Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A Study Of ‘Caring’ Academics And Their Work Within A UK University

By Caroline Walker-Gleaves


This researcher investigated three academics perceived to be caring, in the naturalistic setting of their everyday work in a UK university. The three academics were selected using LeCompte & Preissle’s (1993) Reputational Case Selection methodology. Two purposes framed this investigation: 1. To gain an in-depth understanding of the educational and pedagogical beliefs and practices of higher education academics who are perceived to be caring and 2. To examine how identity is constructed through autobiography.\ud Using a dual phenomenology and life-history methodology, data sources included a series of interviews, teaching metaphors, observations, participants’ personal writing, research notes and other salient material. Dialogue between the researcher and participants played a major part in ensuring the rigour of the study: throughout, participants were given the opportunity to critically assess their portrayals within the thesis.\ud Results indicated that the participants differed in their views about being perceived as ‘caring’ and possessed a range of beliefs related to its place in academic work. In addition, there was variance in the cultural context of the academics’ work, revealing a difference in the conceptions of institutional prerogatives about ‘the value of caring’. The academics’ autobiographies shaped their values and ethics, and these played a significant role in how their pedagogic identities and practices were conceptualized.\ud This empirical study assists in understanding academic identities at a time of profound change in higher education. It can also contribute to a currently under-theorized account of academic work that weaves values and pedagogic scholarship and examines its effects on students’ experiences.\ud Implications are offered for future research involving the investigation of caring pedagogies in relation to students’ achievement, retention and the values and ethics that might develop as a result of caring teaching

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2010
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2006). (Be) Coming, (Be) Longing: Ways In
  2. (2002). (Eds) Failing Students In Higher Education.
  3. (2007). A Caring Society?
  4. (2002). A Caring Teacher: Explorations Into Primary School Teachers’ Professional Identity And Ethic Of Care.
  5. (2004). A Feminist Perspective On Student Assessment: An Epistemology Of Caring And Concern.
  6. (1969). A Hippocratic Oath For The Academic profession.
  7. (1996). A Life In School: What The Teacher Learned.
  8. (2002). A Pedagogy Of Trust In
  9. (2008). A Philosophical Investigation Of The Role Of Teachers: A Synthesis Of Plato, Confucius, Buber And Freire. Teaching And Teacher Education,
  10. (2008). A Real Rollercoaster Of Confidence And Emotions': Learning To Be A University Student. Studies In
  11. (2002). A Special Duty Of Care: Exploring The Narration And Experience Of Teacher Caring.
  12. (2006). A Study Of The Difficulties Of Care And Support In New University Teachers’ Work. Teachers And Teaching: Theory And Practice,
  13. (2004). Academic And Social Integration In Higher Education: A Survey Of Satisfaction And Dissatisfaction Within A first-Year Education Studies Cohort At A New University.
  14. (2008). Academic Professionalism In The Managerialist Era: A Study Of English Universities. Studies In
  15. (1999). Academic Work In The 21st Century: Changing Roles And Policies. Canberra: Commonwealth Of Australia Higher Education Research And Policy Division.
  16. (1998). Academics Responding To Change: New Higher Education Frameworks And Academic Cultures.
  17. (2002). Academics' metaphors and beliefs about university teaching and learning. Paper presented at the Australian Association for Research in Education,
  18. (2007). Acknowledging The Affective In Higher Education.
  19. (1998). Act
  20. (2005). All In A Day’s Work: Primary Teachers ‘Performing’ And ‘Caring’.
  21. (1984). An Ethic Of Caring And Its Implications For Instructional Arrangements.
  22. (2008). An Examination Of The Interrelationships Between Self-Esteem, Others' Expectations, Family Support, Learning Approaches And Academic Achievement. Studies In
  23. (2009). Assurance Agency
  24. (2003). Barriers to reflective practice: the changing nature of higher education.
  25. (2009). Be Heard: The National Student Survey.
  26. (1994). Beginning qualitative research: a philosophic and practical guide.
  27. (2008). Being A Teacher In Further Education In Changing Times.
  28. (1965). Between Man And Man.
  29. (1999). Beyond The Degree: Men And Women At The Decision-Making Levels
  30. (2008). Body, Caring And Power In Teacher-Pupil Relationships: Encounters In Former Pupils' Memories.
  31. (2008). Boundary Dilemmas In
  32. (2009). Bowing From The Heart’: An Investigation Into Discourses Of Professionalism And The Work Of Caring For Students In Further Education.
  33. (2001). Bridging Pedagogic Gaps: Conceptual Discontinuities In
  34. (1993). By Chart And Chance And Passion: The Importance Of Relational Knowing In Learning To Teach.
  35. (2006). Can Students Within Higher Education Learn To Be Resilient And Educationally Speaking, Does It Matter?
  36. (2004). Caring Pharmacists, Caring Teachers.
  37. (1996). Caring Professors: A Model.
  38. (1984). Caring: A Feminist Approach To Ethics And Moral Education.
  39. (1992). Caring: The Expert Teacher’s Edge.
  40. (2008). Carnegie Academy For The Scholarship Of Teaching And Learning.
  41. (2003). Challenges Enacting Caring Teacher Education.
  42. (2003). Challenging The Dogma: Towards A More Inclusive Conceptualization Of The Scholarship Of Teaching.
  43. (2005). Charting a Critical Course on the Scholarship of University Teaching Movement.
  44. (2003). Claiming A Scared Face: The Role Of Spirituality And Cultural Identity In Transformative Adult Higher Education.
  45. (2007). Conceptions of Effective Teaching In
  46. (2003). Constructing Images Of Ourselves? A Critical Investigation Into 'Approaches To Learning' Research In Higher Education.
  47. (1998). Corrected Proof, Online Science Direct.
  48. (2004). Cultural Models of Care
  49. (2002). Dealing With Dave’s Dilemmas: Exploring The Ethics Of Pedagogic Practice, Teaching In
  50. (1995). Designing Qualitative Research. Thousand Oaks,
  51. (2009). Distinctive Qualities of Expert Teachers. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,
  52. (2007). Does Higher Education Need a Hippocratic Oath?
  53. (1996). Doing Good And Feeling Bad: The Work Of Women University Teachers.
  54. (2002). Educating Moral People.
  55. (2009). Education Academy
  56. (2001). Education As A Moral Practice.
  57. (2005). Education, The Law And You.
  58. (2001). Educational Needs Disability Act
  59. (2001). Emotions And Professional Identity In Academic Work: Conceptions Of Caring And Order.
  60. (1979). Empirical phenomenological analysis of being criminally victimized. In
  61. (2003). Employment Equality (Sexual Orientation) Regulations
  62. (2005). Engaging The Curriculum In
  63. (1993). Ethnography And Qualitative Design
  64. (1998). Ethnography: Step by Step (2nd edition). Thousand Oaks,
  65. (1991). Expertise And The Teacher As Expert: Rethinking A Questionable Metaphor.
  66. (1989). Fear of Falling: The Inner Life of the Middle Class.
  67. (1986). Fidelity In
  68. (2001). For Education And Employment
  69. (2007). For Education And Skills
  70. For Education And Skills) (2002) Green Paper ‘14–19: Opportunity And Excellence’.
  71. (2007). From Husserl To Van Manen: A Review Of Different Phenomenological Approaches.
  72. (2005). From Life Crisis To Lifelong Learning: Rethinking Working Class Dropout From Higher Education.
  73. (2008). Going The Extra Mile', 'Fire-Fighting', Or LaissezFaire? Re- Evaluating Personal Tutoring Relationships Within Mass Higher Education', Teaching
  74. (2003). Happiness And Education. Cambridge:
  75. (2008). Higher Education Academy (HEA)
  76. (2005). Higher Education Pedagogies.
  77. (2004). Higher Education Teachers And Emotional Labour.
  78. (1995). History Of The Notion Of Care’. In W.T. Reich (Ed) Encyclopedia Of Bioethics (Revised Edition).
  79. (2009). How do teachers view their own pedagogical authority?
  80. (1998). How six outstanding mathematics professors view teaching and learning: The importance of caring.
  81. (2006). I Don’t Feel Like A Student, I Feel Like Me!”: The Over-Simplification Of Mature Learners’ Experiences.
  82. (1998). I Want To Be Nice, But I Have To Be Mean": Exploring Prospective Teachers'
  83. (1999). Identity and induction: Establishing theself in the first years of teaching.
  84. (2008). Identity, Well-Being And Effectiveness: The Emotional Contexts Of Teaching.
  85. (1977). In A Different Voice: Women’s Conceptions Of Self And Of Morality.
  86. (1982). In A Different Voice.
  87. (2009). Individual And Institutional Factors In The Tendency To Drop Out Of Higher Education: A Multilevel Analysis Using Data From The Konstanz Student Survey.
  88. (2007). International Perspectives On Teaching Excellence In
  89. (2004). Interpreting Student Early Departure From Higher Education Through The Lens Of Cultural Capital.
  90. (1989). Interpretive Biography.
  91. (1998). Interviewing As Qualitative Research: A Guide For Researchers In Education And The Social Sciences.
  92. (1996). Interviews: An Introduction To Qualitative Research Interviewing. Thousand Oaks,
  93. (2004). Introduction. In Reclaiming universities from a runaway
  94. (2003). It's A Struggle': The Construction Of The 'New Student' In Higher Education.
  95. (2001). Justice And Lecturer Professionalism. Teaching In
  96. (1987). Knowledge And Teaching: Foundations Of The New Reform.
  97. (2003). Learning In The Field: An Introduction To Qualitative Research (2nd Ed.). Thousand Oaks,
  98. (2004). Learning Or Therapy? The Demoralisation Of Education.
  99. (2004). Leaving University Early: Exploring The Differences Between Continuing And Non-Continuing Students. Studies In
  100. (2001). Life History Research In Educational Settings.
  101. (2002). Lives In Context: The Art Of Life History Research.
  102. (1999). Making Sense Of Academic Life: Academics, Universities And Change.
  103. (2003). Making Stories: Law, Literature and Life.
  104. (2007). Managing 'Nearly Reasonable' Risk
  105. (2004). Meaning, Identity And 'Motivation': Expanding What Matters In Understanding Learning
  106. (2004). Memories Of A Fledging Teacher: A Beginning Teacher’s Autobiography. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,
  107. (2005). Merging Social Justice And Accountability: Educating Qualified And Effective Teachers. Theory Into Practice,
  108. (2008). Mind In Life: Biology, Phenomenology, And The Sciences Of Mind.
  109. (2005). Models Of Professional Development In The Education And Practice Of New Teachers In
  110. (1985). Naturalistic Inquiry.
  111. (2007). New Academics Negotiating Communities Of Practice: Learning To Swim With The Big Fish. Teaching
  112. (2000). No Man’s Land: Caring And Male Student Primary Teachers. Teachers And Teaching: Theory And Practice,
  113. (2008). Of bedpans and ivory towers? Nurse academics' identities and the sacred and profane: A Bernsteinian analysis and discussion paper'.
  114. (2005). Ofsted (Office For Standards In Education)
  115. (1998). On Self and Social Organization. Ed. Schubert Hans-Joachim.
  116. (2002). Overcoming Fragmentation In Professional Life: The Challenge For Academic Development.
  117. (2009). Oxford English Dictionary.
  118. (1996). Pedagogy, Symbolic Control And Identity.
  119. (2006). Personal Tutoring In
  120. (1996). Personality, modernity, and the storied self: A contemporary framework for studying persons.
  121. (1989). Phenomenological Research Methods. In
  122. (1994). Phenomenological Research Methods. Thousand Oaks:
  123. (2002). Phenomenology As A Method To Investigate The Lived Experiences: A Perspective From Husserl And Merleau-Ponty’s Thought.
  124. (2004). Preservice Interns Implement Service-Learning: Helping Young Children Reach Out to Their Community.
  125. (2009). Professional identity creation: Examining the development of beginning preservice teachers’ understanding of their work as teachers.
  126. (2001). Professional Roles, Caring, And Scaffolds: Latino Teachers’ And Paraeducators’ Interactions With Latino Students.
  127. (2002). Profound Sexual And Spiritual Encounters Among Practicing Christians: A Phenomenological Analysis.
  128. (2002). Qualitative Analysis On Stage: Making The Research Process Public.
  129. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. Thousand Oaks,
  130. (1990). Qualitative Evaluation And Research Methods.
  131. (2003). Race Relations Act
  132. (2005). Rationales And Practices Used By Caring Physical Education Teachers.
  133. (2004). Relational Agency And Disposition In
  134. (2004). Relational Analysis Of Personal Epistemology And Conceptions About Teaching And Learning.
  135. (1992). Reputation And Predecessor Selection: Parsons And The Institutionalists.
  136. (2003). Research Selectivity And Female Academics In UK Universities: From Gentleman’s Club And Barrack Yard To Smart Macho? Gender And Education,
  137. (2006). Researching Lived Experience: Human Science For An Action Sensitive Pedagogy.
  138. (1990). Researching Lived Experience: Human Science For An Action-Sensitive Pedagogy.
  139. (2004). Retention And Success In
  140. (2002). Retired Teachers Reflect On Learning From Experience. Teachers and Teaching,
  141. (2001). Revisiting Academics’ Beliefs About Teaching And Learning.
  142. (1975). Schoolteacher. Chicago:
  143. (2009). Secondary Teachers' Conceptual Metaphors Of Teaching and Learning: Changes Over The Career Span. Teaching and Teacher Education,
  144. (1991). Shaping pedagogies through personal histories in preservice education.
  145. (1991). Situated Learning - Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Cambridge:
  146. (1985). Sketch Of A Psychological phenomenological Method.". In
  147. (1998). Sociocultural Psychology And Caring Pedagogy: Exploring Vygotsky’s ‘Hidden Curriculum’.
  148. (2008). Spirituality And Pedagogy: Faculty’s Spirituality And Use Of Student-Centred Approaches To Undergraduate Teaching. The Review of Higher Education,
  149. (1990). Structures, habitus, practices.
  150. (1997). Student Motivation In Middle School: The Role Of Perceived Pedagogical Caring.
  151. (2006). Student Perception Of Caring Teaching In
  152. (1992). Studying Teachers’ Lives.
  153. (2006). Teacher Identity Discourses: Negotiating Personal And Professional Spaces. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
  154. (2003). Teachers Make A Difference: Distinguishing Expert Teachers From Novice And Experienced Teachers. Paper Presented At The Australian
  155. (2004). Teaching At The Border Of Despair And Hope: Supporting The Education Of Non- Traditional Working Class Student Teachers. Westminster Studies In
  156. (2009). Teaching Excellence In Nursing Education: A Caring Framework.
  157. (2007). Teaching Imaginary Children:
  158. (2004). Teaching With Integrity.
  159. (1994). Telling Teaching Stories.
  160. The (2004) The Bucharest Declaration Concerning Ethical Values And Principles For Higher Education
  161. (2006). The Audacity Of Hope: Towards Poorer Pedagogies.
  162. (2007). The Challenges Of Insider-Research In Educational Institutions: Wielding A Double-Edged Sword And Resolving Delicate Dilemmas. Oxford Review of Education,
  163. (1998). The Corrosion Of Character.
  164. (1967). The Discovery Of Grounded Theory: Strategies For Qualitative Research.
  165. (2007). The Effect Of Pedagogical Training On Teaching In
  166. (2006). The Emotional Impact Of Learning In Small Groups: Highlighting The Impact On Student Progression And Retention. Teaching In
  167. (2006). The Emotional Labour Of Caring
  168. (1998). The Emotional Practice Of Teaching.
  169. (2002). The Formation Of Identity: The Importance Of Ideals.
  170. (2003). The Impact Of Field Experience On Preservice Teachers' Understandings Of Caring.
  171. (2003). The Importance of Ideals in Education.
  172. (2007). The Life and Death of a Course. Teaching
  173. (1983). The Managed Heart: Commercialisation Of Human Feeling.
  174. (2002). The necessity of teacher development. In
  175. (1991). The Pedagogy Of Poverty Versus Good Teaching.
  176. (2004). The Politics Of Care - Emotional Labour And Trainee FE Lecturers.
  177. (2004). The Power Of Autobiography.
  178. (2001). The Psychology of Life Stories.
  179. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner. How Professionals Think In Action.
  180. (1999). The Relational Zone: The Role Of Caring In
  181. (1994). The Richness Of Phenomenology: Philosophic, Theoretic, And Methodologic Concerns. In
  182. (2004). The Scholarship Of Teaching As A Core Professional Value: What Does This Mean To The Academic? Teaching
  183. (1993). The stories we live by: Personal myths and the making of the self.
  184. (2002). The Tone of Teaching.
  185. (1995). The Use Of Expert Teachers To Improve Education.
  186. (1968). The Visible And The Invisible. Evanston, III:
  187. (2003). Themes Of Hope And Healing: Infertile Couples' Experiences Of Adoption.
  188. (1973). Thick Description: Toward An Interpretive Theory Of Culture.
  189. (1987). Thinking Through Confucius.
  190. (1962). Thought and language.
  191. (2000). Ties That Bind: A Social Network Approach To Understanding Student Integration And Persistence.
  192. (1995). Toward A Theory Of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy.
  193. (2001). Towards A New Academic Professionalism: A Manifesto Of Hope.
  194. (1996). Trust Is Not Enough: Classroom Self-Disclosure And The Loss Of Private Lives.
  195. (2005). Understanding Teaching Excellence In
  196. (2004). Universities In The Marketplace: The Commercialization Of Higher Education.
  197. (2008). Using Digital And Paper Diaries For Learning And Assessment Purposes In
  198. (2005). Values In
  199. (2008). Voices From Within: Teaching In Higher Education As A Moral Practice. Teaching In
  200. (2005). Want to Graduate Nurses Who Care? Assessing Nursing Students’ Caring Competencies.
  201. (2002). What Happens When Researchers Inquire Into Difficult emotions? Reflection On Studying Women’s Anger Through Qualitative Interviews.
  202. (2007). What Is Meant By ‘Support’ In Higher Education? Toward A Model Of Academic And Welfare Support.
  203. (2001). What Spring Does With The Cherry Trees': The Eros Of Teaching And Learning. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,
  204. (1998). Writing On Academic Careers.
  205. (2008). You Choose To Care’: Teachers,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.