Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

An Investigation of the Relationship Between Andragogy and Hong Kong Students' Approaches to Learning in Performing Arts Education: A Case Study.

By Gaebriella Wilkins


This case study, based on students in the Applied Arts department of an academy in Hong Kong, investigates the relationship between andragogy and student approaches to learning by looking at the curriculum delivery and how the student approaches to learning affect the outcome.\ud Hong Kong is an international city at the intersection between Chinese and Western cultures. Whilst its most recent past has been influenced by western culture, its origin is derived from traditional Chinese culture. For its part, The Academy is in a unique position to make a strong contribution to the development of performing arts both in China and Hong Kong. Established by Ordinance in 1984 in response to the city’s growing need to develop arts and arts education, the Academy holds a strategic position capable of bridging Chinese and Western culture.\ud The curriculum follows the model of an American performing arts school – a model based on Western teaching and learning styles and one that requires andragogical approaches and interactive participation in the creative process. In contrast to this approach, Academy students are recipients\ud of pedagogical practices that value analytical abilities over self-exploration. They learn through second language instruction, delivered in a way that is unfamiliar to them.\ud Data collection focused on the Applied Arts department of the School of Technical Arts and involved students and faculty members. Through an interpretative paradigm it set out to discover whether a fundamental change to the curriculum is required.\ud The outcome of the research revealed that students have difficulties reconciling their inherent learning styles with the curriculum content and implementation. Requiring them to break away from a familiar and comfortable mode of learning, to a style of learning that requires them to learn with understanding and personal control over the process, is a jump that creates much difficulty. The general consensus revealed that The Academy should move away from the present American model and develop an independent system that will acknowledge the natural and engrained learning styles of the students and adopt educational philosophies that are more suitable for Hong Kong

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2008
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. [1983], Education as Social Invention, doi
  2. [1983a], Culture and management development,
  3. A Model of Student Approaches to Learning Encompassing Ways to Influence and doi
  4. (1982). A Perspective on Education in Hong Kong, Hong Kong: Government Printing.
  5. (1998). Academic Board meeting AB03/04, The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts,
  6. (1977). An Intellectual Autobiography: Philosopher at Large, doi
  7. Applying Significant Bilingual Instructional Features in the Classroom,
  8. (1977). Attitudes and Opinions, doi
  9. (1999). Change Forces, The Sequel, London, doi
  10. Changing our Schools, Linking school effectiveness and school, improvement, doi
  11. (1995). Closing the Gap,
  12. (1998). Cognitive Styles and Learning Strategies, doi
  13. (1983). Communicating Naturally in a Second Language: Theory and Practice in Language Teaching, doi
  14. (1984). Conducting Small-Scale Investigations in EducationalManagement,
  15. (1988). Cross-cultural training across the individualism-collectivism divide’, doi
  16. (1985). Cross-cultural training: The competitive edge,
  17. (1966). Cultural Analysis in Overseas Operations, doi
  18. (1991). Cultural and Organisations: Softward of the Mind,
  19. (1981). Culture and memory development, quoted
  20. (1980). Culture’s Consequences: International differences in Work-related Values, doi
  21. (1995). Educating Hearts and Minds, doi
  22. (1991). Education and Politics: the case of Hong Kong from an historical perspective, doi
  23. (2000). Education Blueprint for the 21st Century, Hong Kong Education Commission,
  24. Education Commission [1997], Policy Address, public/documents/APCITY/UNPAN007453.pdf,
  25. (1978). Educational Research: the Art and Science of Investigation, Allyn and Bacon,
  26. (1995). Effective Learning, Chartered Institute of Personnel Development,
  27. (1998). Encouraging Creativity in the Performing Arts Curriculum, Managing the Impact of the Pre-Tertiary Education System in Hong Kong, unpublished paper for Master of Business Arts programme,
  28. et al [1984], Andragogy in Action, Applying modern principles of adult education, doi
  29. Gaebriella Wilkins New York Home Affairs Bureau [2004], Culture and Heritage Commission Policy Recommendation Report – Government Response, United States of America.
  30. (1984). Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions: An independent validation using Rokeach's Value Survey. doi
  31. (1985). Horace’s Compromise: The Dilemma of the American High School, doi
  32. (1996). How Hong Kong Students cope with Assessment, quoted
  33. Human Behavior in Global Perspective: An Introduction to Cross Cultural Psychology, doi
  34. (1978). Human information processing and environmental complexity: An experiment in four cultures,
  35. (1988). Improve Your People Skills, London, Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development,
  36. (1985). Intercultural Education for Multicultural Societies, doi
  37. (2001). Jerome Bruner’s Educational Theory, Friederichs, Jane O’Brien, [1988], The Current Hong Kong Education Situation in Comparative Perspective,
  38. (1998). John Dewey and the Challenge of Classroom Practice, doi
  39. (1986). Language Minority Students in the Mainstream Classroom,
  40. (1973). Language Minority Students in the Mainstream Classroom, Clevedon, Multilingual Matter Ltd Cheng, Kai-ming and Kam-cheung Wong [1996], Journal of Educational Administration. Vol 34 No.5. Hong Kong , MCB,
  41. (2000). Learning and Teaching: a cross-cultural perspective, doi
  42. (1985). Lifelong learning: An Omnibus of Practice and
  43. Making Sense of Teaching,
  44. (1980). Management Education for Orientals,
  45. (1982). Managing Cultural Synergy, doi
  46. (1996). Mission Statement, The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts,
  47. (2002). Modelling / Coaching / Scaffolding, a WWW site Wittrock [1977], The Generative Processes of Memory, quoted in M.C.Wittrock [ed] [1986]. The Human Brain, Englewood Cliffs NJ:
  48. (1993). Observational Checklist for the office of
  49. (1997). One Country Two Systems, Three Languages, Changing Language Use in Hong Kong.
  50. (2003). Overseas Visiting Panel [1994], Target Oriented Curriculum [TOC], Hong Kong Government Report,
  51. (1993). Practical Research, Planning and Design, doi
  52. (1995). Quality in Education: Insights from Different Perspectives, Hong Kong Educational Research Association.
  53. (1993). Real World Research, A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner Researchers. doi
  54. Restructuring the key to effective school management, doi
  55. (2000). Review of Education System Reform Proposals: Education Blueprint for the 21st Century, Consultation Document
  56. (1993). Riding the Waves of Culture. Understanding Cultural Diversity in Business, London, Nicholas Brealey Publishing Limited United National Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) What is Cultural Diversity? doi
  57. (1996). School effectiveness in East Asia, Concepts, origins and Implications, doi
  58. (1989). Schooling for democracy: critical pedagogy in the modern age. doi
  59. (1987). Students Approaches to Learning doi
  60. (1999). Students Handbook, The Hong Kong Academy For Performing Arts,
  61. (1996). Submission to Hong Kong Council for Academic Accreditation Volume 1. The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts,
  62. (1992). Successful School Improvement, doi
  63. (1999). Teaching as a Performing Art, Teachers College, doi
  64. Teaching Students to assume an active role in their learning’, quoted
  65. (1972). The Analysis of Subjective Culture: doi
  66. (1996). The Chinese Learner: Cultural Psychological and Contextual Influences, doi
  67. (1995). The Chinese, Kuala Lumpur,
  68. (1998). The Curriculum Experiment. Meeting the Challenge of Social Change. doi
  69. (1995). The Development of Cognitive Anthropology, Cambridge: doi
  70. (2000). The Educational Theory of Lev Semenovich in
  71. (1993). The Fragrant Chinese, Hong Kong, The Chinese
  72. The Learning Gap, doi
  73. The Learning Styles Helper’s Guide,
  74. (1994). The Living Tree, The Changing Meaning of Being Chinese Today, doi
  75. (1982). The Manual of Learning Styles, Berkshire, Peter Honey Publications Ltd Hong Kong Economic Journal [1998], Hong Kong, March p. 26 Hycner,
  76. (1991). The New Meaning of Education Change,
  77. (1981). The psychology of literacy, Cambridge KMA: doi
  78. (1986). The Psychology of the Chinese People, Hong Kong, doi
  79. The South China Morning Post, doi
  80. The South China Morning Post, Arts Section, Hong Kong, doi
  81. (1983). Toward a Developmental Theory of Andragogy,
  82. (1986). Understanding and Facilitating Adult Learning. Milton Keynes,
  83. (1981). Understanding intercultural communication,
  84. (1989). Understanding the Chinese Mind, Hong Kong, doi
  85. (1995). Using portfolios for teacher assessment: Formative and summative approaches,
  86. (1994). When Teaching Becomes Learning,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.