Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Poor Relief and Welfare: a comparative study of the Belper and Cheltenham Poor Law Unions, 1780 to 1914

By Christine Violet Seal


There are few local studies of a comparative nature encompassing poor law unions in different regions. This thesis is unique in considering a union in the north midlands and one bordering the south-west, from 1780 to 1914. The provision of relief in Cheltenham and Belper is set in the context of social and economic conditions in these two areas. Were Cheltenham and Belper different in their management of their poor between 1770 and 1914, and how did poor relief in these two unions conform or differ to the specifications laid down in the 1834 Act? \ud Chapter 1 looks at relief under the old poor law, while chapter 2 considers the manner in which the unions were formed. Chapters 3, 4 and 6 analyse the workhouse and union populations at various times, and chapter 5 investigates charity and its assistance to the poor. Several major themes are looked at including emigration, vagrants, the children and aged. \ud Cheltenham and Belper managed their poor in a similar manner, except most notably with regard to assisted emigration. Only Cheltenham used this to reduce pauperism. It provided out-relief for a greater number of paupers than Belper, and its expenditure per head was much higher. Workhouse populations were very distinctive in 1851. Belper had a high percentage of children and female able-bodied paupers at that time. By 1911 the workhouse populations had become more similar in both unions, being dominated by the elderly, sick and infirm. The thesis argues for general trends, observes a common trajectory of change, assesses charity alongside formal relief, and shows how interestingly different socio-economic contexts affected the comparative details and nature of pauperism. It thus invites further comparative research into the varied regional application of the 1834 Poor Law Amendment Act, using the benchmarks and salient features highlighted here

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2010
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1999). 2 For studies covering short periods in the nineteenth century see Goose
  2. (1969). A History of doi
  3. (1988). A History of Charlton Kings (Gloucester,
  4. (1965). A History of Cheltenham (Leicester, doi
  5. a Picture and Endowment of
  6. (2008). A radical historian’s pursuit of rural history: the political career and contribution of Reverend Dr John Charles Cox, doi
  7. (1850). A walk in a workhouse’ from Household Words doi
  8. Abstract and Returns relative to the Expense and Maintenance of the Poor (1804). Annual Reports of the Poor Law Commission, Poor Law Board and Local Government Board.
  9. (2006). Acts of charity’,
  10. (1934). Ageing and Economy: Historical Issues
  11. (2003). Agents in their own concerns? Charity and the economy of makeshifts
  12. (2000). Agricultural trade unionism and the crusade against outdoor relief: poor law politics in the Brixworth union,
  13. (2004). Almshouse versus workhouse: residential welfare in eighteenth century Oxford’, doi
  14. (2004). Almshouses (Princes Risborough,
  15. also part of Belper Union, the first friendly society for the benefit of the sick and infirm members was set up in 1794.
  16. (2000). An Illustrated History of Belper and its Environs
  17. (1985). Annals of the Labouring Poor: Social Change and Agrarian England, doi
  18. (2003). Attitudes to poverty and social reform in Cheltenham, 1870-1899’ (unpublished MA thesis,
  19. (1894). Belper and its People
  20. (1996). Cheltenham, a Pictorial History
  21. Commission of Inquiry into Administration and Practical Operation of Poor Laws, Tenth Volume, Appendix (A), Reports of Assistant Commissioners, Part I (Vol. XXVIII – sess.
  22. (1999). Continuity and change in English rural society: the formation of poor law unions in Oxfordshire’, doi
  23. (1926). D19 C/W 1/31, board of guardian minutes,
  24. Education in Crich – a brief history in (29.8.2008).
  25. (1929). English Poor Law History, Part II: doi
  26. (1910). English Poor Law Policy (London, doi
  27. (1987). English poor law policy and the crusade against outrelief’, doi
  28. (1985). English rural society and the new poor law: Bedfordshire 1834-47’, doi
  29. (1995). From Artisans to Paupers: Economic Change and Poverty in London, doi
  30. (1981). From Pauperism to Poverty doi
  31. (1998). Head versus heart? Voluntary associations and charity organization in England, c.1700-1850’, doi
  32. (2008). In darkest London’,
  33. (1891). Kelly’s Directory of the Counties of Derby,
  34. (2002). Kent workhouse populations in 1881: a study based on the census enumerators’ books’, doi
  35. (1998). Landed interest, local government and the labour market in England’, doi
  36. (1998). Lees, The Solidarities of Strangers: the English Poor Laws and the People, doi
  37. (1863). Norman’s History of
  38. (1911). Notes – Existing Defects.
  39. (1992). Old questions, new data and alternative perspectives: families’ living standards in the industrial revolution’, doi
  40. (2003). On account of their disreputable characters: parish assisted emigration from rural doi
  41. (1995). Organized Charity and the Poor Law in Victorian England doi
  42. (1999). Parish economies of welfare, doi
  43. (2006). Pauper protests: power and resistance in early nineteenth-century London workhouses’, doi
  44. (1989). Pauperism and the Leicester Workhouse in 1881’,
  45. (1892). Pauperism, a Picture and Endowment of Old Age
  46. (1990). Paupers and pensioners: past and present’, doi
  47. (1908). pensions were provided under the Old Age Pensions Act for all those over 70, but this was subject to a means test and precluded any pauper who had received poor relief. By
  48. (1991). Philanthropy and the Poor Law in Richmond,
  49. (1966). Philanthropy and the Victorians’,
  50. (1992). Poor Relief in Merthyr Tydfil Union in Victorian Times (Glamorgan, doi
  51. (1998). Poverty and Poor Law Reform doi
  52. (1998). Poverty and Poor Law Reform in Nineteenth Century Britain, 1834-1914: from Chadwick to Booth (London, doi
  53. (2000). Poverty and pragmatism i the northern uplands of England: the North Yorkshire Pennines c1770-1900’, doi
  54. (2000). Poverty and pragmatism in the northern uplands of England: the north Yorkshire Pennines, c.1770-1900’, doi
  55. (1988). Poverty and the State: an Historical Sociology (Milton Keynes, doi
  56. (1991). Poverty and the Workhouse in
  57. (2000). Poverty and Welfare in England, 1700-1850: a Regional Perspective doi
  58. (2005). Poverty, old age and gender in nineteenth century England: the case of Hertfordshire’, doi
  59. (1993). Power and Pauperism: the workhouse system, 1834-1884 doi
  60. Private charity and the 1834 poor law’, (5.2.2007).
  61. (2007). Protesting about Pauperism: Poverty, Politics and Poor Relief in late Victorian England, 1870-1900 doi
  62. (2007). Protesting about Pauperism: Poverty, Politics and Poor Relief in late-Victorian England, doi
  63. Provisional Workhouses, appendix to report (London, 1867-8), (5.1.2009).
  64. (1997). Reconstructing lives: the poor, the poor law and welfare in doi
  65. (1993). Report of St. Paul’s Hospital formerly Cheltenham Union Workhouse
  66. (1994). Secondary Sources (The place of publication is London unless otherwise stated) Books A. Barrass, Belper looking into the Past (Belper,
  67. (1992). Settlement, poor law and the rural historian: new approaches and opportunities’, doi
  68. (1969). Social Administration in Lancashire, 1830-1860: Poor Law, Public Health and Police doi
  69. (1795). Society and Pauperism: English Ideas on Poor Relief, doi
  70. (1999). Society and the Poor doi
  71. (1981). Society, Belper, a study of its History based on Visual Evidence
  72. (1894). Society, Charity Organisation Work in Cheltenham: Appeal for Help doi
  73. (1999). State, Society and the Poor doi
  74. Statistical notice of the town and parish of Cheltenham’, doi
  75. (2008). Summary of ‘Importance of the English almshouse as part of the mixed economy of welfare’,
  76. (1988). Tale of Crich (Fritchley,
  77. (1894). The Aged Poor in England and doi
  78. (1966). The allowance system under the new poor law’, doi
  79. (1982). The Book of Cheltenham
  80. (1961). The Charity Organisation Society, 1869-1913: its Ideas and Work doi
  81. The crisis of poor relief
  82. (2004). The Decline of Life: Old Age in Eighteenth-Century England doi
  83. (2004). The Dorking emigration scheme of 1832’, doi
  84. (2003). The economy of makeshifts and the role of the poor law: a game of chance’
  85. (1981). The English poor laws and the origins of the British welfare state’
  86. (2002). The English Poor Laws, doi
  87. (2003). The Evolution of the British Welfare State: a History of Social Policy since the Industrial Revolution doi
  88. (1760). The experience of poverty in a rural community:
  89. (1974). The hungry forties and the new poor law: a case study’, doi
  90. (1986). The Illustrated History of Duffield (Derby,
  91. (1969). The implementation of the 1834 Poor Law Amendment Act on Tyneside’, doi
  92. (1975). The labour market and the continuity of social policy after 1834: the case of the eastern counties’, doi
  93. (1978). The later years of the workhouse, 1890-1929’
  94. (2005). The Medway union workhouse, 1876-1881: a study based on the admission and discharge registers and the census enumerators’ books’,
  95. (1974). The Poor in Eighteenth-century France, doi
  96. (1976). The poor law and philanthropy’ doi
  97. (1909). The Poor Law Report of doi
  98. (1984). The poor law reports of 1909 and the social theory of the Charity Organisation Society’,
  99. (1998). The populations of two Hampshire workhouses, 1851-1861’,
  100. (1990). The relief of poverty in mid-nineteenth century doi
  101. (1834). The Relief of Poverty, doi
  102. (1898). The relief of the deserving poor’, Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge
  103. (1977). The relief of the poor in doi
  104. (1819). The Report of the Commissioners to enquire concerning charities in England and Wales relating to the County of Gloucester,
  105. (1976). The rural poor law’ doi
  106. (1986). The search for a cure for vagrancy in Worcestershire’, doi
  107. The State of the Poor: a History of the Labouring Classes in England (1797), doi
  108. The State of the Poor: a History of the Labouring Classes in England, doi
  109. The statistics of wages in the United Kingdom during the last hundred years (Part I) agricultural wages’,
  110. (1983). The Workhouse System 1834-1929: the History of an English Social Institution doi
  111. (2003). The Workhouse: a Social History doi
  112. (1999). The Workhouse: a Study of Poor Law Buildings in
  113. (1984). The working class and state welfare in doi
  114. (1984). The working class and state welfare in Britain, 1880-1914’, doi
  115. (1976). Urban poor law’ doi
  116. (1977). Vagrancy and the new poor law in late-Victorian and Edwardian England’, doi
  117. (1991). Vagrancy in mid-Victorian Richmond, Surrey’,
  118. (1990). Victorian Workhouse: a study of the Bromsgrove Union Workhouse
  119. (2001). Welfare-to-work schemes and a crusade against outdoor relief in the Brixworth union, Northamptonshire, doi
  120. White’s Directory of Derbyshire, 1857 on www.belperThe Cheltenham and County Looker-On The Times, Amber Valley Visitor Centre leaflets:
  121. (1978). Women and the poor law in Victorian and Edwardian England’, doi
  122. (1999). Workhouse populations in the mid-nineteenth century: the case of Hertfordshire’,
  123. (2007). Workhouse, the People, the Places, the Life Behind Doors (Kew,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.