Location of Repository

Images of the Military Orders, 1128-1291: Spiritual, Secular, Romantic

By Helen Jane Nicholson

Abstract

The intention of this study is to examine attitudes towards the military orders, in particular the international orders of the Temple, the Hospital and the Teutonic order, between papal recognition of the order of the Temple in 1128, and the final destruction of the kingdom of Jerusalem in 1291, both in the light of recent studies of attitudes towards crusading, and seeking to illuminate the circumstances behind the trial and destruction of the order of the Temple in the early fourteenth century.\ud The study examines the opinions held of the military orders in different sections of society, the rulers of Catholic Christendom, the clergy and the laity. It also discusses the fictional image woven around the orders by chroniclers and the writers of epics and romances; the former adapting traditional topoi, the latter drawing on reality. Finally, there is an examination of the measures taken by the orders to form and improve their image in the eyes of Christendom.\ud Much of the criticism of the military orders was directed at them as regular orders, but they received less criticism than other groups within the Church. In the second half of the thirteenth century the orders' relative unpopularity decreased, as the friars' privileges began to attract criticism, and as European interest in the Holy Land waned. They retained a good reputation as knights of Christ, even after the loss of Acre.\ud Although all of the military orders attracted praise and criticism, the main attention of chroniclers and storytellers was on the order of the Temple, which was seen to epitomize the concept of the military order. It claimed to be, and was widely recognized as, above all others responsible for the defence of the Holy Land; hence it was more vulnerable to criticism than the other military orders

Topics: History, Philosophy, Religion
Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 1989
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4725

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1905). 1 (Holm, 1829) Diplomatic Documents preserved in the Public Record Office,
  2. 1--3-1-John of Wiirzburg PL 155 col. 1087. JL32 Amargier, "La d6fense du Temple, ' pp-495-500. Appendix I. 3-37 Prawer, '-Military orders, "
  3. 1873) Perlesvaus: le Haut livre du Graal, doi
  4. (1968). 1893,1904) Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum, doi
  5. (1900). 1899) Osney Annals,
  6. 2149; the emperor Frederick II in Matthew Paris, Chronica Majora, 4 p-302; Robert of Artois
  7. 216; Registrum Johannis de Pontissara, episcopi Wyntoniensis
  8. (1914). 3rd series 25 (London, doi
  9. (1933). 4 vols. in 7 parts (Record Commission, London, 1816-69) Fontes Egmundenses,
  10. (1965). 41 vols. (Berlin, 1838-69) "De Constructione castri Saphet,
  11. 5 vols. doi
  12. 999; Hamilton, Latin Church, p. 240; Riley-Smith, Knights of St.
  13. 9Magistri Thadei Neapolitani, Historia de desolacione et conculcacione civitatis Acconensis et tociue te=e sancte,
  14. (1913). ab anno 1198 usque ad annum 1431 perducta (Munster, 1898, second edition
  15. Ambroise, lines 3021-33; Prutz, 'Gedicht auf die Belagerung Accons, % lines 767-786,1125-8-Philip Mousket, "Historia Regum Francorum,
  16. (1963). Anglo-Norman Literature and its background, doi
  17. (1965). Annali Genovesi di Caffaro e de**suoi continuatori dal MXCIX
  18. BEC 5,6eme s6rie (1869) 245-97,461-531,649-87 "Descente de Saint Paul en enfer, *'
  19. (1984). Between Mount Moriah and the Holy Sepulchre: the changing traditions of the Temple Mount in the Central Middle Ages, '
  20. (1913). Bibliotheca Bio-Bibliographia Della Terra Sancta e dell"oriente francescano., 2 (Quarrachi,
  21. (1932). Bibliotheque de 1"6cole des Hautes-Etudes (Paris,
  22. (1909). Chibnall (London and Edinburgh,
  23. (1977). Choix des po6sies originales des troubadours, 4 Bertrand de Bar-sur-Aube, Girart de Vienne,
  24. (1978). Chrestien de Troyes, Cliges,
  25. Chroniquel'* trans. Jean du Vignay,
  26. (1962). Collection de textes pour servir a 1"6tude et a 1'enseignement de 1"histoire, 2 vols. (Paris, 1886-1893) Guigues, abbot of La Grande Chartreuse, letter to the order of Temple,
  27. Collection des documents in6dits sur 1'histoire de France,
  28. (1968). Deutsches Heldenbuch 3-4 (reprinted Dublin/Zurich,
  29. (1951). Die Literatur des Deutschen Ritterordens (Giessen,
  30. (1951). Die Literatur des Deutschen Ritterordens, (Giessen,
  31. (1932). El-Kamel Altevarylch, " in RHC Or 1 Ibn al-Qalanisi, 'Chronicle, " extr. and trans. in The Damascus chronicle of the Crusades,
  32. (1926). Foedera, conventiones, litterae et cuiuscumque generis acta publica inter reges Angliae et alios quosvis imperatores, reges, pontifices, principes vel communitates,
  33. Forey, "A thirteenth century disputation, " 182-5,186;
  34. (1966). Forschungen zur Deutschen Geschichte, 21 (1881) 449-494 Secondary sources Acta Sanctorum,
  35. (1975). Friedwagner (reprinted Geneva,
  36. g.,, Teutonic order: Codex Diplomaticus et Epistolaris regni Bohemiae, doi
  37. (1985). Gerald of Wales, Opera,
  38. (1900). Hakluyt Society, 2nd series 4
  39. Hardy (London, 1835) Rotuli Parliamentorum: ut et petitiones et placita in Parliamento, 6 vols.
  40. (1932). Hebraeus: The chronography of Gregoxy AbLl"l-Faraj (1225-1286) the son of Aaron, the Hebrew Physician, commonly known as Bar Hebraeus, being the first part of his history of the world,
  41. (1908). Hierarchia Catholica medii aevi, 2nd edition (Munster,
  42. (1975). I and the order of Grandmont, " doi
  43. (1903). If they were criticized alongside
  44. (1961). itinerarium Peregrinorum et gesta Regis Ricardi, doi
  45. IXr 331-340 St. Antony of Padua, Sermones Dominicales et in Solemnitatibus,
  46. (1924). Jean de Joinville: La vie de Saint Louis: le t6moignage de jehan, seigneur de LToinville. Texte du XIVe si'cle,
  47. (1910). John of Pontoise: Registrum Johannis de Pontissara, episcopi Wyntoniensis
  48. (1980). La chanson d*Antioche - Etude Critique (Paris,
  49. (1925). La colere et la douleur d*un templier en Terre Sainte, *' Revue des langues romanes, 81 (1974) 333-Richard Gravesend: Rotuli Ricardi Gravesend diocesis Lincolniensis,
  50. (1982). La continuation de Guillaume de Tyr, de 1228 a 1261, dit du manuscrit de Rothelin, "
  51. Lancashire and Cheshire Record Society, 14 (1886) "Annales Colmarienses
  52. (1985). Le -roman de Tristan doi
  53. (1935). le comte Beugnot, 4 vols. (Paris, 1839-48) Orderic Vitalis, The Ecclesiastical History,
  54. (1938). Le siege de Barbastre, doi
  55. (1974). Les Chansons de croisade (Paris, 1909, reprinted Geneva,
  56. (1967). Liber registorum sive epistolarum, - 3 vols., PL 214-216 ('Registers') - Die Register Innocenz'
  57. (1987). Nigellus de Longchamp dit Wireker (Paris,
  58. no. 135; RRH 1492,1501; Cart., nos. 1682,, 1861. 12 "Rymer*s Foedera., 1,1 pp-333f 334. '*Chronicon Hanoniense quod dicitur Balduini Avennensis, '
  59. (1976). Notice sur le manuscrit Fr 24862' 147-151 Theodoric, Libellus de Locis Sanctis,
  60. (1915). Nt der UniversitNt Freiburg in der Schweiz (Bamberg,
  61. (1948). Odo, bishop of Tusculanum, letter to Innocent IV,
  62. of Anjou, king of Naples and Sicily, but in fact Charles' influence had probably been decisive in securing William's election: William had been master of the order in Sicily and Calabria before his election, and was a convenient -3E. g..,
  63. (1981). Oliver Scholasticus, regum Terrae Sanctae, ' and *'Historia Damiatina, "
  64. (1938). On the testament of Sir Hugh de Neville, written at Acre, 1267" doi
  65. (1964). Pertz et al., 32 vols. (Hanover, 1826-1934) Monumenta ordinis Fratrum Praedicatorum Historica, 3: Acta capitulorum Generalium,
  66. (1967). Philip Mousket, "Historia Regum Francorum, '
  67. (1980). Quinti Belli Sacri Scriptores Minoresf
  68. (1977). Recueil des Actes de Henri II, roi d*Angleterre et Duc de Normandie,, concernant les provinces frangaises et les affaires de France,
  69. (1981). Reform and authority in the medieval and reformation doi
  70. (1971). Reginald of Durham, Libellus de Vita et Miraculis S. Godrici, Heremitae de Finchale,
  71. (1941). reprinted
  72. (1989). Rerum Italicarum Scriptores: Raccolta degli storici Italiani dal cinquecento ad millcinquecento,
  73. (1913). Robert of Torigny, Chronicle, in Chronicles of the Reigns of Stephen, Henry II and Richard 1,4 Roger Bacon, opus Maius,
  74. RS 28,2 (London, 1865) William of Rubruck: The Journey of William of Rubruck to the Eastern parts of the world, as narrated by himself, trans.
  75. (1981). Sacrorum conciliorum nova et amplissima collectio,
  76. (1909). The Cartulary of the Knights of St. John of Jerusalem in England, Secunda Camera. doi
  77. the description of the donations given to the order 1128-9 in Barber, "The origins of the order of the Temple,
  78. (1980). The election of other brothers may have been due to the 152 Hugh: Registres dInnocent IV, nos. 6350,6490;
  79. (1960). The Lacy family in England and Normandy, 1066-1194 (oxford, doi
  80. (1863). The Letters of Gilbert Foliot, doi
  81. (1970). The origins of the order of the Temple, '
  82. (1975). The West and the Crusade, " p. 82; William de Nangis, 'Chronicon,
  83. (1964). Thomas of Spalato, *'Historia Pontificum. Salonitanorum
  84. (1981). Titurel,
  85. (1958). Un document sur les d6buts des Templiers, Revue de 1*, histoire ecclesiastique, 52 (1957) 81-91;
  86. Un poeme latin contemporain sur Saladin,
  87. (1904). Usamah ibn-Munqidh, Memoirs, doi
  88. (1966). vols. (Edinburgh, 1839) **Maius Chronicon Lemovicense. " RHGF 21 'Chronicon Montis Sereni,
  89. vols. (Paris, 1899-1910) - Armenian translation in RHC DocArm 1 Monasticon Anglicanum: a history of the abbies and other monasteries, hospitals, frieries, and cathedral and collegiate churches, with their dependencies.,
  90. vols. (Paris, 1926-52) "Un po6me contemporain sur
  91. vols. (reprinted Aalen,
  92. (1973). vols. SATF (Paris, 1906-11) Le Moniage Rainouart 1: publi6 d'apr6s les manuscrits de L"Arsenal et de Boulogne,
  93. (1953). vols., Collection des documents in6dits sur 1'histoire de France (Paris, 1894-1900) Ambroise, Estoire de Guerre Sainte: Histoire en vers de la troisi6me croisade,
  94. (1919). vols., SHF (Paris, 1891-1901) Historical documents of Ireland,
  95. (1965). Walter Giffard: The register of Walter Giffard, lord archbishop of York 1266-1279,
  96. (1983). Waverley Annals, in Annales Monastici 2 'Wenceslai I
  97. (1987). Women and the military orders in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, ' doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.