Location of Repository

Mountains suspended by a hair: Eruv, a symbolical act by which the legal fiction of community is established

By Robert Charles Ash


In 1991 a group of orthodox Jews applied to the London Borough of Barnet for permission to erect small groups of structures resembling telephone poles, connected - at a height of about twenty feet - by fine nylon filament, at thirty nine locations in the borough. Overall, the number of such structures was to be about eighty. Given that such structures closely resemble common 'street furniture', it was argued by those supporting the proposal that these items would be virtually unseen among the tens of thousands of lamp posts, telephone poles, and the like already in the area. Yet, far from remaining a routine matter for Barnet's Planning Officers, the application became an issue of heated public controversy, engaging the attention of the national and international media. The nature of that opposition is the major focus of this thesis.\ud The religious driving force which lay behind the application relates to the laws of the Jewish shabbat. In order to overcome specific restrictions arising from those laws, Jewish sages long ago devised legal 'solutions'. Among these solutions is one which requires the creation of the physical structures which were the subject of the planning application. In everyday usage the legal solution is referred to by the Hebrew word eruv.\ud It might be argued that this faintly absurd controversy represented in symbolic form the basic dilemma of Jewish life in liberal societies in the late twentieth century. This thesis analyses the eruv conflict in terms of space and place, modernity and post-modernity, and contemporary identities and concludes that the eruv proposal was greeted with hostility because it was seen as a disordering of space which threatened identities within a context of the operation of 'banal nationalism'

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2000
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8548

Suggested articles



  1. (1938). A Colony of Jews in Shakespeare's London',
  2. (1978). A General Theory of Secularization, doi
  3. (1992). A Guide to Jewish Religious Practice,
  4. (1992). A Historical Atlas of the Jewish People,
  5. (1990). A History of the Jews III Britain SInce 1858, Leicester:
  6. (1996). A Tale of Two Cities, doi
  7. (1981). a) Judaism: The Evidence of the Mishnah, Chicago and London:
  8. (1988). An Eruv in Melbourne: A Halachic Analysis, Private Publication.
  9. (1996). An Introduction to the History and Sources of Jewish Law, doi
  10. (1995). An Introduction to Theories of Popular Culture, doi
  11. (1995). Anglo-Jew or English/British? Some dilemmas of Anglo-Jewish history',
  12. (1990). Anglo-Jewry under Edward I - credit agents and their clients',
  13. (1995). Apocalypse Theory and the Ends of the World, doi
  14. (1981). b) A History of the Mishnaic Law of Appointed Times: Part Two Erubin Pesahim, doi
  15. (1995). Banal Nationalism, doi
  16. (1997). Between City and Desert: Constructing the North London Eruv',
  17. (1996). Biblical Law' in Hecht et aI,
  18. (1999). Choice and Religion, doi
  19. (1996). Cities of Tomorrow. doi
  20. (1993). Constructions of "the Jew' in English Literature and Society: Racial Representations, 1875-1945, Cambridge: doi
  21. (1989). Cosmopolitans and Parochials: Modem Orthodox Jews in America, Chicago: doi
  22. (1996). Dimensions of the Sacred,
  23. (1994). Drawing the Line'
  24. (1988). Early Rabbinic Writings, Cambridge: doi
  25. (1970). Elite and Specialized Interviewing: doi
  26. (1997). England, liberalism and the Jews',
  27. (1998). England's Jewish Solution: Experiment and Expulsion, 1262-1290, Cambridge: doi
  28. (1992). Englishness and medieval Anglo-Jewry', in doi
  29. (1998). Eruv and Community Opposition',
  30. (1994). European and English Landscapes as National Symbols'
  31. (1989). European Jewry in the Age of Mercantilism 1550-1750, doi
  32. (1992). Everyone would have to pass through one of the poles-and-wire symbolic gateways Bibliography Alderman, G,
  33. (1985). Faith, myth and politics - the stereotype of the Jews and their expUlsion from England and France', doi
  34. (1992). Formations of Modernity, doi
  35. (1976). From Bible to Mishna: The continuity of tradition, Manchester:
  36. (1996). From pilgrim to tourist, or a short history of identity' in doi
  37. (1994). Funny ... You Don't Look Jewish, doi
  38. (1992). Gennan Jews in Victorian England: a study in drift and defection',
  39. (1980). Geography without man: a humanist critique', School of Geography Research Paper 24, Oxford University; reprinted [with gendered language amended] as 'Geography without human agency: a humanist critique'
  40. (1995). God is in the details' Masoret Magazine. Fall; published on the Internet.
  41. (1983). Hebrew-English Edition of the Babylonian Talmud,
  42. (1962). How To Do Things With Words, doi
  43. (1996). Human Geography: An Essential Anthology,
  44. (1998). Identity Crises: A Social Critique of Postmodernity, Minneanapolis: doi
  45. (1991). Imagined Communities, doi
  46. (1994). Inquiry Report on Application by United Synagogue Eruv Committee to London Borough of Barnet. Bristol: Department of Environment Planning
  47. (1992). Intimations of Post modernity, doi
  48. (1961). Introduction to the Old Testament, doi
  49. (1996). Introduction to the Talmud and Midrash, Minneanapolis: Fortress Press. (A revised, updated and enlarged edition by Sternberger of Strack's Introduction to the Talmud, first published 1887 English translation by Markus Bockmuehl).
  50. (1997). Is Modem Judaism Already Out of Date?',
  51. (1994). Jewish Identities in the New Europe, London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization. doi
  52. (1980). Jewish People, Jewish Thought, doi
  53. (1986). Jewish religious observance in early Victorian London, 1840-1860',
  54. (1991). Kitzur Shulchon Oruch, New York/Jerusalem: Moznaim. English translation in two volumes with notes and diagrams of Rabbi Shlomo Ganzfried's (1864) Kitzur Shulchan Aruch.
  55. (1986). Le Postmodeme explique aux enfants' English translation
  56. (1993). Making good little English children: infant welfare and Anglicization among Jewish immigrants in London, 1880-1939', doi
  57. (1997). Migrant spaces and settlers' time: forming and deforming an inner city', in
  58. (1993). Mishneh Torah, New York/Jerusalem: Moznaim. [A bilingual text, Hebrew with English translation, and commentary on Maimonides' (Rabbi Moshe ben MaimoniRambam) 'Mishneh Torah',
  59. (1991). Modernity and Ambivalence, doi
  60. (1991). Modernity and Self Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age, doi
  61. (1998). Modernity, Culture and "the Jew',
  62. (1993). Muslims: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices: Volume 2: The Contemporary Period, doi
  63. (1996). Naming as norming: "race", gender and the identity politics of naming places in Aotearoa/New Zealand', doi
  64. (1998). National and religious identities in a world of nation states',
  65. (1993). New Strategies in Social Research, doi
  66. (1990). Old-clothes men: 18th and 19th centuries',
  67. (1981). On interviewing one's peers', doi
  68. (1990). Patrick Geddes: Social Evolutionist and City Planner, doi
  69. (1995). Portrait of American Jews: doi
  70. (1996). Postmodern Social Theory' doi
  71. (1990). Private space and the Greek city'
  72. (1956). Protestant-Catholic-lew: An Essay In American Religious Sociology, doi
  73. (1990). Radical Assimilation in English Jewish History 1656-1945, doi
  74. (1996). Reading the Rabbis, doi
  75. (1960). Reform Responsa, doi
  76. (1994). Religion and Globalization, doi
  77. (1965). Religion and Society in Tension, doi
  78. (1969). Religion in Secular doi
  79. (1996). Religion in the Modem World,
  80. (1994). Religious practice and Jewish identity in a sample of London Jews'
  81. (1987). Rethinking fundamentalism: the readjustment of Jewish society in the modern world' doi
  82. (1998). Rethinking Modem Judaism: Ritual, Commandment, Community, doi
  83. (1986). Secularization' doi
  84. (1971). Sephardi and other Jewish immigrants in England in the eighteenth century'
  85. (1984). Shemirath Shabbath: A Guide to the Practical Observance of Shabbath,
  86. (1997). Social Reality, doi
  87. (1996). Sociology of time and space', doi
  88. (1974). Space and place: humanistic perspective' doi
  89. (1987). Studies in Religious Fundamentalism, doi
  90. (1996). Talmudic territory? Space, law and modernist discourse', doi
  91. (1990). The acculturation of the children of immigrant Jews in Manchester, 1890-1930' in Cesarani,
  92. (2000). The Battle for God: Fundamentalism in Judaism, Christianity and Islam,
  93. (1961). The beginnings of the change in the attitude of European society towards the Jews',
  94. (1987). The Board of Deputies of British Jews 1760-1985: A Brief Survey,
  95. (1983). The Chosen People in America, doi
  96. (1989). The Concise Code of Jewish Law,
  97. (1990). The Consequences of Modernity, doi
  98. (1982). The effects of modernization on religious change',
  99. (1960). The English Jewry under the Angevin Kings, doi
  100. (1987). The Englishness of Jewish modernity in England'
  101. (1976). The Essential Talmud,
  102. (1963). The Guide of the Perplexed, doi
  103. (1992). The Hazon Ish: Haredi critic of traditional orthodoxy' in
  104. (1976). The Immigrant Jews of New York. 1881 to the Present, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. (Published in the U.S.A. under the title World of Our Fathers). doi
  105. (1990). The Jewish Heritage In British History: Englishness and Jewishness, London: Frank Casso Langinuir. doi
  106. (1995). The Jewish Religion, A Companion, doi
  107. (1908). The Jews and English Law, doi
  108. (1994). The Jews in Their Land in the Talmudic Age, Cambridge MA and London:
  109. (1960). The lewish Immigrant in England 1880-1914, London: George Allen and Unwin.
  110. (1988). The Living World of the Old Testament,
  111. (1990). The Mishnah: Eruvin, Jerusalem: World Zionist Organization. Mishnah with commentary by Rabbi Pinhas Kehati, English translation by
  112. (1997). The other Durkheim: history and theory in the treatment of classical sociological thought'
  113. (1990). The other self. Anglo-Jewish fiction and the representation of Jews in England, 1875-1905' in Cesarani, D. (ed) The Making of Modem Anglo-Jewry,
  114. (1991). The proposal for a national beit din: Is it good for the Jews?'
  115. (1987). The quest for the Islamic State: Islamic fundamentalism in Egypt and Iran' doi
  116. (1992). The Secularization of Early Modem
  117. (1975). The Secularization of the European Mind in the 19th Century, Cambridge: doi
  118. (1996). The social construction of enemies: Jews and the representation of evil', doi
  119. (1967). The Social Construction of Reality, doi
  120. (1988). The Social Politics of Anglo-Jewry doi
  121. (1931). The Social Teachings of the Christian Churches, London: Allen and Unwin.
  122. (1995). The Sociology of Religion, doi
  123. (1977). The United Synagogue doi
  124. (1992). The Use of Tradition: Jewish Continuity in the Modem Er~ New York: Jewish Theological Seminary.
  125. (1990). Theories of Modernity and Postmodemity,
  126. (1990). Thinking Sociologically, doi
  127. (1984). Tree of Life. Diversity, Flexibility and Creativity doi
  128. (1996). Vanishing Diaspora: The Jews doi
  129. (1992). When Time Shall Be No More. Prophecy Belief in Modem American Culture, doi
  130. (1997). White governmentality: urbanism, nationalism, racism', in
  131. (1993). You're gonna miss me when I'm gone": Early modem common law discourse and the case of the Jews', Wisconsin Law Review.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.