Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

'Can there be cultural competence without culture?' : psychologists' discourse on working with minorities

By Saima Masud


The literature review in this thesis is an exploration of the recent emphasis in policy on\ud the equality of mental health services for minority ethnic clients, with a focus on cultural\ud competence models in clinical psychology. The review is based on a textual analysis of a\ud policy document to consider whether cultural competence is a promotion or restriction of\ud equality. The policy and models of cultural competence were found to employ\ud essentialist definitions that could be an issue in developing appropriate and relevant\ud services. It is argued that a context-specific and flexible interpretation of culture is\ud required.\ud The empirical research examines clinical psychological discourses about working with\ud minority ethnic clients. It discusses an interview study and a group discussion study\ud conducted among clinical psychologists. Drawing on discourse analysis this research\ud examines the interpretative repertoires and discursive strategies that psychologists use in\ud their accounts of working with minority ethnic clients, and how these construct a\ud particular version of cultural competence. In the interviews, an interpretative framework\ud in terms of 'social context' involved a consideration of the client's cultural background,\ud and an interpretative framework of 'individual context' was considered to be a way of\ud formulating the client's own interpretation of cultural background. In the group\ud discussion, the key interpretative framework was the 'individual/curious' repertoire,\ud which also focused on understanding cultural background from the client's interpretation.\ud It is shown that in using these repertoires the psychologists' construction of cultural\ud competence oscillates between a risk of reifying minority ethnic groups and a risk of\ud neglecting issues such as ethnic discrimination.\ud Based upon the literature and empirical parts, the reflective part of this thesis considers\ud the researchers orientation to the research, in terms of epistemology, and as a minority\ud ethnic researcher conducting research on the subject of minorities

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2007
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1996). 7he mismeasure ofman (revised and expanded).
  2. A (2001). Progress in ethnic and racial studies.
  3. (1997). A cognitive theory ofcultural meaning.
  4. (1987). A discourse-centred approach to language and culture. American pragmatics.
  5. (1999). A history ofmodern psychology.
  6. (1979). Ae myth ofreturn: Pakistani's in Britain.
  7. (2000). Against methodolatory: some comments on Elliott, Fischer and Rennie.
  8. (1990). Against the grain.
  9. (2002). Age, gender and ethnicity of those detained under Part 11 of the Mental Health Act
  10. (2003). An ethics code for academics.
  11. (2003). An exploration ofcultural exclusion and cultural identity among British Pakistani Christians. Unpublished master's thesis,
  12. (2006). An introduction to qualitative research (3
  13. (1999). An introduction to social construction.
  14. (1948). An outline ofsocialpsycholoff.
  15. (2003). Analysing discourse: textual analysisfor social research.
  16. (1997). Analysing documentary realities. In
  17. (1987). Anthropology and psychiatry: the role of culture in cross-cultural
  18. (2002). Asian men and mental health assessment. London: Confederation of Indian Organisations.
  19. (1999). at's wrong with social constructionism.
  20. (1997). Background and discourse analysis. A response to Jan Blommaert.
  21. (2002). Beyond feminism and multiculturalism: locating difference and the politics of location.
  22. (1998). Beyond racism and multicultural ism.
  23. (1995). Black people and secure psychiatric facilities.
  24. (2003). Blackfamilies in therapy. understanding the AMcan American experience (2d edn).
  25. (2004). Blind slaves of our prejudices: debating 'culture' and 'race' in Norway.
  26. (2002). Breaking the cycles offear: a review of the relationship between mental health services and African and Caribbean communities.
  27. (2005). Bringing psychology to all societies.
  28. (2006). Britain's shame: the journey from multiculturalism to naturism. Catalyst Magazine,
  29. (2001). Casebookfor integratingfamily lherqpy. ý an ecosystemic approach.
  30. (1991). Categories are for talking: on the cognitive and discursive bases of categorization. 7heory and Psychology,
  31. (1987). Category cohesiveness, theories and cognitive archaeology. In
  32. (1997). Charting the spaces of (un)location: on theorising diaspora. In
  33. (2006). Chilly Britannia: a new variety of British nationalism.
  34. (2000). Clinical Pjychology, race and culture: a training manual.
  35. (1980). Clinical psychology and minority problems.
  36. (2000). Clinical psychology, race and culture: a training manual. Leicester:
  37. (2003). Clinical psychology: reinforcing inequalities or facilitating empowennent?
  38. (2003). Clinical psychology: reinforcing inequalities or facilitating empowerment?
  39. (1984). Clinical treatment of the non-disclosing black client.
  40. (1995). Co-construction: an introduction.
  41. (1987). Cognitive models and prototype theory.
  42. (1992). Community mental health services for black and ethnic minorities.
  43. (1992). CommunitypsycholoSy. theory andpractice.
  44. (1989). Concepts and conceptual structure.
  45. (1989). Concepts, kinds and cognitive development Cambridge,
  46. (1987). Conceptual development and category construction. In
  47. (1992). Connecting 'race' and ethnic phenomena.
  48. (1992). Connecting race and ethnic phenomena.
  49. (2004). Contextualising experiences of depression in women from South Asia communities: a discursive approach. SocioloSy ofHealth and 171ness,
  50. (2005). Conversation analysis and discourse analysis: a comparative and critical introduction.
  51. (1998). Conversation analysis.
  52. (1994). Core domains versus scientific theories: evidence from systematics and Itza-Maya folk-biology. In
  53. (1996). Counselling, class andpolitics: undeclared influences in therapy.
  54. (1995). Critical discourse analysis: the critical study of language.
  55. (1997). Critical discourse analysis.
  56. (1998). Cultural aspects of understanding people with schizophrenic disorders. In
  57. (1994). Cultural sensitivity in family therapy gone ary.
  58. (2002). Cultural sensitivity: a vital examination. New Ideas in PsycholoV,
  59. (1998). Cultural variation in the stigmatisation of mental illness. The Lancet,
  60. (1993). Culture, ethnicity and mental illness.
  61. (1994). Culture, personality and psychopathology.
  62. (1998). Data management and analysis methods. In
  63. (2005). Daughters of tradition:
  64. (2003). Decoding the ethics code: a practical guideforpsychologists. Thousand Oaks,
  65. (1996). Democracy and difference: contesting the houndaries ofthe polificaL
  66. (1994). Development of the multicultural counseling inventory: a self report measure of multicultural competences.
  67. (2005). Dilemmas of gender and culture: thejudgement, the democrat and the political activist. In
  68. (2003). Discipline andpunish: the birth of1heprison. London:
  69. (1994). Discourse analysis in an occupational context. In
  70. (2007). Discourse analysis in France. A conversation.
  71. (2001). Discourse analysis: dialogue on language and identity.
  72. (2002). Discourse analysis: investigalingprocesses ofsocial construction.
  73. (2002). Discourse analysis: investigatingprocesses ofsocial construction.
  74. (2001). Discourse and discrimination: rhetorics of racism and anti-Semitism.
  75. (1992). Discourse and social change.
  76. (1987). Discourse and social psycholqgy.
  77. (1992). Discourse dynamics.
  78. (2003). Discrimination and legislation.
  79. (1992). Discursive psycholpSy.
  80. (2006). Do therapists address ethnic and racial differences in cross-cultural psychotherapy?
  81. (2007). Documentary data: single, medium, multiple modes?
  82. (1994). Essentialist beliefs in children: the acquisition of concepts and theories. In
  83. (2003). Ethics in a multicultural context. Thousand Oaks,
  84. (1989). Ethnic differences in consultation rates in urban general practice.
  85. (1989). Ethnic differences in general practitioner consultations.
  86. (1997). Ethnic differences in satisfaction with mental health services among representive, people with psychosis in South London: Prism study 4.
  87. (2004). Ethnic disparities in health and healthcare: afocused review of the evidence and selected examples ofgood practice. London: Health Observatory.
  88. (1992). Ethnic identity: challenging the boundaries of social psychology.
  89. (1986). Ethnic minorities and the Mental Health Act: patterns of explanation.
  90. (1986). Ethnic minorities and the Mental Health Act: patterns of explanation. AWchiatric
  91. (2002). Ethnic minority psychiatric illness rates in the Community (EMPIRIC). London: the Stationary Office.
  92. (2003). Ethnic variations in pathways to and use of specialist mental health services in the UK: systematic review.
  93. (2003). Ethnic variations in pathways to specialist mental health services in the United Kingdom: a systematic review.
  94. (2004). Ethnicity as cognition. Theory
  95. (1997). Ethnicity, equity and the best use of health services in the British NHS.
  96. (1989). Ethnocultural issues in the assessment of psychopathology. In
  97. (1995). Ethnography andprinciples in practice (2
  98. (1992). Executive Mental Health Task Force
  99. (2003). Failures of imagination: the refugee's narrative in psychiatry.
  100. (2005). Fear will only fuel the riots. The Guardian,
  101. (2004). Fear, black people and mental illness: a vicious circle.
  102. (1998). Feminism and multicultumlism: some tensions.
  103. (1998). Feminism and multicultural ism: some tensions.
  104. (2001). Feminism, multicultural ism, oppression, and the state.
  105. (1992). ff'hat's wrong with ethnography: methodological explorations.
  106. (1981). Footing. In
  107. (1998). Forensicpsychialry, race and culture.
  108. (2002). From naturally occurring data to naturally organised ordinary activities: comment on Speer.
  109. (2006). Heterosexism, racism and psychology.
  110. (2005). Inaugural meeting: psychology and human rights conference,
  111. (1990). Inessential woman: prohlems ofexclusion infeminist thought.
  112. (2005). Interview Tariq Ramadan: dreams of a patchwork philosopher. Ae Guardian,
  113. (2001). Introducing qualitative research inpsychology. adventures in theory andpraclice. Berkshire:
  114. (1992). Introduction. In
  115. (1999). Is multiculturalism bad for women? In
  116. (1989). Language, power and ideology.
  117. (1990). List construction as a task and resource.
  118. (1993). Mental Health and Britain's black communities. London: King's Fund.
  119. (2001). Mental health services for "diff icult" women. Feminist Review,
  120. (1993). Mental health. In
  121. (1980). Mental illness in the community: thepathway to psychiatric care.
  122. (1995). Michel Foucault. The Psychologist,
  123. (2002). Minority ethnic issues in social exclusion and neighbourhood renewal. London: Cabinet Office.
  124. (2002). Mistresses of their own destiny: group rights, gender and realistic rights of exit.
  125. (1995). Multicultural citizenship: a liberal theory ofminority rights.
  126. (2007). Multicultural ism absent from tomorrow's cohesion report.
  127. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry.
  128. (1954). ne nature ofprejudice.
  129. (2000). Negotiating identities across cultural boundaries: complicating cultural competence with power and privilege.
  130. (2000). Objectivity and reliability in qualitative analysis: realist, contextualist and radical constructionist epistemologies.
  131. (1990). On seeking and rejecting: validity in qualitative research.
  132. (1984). Openingpandora's box: a sociological analysis of scienlists'discourse. Cambridge:
  133. (1984). Openingpandora's box: a sociological analysis of scientists'discourse. Cambridge:
  134. (1998). Patient satisfaction: ethnic origin or explanatory model?
  135. (1980). Patients and healers in the context ofculture.
  136. (1997). Perceived ethnicity and risk of compulsory detention. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology,
  137. (2003). Perils of race and culture for clinical psychology trainees: the missionary position in the 21" Century. Clinical Psychology, 28,29-32. Horton-Salway, A (200 1). The construction of MR: the discursive action model. In
  138. (1995). Person-centred therapy today. newfrontiers in theory andpractice.
  139. (1986). Pluralism, race and ethnicity in selected African countries. In
  140. (1980). PowerlKnowledge: selected interviews and other writings,
  141. (1999). Prevalence of anxiety and depressive illness and help seeking behaviour in African Caribbeans and White Europeans: Two phase general population survey.
  142. (2004). Prison discourse: language as a means ofcontrol and resistance.
  143. (2000). Problematizing transcription: purpose, paradigm and quality.
  144. (2004). Professional ethics across national boundaries.
  145. (1994). Psyche-spirit as well as mind?
  146. (1992). Psychiatric diagnosis and racial bias: empirical and interpretative approaches.
  147. (1989). Psychological essentialism. In
  148. (1996). Psychology as an ethical discipline and profession.
  149. (2000). Psychology beyond Western perspectives. Leicester:
  150. (1991). Psychosis in migrants from the Indian subcontinent and English controls.
  151. (1999). Public conceptions of mental illness: labels, causes, dangerousness, and social distance.
  152. (1992). Qualitative research and psychological theorising.
  153. (1997). Race ", racism andpsychology. - towards a reflexive history.
  154. (1990). Race and class revisited: conceptualising race and racisms.
  155. (2000). Race Relations Amendment Act
  156. (2006). Race relations chief warns ... about the difficulties of www.
  157. (1996). Race, culture and counselling.
  158. (1982). Race, culture and mental disorder.
  159. (1989). Race, culture and psychotherapy. Psychiatric Bulletin,
  160. (1995). Racial and ethnic variations in helpseeking attitudes. In
  161. (1992). Racialised boundaries: race, nation, gender, colour and class and the anti-racist struggle.
  162. (1992). Racialized boundaries: race, nation, gender, colour and Class and the anti-racist struggle.
  163. (1990). Racism: territoriality and ethnocentricity. In
  164. (2000). Reaching out injamily therapy: home-based school and community interventions.
  165. (1996). Recognition of psychological problems in primary care: differences between ethnic groups.
  166. (2000). Reflexive methodology. new vistasfor qualitative research.
  167. (2003). Reflexivity and the doubles of modem man: the discursive construction of anthropological subject positions. In
  168. (1992). Refusing holy orders: women and fundamentalism in Britain. London:
  169. Research, 8(2). Retrieved May 5,2007, from http: //%vmv.
  170. (1998). Researching society and culture.
  171. (2002). Rethinking individualism and collectivism.
  172. (2000). Rethinking multiculturalism: cultural diversity andpolitical theory.
  173. (2003). Sanjhe rang/shared colours, shared lives: a multicultural approach to mental health practice. Joumal ofSocial Work Practice,
  174. (2005). Secure borders and safe haven and the gendered politics of belonging: beyond social cohesion.
  175. (2005). Secure borders and safe haven and the gendered politics of belonging: beyond social cohesion. Ethnic and Racial Sludies,
  176. (1998). Selfand identity in modern psychology and Indian thought.
  177. (1982). Should there be an academic code of ethics?
  178. (1997). Similarity and difference in multicultural counseling: considering the attraction and repulsion hypothesis. The Counseling Psychologist,
  179. (1992). Sornatisation of Asians: an artefact of medicalization? Transcultural psychiatric Research Review,
  180. (1982). Steppin' out of Babylon: race, class and autonomy.
  181. (1997). Stereotypes as explanations: a subjective Edwards,
  182. (1996). Stigma, depression and sornatisation in South India.
  183. (2005). Structural violence and schizophrenia.
  184. (1978). Studies in the organisation ofconversational interaction.
  185. (1988). Technologies of the self In
  186. (2004). Text, context, pretext: critical issues in discourse analysis.
  187. (1983). The causes of disease: women talking.
  188. (1995). The essential element of culturally sensitive psychiatric services.
  189. (1999). The first contact of patients with schizophrenia with psychiatric services: social factors and pathways to care in a multi-ethnic population. hychological
  190. (1996). The genesis of racist discourse in Austria since 1989. In
  191. (2003). The liberal archipelago: a theory oftliversity andfteedom.
  192. (1990). The mental health of Asians in Britain: little disease or underreporting?
  193. (1999). The multi-layered citizen: citizenship in the age of 'glocalization'.
  194. (1994). The multicultural perspective in therapy: a social constructionist approach.
  195. (1994). The naturalness of religious ideas: a cognitive theory of religion. Berkeley:
  196. (1992). The poison of racism and the self poisoning of adolescents.
  197. (2001). The primacy of the ingroup: the interplay of entativity and identification.
  198. (1992). The question of cultural identity.
  199. (2003). The right of refugee clients to an appropriate and ethical psychology service. Ylze Intemational Joumal ofHuman Rights,
  200. (2006). The rights approach: the future of equality law in Britain. Catalyst Magazine,
  201. (2006). The time is right for a fundamental review: complexity and cohesion. Public Magazine,
  202. (1986). Theories ofdiscourse: an introduction.
  203. (1995). Thepolitics ofpresence.
  204. (1989). Understanding race, ethnicity andpower. - the key to efficacy in clinical practice.
  205. (2001). Understanding the excess of psychosis among the Affican-Caribbean population in England.
  206. (1996). US academics and third world women: is ethical research possible. In
  207. (1999). Using Foucault's methods.
  208. (1994). What comes a ust) after "post"? The case of ethnography. In
  209. (1992). what's wrong with ethnography. methodological explorations.
  210. (1996). White counselor self-awareness: a prerequisite for developing multicultural competence for change.
  211. (1983). Whites' opposition to busing: symbolic racism or realistic group conflict?
  212. (1992). Why humans have cultures.
  213. (2001). Women and mental health: a feminist review. Feminism andPsycholoD,,
  214. (1984). Women and the psychiatric paradox. Milton Keynes:
  215. (2000). Yhe cultural analysis oftexts.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.