Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

'Caesarism' in the politics and sociology of Max Weber

By Peter Baehr

Abstract

This thesis attempts to describe the meanings, chart the development\ud and evaluate the cogency of 'Caesarism', with particular reference to that\ud concept's place and significance in the thought of Max Weber. It begins\ud (Chapter 2) by investigating the genesis and historical trajectory of the\ud term, concentrating on French and German usage between the period 1850-1880.\ud My concern here is to determine the social causes of the word's emergence,\ud the social problems and issues that it articulated and the reasons that\ud account for its decline as a vernacular expression among the educated political\ud public. With the term's original intellectual milieu established the next\ud task is to proceed (Chapters 3 and 4) to the centrepiece of this study,\ud an exposition and critique of Caesarism as both word and concept in Weber's\ud political and sociological writings. Four primary contexts in which Weber\ud employed 'Caesarism' are discussed: Bismarck's governance; 'plebiscitary\ud leadership' in modern liberal-democratic states; the military 'dictatorships'\ud of the likes of Cromwell and Napoleon; and the constitutional position\ud of the Weimar Reich President. In the process of the discussion, 'Caesarism’ ‘s\ud relationship to the more famous 'charisma' is explored. Following on from\ud this I assess the view of the 'irrational masses' that underlies Weber's\ud theory of leadership, and seek to demonstrate that view's empirical implausibility\ud and logical incoherence while, at the same time, defending Weber\ud from the charge of 'irrationalism' and defending also the value of the notion\ud of 'irrationality' itself. Finally (Chapter 5) surveys a selection of recent\ud attempts to apply the concept of 'Caesarism' to specific institutions, epochs\ud and types of leadership. Though locating problems with these attempts,\ud my suggestion is that 'Caesarism' can indeed do some sociological work for\ud us, provided that our ambitions for the concept are modest and our approach\ud historically informed

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1986
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8605

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. 165, and 'The Class Struggles in France: 1848 to 1850', transl.
  2. 1815-1914: The Bourgeois Century
  3. 1848-1945. Politics and Anger
  4. 410. the name of order'; 5. 'Bonapartism', Caesarism and 'bureaucratic authoritarianism' 'Bonapartism' and 'Caesarism' are concepts consonant with one another
  5. (1858). 453-54, from Marx's New York Tribune article, 'The Rule of the Pretorians',
  6. (1984). A Constitutional History
  7. (1984). A Future That Will Work (Harmondsworth:
  8. (1979). A History of Germany,
  9. (1979). A hostile and simplistic account
  10. (1977). A Nietzsche Reader (Harmondsworth:
  11. (1958). A Selection of Poems
  12. (1977). A Short History of the French Revolution 1789-1799
  13. (1976). A Vocabulary of Culture and Society
  14. (1922). Agrarverhältnisse im Altertum',
  15. An asymmetrical partnership',
  16. (1964). An Essay on the British Constitution
  17. (1983). and Articles from Die rote Fahne
  18. (1969). and London
  19. (1973). and Social Classes (London:
  20. (1979). and the Sirens. Studies in Rationality and Irrationality
  21. (1980). Anorexia Nervosa (Harmondsworth:
  22. (1980). Arguments Within English Marxism
  23. (1920). Aufsätze zur Religionssoziologie, Vol. I
  24. (1924). Aufsätze zur Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte
  25. (1924). Aufsätze zur Soziologie und Sozialpolitik
  26. August Thalheimer's Theory of Fascism',
  27. (1984). Authoritarian Populism, Two Nations, and Thatcherism',
  28. Authoritarian Populism: A Reply to Jessop et al.
  29. Bau und Leben des socialen Körpers, Vol. II (Tübingen: 1896; 2nd edn.
  30. (1971). Baudelaire (Harmondsworth:
  31. before Weberian Sociology',
  32. Begriff der "plebiszitären Führerdemokratie" bei Max Weber', Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie,
  33. (1933). Behemoth: The Structure and Practice of National Socialism,
  34. (1981). Bibliographie zur Max Weber - Gesamtausgabe', Prospekt der Max Weber Gesamtausgabe
  35. (1968). Bismarck and the German
  36. (1970). Bismarck's Imperialism 1862-1890', Past and Present,
  37. Bonapartism as a Model for Bismarckian Politics',
  38. Bonapartism, Fascism and National Socialism',
  39. (1973). Bread and Circuses: The Roman Emperor and his People
  40. (1983). Bread and Circuses: Theories of Mass Culture as Social Decay
  41. (1962). Burckhardt e la parola "Cesarismol", Rivista Storica Italiana,
  42. (1978). Bureaucracy and Civil Society. A Critical Discussion of the Political Theory of Karl Marx
  43. (1983). Caesar and his Public Image
  44. Caesar and Satan',
  45. Caesar and the Elizabethan Villain',
  46. (1924). Caesar: Geschichte seines Ruhms
  47. Caesar's Laurel Crown - the case for a Comparative Concept',
  48. Caesarism, Circuses and Monuments',
  49. (1879). Cäsarismus, sein Wesen und sein Schaffen
  50. Categories of Interpretive Sociology',
  51. (1977). Causing Death and Saving Lives (Harmondsworth:
  52. (1974). Change and Continuity
  53. (1954). Character and Social Structure
  54. (1963). Civilisation and its Discontents
  55. (1974). Consciousness and Society. The Reorientation of European Social Thought,
  56. Conservatism and "caesarism", 1903-22',
  57. (1948). Constitutional Dictatorship
  58. Conversations Lexicon (Leipzig: 1883,13th
  59. (1971). de la langue frangaise
  60. De Weber ä Nietzsche',
  61. (1965). Decline of the English Murder and Other Essays (Harmondsworth:
  62. (1976). Defining social imperialism: use and abuse of an idea',
  63. (1968). Democracy
  64. (1902). Democracy and the Organisation of Political Parties,
  65. Der Cäsarismus Napoleons III. im Widerhall der öffentlichen Meinung Deutschlands', Historische Zeitschrift,
  66. (1917). Der englische Staat und der deutsche Staat
  67. (1980). Destructive, but far from mindless',
  68. (1983). Dictatorship Over Needs: An Analysis of Soviet Societies
  69. (1966). Dictionnaire aiphabetique et analogique de la langue frangaise
  70. (1873). Dictionnaire de la langue francaise
  71. (1983). Die Bonapartismustheorie von Marx und
  72. Eighteenth-century English society: class struggle without class?
  73. (1976). Elective Dictatorship
  74. (1973). Elites Against Democracy: Leadership ideals in Bourgeois Political Thought in Germany 1890-1933
  75. (1970). Essays and Aphorisms (Harmondsworth:
  76. (1977). Essays in Social Theory (London:
  77. (1962). Essays on the Behavioural Study of Politics (Illinois:
  78. (1952). Essays on the Sociology of Knowledge
  79. (1961). Essential Works of
  80. (1938). Europe and the French Imperium,
  81. (1965). For and Against (Harmondsworth:
  82. (1976). Freud and Modern Society (Sunbury-on-Thames:
  83. (1962). From History to Sociology: The Transition in German Historical Thinking
  84. (1978). From Mobilisation to Revolution
  85. (1972). From Rousseau to Lenin (London:
  86. From Socialism to Fascism: the relation between theory and practice in the work of Robert Michels', Parts I and II,
  87. (1982). German Liberalism in the Nineteenth Century
  88. (1967). Germany without Bismarck: The Crisis of Government
  89. (1966). Goethe: Conversations and Encounters,
  90. Goths and Vandals - Crime in History', Contemporary Crises,
  91. (1918). Grain Riots and Government Policy in South India,
  92. Grand dictionnaire universal du XIXe
  93. (1967). Grandeur and Decline (Harmondsworth:
  94. (1955). Group psychology and the analysis of the ego',
  95. (1967). Gulliver's Travels (Harmondsworth:
  96. (1973). Harmondsworth:
  97. (1981). Heart and Mind: The Varieties'of Moral Experience (London:
  98. (1964). Hindenburg and the Weimar
  99. Histoire de Jules Cesar
  100. (1913). Historical Essays
  101. (1967). Historical Introduction to the Study of Roman Law
  102. (1906). Historisches Schlagwörterbuch
  103. History of Civilisation Vol.
  104. (1966). Hitler's War Directives:
  105. (1953). Hume's Political Essays
  106. (1976). I (Harmondsworth:
  107. (1978). I and II
  108. (1981). III (Harmondsworth:
  109. (1926). im Neunzehnten Jahrhundert
  110. (1965). Imperialism: The Story and Significance of a Political Word, 1840-1960
  111. (1978). Irrationalism and Marxism',
  112. (1978). Janus: A Summing Up
  113. (1959). Judgements on History and Historians
  114. (1977). Karl Marx's Theory of Revolution
  115. (1975). Knies: The Logical Problems of Historical Economics
  116. (1972). Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach
  117. L'ere des Cesars (Paris: 1850; 2nd edn.
  118. (1983). Labour's Lost Millions', Marxism Today,
  119. (1983). Languages of Class. Studies in English Working Class History,
  120. Leadership in the German Reichstag, 1871-1918',
  121. (1966). Lectures on European History 1789-1914
  122. (1964). Lenin on the Karensky coalition Provisional Government as Bonapartist, in 'The Beginning of Bonapartism' and 'They do not see the wood for the trees',
  123. (1981). Leninism and Western Socialism
  124. (1978). Logic and Society. Contradictions and Possible Worlds
  125. Looting, Grain Riots and Government Policy
  126. (1982). Marginalism and Modern Sociology
  127. (1960). Marx devant le Bonapartisme
  128. (1962). Marx explains the trade crisis as a manifestation of capitalist overproduction, ibid.,
  129. Marx on the State: The Events in France between 1848-1850', Theory and Society,
  130. (1975). Marx-Engels Selected Correspondence
  131. (1977). Marxism: A Critical Reader
  132. (1962). Marxist Economic Theory
  133. Mass-Producing Traditions: Europe, 1870-1914',
  134. Max Weber and Robert Michels',
  135. Max Weber and the heteronomy of purposes',
  136. (1975). Max Weber: A Biography
  137. (1981). Max Weber: Legitimation, Method and the Politics of Theory',
  138. (1972). Max Weber: The Interpretation of Social Reality (London:
  139. Max Weber's "Central Question"'
  140. (1966). Max Weber's Political Ideas in the Perspective of our Time
  141. (1979). Max Weber's Vision of History: Ethics and Methods
  142. Meaning and understanding in the history of ideas',
  143. (1841). Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions Vols.
  144. (1984). Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach
  145. (1984). Militarism: The History of an International Debate,
  146. (1971). Movements in European History
  147. (1954). Napoleon's Letters
  148. (1968). Negations (Harmondsworth:
  149. (1973). No one had fought with more fanaticism in the June days for the salvation 57. N. Poulantzas, Political Power and Social Classes
  150. Notes on exterminism, the last stage of civilisation',
  151. (1964). Notes on the theory of dictatorship'
  152. (1975). On Materialism
  153. (1975). Parliaments and Estates
  154. (1949). Party Politics in the Age of Caesar
  155. (1974). Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism
  156. (1974). Patrician Society, Plebeian Culture',
  157. (1966). Pensees (Harmondsworth:
  158. (1956). Per un riesame della storia dell'idea di Cesarismo'
  159. (1982). Personal Impressions
  160. (1977). Philosophy and Methodology in the Social Sciences (London:
  161. Plebeian Culture',
  162. Political Economy and Social Legislation in Germany, ca. 1870-1890', History of European Ideas,
  163. (1915). Political Parties
  164. (1968). Politician and Statesman
  165. (1977). Politics and Ideology in Marxist Theory
  166. (1972). Politics and Sociology in the Thought of Max Weber
  167. Politik: Geschichtliche Naturlehre der Monarchie, Aristokratie und Demokratie
  168. Politische Schriften (Tübingen: 1958,1971 = 2nd and _ edns.
  169. (1981). Populism (London:
  170. (1973). Poulantzas and the Capitalist State',
  171. Presidential Power: Restoring the Balance', Political Science Quarterly,
  172. (1969). Princeps
  173. (1958). Pro Sestio
  174. (1973). Problems of the Self
  175. (1973). Religious developments from the close of the Republic to the reign of Nero',
  176. (1971). Representation
  177. (1975). reprint; orig.
  178. (1980). Reshaping the German Right
  179. (1968). Revolution in the Revolution?
  180. (1975). Roman Society (Harmondsworth:
  181. (1980). Science Advisers, Scientific Advisers and Nuclear Weapons
  182. Scientific Explanation and Human Emancipation',
  183. (1971). Selections from the Prison Notebooks
  184. (1971). Social Conflicts in the Roman
  185. (1949). Social Conflicts, 8. Urban plebs formed only a fraction of the 173.
  186. (1976). Social Evolution and Sociological Categories
  187. (1982). Social Relations and Human Attributes
  188. Socialism and Capitalism in the work of Max Weber',
  189. (1963). Sociology at the Crossroads and Other Essays
  190. State and Society, 1880-1930'
  191. (1915). Storia d'Italiana dal 1871 al
  192. (1976). Stuart Mill on Politics and Society,
  193. (1973). Surveys from Exile (Harmondsworth:
  194. (1985). Thatcherism and the Politics of Hegemony: a Reply to Stuart Hall',
  195. (1974). The Age of Bureaucracy. Perspectives on the Political Sociolo of Max Weber
  196. (1976). The Agrarian Sociology of Ancient Civilisations
  197. The Agrarian Sociology of Ancient Civilisations,
  198. The American Commonwealth, Vol. I (New York: 1910,3rd edn.
  199. (1977). The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness (Harmondsworth:
  200. The Ancient City: From Fustel de Coulanges to Max Weber and Beyond',
  201. (1982). The Annals of Imperial Rome
  202. (1982). The Annals of Imperial Rome (Harmondsworth:
  203. (1976). The Army and the Allies
  204. The Army and the Land in the Roman Revolution',
  205. (1982). The Battle for Socialist ideas in the 1980s', Socialist Register
  206. (1967). The Civil War (Hardmondsworth,
  207. (1981). The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World
  208. (1958). The Coming Caesars
  209. (1982). The Conquest of Gaul (Harmondsworth: revised
  210. (1973). The Conscious Brain (Harmondsworth: 1976; 2nd edn.; orig.
  211. (1945). The Course of German History
  212. (1983). The Court Society
  213. (1909). The Crisis of Liberalism
  214. (1976). The Crisis of the Dictatorships
  215. (1969). The Crisis of the Roman Republic
  216. (1960). The Crowd
  217. (1981). The Crowd in History,
  218. (1932). The Decline of the West,
  219. (1978). The Destruction of Nature in the Soviet
  220. (1980). The Destruction of Reason
  221. (1983). The Dialectics-of Disaster: a preface to hope (London:
  222. (1979). The Disintegrating West (Harmondsworth:
  223. (1963). The English Constitution
  224. (1978). The Foundations of Modern Political Thought. Vol. I: The Renaissance
  225. (1974). The French Revolution, 1787-1799,
  226. (1904). The Governance of
  227. (1973). The Great Fear of 1789
  228. (1983). The Great Moving Right Show',
  229. (1954). The Historian'-s Craft
  230. (1895). The Historical and Secret
  231. (1975). The Historical Essays of Otto Hintze,
  232. (1978). The History of Manners (The Civilizing Process,
  233. (1901). The History of Rome,
  234. (1980). The Ideology of Power and the Power of Ideology
  235. (1959). The Imperial Idea and Its Enemies
  236. (1973). The Imperial Presidency (New York :
  237. (1977). The instruments of decline',
  238. (1970). The Iron Cage: an Historical Interpretation of Max Weber
  239. (1933). The Life of Caesar
  240. (1981). The Logic of Social Action
  241. (1985). The Lost World of British Communism',
  242. The Man and Statesman. Being the Reflections and Reminiscences of Otto Prince von Bismarck, Vols. I and II
  243. (1976). The Man on Horseback
  244. (1978). The meanings and confusions of Weberian "rationality"',
  245. (1971). The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century',
  246. (1971). The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century', Past and Present,
  247. The national state and economic policy',
  248. (1972). The Origins of the Peloponnesian War
  249. (1984). The Peculiarities of German History
  250. (1979). The Pessimistic Materialism of Giacomo Leopardi',
  251. (1956). The Philosophy of History
  252. (1958). The Political System of Napoleon III
  253. (1962). The Politics (Harmondsworth:
  254. (1979). The Possibility of Naturalism
  255. The problem of thematic unity in the works of Max Weber'
  256. (1930). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism
  257. (1975). The Psychopathology of Everyday Life (Harmondsworth:
  258. (1966). The Real World of Democracy
  259. The Reich President',
  260. (1951). The Religion of China
  261. (1972). The Revolution Betrayed
  262. The riots in Toxteth, Liverpool: a survey',
  263. (1964). The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich
  264. (1940). The Role of the Individual in History (London:
  265. (1974). The Roman Economy.
  266. (1969). The Roman Nobility
  267. (1974). The Roman Revolution
  268. (1976). The Romantic Rebellion. Romantic versus Classic Art
  269. (1977). The Rule of Capital and the Rise of Democracy',
  270. (1916). The Silent Dictatorship: The Politics of the German High Command under Hindenburg and Ludendorff,
  271. (1979). The Social Bases of Obedience and Revolt
  272. (1913). The Social Contract (London:
  273. (1970). The Sociological Imagination (Harmondsworth:
  274. (1949). The Structure of Social Action,
  275. (1984). The Structure of Social Theory
  276. (1975). The Struggle Against Fascism in Germany (Harmondsworth:
  277. (1970). The Trumpet Shall Sound (London:
  278. (1979). The Twelve Caesars (Harmondsworth:
  279. (1960). The very first paragraph of Augustus' Res Gestae says that
  280. (1969). Three Faces of Fascism
  281. Toward a Concept of Political Illegitimacy: Bonapartist Dictatorship and Democratic Legitimacy', Political Theory,
  282. (1978). Two Notes on the End of the World',
  283. (1964). und Gesellschaft
  284. (1958). Vanished Supremacies
  285. (1982). Vico: Selected Writings
  286. (1916). Vols. I and II
  287. Weber and German Politics (London: 1956; 2nd edn.
  288. (1984). Weber and the Dispute over Reason and Value
  289. (1985). Weber and the Theory of Modern Politics
  290. (1964). Weber: Werk und Person
  291. (1978). Weber's practical endorsement of the term/concept 'Caesarism' in a 9.
  292. What is He? (London: 1833= 2nd edn.
  293. (1964). What is History?
  294. (1952). Wishes". A codicil to the will of Theodor Mommsen',
  295. (1967). Works Vol. I
  296. (1963). Zwischen Demokratie und Diktatur. Verfassungspolitik und Reichsreform in der Weimarer Republik, Vol. I

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.