Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Different methods, different wilds: Evaluating alternative mappings of wildness using fuzzy MCE and Dempster-Shafer MCE

By Alexis J. Comber, Steve Carver, Steffen Fritz, Robert McMorran, Justin Washtell and Peter Fisher


Different multi-criteria evaluation (MCE) approaches are applied to a fuzzy wildness mapping problem in Scotland. The result of fuzzy weighted linear combination and fuzzy order weighted averaging approaches are compared with the application of a Dempster-Shafer MCE. We discuss the implications of different approaches in light of decision making associated with suitability in a context where (i) suitability (wildness) may not be very well defined, (ii) the decision makers may not fully understand the informatics aspects associated with applying weights, but (iii) require decisions to be accountable and transparent. In such situations we suggest that the outputs of Dempster-Shafer MCE may be more appropriate than a fully fuzzy model of suitability

Topics: Uncertainty, Wildness, Fuzzy, Dempster-Shafer, Multi-criteria evaluation
Publisher: Elsevier
Year: 2009
DOI identifier: 10.1016/j.compenvurbsys.2009.10.006
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2000). A fuzzy modelling approach to wild land mapping in Scotland,
  2. (1989). A reconnaissance-level inventory of the amount of wilderness remaining in the world.
  3. (2006). A review of the benefits and opportunities attributed to Scotland's landscapes of wild character.
  4. (1993). An experimental system for the integration of GIS data in knowledge-based image analysis for remote sensing of agriculture. doi
  5. (2000). Application of fuzzy measures in multi-criteria evaluation in GIS. doi
  6. (1995). Australian approaches to wilderness.
  7. (2005). Beyond Conservation: a wildland strategy. doi
  8. (2004). Comparing and combing different expert relations of how land cover ontologies relate. In doi
  9. (2009). Delineating urban housing submarkets with fuzzy clustering. Environment and Planning B: Planning and doi
  10. (2007). Dempster-Shafer Theory in geographic information systems: A survey. doi
  11. (2006). GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature. doi
  12. (2006). IDRISI Andes Tutorial.
  13. (2004). Implementation of the analytical hierarchy process with doi
  14. (2008). Implementing an extension of the analytical hierarchy process using ordered weighted averaging operators with fuzzy quantifiers in ArcGIS. doi
  15. (2006). Integrating multicriteria analysis and geographic information systems: the ordered weighted averaging (OWA) approach. doi
  16. (1991). Integrating multicriteria evaluation with GIS.
  17. (1999). Mapping remote areas using GIS.
  18. (1996). Mapping the wilderness continuum using raster GIS.
  19. (2005). Modeling localities with fuzzy sets in doi
  20. (2005). Mountains and wilderness: identifying areas for restoration.
  21. (2007). Multi-criteria evaluation. In
  22. (1983). Multi-criteria evaluations for urban and regional planning.
  23. (2005). Multicriteria decision analysis in spatial decision support: the ASSESS analytic hierarchy process and the role of quantitative methods and spatially explicit analysis. doi
  24. (2000). New approaches to wild land mapping in Europe. In
  25. (1988). On ordered weighted averaging aggregation operators in multicriteria decision making. doi
  26. (2007). Setting Site Specific Critical Loads: An Approach using Endorsement Theory and Dempster–Shafer. doi
  27. (1998). SimLand: a prototype to simulate land conversion through the integrated GIS and CA with AHP-derived transition rules. doi
  28. (1994). The Australian National Wilderness Inventory: wildland survey and assessment in Australia. In C. Sydoriak (Ed.). Wilderness: The Spirit Lives.
  29. (2002). The human footprint and the last of the wild. doi
  30. (2002). The use of Dempster–Shafer model and GIS in integration of geoscientific data for porphyry copper potential mapping, north of Shahr-e-Babak, Iran. doi
  31. (2007). Using GIS-based methods of multicriteria analysis to construct socio-economic deprivation indices. doi
  32. (2002). Web-enabled spatial decision analysis using Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA). doi
  33. (1996). Wild land or wilderness - is there a difference?
  34. (2002). Wild land policy. [available 04/03/2009]
  35. (1982). Wilderness and the American Mind. doi
  36. (2002). Wilderness attribute mapping in the United Kingdom.
  37. (2002). Wildness in Scotland’s Countryside, Policy Statement [available 04/03/2009].

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.