Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Making an efficient and well functioning corporate rescue system in Chinese bankruptcy laws: from the perspective of a comparative study between England and China.

By Haizheng Zhang


This research aims at identifying the inadequacies and weaknesses of the current\ud Chinese corporate rescue laws by doing a comparison between England and China, and\ud learning from the advanced experience and legal institutions of the English rescue laws. The study commences with a conceptual approach to the legal concept of corporate\ud rescue, which considers the corporate rescue culture from a theoretical perspective and\ud provides a necessary preparation for the following comparative analysis. It then\ud identifies the underlying factors in relation to the bankruptcy and rescue laws of the two states from several aspects: different cultures and ideologies, historical development of bankruptcy legislation, internal economic reform and external pressure prompting the Chinese insolvency law reforms. The exploration of particular contextual factors enables the differences of rescue laws in each legal system to be appreciated on the one hand; and to a large degree determines whether or not China could borrow the advanced\ud rescueoriented mechanisms and policies from the UK on the other hand. Subsequently, the thesis makes a comprehensive comparison of the formal corporate rescue regimes, identifies the philosophy and policy aims underlying the legal rules, and analyses the\ud balance and control of power of all the stakeholders and the redistribution of bargaining power of every player in each rescue network. The consideration of the balance of the power of each interested group in a rescue attempt aims to resolve a key issue as to how to design the rules to bring all the interested parties to the negotiation table and approve a reorganization plan. The study attempts to explore the potential problems in China’s\ud corporate rescue laws, envisage future trends and come up with some appropriate\ud solutions which may facilitate the construction of an effective and efficient corporate rescue system in China’s bankruptcy legal framework

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2008
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2008). (forthcoming) Peerenboom, R., China’s Long March Toward Rule of Law (CUP,
  2. (2008). 10 Information is available at (last visit 31
  3. (2002). A Hsu and A Walters, The Impact of the Enterprise Act
  4. (2007). A New Insolvency Law in China”
  5. (2007). A Preliminary Analysis of Prepackaged Administrations, Report to The Association of Business Recovery Professionals in
  6. (1996). A Principled Justification for Business Rescue Laws: A Comparative Perspective (Part II)”
  7. (1999). A Review of Company Rescue and Business Reconstruction Mechanisms, The Insolvency Service,
  8. (2000). A Review of Company Rescue and Business Reconstruction Mechanisms:Report by the Review Group , The Insolvency Service,
  9. (1986). Administration: Part II of the Insolvency Act
  10. (2004). Administrative Receivership and Administration—An Analysis”
  11. (1998). Adopting Corporate Rescue Regimes in China: A Comparative Survey”
  12. (2000). An Agency Cost Analysis of the Wrongful Trading Provisions”
  13. (2006). An Analysis of the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations
  14. (2006). An Institutional Analysis of China’s State Power Structure and its Operation”
  15. An Overview of Insolvency
  16. (2005). Annotated Guide to the Insolvency Legislation
  17. (1993). Arrangement and Administration Orders: A Consultative Document, The Insolvency Servive,
  18. (2008). Availability of continuing financing in corporate reorganizations: the UK and US perspective”
  19. (2002). BackAlley Banking: Private Entrepreneurs in China
  20. (2006). Banking on Reform”
  21. (2002). Banking on the Managers”
  22. (2002). Bankruptcy Law Reform in China”, a paper presented on the Second Forum for Asian Insolvency Reform (FAIR),
  23. (2002). Bargaining in the Shadow of the Enterprise Act
  24. (1999). Bird in a Cage: Legal Reform in China after Mao
  25. (1993). China at the Threshold of a Market Economy (International Monetary Fund
  26. (2006). China’s Banking Reform in the Context of Globalization and Transition”
  27. (1987). China’s Bankruptcy Law: Socialist in Characteristics, Capitalists in Methods”
  28. (2005). China’s Central Government Sets Short Timetable for Bankruptcy Law Reform”
  29. (2003). China’s Industrial Stateowned Enterprises: Between Profitability and Bankruptcy, (World Scientific,
  30. (1987). China’s New Bankruptcy Law: A Translation and Brief Introduction”
  31. (2006). China’s New Bankruptcy Law: Notable Features and Key Problems of Enforcement”
  32. (2008). China’s New Corporate Rescue Laws: Perspectives and Principles”
  33. (2007). China’s New Law on Enterprise Bankruptcy: A Story with a Happy End?”
  34. (2005). China’s Ownership Transformation: Process, Outcome,
  35. (2001). Chinese Bankruptcy Law in an Emerging Market Economy: The Shenzhen Experience”
  36. (2000). Chinese Bankruptcy Law: Milestones and Challenges”
  37. (2005). Chinese Corporate Governance and Prospects for Reform”
  38. (2000). Company Law Committee, Comments on the Insolvency Bill,
  39. (2008). Company Voluntary Arrangements and Rescues: A New Hope and a Tudor Orthodoxy”
  40. (2003). Company Voluntary Arrangements: the landlord position”
  41. (2004). Concentrated Ownership and Control of Corporate Reorganizations”
  42. (2002). Constructing a Market Economy: Diverse Paths from Central Planning
  43. (2005). Control and Coordination in Corporate Rescue”
  44. (2007). Control and corporate rescue – an AngloAmerican evaluation”
  45. (2002). Corporate Governance and Enterprise Reform
  46. (2005). Corporate governance: a comparative analysis between the UK and China”
  47. (2002). Corporate Insolvency Law: Perspectives and Principles (CUP Cambridge
  48. (2002). Corporate Insolvency Law: Perspectives and Principles (CUP,
  49. (2005). Corporate Insolvency Law: Theory and Application (OUP,
  50. (1995). Corporate Recovery: ‘The London Approach’”
  51. (1934). Corporate Reorganization: Section 77B of the Bankruptcy Act
  52. (1997). Corporate Rescue: A Conceptual Approach to Insolvency Law (Sweet
  53. (2006). Corporate Rescue: An Overview of Recent Developments from Selected Countries (2 nd edn,
  54. (2000). Corporate rescue: Empirical evidence on company voluntary arrangements and small firms”
  55. (1989). Corporate Rescues and Insolvencies (2 nd edn,
  56. (2005). Corporate Restructuring: Lessons from Experience (the World Bank,
  57. (1993). Corporate Turnaround: A Practical Guide to Business Survival (Nichols,
  58. (1997). Corporate Workouts—A UK Perspective”
  59. (2002). Corporate/Debt Restructuring: Japan, the Hong Kong SAR & the People’s Republic of China: A Roundtable Discussion”
  60. (2004). Creditorand DebtorOriented Corporate Bankruptcy Regimes Revisited”
  61. (2005). Creditors’ Rights and Contractual Exchange
  62. (2006). Culture and Society: Legal Ideas in the Mirror of Social Theory (Ashgate,
  63. (1996). Debtor rehabilitation: implications for the landlordtenant relationship”
  64. (2005). Doctoring in the Shadows of Insolvency”
  65. (1982). Documents and Conference Papers Report of the Review Committee on Insolvency Law and Practice (Cmnd 8558,
  66. (2005). Drafting Bankruptcy Laws in Socialist Market Economy: Recent Development in China and Vietnam”
  67. (1997). Early Warning Indicators of Corporate Failure (Ashgate,
  68. (1993). Efficiency versus Ideology—The Insolvency Law of the People’s Republic of China”
  69. (1999). Enforcing wrongful trading as a standard of conduct for directors and a remedy for creditors: the special case of corporate insolvency”
  70. (2003). Enterprise Act 2002: Changes to Corporate Insolvency”
  71. (2006). Enterprise Bankruptcy Law: A Comparative Analysis and Case Materials (China Legal Publishing House,
  72. (2005). European Comparative Company Law (CUP,
  73. (2001). Exit from Administration”
  74. (2003). FIE Bankruptcy Legal Framework Clarified by the New Judicial Rules in the People’s Republic of China”
  75. (2005). finance and economic growth in China”
  76. (2005). finance, and economic growth in China”
  77. (2005). Floating Charge Over Book Debts”
  78. (1990). From Central Planning to Market Economy: Some Microeconomic Issues”
  79. (2002). From Rice Bowl to Safety Net: Insecurity and Social Protection during China’s Transition”
  80. (2006). How Law Affects Lending”, Columbia Law and Economic Working Paper No.285,
  81. (2006). Improving Corporate Governance in StateOwned Corporations in China: Which Way Forward?”
  82. (2002). In Search of a Rescue Regime: The Enterprise Act
  83. (2002). Insolvency and the Enterprise Act
  84. (1996). Insolvency Law and Reform in the People’s Republic of
  85. (2005). International Listing as a Mechanism of Commitment to More Credible Corporate Governance Practices: the case of the Bank of China (Hong Kong)”
  86. (1987). Introduction to the General Provisions Civil Law of People’s Republic of China”
  87. (2006). Labour and the Corporation”
  88. (2001). Labour Law Text and Materials (Hart,
  89. (1998). Legal Cultures, Legal Paradigms and Legal Doctrine: Towards a New Model for Comparative Law”
  90. (2004). Legal Theory and Practical Analysis (People’s
  91. (2006). Looking for Law in China”
  92. Market Professionalism and the Commodification of Professional Expertise”, a paper presented at the 2005 British Accounting Association Conference, HeriotWatt
  93. (2007). Modelling an effective corporate governance system for China’s listed stateowned enterprises: issues and challenges in a transitional economy”
  94. (2001). Moratoria on enforcement rights: revisiting corporate rescue” [2004] Conveyancer and Property Law 89 Milman, D., “Schemes of Arrangement: Their Continuing Role”
  95. (1997). Normative Bricolage: Informal Rulemaking by Accountants and Lawyers
  96. (2003). On Fairness and Efficiency”
  97. (2002). People’s Republic of China: the Legal Features of Chinese Capital Markets in the Light of the Zhengzhou Baiwen Case”
  98. (2003). Policy Aims of the Enterprise Act” (Autumn
  99. (2006). Prepackaged administrations—trick or treat?”
  100. (2006). Prepackaged administrations: bargains in the shadow of insolvency or shadowy bargains”
  101. (2005). Principles of Corporate Insolvency Law (3 rd edn,
  102. (2001). Productivity and Enterprise: Insolvency—A Second Chance, (Cm 5234,
  103. (2000). Receiverships and the Rescue Culture”
  104. (2002). Recent developments in China’s social security system”
  105. (2002). Reforming the Governance of Corporate Rescue: The Enterprise Act
  106. (2004). Reforms, Globalization and Social Justice in China”
  107. (1992). Regulation and its Discontents: Understanding Economic Law in
  108. (2003). Reinvigorating Corporate Rescue”
  109. (2006). Report on Insolvency Outcomes, presented to the Insolvency Service in
  110. (2002). Rescue and Reconstruction”
  111. (1998). Rescuing Business: The Making of Corporate bankruptcy
  112. (2002). Resolution of Financial Distress: An International Perspective on the Design of Bankruptcy Laws (the World Bank,
  113. (2001). Rethinking Receivership”
  114. (1999). Review of Company Rescue and Business Reconstruction Mechanisms: Rescue Culture or Avoidance Culture? (CCH Bicester,
  115. (1995). Revised Proposals for a New Company Voluntary Arrangement Procedure: A Consultative Document,
  116. Schemes of Arrangement and Asbestos Litigation:
  117. (2006). Shareholders Rights in the UK Public Companies Restructurings—the Case of British Energy Plc”
  118. (2006). Should We Redistribute in Insolvency”,
  119. (2006). Social policymaking and its institutional basis: Transition of the Chinese social security system”
  120. (2003). Social security reforms in China: issues and prospects”
  121. (2006). Study of Administration Cases, Report to the Insolvency Service in
  122. (2000). Substance Crises, Managerial Corruption and Labour Protests in
  123. (2007). Superpriority new financing and corporate rescue”
  124. (2007). Tentative Steps”
  125. (2006). The
  126. (1996). The Administration Procedure and Creditors’ Voluntary Arrangements (Centre for Commercial Law Studies QMW,
  127. (2002). The Association of Business Recovery Professionals (R3), Corporate Insolvency in the UK: A Decade of Change
  128. (2002). The Bad Assets of Banks & Corporate Rescue in China”,
  129. (1997). The British Bankers Association (BBA), “Banks and Businesses: Working Together When You Borrow”,
  130. (2006). The Case for the Abolition of the Floating Charge”,
  131. (2006). The Characterization of Fixed and Floating Charges”,
  132. (2004). The Control of Wealth in Bankruptcy”
  133. (2008). The Corporate Reorganization Regime under China’s New Enterprise Bankruptcy Law”
  134. (2006). The Court’s Role in the Proceedings of Enterprise Bankruptcy and Restructuring and Problems that Needs to be Solved”, a paper presented at the Forum on Asian Insolvency Reform in April
  135. (2001). The Courts and the Administration Regime: Supporting Legislative Policy”
  136. (2003). The Enterprise Act and Insolvency Law Reform”
  137. (2004). The Harm Done by Administrative Receivership”
  138. (1997). The Idea of Property in Law (OUP,
  139. (2002). The Impact of the Enterprise Act
  140. (2000). The Insolvency Act
  141. (2007). The Interpretation and Substance of Bankruptcy Law (Law PressChina,
  142. (1994). The Law and Practice of Corporate Administrations (Butterworths,
  143. (2003). The Legal System of the People’s Republic of China in a Nutshell
  144. (2001). The Logic and Limits of Bankruptcy Law (BeardBooks
  145. (1994). The London Approach: Distressed Debt Trading”
  146. (1996). The London Approach”
  147. (2006). The Long March Towards China’s New Bankruptcy Law”,
  148. (1987). The Making of the Chinese Bankruptcy Law: A Study in the Chinese Legislative Process”
  149. (1999). The Nature and Functions of A Rescue Culture”
  150. (2007). The New Chinese Bankruptcy Law: Text and Limited Comparative Analysis”
  151. The New Development of Chinese Law
  152. (2003). The Ownership Reform in China: what direction and how far?”
  153. (2004). The Past, Present and Future of DebtorInPossession Financing”
  154. (2003). The people’s court in transition: the prospects of the Chinese judicial reform”
  155. The Preferential Debts Regime in Liquidation Law:
  156. (1995). The Professional Restructuring of Corporate Rescue: Company Voluntary Arrangements and the London Approach”,
  157. (2005). The Recasting of Insolvency Law”
  158. (1997). The Rescue Culture in the United Kingdom”
  159. (2007). The rise of prepackaged corporate rescue on both sides of the Atlantic”
  160. (2007). The rise of the prepackaged corporate rescue on both sides of the Atlantic”
  161. (2003). The Rule of Law as Transition to Democracy in China”
  162. (2004). The Significance Brought by the Drafting of the New Bankruptcy Law to China’s Credit Culture and Credit Institution: A Perspective of Bankruptcy Law”,
  163. (2006). The Speech on Enterprise Bankruptcy Law (Law PressChina,
  164. (2006). The Valuation of Distressed Companies: A Conceptual Framework,
  165. (2006). The Valuation of Distressed Companies: A Conceptual Framework, Part I”
  166. (2005). The World Bank, Principles for Effective Insolvency and Creditor Rights Systems (Revised Draft,
  167. (1996). the World Trade Organization, and the Agreement on TradeRelated Investment Measures”
  168. Theory of Chinese Bankruptcy Legal System
  169. (2007). Think about Property: From Antiquity to the Age of Revolution (CUP,
  170. (1999). Toward a New International Financial Architecture: A Practical PostAsia Agenda (Institute for International Economics
  171. (2000). Trade Representative, Report to Congress on China’s WTO Compliance
  172. (2001). TUPE Operates to Damage Rescue Culture”
  173. (2000). TUPE or not TUPE? Employee Protection, Corporate Rescue and ‘One Unholy Mess’”
  174. (2006). TUPE: Law and Practice (Jordans,
  175. (2006). Twelve Years to Sharpen One Sword: The
  176. (2000). UK Corporate Rescue: Recent Developments—Changes to Administrative Receiverships, Administration, and Company Voluntary Arrangements—The Insolvency Act
  177. (1994). Voluntary Administration: ‘The New Wave or the New Waif in Insolvency Law’”
  178. (2006). Voluntary Arrangements (2 nd edn, LexisNexis Butterworths,
  179. (1993). What courts do to secured creditors in Chapter 11 cram down”
  180. (2005). What future for liquidation in light of the Enterprise Act reforms”
  181. (1994). Wrongful Trading and Company Rescue”
  182. (2005). Wrongful trading and the liability of company directors: the theoretical perspective”
  183. (2006). Wrongful trading and the point of liability”
  184. (1999). Wrongful Trading Is it a Real Threat to Directors or a Paper Tiger?”
  185. (2001). Wrongful Trading”
  186. (2007). WTO: Wanting Time’s Over—China Opens Its Domestic Banking Market to Banks after Recent Changes to Its Banking Law and Regulations Makes Them WTO Compliant”

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.