Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Investigating the relationship between open magnetic flux and the substorm cycle

By Peter David Boakes


This thesis is concerned with the open magnetic flux content of the magnetosphere\ud during the substorm cycle.\ud We develop an automated technique of identifying the global location of the\ud open/closed magnetic field line boundary (OCB) from auroral images of the\ud ionospheric northern polar cap made by the IMAGE FUV detector, and hence of\ud estimating the open magnetic flux content of any one hemisphere (Fpc). Systematic\ud offsets are found between the location of the OCB as estimated from the auroral\ud images and from in-situ measurements of precipitating particles consistent with\ud previous studies. These offsets are used to provide a more accurate global\ud estimation of the location of the OCB.\ud This method is used to estimate the average Fpc content of the magnetosphere from\ud 12,731 auroral images from December and January of 2000-2002, 173 of which\ud occur at the time of substorm onset. From these distributions we are able, for the\ud first time, to determine the probability of substorm onset as a function of Fpc. The\ud probability of substorm onset is found to be negligible below ~ 0.3 GWb, increases\ud linearly until ~0.9 GWb, and is undefined above this. These results are discussed in\ud terms of various models for substorm onset and place important constraints on any\ud future models.\ud We also find that substorms showing a clear particle injection signature, as seen at\ud geosynchronous orbit, occur, on average, at higher values of open magnetic flux\ud than those showing varied or no injection activity. In the final part of this thesis we\ud investigate these three distinct categories of substorms further by carrying out a\ud superposed epoch analysis of Fpc, maximum nightside auroral brightness, solar wind\ud and IMF conditions, geomagnetic activity and auroral oval boundary motions. We\ud find that the level and form of solar wind driving appears to characterise the\ud injection signature seen

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2010
DOI identifier: 10.1029/2008JA0133402008a.
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2001). A case study of HF radar spectra and 630.0 nm auroral emission in the pre-midnight sector,
  2. (2002). A comparison of substorms occurring during magnetic storms with those occurring during quiet times,
  3. (2007). A comparison of the probability distribution of observed substorm magnitude with that predicted by a minimal substorm model,
  4. (2004). A critical condition in magnetotail pressure for leading to a substorm expansion onset: Geotail's observations,
  5. (2007). A decade of the Super Dual Auroral Radar Network (SuperDARN): scientific achievements, new techniques and future directions,
  6. (1995). A Far-Ultraviolet Imager for the International Solar-Terrestrial Physics Mission,
  7. (2004). A minimal substorm model that explains the observed statistical distribution of times between substorms,
  8. (1989). A new magnetic coordinate system for conjugate studies at high latitude,
  9. (1995). A New Theory for Magnetospheric Substorms,
  10. (1930). A new theory of magnetic storms,
  11. (2005). A statistical comparison of SuperDARN spectral width boundaries and DMSP particle precipitation boundaries in the morning sector ionosphere,
  12. (2004). A statistical comparison of SuperDARN spectral width boundaries and DMSP particle precipitation boundaries in the nightside ionosphere,
  13. (2009). A statistical study of the spatial structure of interplanetary magnetic field substorm triggers and their associated magnetic response,
  14. (1985). A Statistical-Model of Auroral Electron-Precipitation,
  15. (1960). A study of the interplanetary ionized gas, high-energy electrons, and corpuscular radiation from the sun by means of the three-electrode trap for charged particles on the second Soviet cosmic rocket,
  16. A superposed epoch analysis of auroral evolution during substorm growth, onset and recovery: open magnetic flux control of substorm intensity,
  17. (1991). A Synthesis of Magnetospheric Substorm Models,
  18. (1984). a Synthesis of Ring Current Spectra and Energy Densities Measured with Ampte Cce,
  19. (2003). A technique for accurately determining the cuspregion polar cap boundary using SuperDARN HF radar measurements,
  20. (2007). abrupt pressure decreases as a substorm onset trigger,
  21. (1984). AFGL-TR-84- 0317, Air Force Geophys.
  22. (2002). An evaluation of the statistical significance of the association between northward turnings of the interplanetary magnetic field and substorm expansion onsets,
  23. (1995). An Introduction To Space Plasma Physics,
  24. (2002). An unusual geometry of the ionospheric signature of the cusp: implications for magnetopause merging sites,
  25. (2008). and KuaFu Working Team, Space weather explorer - The KuaFu mission,
  26. (1916). Are the Solar Corpuscular Rays that penetrate the Earth's Atmosphere Negative or Positive Rays?", Videnskapsselskapets Skrifter, I Mat Naturv. Klasse No.1,
  27. (2006). Association of substorm chorus events with drift echoes,
  28. (2007). Aurora and open magnetic flux during isolated substorms, sawteeth, and SMC events,
  29. (1990). Auroral activity associated with unsteady magnetospheric erosion: Observations on
  30. (2003). Auroral boundary correlations between UVI and DMSP,
  31. (2007). Auroral conjugacy studies based on global imaging,
  32. (1966). Auroral electrojet index AE and its universal time variations,
  33. (1997). Basic Space Plasma Physics,
  34. (2000). Boundary-oriented electron precipitation model,
  35. (1987). Chaotization of the Electron Motion as the Cause of an Internal Magnetotail Instability and Substorm Onset,
  36. (1983). Characterization of Geostationary Particle Signatures Based on the Injection Boundary Model,
  37. (2005). Cluster observations of traveling compression regions in the near-tail,
  38. (1997). Cluster-science and mission overview,
  39. (2007). Comparative statistical analysis of storm time activations and sawtooth events,
  40. (1979). Comparison of Auroral Ovals from All-Sky Camera Studies and from Satellite Photographs,
  41. (2009). Contributions of the driven process and the loading-unloading process during substorms: A study based on the IMAGE-SI12 imager,
  42. (1997). Coordinated observations demonstrating external substorm triggering,
  43. (2004). Correction to “Predicting interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) propagation delay times using the minimum variance technique”,
  44. (1996). Current disruption in the Earth's magnetosphere: Observations and models,
  45. (2006). Dayside and nightside reconnection rates inferred from IMAGE FUV and Super Dual Auroral Radar Network data,
  46. (2000). Dayside convection and auroral morphology during an interval of northward interplanetary magnetic field,
  47. (1977). Dependence of Substorm Occurrence Probability on Interplanetary Magnetic-Field and on Size of Auroral Oval,
  48. (1991). Diagnosis of Auroral Dynamics Using Global Auroral Imaging with Emphasis on Large-Scale Evolution',
  49. (2004). Difference in magnetotail variations between intense and weak substorms,
  50. (1989). Digital Filters (3rd ed),
  51. (1967). Dynamics of auroral belt and polar geomagnetic disturbances,
  52. (1958). Dynamics of the interplanetary gas and magnetic fields,
  53. (2005). Electron acceleration in downward auroral field-aligned currents,
  54. (1975). Empirical Relationship between Interplanetary Conditions and Dst,
  55. (2000). Evaluation of low-latitude Pi2 pulsations as indicators of substorm onset using Polar ultraviolet imagery,
  56. (1998). Event study of deep energetic particle injections during substorm,
  57. (2005). Evolution of the dispersionless injection boundary associated with substorms,
  58. (1992). Excitation and Decay of Solar Wind-Driven Flows in the Magnetosphere-Ionosphere System,
  59. Far ultraviolet imaging from the IMAGE spacecraft. 1. System design,
  60. Far ultraviolet imaging from the IMAGE spacecraft. 2. Wideband FUV imaging,
  61. (1962). Flow of plasma around the earth,
  62. (2006). Flux closure during a substorm observed by Cluster, Double Star, IMAGE FUV, SuperDARN, and Greenland magnetometers,
  63. (1992). Geotail mission to explore Earth’s magnetotail,
  64. (2005). Global and local equatorward expansion of the ion auroral oval before substorm onsets,
  65. (2006). Global morphology of substorm growth phases observed by the IMAGE-SI12 imager,
  66. (1970). Growth phase of magnetospheric substorms,
  67. (1975). Heos 2 plasma observations in the distant polar magnetosphere: The plasma mantle,
  68. (1995). Hf Radar Signatures of the Cusp and Low-Latitude Boundary-Layer,
  69. (1997). HF-radar observations of the dayside magnetic merging rate: A Geospace Environment Modeling boundary layer campaign study,
  70. (1978). High-Resolution Energetic Particle Measurements at 6.6-Re .3. Low-Energy Electron Anisotropies and Short-Term Substorm Predictions,
  71. (2006). High-resolution global storm index: Dst versus SYM-H,
  72. (2000). How northward turnings of the IMF can lead to substorm expansion onsets,
  73. (2000). IMAGE mission overview,
  74. (1994). Imaging Results from Dynamics Explorer-1,
  75. (2008). Improved calculations of interplanetary magnetic field phase front angles and propagation time delays,
  76. (2001). Incoherent scatter radar identification of the dayside magnetic separatrix and measurement of magnetic reconnection,
  77. Influences on the radius of the auroral oval,
  78. (1961). Interplanetary Magnetic Field and the Auroral Zones,
  79. (2001). Interplanetary shock triggering of nightside geomagnetic activity: Substorms, pseudobreakups, and quiescent events,
  80. (1970). Inward Motion of Magnetopause before a Substorm,
  81. (1992). Ionospheric Convection and the Substorm Cycle, in:
  82. (1951). Kometschweife und solare Korpuskularstrahlung,
  83. (1978). Large-Scale Characteristics of Field-Aligned Currents Associated with Substorms,
  84. (1987). Latitudinal Motions of the Aurora during Substorms,
  85. (1995). Locating the Polar-Cap Boundary from Observations of 6300 Angstrom Auroral Emission,
  86. (1996). Lyman-Birge-Hopfeld bands in proton auroras,
  87. (2009). Magnetic flux in the magnetotail and polar cap during sawteeth, isolated substorms, and steady magnetospheric convection events,
  88. (2007). Magnetic flux transport in the Dungey cycle: A survey of dayside and nightside reconnection rates,
  89. (2001). Magnetosphere of Earth: Substorms, in Encyclopedia of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Edited by Paul Murdin, article 2351,
  90. (2002). Magnetospheric and auroral activity during the 18
  91. (2006). Magnetospheric current systems during stormtime sawtooth events,
  92. (2009). Magnetotail total pressure and lobe magnetic field at onsets of sawtooth events and their relation to the solar wind,
  93. (1995). Mapping of the Auroral Oval and Individual Arcs during Substorms,
  94. (1992). Mapping the Dayside Ionosphere to the Magnetosphere According to Particle-Precipitation Characteristics,
  95. (2001). Maps of ionospheric field-aligned currents as a function of the interplanetary magnetic field derived from Dynamics Explorer 2 data,
  96. (1996). Measurement of the magnetotail reconnection rate,
  97. (1999). Meridian-scanning photometer, coherent HF radar, and magnetometer observations of the cusp: a case study,
  98. (1977). Model for Thinning of Plasma Sheet,
  99. (2002). Modeling energetic particle injections in dynamic pulse fields with varying propagation speeds,
  100. (1996). Morphology of nightside precipitation,
  101. (2005). Motion of the dayside polar cap boundary during substorm cycles: I. Observations of pulses in the magnetopause reconnection rate,
  102. (1978). Multiple-satellite studies of magnetospheric substorms: Distinction between polar magnetic substorms and convection-driven negative bays.
  103. (1996). Near-Earth magnetotail shape and size as determined from the magnetopause flaring angle,
  104. (1996). Neutral line model of substorms: Past results and present view,
  105. (2007). Numerical Recipes: The art of scientific computing, 3rd ed.,
  106. (2007). Observational and modelling of the injection observed by
  107. (2005). Observational evidence of the loading-unloading substorm scheme,
  108. (2004). Observations of magnetospheric substorms occurring with no apparent solar wind IMF trigger,
  109. (2006). Observations of nightside magnetic reconnection during substorm growth and expansion phases,
  110. (1980). Observations of plasma injection,
  111. (2007). Observations of significant flux closure by dual lobe reconnection,
  112. (2003). Observations of the phases of the substorm,
  113. (2003). Occurrence frequencies of IMF triggered and nontriggered substorms,
  114. (2007). On the association between northward turnings of the interplanetary magnetic field and substorm onsets,
  115. (1967). On the extraterrestrial ring current during geomagnetic storms,
  116. (2004). On the relation between solar wind, pseudobreakups, and substorms,
  117. (1977). On the state of the magnetosphere during prolonged period of southward oriented IMF,
  118. (2009). On the triggering of auroral substorms by northward turnings of the interplanetary magnetic field,
  119. (2001). Particle injections with auroral expansions,
  120. (1969). Particle substorms observed at the geostationary orbit,
  121. (1971). Penetration of magnetosheath plasma to low altitudes through the dayside magnetospheric cusps,
  122. (2004). Physics of the Earth’s Space Enviroment,
  123. (1943). Physikalische Untersuchungen an Kometen I. Die Beziehungen der primären Schweifstrahls zum Radiusvektor,
  124. (1999). Pi2 pulsations and substorm onsets: A review,
  125. (1976). Plasma and magnetic field characteristics of the distant polar cusp near local noon: The entry layer,
  126. (1971). Plasma Clouds in
  127. (1984). Plasma sheet behaviour during substorms,
  128. (1999). Polar cap area and boundary motion during substorms,
  129. (1967). Polar magnetic disturbances and the interplanetary magnetic field,
  130. (1985). Polar rain: Solar coronal electrons in the Earth's magnetosphere,
  131. (1985). Polar-Cap Inflation and Deflation,
  132. (1972). Preconditions for Triggering of Polar Magnetic Substorms by Storm Sudden Commencements,
  133. (2003). Predicting interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) propagation delay times using the minimum variance technique,
  134. (1967). Preliminary Observations of a Geomagnetospheric Wake at 1000 Earth Radii,
  135. (1981). Propagating Substorm Injection Fronts,
  136. (2004). Quantitative magnetotail characteristics of different magnetospheric states,
  137. (1995). Quasi-periodic, substorm associated, global flux variations observed at geosynchronous orbit,
  138. (2007). Reasons why some solar wind changes do not trigger substorms,
  139. (1947). Reflecting microscopes,
  140. (2002). Relation of substorm breakup arc to other growth-phase auroral arcs,
  141. (1975). Relationship between Interplanetary Magnetic-Field and Isolated-Substorms,
  142. (2008). Remote sensing of the spatial and temporal structure of magnetopause and magnetotail reconnection from the ionosphere,
  143. (2008). Response of the Earth's magnetosphere to changes in the solar wind,
  144. (2004). Response of the magnetotail to changes in the open flux content of the magnetosphere,
  145. (1975). Roles of North-South Component of Interplanetary Magnetic-Field on Large-Scale Auroral Dynamics Observed by DMSP Satellite,
  146. (1968). Satellite Studies of Magnetospheric Substorms on
  147. (1999). Size of the auroral oval: UV ovals and precipitation boundaries compared,
  148. (2005). Solar wind control of the radial distance of the magnetic reconnection site in the magnetotail,
  149. (2005). Solar wind drivers for steady magnetospheric convection,
  150. (1998). Solar Wind Electron Proton Alpha Monitor (SWEPAM) for the Advanced Composition Explorer,
  151. (2005). Solar wind spatial scales in and comparisons of hourly Wind and ACE plasma and magnetic field data,
  152. (1986). Solar-Wind Triggering of Substorm Expansion Onset,
  153. (1986). Some Generalizations on the Method of Superposed Epoch Analysis,
  154. (2009). Spatial distribution of average vorticity in the high-latitude ionosphere and its variation with interplanetary magnetic field direction and season,
  155. (2003). Statistical behavior of proton and electron auroras during substorms,
  156. (2007). Statistical description of the bulge-type auroral substorm in the far ultraviolet,
  157. (1977). Statistical Study of Instantaneous Nightside Auroral Oval - Equatorward Boundary of Electron-Precipitation as Observed by Isis-1 and 2 Satellites,
  158. (2004). Statistical study of thin current sheet evolution around substorm onset,
  159. (1996). Steady magnetospheric convection: A review of recent results,
  160. (2002). Steady magnetospheric convection: Statistical signatures in the solar wind and AE,
  161. (1971). Storm Sudden Commencements and Polar Magnetic Substorms,
  162. (2002). storm-time sawtooth events using ground magnetic data,
  163. (1998). Structure and dynamics of magnetic reconnection for substorm onsets with Geotail observations,
  164. (1998). Structure of the low-latitude boundary layer: A case study with Geotail data,
  165. (1975). Substorm and Interplanetary Magnetic-Field Effects on Geomagnetic Tail Lobes,
  166. (1974). Substorm injection boundaries, in Magnetospheric Physics,
  167. (1997). Substorm ion injections: Geosynchronous observations and test particle orbits in three-dimensional dynamic MHD fields,
  168. (2004). Substorm onset observations by IMAGE-FUV,
  169. (1994). Substorm Time Constants,
  170. (1976). SubstormAssociated Particle Boundary Motion at Synchronous Orbit,
  171. (2001). Substorms associated with azimuthal turnings of the interplanetary magnetic field,
  172. (2002). SuperDARN E-region backscatter boundary in the dusk-midnight sector - tracer of equatorward boundary of the auroral oval,
  173. (1995). Swe, a Comprehensive Plasma Instrument for the Wind Spacecraft,
  174. (1972). Systematics in Auroral Energy Spectra,
  175. (1998). The ACE magnetic fields experiment,
  176. (1996). The appearance of plasmaspheric plasma in the outer magnetosphere in association with the substorm growth phase,
  177. (2006). The auroral and ionospheric flow signatures of dual lobe reconnection,
  178. (1985). The Auroral Luminosity Structure in the HighLatitude Upper-Atmosphere - its Dynamics and Relationship to the Large-Scale Structure of the Earths Magnetosphere,
  179. (1984). The Auroral Oval Position, Structure, and Intensity of Precipitation from
  180. (2001). The Cluster mission -
  181. (1971). The Comprehensive Plasma Instrumentation (Cpi) for the Geotail Spacecraft,
  182. (1972). The configuration of the magnetosphere. In:
  183. (1964). The Development of the auroral substorm,
  184. (1995). The Double Oval Uv Auroral Distribution .1. Implications for the Mapping of Auroral Arcs,
  185. (2005). The Double Star mission,
  186. (1990). The Energetic Ion Substorm Injection Boundary,
  187. (1994). The Geotail Magnetic-Field Experiment,
  188. (1962). The interaction between the solar wind and the earth's magnetosphere,
  189. (1965). The length of the magnetospheric tail,
  190. (2004). The location of the open-closed magnetic field line boundary in the dawn sector auroral ionosphere,
  191. (1990). The Magnetogram Inversion Technique and some Applications,
  192. (1976). The magnetospheric boundary layer: Site of plasma, momentum, and energy transfer from the magnetosheath into the magnetosphere,
  193. (1986). The May 2-3,
  194. (2000). The nightside poleward boundary of the auroral oval as seen by DMSP and the Ultraviolet Imager,
  195. (1902). The Norwegian Aurora Polaris Expedition,
  196. (1993). The Occurrence Rate of Magnetospheric-Substorm Onsets - Random and Periodic Substorms,
  197. (1980). The Physics of plasma injection events,
  198. (2001). The response of the HF radar spectral width boundary to a switch in the IMF B-y direction: Ionospheric consequences of transient dayside reconnection?,
  199. (1963). The structure of the exosphere or adventures in velocity space. In:
  200. (1985). The Temporal Evolution of a Small Auroral Substorm as Viewed from High-Altitudes with Dynamics Explorer-1,
  201. (1995). The Wind Magnetic-Field Investigation,
  202. (1981). Timing of Energetic Proton Enhancements Relative to Magnetospheric Substorm Activity and its Implication for Substorm Theories,
  203. (1966). Transition region magnetic field and polar magnetic disturbances,
  204. (1986). Triggering of Substorm Expansion by the Imf Directional Discontinuities - Time-Delay Analysis,
  205. (2002). Twodimensional structure of auroral poleward boundary intensifications,
  206. (2008). Typical auroral substorm: A bifurcated oval,
  207. (1973). Uniform Belt of Diffuse Auroral Emission seen by
  208. (2007). Unravelling the mechanisms responsible for radiation belt enhancements,
  209. (1995). Use of mid-latitude magnetic data for modelling and diagnostics of magnetospheric substorms,
  210. (1990). Variations in the polar cap area during intervals of substorm activity on
  211. (2003). Variations in the polar cap area during two substorm cycles,
  212. (2001). WIND nominal mission performance and extended mission design,
  213. (1989). with contributions from Heelis

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.