's Tom Jones".
  81. (1968). Profiles in Literature.
  82. (1967). Protean Shape: A Study in Eighteenth-Century Vocabulary and Usage. doi
  83. (1960). Prudence' in Tom Jones: A Study of Connotative Irony".
  84. (1962). Prudence". doi
  85. (1951). Ralph Cudworth: An Interpretation. doi
  86. Rational Theology and Christian PhilOSODhy
  87. (1968). Reason and Nature in Eighteenth-Century Thought.
  88. (1980). Religious Liberalism in Eighteenth-Century England.
  89. (1967). Satire and the Novel in Eighteenth-Century England.
  90. (1957). Satiric and Comic Theory in Relation to Fielding", doi
  91. Select Sermons of Dr. Whichcot. Ed. with Preface by Anthony Ashley Cooper, Third Earl of Shaftesbury. 3rd edition, revised by William Wishart.
  92. (1970). Sermons Preached at the Rolls Chapel and A
  93. (1967). Sex and the Foundling Boy: The Problem in Tom Jones".
  94. (1931). Shaftesbury and the Doctrine of Benevolence in the Eighteenth Century". doi
  95. (1931). Shaftesbury and the Doctrine of Moral Sense in the Eighteenth Century". doi
  96. (1967). Shaftesbury's Philosophy of Religion and Ethics: A Study in Enthusiasm. doi
  97. (1954). SOURCES (a) On Fielding Allen, Walter. "Fielding", in his The English Novel: A Short Critical History.
  98. (1971). Square, and the Fitness of Things". doi
  99. (1967). Suggestions toward a Genealogy of the 'Man of Feeling"', doi
  100. (1961). Swift and Anglican Rationalism: The Religious Background of "A Tale of a Tub".
  101. Tendencies of Religious Thought in England, doi
  102. (1961). The Analogy of Religion, doi
  103. (1961). The Analogy of Religion. doi
  104. (1974). The Augustan Vision. doi
  105. (1954). The Augustan World: Life and Letters in Eighteenth-Century England. doi
  106. (1959). The Background of Fielding's Laughter". doi
  107. (1926). The Cambridge Platonists: A Study. doi
  108. (1969). The Cambridge Platonists. The Stratford-upon-Avon Library.
  109. (1903). The Complete Works of Henry Fielding, Esq., With an Essay on the Life, Genius, and Achievement of the Author, by William Ernest Henley. 16 vols.
  110. (1973). The Concept of Benevolence: Aspects of Eighteenth-Century Moral Philosophy. doi
  111. The Conscionable Christian (1623), and Thomas Nabbes, Microcosmus. A Morall Maske (1637). Battestin seems to have been 91 Ralph Cudworth, A Treatise concerning
  112. (1970). The Created Self: The Reader's Role in Eighteenth-Century Fiction.
  113. (1969). The Critical Heritage. doi
  114. (1951). The Cultural Revolution of the Seventeenth Century. doi
  115. (1970). The Debate on Eternal Punishment in Late Seventeenth- and Eighteenth-Century English Literature". doi
  116. (1959). The Double Standard". doi
  117. (1956). The Early Masters of English Fiction. doi
  118. (1934). The Eighteenth-Century Background. Harmondsworth,
  119. (1965). The Eighteenth-Century Concept of the Good Man in relation to the Novels of Henry Fielding".
  120. (1969). The Eighteenth-Century Pulpit: A Study of the Sermons of Butler, doi
  121. (1947). The Eternal Fitness of Things': An Aspect of Eighteenth-Century Thought". doi
  122. (1924). The Fable of the Bees: or, Private Vices, Publick Benefits. doi
  123. The Foundation of Moral Goodness: or, A Further Inquir into the Original of Our Idea of Virtue.
  124. (1976). The Grease of God': The Form of Eighteenth-Century English Fiction". doi
  125. (1967). The Harlot's Progress in Eighteenth-Century England". doi
  126. (1918). The History of Henry Fielding. doi
  127. (1975). The History of Tom Jones, A Foundling. Ed. Fredson Bowers with introduction and commentary by doi
  128. (1976). The Hungry Author and Narrative Performance in Tom Jones".
  129. (1953). The Importance of Shaftesbury". doi
  130. (1966). The Ironic Mode: A Comparison of Jonathan Wild and The Beggar's Opera". doi
  131. (1966). The Making of "Jonathan Wild": A Study in the Literary Method of Hen Fieldin .
  132. (1965). The Malleability of Man in Eighteenth-Century Thought".
  133. (1959). The Moral Basis of Fielding's Art: A Study of "Joseph Andrews". doi
  134. (1947). The Moral Sense. Oxford Classical and Philosophical Monographs. doi
  135. (1960). The Naked Virtue of Amelia". doi
  136. (1976). The Newtonians and the English Revolution. Hassocks, doi
  137. (1947). The Nicomachean Ethics. doi
  138. (1947). The Origins of the 'Moral Sense l". doi
  139. (1974). The Problem of Amelia: Hume, Barrow, and the Conversion of Captain Booth". doi
  140. (1974). The Providence of Wit: Aspects of Form in Augustan Literature and the Arts. doi
  141. (1941). The Republic of Plato. Trans. Francis Macdonald Cornford. doi
  142. The Second Part of the Foundation of Moral Goodness. 1729. Barrow, Isaac. The Works of Isaac
  143. (1972). The Seventeenth-Century Background. doi
  144. (1965). The Spirit of Anglicanism: A Survey of Anglican Theological Method in the Seventeenth Century. doi
  145. (1974). The Study of Eighteenth-Century Literature: Past, Present, and Future".
  146. (1984). The Third Earl of Shaftesbury, doi
  147. (1965). The True Patriot: and The History of Our Own Times. doi
  148. (1983). The Wesleyan Edition of the Works of Henry Fielding. doi
  149. (1972). The Wesleyan Edition. doi
  150. Third Earl of. doi
  151. (1959). Three Traditions of Moral Thought. doi
  152. (1970). To the Palace of Wisdom: Studies in Order and Energy from Dryden to Blake. Arcturus Books,
  153. (1972). Tom Jones from the Outside".
  154. (1962). Torn Jones". In Fieldin :A Collection of Critical Essays,
  155. Twenty Sermons. 1755. Hobbes, Thomas. The English Works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury.
  156. (1948). under the title The Moral Law.
  157. Vertu", Dictionnaire Philoso hi ue (1764), in Oeuvres Completes de Voltaire,
  158. (1914). vols. Everyman's Library,
  159. (1966). with authorial revisions, from The Kenyon Review,
  160. (1975). with introduction and commentary by
  161. Writers and Their Work,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.