Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Academics’ Perspectives of Performance Management in a British University Context

By William Hon Kwan Tam

Abstract

This study provides an in-depth understanding of how academics perceive and\ud experience a performance management system in a British university. Specifically, it\ud examines - within the context of a university department - the meaning and purposes of performance management; the effectiveness of the processes; the management of the system and its effectiveness; the impact of the system on academics’ working lives; and the areas requiring improvement. The study particularly explores the tension between\ud performance management as a means of accountability within a managerial context and the more traditional academic ethos of professional autonomy. The research adopts a\ud qualitative case study approach by selecting a School of Education in an older researchled University. The case School was primarily chosen for its ease of access. However, it had also operated performance management for some time, and it had academics with both high and low research profiles, a phenomenon which was likely to present a range of experiences of the performance management system. Twelve academics with varied backgrounds in terms of years of service, seniority and gender were participants in the study. Data were collected through in-depth, semi-structured interviews and documentary sources between September 2006 and February 2007. A two-level analytical coding approach was used to derive themes from the collected data. Among the major findings were that the participants found the meanings and purposes of performance management ambiguous; and that the many different processes contained within the system were perceived as fragmenting and confusing in achieving the intended outcomes. Compounding the concern was the lack of dedicated and able academics to manage the process. With work intensification - a prominent feature of academic life, academics became frustrated with the lack of time available for their research work. To defend their research ethos, the study provides evidence that some academics look for a more structured system to address the unbalanced workload issue

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2008
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/4036

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2002). 20 September). Australian universities as enterprise universities: Transformed players on a global stage, Globalisation: what issues are at stake for universities? Available at http://www.bi.ulaval.ca/GlobalisationUniversities /pages/actes/CurrieJan.pdf.
  2. (1992). A
  3. (1990). A matter of record: Documentary Sources in Social Research, Cambridge,
  4. (1978). A performance management system: Research, design, introduction and evaluation.
  5. (2000). A systems perspective of performance management in public sector organisations.
  6. (1997). Academic capitalism – Politics, policies and the entrepreneurial university.
  7. (1998). Academic contests? Merit pay in Canadian Universities.
  8. (1998). Academic freedom and autonomy in the United Kingdom and Germany.
  9. (1974). Academic freedom and higher education in England.
  10. (2005). Academic freedom as intellectual property: When collegiality confronts the standardisation movement.
  11. (1990). Academic freedom, autonomy and accountability in British universities.
  12. (2005). Academic identity and autonomy in a changing policy environment.
  13. (2005). Academic labour and the politics of quality in higher education: A critical evaluation of the conditions of possibility of resistance.
  14. (2006). Academic staff workloads and job satisfaction: Expectations and values in academe.
  15. (1997). Academic values and the university as corporate enterprise.
  16. (2003). Academic workload planning revisited.
  17. (1991). Academics and their labour process. In
  18. (2005). Achieving accountability in higher education: Balancing public, academic and market demands.
  19. (1997). Active Interviewing. In
  20. (2007). All change within the academy: Dissonance and role conflict or the potential for new forms of professionalism?
  21. (2002). An “expert witness” perspective on performance appraisal in universities and colleges.
  22. (1994). An expanded sourcebook: Qualitative data analysis (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks,
  23. (2004). Analysing documentary realities In Silverman, D (Eds.) Qualitative Research: Theory, Method and Practice,
  24. (2001). Analyzing interview data: The development and evolution of a coding system.
  25. (1984). Andragogy in action.
  26. (2007). Annual Review 2007/2008 Promotion to Personal Chairs,
  27. (2004). Appraisal and Feedback.
  28. (1992). April-June). The introduction of university staff appraisal.
  29. (2000). Assessing the quality of quality assessment: The inspection of teaching and learning in British universities.
  30. (1979). Autumn). Goal Setting: A motivational technique that works. Organisational Dynamic,
  31. (1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques.
  32. (2002). Being managed: Performance management form the teachers’ point of view.
  33. (2001). Between the ivory tower and the academic assembly line.
  34. (1997). Beyond the Robbins trap: Reconceptualising academic responses to change in higher education (or….quiet flows the Don?).
  35. (2007). Can academic autonomy survive in the knowledge society? A perspective from Britain.
  36. (1992). Can performance management work in Australian Universities?
  37. (1996). Can we reveal the inner world of teaches? Some research issues.
  38. (2006). Carving out time and space in the managerial university.
  39. (1994). Case Studies. In
  40. (1999). Case study research in educational settings.
  41. (2003). Case study research: Design and methods. Thousand Oaks,
  42. (2002). Challenges to the academic role of change agent.
  43. (2004). Changing internal governance: A discussion of leadership roles and management structures in UK universities.
  44. (1998). Collecting and Interpreting Qualitative Materials. Thousand Oaks,
  45. (1981). Competition and control at work.
  46. (1998). Conducting a piece of educational research: Choice of topic, adoption of suitable research methodology, and narrowing down of investigative focus.
  47. (2001). Constraints, Compromises and Choice: Comparing Three Qualitative Research Studies. The Qualitative Report,
  48. (2002). Counting out the scholars: The case against performance indicators in higher education.
  49. (1999). Diversity of appraisal and performance-related pay practices in higher education.
  50. (2001). Do You Really Live Here?" Thoughts on Insider Research.
  51. (2004). Documentary Research in Education, History and the Social Sciences. London and
  52. (2002). Does the development of mass education necessarily mean the end of quality?
  53. (2000). Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Application, Sixth Edition. Upper Saddle River,
  54. (2002). Emerging concepts of academic leadership and their implications for intra-institutional roles and relationships in higher education.
  55. (1997). Ethical dilemmas and practical problems for the practitioner researcher,
  56. (1996). Fall). Three cultures of management: The key to organisational learning.
  57. (1999). Fuelling discovery or monitoring productivity: Research scientists’ changing perception of management.
  58. (1998). Fundamental changes in institutional governance structures: The United Kingdom.
  59. (2001). Funding mechanism on quality assessment: Responses to the research assessment exercise in English institutions.
  60. (2001). Globalisation, new managerialism, academic capitalism and entrepreneurialism in universities; is the local dimension still important?
  61. (1995). Goal setting, domestication and academia: the beginning of an analysis. In
  62. (2004). Goodhart’s law and performance indicators in higher education.
  63. (2006). Guide on The Development Of Individual Teaching Skills (Peer Observation Of Teaching).
  64. (1997). Higher education markets and public policy.
  65. (2003). Higher education, commercial criteria and economic incentives.
  66. (1987). How can we implement a pay-for-performance policy successfully? In
  67. Human Resource Management and Development Strategy. (https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/personnel/docs/hrstrat2002.pdf; accessed on 25/11/2006).
  68. (1998). Human Resource Management: A strategic introduction.
  69. (1985). Implementing organisational change: A practical guide to managing change efforts.
  70. (2005). Implementing performance management in England’s primary schools.
  71. (1992). Improving Higher Education: Total quality care.
  72. (2007). In Defense of Being "Native": The Case for Insider Academic Research,
  73. (1999). Independent Review of Higher Education, Pay and Conditions. An independent committee chaired by Sir Michael Bett. [The Bett Report.] London, UK: The Stationery Office.
  74. (1991). Interviewing as qualitative research.
  75. (1996). Interviews: An introduction to qualitative research interviewing. Thousand Oaks,
  76. (1998). Introduction to social research: Quantitative and qualitative approaches.
  77. (1968). January-February). One more time: How do you motivate employees? Harvard Business Review,
  78. (1997). Job satisfaction among academic staff: An international perspective.
  79. (1997). Just how managed is the McUniversity? Organisation Studies,
  80. (1992). Leadership and management in higher education.
  81. (1984). Leadership and organisational culture.
  82. (2000). Leading academic change- essential roles for department chairs.
  83. (1993). Leading academics.
  84. (1996). Leading change.
  85. (1997). Linking measurement and motivation: A challenge for education, in
  86. (1998). Losing our religion: On the precariousness of precise normative standards in complex accountability systems. In
  87. (1999). Making sense of performance management: Official rhetoric and teachers’ reality. Asia Pacific
  88. (2004). Management and leadership in the contemporary university.
  89. (2005). Management as ideology: The case of ‘new managerialism’ in higher education.
  90. (1997). Managerialism and professionalism in the ‘Cinderella service’.
  91. (1994). Managerialism and the academic profession: The case of England.
  92. (1993). Managerialism and the public services, 2nd Edition.
  93. (2005). Managerialism, internationalisation, Taylorisation and the deskilling of academic work: Evidence from an Australian university. In
  94. (1999). Managing ambiguity: Between markets and managerialism – a case study of ‘middle managers’ in further education.
  95. (1997). Managing Appraisal. In
  96. (2001). Managing dilemmas in appraising performance: An approach for school leaders.
  97. (2002). Managing employee performance: Design and implementation in organisations.
  98. (2003). Managing for performance today and tomorrow. In
  99. (1998). Managing performance-related pay based on evidence from the financial services sector.
  100. (2004). Managing performance: Performance management in action. London: Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development.
  101. (2000). Managing Quality in Higher Education: An international perspective on institutional assessment and change.
  102. (1995). Managing the academics: Commodification and control in the development of university education in the U.K.
  103. (1999). March/April). Doubting the philosophical assumption of interpretive research.
  104. (1991). Merit pay and job enlargement as reform: Incentives, implementation, and teacher response. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,
  105. (1991). Merit pay in academia: Perceptions from the school of business.
  106. (1992). Merit pay- linking pay increases to performance ratings.
  107. (2000). Mutual benefits or managerial control? The role of appraisal in performance related pay for teachers.
  108. (1998). New Managerialism’ and Higher Education: The management of performance and cultures
  109. (1959). On the meaning of alienation.
  110. (1997). Parallels between qualitative research and sequentially performed quantitative research.
  111. (2006). Pay for performance where output is hard to measure: the case of performance pay for school teachers.
  112. (1997). Paying teachers for what they know and do: New and smarter compensation strategies to improve schools. Thousand Oaks,
  113. (2001). Performance appraisal and management: The developing research agenda.
  114. (2000). Performance appraisal and performance management a multilevel analysis.
  115. (1993). Performance appraisal and the emergence of management.
  116. (1988). Performance appraisal: A survey of academic staff opinion.
  117. (2005). Performance indicators and widening participation
  118. (2000). Performance indicators as conceptual technologies.
  119. (1997). Performance management and the psychological contract.
  120. (2006). Performance Management for Teachers and Head Teachers: Guidance.
  121. (2002). Performance Management in Education: Improving practice.
  122. (2000). Performance Management in Schools: Performance management framework.
  123. (2004). Performance management in the public sector: Fact or fiction?
  124. (2005). Performance management in the UK public sector.
  125. (2000). Performance management model: A system-based approach to public service quality.
  126. (2007). Performance management systems in and of higher education institutions in England.
  127. (1996). Performance management, job satisfaction and organisational commitment.
  128. (2004). Performance Management: A model and research agenda.
  129. (2005). Performance management. Survey report.
  130. (2005). Performance pay for teachers: Linking individual and organisational-level targets.
  131. (2004). Performance pay for teachers: the views and experiences of heads and teachers.
  132. (1999). Performance related pay in schools: An assessment of the green papers. A report prepared for the National Union of Teachers,
  133. (2000). Performance, Pay and Professionals,
  134. (2001). Personnel management in UK universities.
  135. (2005). Preparing for leadership: What academic department chairs need to know.
  136. (1996). Professional identity and the restructuring of higher education.
  137. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research methods, 2nd Edition.
  138. (1998). Qualitative methods: Technique or size? In
  139. (1998). Qualitative research and case study applications in education.
  140. (2003). Quality and power in higher education.
  141. (2005). Quality and trustworthiness in qualitative research in counselling psychology.
  142. (2001). Quality assessment and the tension between teaching and research.
  143. (2006). Quality assurance in UK higher education: issues of trust, control, professional autonomy and accountability.
  144. (1995). Quantitative and Qualitative research approaches in education.
  145. (1998). Re-framing Foucault: The case of performance appraisal. In
  146. (2005). Red tape and public employees: Does perceived rule dysfunction alienate managers?
  147. (1997). Regenerating professionalism within the academic workplace. In
  148. (1985). Report of the Steering Committee for Efficiency Studies in Universities.
  149. (1989). Research and the teacher: A qualitative introduction to school-based research.
  150. (2006). Research Ethics Framework. Economic and Social Research Council. Available at http://www.esrcsocietytoday.ac.uk/ESRCInfoCentre/Images /ESRC_Re_Ethics_Frame_tc_tcm6-11291.pdf.
  151. (1994). Research methods in educational management.
  152. (1997). Research selectivity, managerialism and the academic labour process: The future of nonmainstream economics in UK universities.
  153. (2005). Rethinking academic identities in neo-liberal times.
  154. (2002). Rewarding and developing staff in higher education: Good practice in setting HR strategies. Higher Education Funding Council for Education,
  155. (1997). Risk and reward: Perspectives on the implementation of Kentucky’s school based performance award.
  156. (2002). Separating the developmental and evaluative performance appraisal uses.
  157. (1993). September-October). Why Incentive Plans Cannot Work.
  158. (2004). Socializing school administrators to meet leadership challenges that doom all but the most heroic and talented leaders to failure.
  159. (1996). Spring). Globalisation, contract government and the Taylorization of intellectual labour in academia.
  160. (1996). Spring). New modes of control in the public service.
  161. Staff Development and Appraisal Scheme. https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk: 8000/staffdev/ma/appraisal.html; accessed on 11/8/2007).
  162. (1992). Subjectivity in qualitative research.
  163. (1998). Successfully completing case study research: combining rigour, relevance and pragmatism.
  164. (2000). Teachers before the threshold.
  165. (1997). Teaching appraisal in higher education: an Australian perspective.
  166. (2000). Terms and Conditions of Appointment for Academic Staff. (https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/personnel/nav/terms.htm; accessed on 25/11/2006).
  167. (1997). The academic labour process: From collegiality and professionalism to managerialism and proletarianisation?
  168. (2005). The assault on the professions and the restructuring of academic and professional identities: A Bernsteinian analysis.
  169. (2007). The challenges of insider research in educational institutions: wielding a double-edged sword and resolving delicate dilemmas.
  170. (2000). The changing university: Meeting a need and needing to change.
  171. (1979). The concepts of alienation and involvement revisited.
  172. (2005). The contemporary academic labour process, the institutionalisation of research practices and qualitative research.
  173. (1998). The deadly dull issue of university “administration”? good governance managerialism and organising academic work.
  174. (2002). The determinants of research group performance toward mode 2.
  175. (2006). The effect of the research assessment exercise on organisational culture
  176. (2001). The Ethics of Outsider Research.
  177. (1983). The higher education system.
  178. (2001). The HR scorecard, linking people strategy, and performance.
  179. (1998). The Human Equation.
  180. (1987). The human side of enterprise.
  181. (2006). The impact of external forces on academic identity.
  182. (2001). The impact of performance indicators on the work of university academics: Evidence from Australian universities.
  183. (2002). The impact of research selectivity on academic work and identity in UK universities.
  184. (2004). The Influence of Peer Review on the Research Assessment Exercise,
  185. (2000). The interview: From structured questions to negotiated text. In
  186. (2004). The knowledge worker, the manager-academic and the contemporary UK university: New and old forms of public management?
  187. (2006). The Learning and Teaching Strategy-
  188. (2006). The locus of power in UK universities: Its impact on educational development centers.
  189. (1998). The marketisation of higher education: Management, discourse and the politics of performance.
  190. (1995). The McUniversity: Organisation, management and academic subjectivity.
  191. (1989). The nature of work: an introduction on the debate of labour process. Second Edition,
  192. (1998). The new higher education. Stoke on Trent, UK:
  193. (1996). The new public management in action. Oxford:
  194. (2000). The new UK quality framework.
  195. (1999). The paradoxes of research assessment and funding.
  196. (1994). The philosophy of research design. In
  197. (1991). The proletarianisation of academic labour.
  198. (2000). The Relevance of Qualitative Research.
  199. The School of Education.
  200. (2001). The significance of teacher performance and its appraisal. In
  201. (1978). The ubiquity of the technique of goal setting in theories of and approaches to employee motivation.
  202. (2000). The UK research assessment exercise: Unintended consequences.
  203. The University Protocol on Student Feedback. The learning and teaching committee. (https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/academic/quality/guidelines/cotlfeed.pdf; accessed on 8/9/2007).
  204. The University. https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/portals/university.html; accessed on 11/8/2007).
  205. (2001). Thematic networks: An analytic tool for qualitative research.
  206. (1995). Theories of Educational Management, Second Edition. Thousand Oaks,
  207. (2003). Understanding academic freedom: The views of social scientists.
  208. (2003). Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher Education.
  209. UoL (2007a). University Profile.(https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/press/profile /profile.pdf; accessed on 11/8/2007).
  210. UoL (2007c). Mission Statement. https://wwwgate.le.ac.uk:8000/portals/ mission_stat.html; accessed on 11/8/2007).
  211. (2000). Using performance indicators to hold schools accountable: Implicit assumptions and inherent tensions.
  212. (2004). What about the workers? The expansion of higher education and the transformation of academic work.
  213. (1998). What managerialists forget: Higher education credit frameworks and managerialist ideology.
  214. (2003). Why was the QAA approach to teaching quality assessment rejected by academics
  215. (1996). Winter). Qualitative research inquiry: Issues of power and ethics.
  216. (2002). Work alienation and organizational leadership.
  217. (2006). Work allocation models and “collegiality” in academic departments.
  218. (2004). Work intensification and emotional labour among UK university lecturers: An exploratory study.
  219. (2000). Working in higher education in the United Kingdom. In

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.