Location of Repository

Sports equity strategies and local football in England

By Jim Lusted

Abstract

This study traces the implementation of The English Football Association’s Ethics and Sports Equity Strategy (E&SES), which aims to tackle inequalities - including racism – in English football, but particularly in the often overlooked local, grass-roots form of the game. Case studies of five County Football Associations were undertaken to assess the implementation of the E&SES, involving 57 semi-structured interviews with local football stakeholders and participant observation at County FA and National FA offices. Following critical realist principles, the structural conditions of local football were outlined using historical documentary evidence, tracing the legacy of amateurist ideas of fairness and apoliticism, and identifying the exclusivity of ‘club cultures’ at County FAs. The influence of more recent policy developments that have politicised and professionalised the local game were then assessed.\ud Research found resistance to change among long-standing County FA Governance\ud personnel, attributed to components of amateurism including ‘paternalism’, ‘protectionism’ and ‘fairness’. Here, many saw the E&SES as being unfair itself and causing fresh problems, as it supported preferential treatment of some members over others. Such an intervention was therefore seen as unnecessary and unwarranted, so long-standing amateurist conditions were legitimised and reproduced by key actors. The ‘club cultures’ of County FAs were also informed by ideas of race, often derived from Victorian British colonialism; this, despite widespread denials from key personnel of any racism in the game. The notion of ‘colour-blind’ racism was used to explain this often contradictory process. This colour-blind sentiment made any use of ideas of race as a form of resistance to County FA policy or procedure necessarily problematic.\ud The structural conditions of local English football harbour complex processes of\ud racialised exclusion that require further interrogation. Utilising ‘whiteness’ to account for the racism here has merit, but risks missing some of the wider mechanisms behind exclusion; something a critical realist framework may be better placed to identify

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2009
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/7406

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2003). (2006b) Sports History: A Practical Guide Basingstoke: Palgrave Polley,
  2. (1969). A History of British Football.
  3. (2007). A Little Social Concern"’
  4. (1993). A person-centred approach to dealing with resistance to change.’
  5. (2001). A Sporting Future For All: The Government's Plan for Sport.
  6. (2007). A Wider Social Role for Sport: Who's Keeping the Score?
  7. (2001). Achieving Racial Equality: A Standard for Sport. London, Sporting Equals.
  8. (2006). Active People Survey 2005/6.
  9. (2004). Activity Report:
  10. (2000). Against Race: imagining political culture beyond the color line. Cambridge,
  11. (1999). Amateurism to Professionalism: Modelling
  12. (2001). An Epoch in the Annals of National Sport”: Football in Sheffield and the Creation of Modern Soccer and Rugby.’
  13. (1973). Annual Report.
  14. (2008). Annual Review of Football Finance: Highlights. Accessed th
  15. (1996). Asians Can't Play Football. Midland Asian Sports Forum.
  16. (1960). Association Football: Volume One.
  17. (1967). Beyond a Boundary. London, Serpent's Tail.
  18. (1999). Beyond the racist/hooligan couplet: race, social theory and football culture.’
  19. (2000). Biology, Ideology and Sport’
  20. (2006). Black and minority ethnic inclusion in Leicestershire and Rutland affiliated football clubs: A study of player, workforce and club development.
  21. (2001). Black pearl, black diamonds”: Exploring racial identities in rugby league’
  22. (1982). Black Sportsmen.
  23. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.
  24. (1994). Boys keep swinging: Masculinity and football culture in England’
  25. (2007). British Asians and Football.
  26. (2008). Calls intensify for action over abusive chants Accessed 10 th
  27. (1993). Campaigning for Equity.
  28. (1991). Can Play, Will Play? Women and Football in Britain’
  29. (2003). Case Study Research: Design and Methods.
  30. (1970). Caste Class and Race.
  31. (2005). Cautionary Notes on Whiteness and Sports Studies.
  32. (1979). Colonial Immigrants in a British City.
  33. (1986). Committee of Inquiry into Crowd Safety and Control at Sports Grounds: The Final Report. Home Office,
  34. (2001). Community Cohesion: A Report of the Independent Review Team.
  35. (1999). Corner Flags and Corner Shops.
  36. (2007). County Handbook.
  37. (2002). Critical Realism and Critical Philosophy.’
  38. (1997). Critical realism and realist research in human geography: a method or a philosophy in search of a method?’ Progress in Human Geography
  39. (1998). Critical Realism: Essential Readings.
  40. (1998). Dangerous Phrases”: Realism,
  41. (1999). Deinstitutionalising the Amateur Ethic: An Empirical Examination of Change in a Rugby Union Football
  42. (2001). Developing 'sport for all'? Addressing inequality in sport’
  43. (2008). Developing Sports Practice’
  44. (2005). Dimensions of Social Theory.
  45. (1993). Doing research, writing politics: the dilemmas of political intervention in research on racism "
  46. (2004). Driving up participation: The challenge for sport.
  47. (2002). Encyclopedia of British Football.
  48. (1991). English Football in the 1990's: Taking Hillsborough Seriously’
  49. (1970). Essays in Sociology: translated, edited by
  50. (1997). Essentialism, social constructionism, and beyond.’
  51. (2006). Explaining Society: Critical realism in the social sciences.
  52. (1973). Explanations in History’
  53. (2005). Exposing the invisible hand: The roots of laissez-faire's hidden influence.’
  54. (2005). FA Structural Review: Conclusions. London, The Football Association.
  55. (2002). Fair Play in Sport: A Moral Norm System.
  56. (1979). Fair Play: Ethics in Sport and Education.
  57. (1998). Fair play: historical anachronism or topical ideal?’
  58. (2004). Fairness For All: A New Commission for Equality and Human Rights White Paper.
  59. (2000). Figurational Sociology and its Application to Sport’
  60. (1990). Final Report. Home Office.
  61. (2004). Football and Fascism: The National Game under Mussolini.
  62. (2007). Football and social inclusion: Evaluating social policy’
  63. (1997). Football and the English: a social history of association football in England,
  64. (1981). Football and the Fascists.
  65. (2008). Football Association (2008) Birmingham County FA - About Us. Accessed on 16th
  66. (2000). Football in the Digital Age: Whose Game is it Anyway?
  67. (2006). From “Sport for All” to Not About 'Sport' at All? Interrogating Sport Policy Interventions in the United Kingdom.’
  68. (2000). From Legislation to Integration? Race Relations in Britain. Basingstoke,
  69. (1994). Games and Empires: Modern Sports and Cultural Imperialism Columbia,
  70. (2003). Gender equity policies in national governing bodies: An oxymoron or a vehicle for change?’
  71. (2005). Gentlemen, Barbarians and Players: A Sociological Study of the Development of Rugby Football.
  72. (2008). Goals Soccer Centres Plc
  73. (2003). Grounded Theory: Objectivist and Constructivist Methods’
  74. (1993). Historical Capitalism.
  75. (1953). History of the Football Association. London,
  76. (1970). Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play Element in Culture.
  77. (1989). Hooligans Abroad: The Behaviour and Control of English Fans in Continental Europe.
  78. (1990). In Other Words: Essays Towards a Reflexive Sociology. Stanford,
  79. (2004). Independent Football Commission
  80. (2005). Introduction: Muscular Christianity After 150
  81. (2004). Introduction: Race/Nation/Sport."
  82. (1999). Investing in the Community: A report by the Football Task Force.
  83. (2000). Leisure Experience and Identity: What Difference does Difference Make?’
  84. (2005). Leisure Theory: Principles and Practice Bsingskoke: Palgrave Rojek,
  85. (2007). Lessons from sports: children's socialization to values through family interaction during sports activities.’
  86. (1992). Lick My Boots: Racism and British Football. Leicester, Sir Norman Chester Centre for Football Research.
  87. (1995). Local authority leisure policies for Black and ethnic minority provision in Scotland’
  88. (2006). Local Club Secretary,
  89. (1990). Lord Justice Taylor
  90. (2004). Making Realism Work: Realist social theory and empirical research.
  91. (2006). Managing and Monitoring Equality and Diversity in UK Sport: An Evaluation of the Sporting Equals Racial Equality Standard and its Impact on Organizational Change.’
  92. (1984). Marxism versus the "Sociology of Race Relations"?’
  93. (1997). Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods in sports fan research’ The Qualitative
  94. (1998). Moving the Goalposts.
  95. (2001). Moving with the Ball: The Migration of Professional Football Players
  96. (1994). Muscular Christianity: Embodying the Victorian Age. Cambridge,
  97. (2006). My Father and other working class football heroes London,
  98. (1996). Myth and reality in the 1895 rugby split’
  99. (1992). New Ethnicities’
  100. (2006). New Labour, racism and 'new' football in
  101. (2006). No Ball Games Allowed? A Socio-Historical Examination of the Development and
  102. (2000). No racism here? A preliminary examination of sporting innocence.’
  103. (1991). North and South: The Rivalry of the Football League and the Football Association’
  104. (2004). Obstacle race? 'Race', racism and the recruitment of British Asian professional footballers.’
  105. (2004). On the moral economy of racism and racist rationalisations in sport.’ International Review for the Sociology of Sport
  106. (2004). One of the lads? Dual ethnicity and assimilated ethnicities in the careers of British Asian professional footballers.’
  107. (2001). Organizations in Society.
  108. (1995). Orientalism: Western Conceptions of the Orient.
  109. (2000). Part of the Game? An Examination of Racism in Grass Roots Football. London, Kick It Out.
  110. (2005). Personal correspondence with the author:
  111. (2001). Playing their own game: A South Asian football experience’
  112. (2002). Power Games: A Critical Sociology of Sport.
  113. (2003). Pressures on sports volunteers arising from partnerships with the central government.’
  114. (1999). Privatisation and the impact on voluntary associations: tensions between service provision and citizenship.’
  115. (1988). Programme for a sociology of sport
  116. (2005). Promoting racial equality within sports organisations.’
  117. (2006). Protect me from what I want’: Football fandom, celebrity cultures and ‘new’ football in England.
  118. (2002). Qualitative Analysis: Practice and Innovation.
  119. (1988). Quantity and Quality in Social Research.
  120. (2004). Race and cultural identity: playing the race game inside football.’
  121. (2008). Race and Sport: Critical Race Theory.
  122. (2005). Race Equality and Leisure Policy Discourses in
  123. (2008). Race equality and sport networks: Social capital links’
  124. (1983). Race Relations in Sociological Theory.
  125. (1997). Race relations, sociology of sport and the new politics of race and racism.’
  126. (2005). Race”, sport and leisure: lessons from critical race theory."
  127. (2003). Racial attitudes or racial ideology? An alternative paradigm for examining actors' racial views.’
  128. (2004). Racial Equality in Football: A Survey. London, Commission for Racial Equality.
  129. (1993). Racism after 'Race Relations'.
  130. (2001). Racism and Anti-Racism in Football.
  131. (1982). Racism and Migrant Labour.
  132. (1996). Racism and Society.
  133. (1996). Racism and Xenophobia in European Football.
  134. (2003). Racism without Racists: Color-Blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in the United States.
  135. (2007). Racism: A very short introduction Oxford,
  136. (2003). Raising the Standard - An Evaluation of Progress.
  137. (1998). Realism and Morphogenesis’
  138. (2000). Realism and Racism.
  139. (2002). Realism and Sociology: Anti-foundationalism, ontology and social research.
  140. (1995). Realist Social Theory: A Morphogenetic Approach. Cambridge,
  141. (2003). Reseach Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches.
  142. (2003). Researching 'Race' and Ethnicity.
  143. (2008). Revealed: Spurs songs for Sol Accessed 10 th
  144. (2006). Revenge of the Crouch End Vampires: The AFA, the FA and English Football’s ‘Great Split’,
  145. (1998). Selected issues in the Philosophy of social science’
  146. (2002). Shades of white: an examination of whiteness in sport.’
  147. (1998). Social Capital: Its Origins and Applications in
  148. (2000). Social Control and Sport.’
  149. (1994). Social Identity and Public Order’
  150. (1942). Social Insurance and Allied Services.
  151. (2001). Social Research Methods.
  152. (1999). Social Research: Issues, Methods and Process.
  153. (2004). Spain coach in mire over Henry jibe. Accessed 1st August,
  154. (1990). Sport and British Politics since 1960. London,
  155. (1994). Sport and Leisure in Social Thought.
  156. (2005). Sport and Organizational Studies: Exploring Synergy.’
  157. (2008). Sport and Social Capital.
  158. (1991). Sport and Social Class.’
  159. (1989). Sport and the British.
  160. (1994). Sport and the maintenance of masculine hegemony’
  161. (1993). Sport and the Making of Britain.
  162. (2002). Sport England's Equity Policy.
  163. (1989). Sport in Britain: A Social History. Cambridge,
  164. (1991). Sport in the Nineties: New Horizons.
  165. (1999). Sport Matters: Sociological Studies of Sport, Violence and Civilization.
  166. (2006). Sport, Culture and Society.
  167. (1996). Sport, Identity and Ethnicity
  168. (1998). Sport, masculinity and black cultural resistance.’
  169. (1991). Sport, Racism and Ethnicity.
  170. (1991). Sport, Time and Society - the British at Play.
  171. Sporting Equals (2004) Promoting Racial Equality Through Sport. London, Sporting Equals.
  172. (1991). Sports Equity: A New Concept?’ Sport and Leisure Scotland Conference.
  173. (2003). Sports Volunteering in
  174. (2008). Spurs fans racist for booing Sol Campbell? They are if you believe the newspapers.
  175. (2008). Structural Characteristics of Sports Organizations: Main Trends in the Academic Discussion.’
  176. (2000). Taboo: Why Black athletes dominate sport and why we are frightened to talk about it.
  177. (2006). Tension at FA over Burns review.’
  178. (2006). The Amateur Ideal and British Sports Diplomacy,
  179. (2008). The Amateur Ideal and British Sports Diplomacy, 1900-1945’
  180. (2008). The association game: a history of British football.
  181. (2004). The Beautiful Game? Searching for the Soul of Football.
  182. (1993). The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness.
  183. (1994). The Brighton Declaration on Women and Sport.
  184. (1985). The Bureaucratization of a Voluntary Sport Organisation.’ International Review for the Sociology of Sport
  185. (2001). The Changing Face of Football.
  186. (1978). The Civilizing Process.
  187. (1984). The Constitution of Society : outline of the theory of structuration. Cambridge,
  188. (1994). The Cultural Bond: Sport,
  189. (2004). The Dick, Kerr’s Ladies: The Factory Girls who took on the World.
  190. (1999). The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research.
  191. (1992). The end of antiracism’
  192. (1995). The ethos of games’
  193. (1998). The first Black footballer, Arthur Wharton, 1865-1930: an absence of memory.
  194. (2000). The Football Association
  195. (2002). The Football Association (2002) Membership Profile: Results of Monitoring Survey
  196. The Football Association (2004a) Ethics and Sports Equity Strategy. London, The FA.
  197. The Football Association (2004b) Football For All.
  198. (2004). The Football Association (2004c) Football Trends Report
  199. (2004). The Football Association's Child Protection in Football Research Project 2002-2006: Rationale, design and first year results.
  200. (2004). The Football Foundation
  201. (1984). The football world: a contemporary social history.
  202. (1998). The Good Research Guide.
  203. (1991). The Government and Politics of Sport.
  204. (2008). The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail: myths of scientific racism and the pursuit of excellence in sport.’
  205. (1985). The impact of Sport for All policy 1966-1984 and a way forward.
  206. (1983). The Invention of Tradition Cambridge,
  207. (2008). The Janus-faced sport”: English football, community and the legacy of the 'third way'.’
  208. (2006). The Leicester School and the
  209. (1979). The Making of a Working-Class Football Culture in Victorian England."
  210. (2001). The New Nature of History: Knowledge,
  211. (1991). The New Racism. London, Junction Books.
  212. (2002). The Open Society and its Enemies.
  213. (1994). The People's Game: The History of Football Revisited.
  214. (2003). The politics of ‘race’ and sport policy’
  215. (2001). The Politics of Leisure Policy.
  216. (1986). The Politics of Sport.
  217. (2002). The Politics of Sports Development.
  218. (2005). The Potential of Path Dependence in
  219. (2004). The Power of Identity.
  220. (1986). The Quest for Excitement: Sport and Leisure in the Civilising Process.
  221. (1988). The Roots of Football Hooliganism.
  222. (1938). The Rules of Sociological Method.
  223. (2002). The social conscience of the early Victorians. Stanford,
  224. (1991). The sociology of football: a research agenda for the 1990s.’ Sociological Review
  225. (1999). The Steven Lawrence Inquiry: Report of an Inquiry by Sir William Macpherson of Cluny.
  226. (2000). The Third Way and its Critics. Cambridge,
  227. (2006). The Uses of Whiteness: What sociologists working on Europe can draw from US research on whiteness.’
  228. (2004). The Victorians and Sport.
  229. (2002). The world at their feet” Professional football and International Labour Migration.’
  230. (1987). There Ain't No Black in the Union Jack’: The cultural politics of race and nation.
  231. (1999). Thinking the unthinkable or playing the game? The Football Task Force, New Labour and the reform of English football’
  232. (2007). Towards a Critical Theory of
  233. (1993). Two Traditions.’
  234. (1991). Understanding Everyday Racism: an Interdisciplinary Theory.
  235. (2005). Understanding Participation in Sport: A Systematic Review.
  236. (1994). Understanding Social Theory.
  237. (1997). Understanding Sport Organisations.
  238. (1998). What Moral Significance has Physical Education? A Question in Need of Disambiguation.’
  239. (2005). What's the Big Idea? A Critical Exploration of the Concept of Social CapitaLand its Incorporation into Leisure Policy Discourse.’
  240. (2001). White Supremacy and Racism in the Post Civil Rights Era.
  241. (1993). White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness.
  242. (2001). Whose Game is it Anyway? Racism in Local League Cricket.’
  243. (1996). Women on the Ball.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.