Location of Repository

Transforming retired military officers into school principals in Israel

By Alex Schneider


Traditionally, school principals are selected from experienced teachers working in the field of education. During the last century, educational systems have gone through major conceptual changes, including changes of role for educational leaders. Modifications of the principal’s role have led to broadened requirements for fulfilling the task. This may lead to a shortage of candidates for headship. In this case the recruitment of additional candidates for leadership roles may become an increasing challenge. One possible solution may be found by integrating personnel from beyond the field of education with the right qualities, abilities and capabilities willing to take this mission upon themselves.\ud \ud Since existing training programmes might not provide responses to their requirements, the purpose of this thesis is to try and present an appropriate way of incorporating candidates and training them to perform their mission successfully. The training concept is based upon providing essential characteristics of principalship. These include leadership qualities, management abilities and pedagogical capabilities, designed for candidates outside the field of education to support the process of incorporating them into principalship. Examination of the training process was conducted for both schoolteachers and for retired ex-military personnel during their transfer from military duties to the field of education. The research identified requirements for pre-service training in the fields of leadership, management and pedagogy. In both courses it compared and assessed similarities and differences between the groups. Evaluation of candidates’ abilities and capabilities in the fields of leadership, management and pedagogical skills established the areas in which they needed support during their transfer to principalship.\ud \ud In this research the main hypothesis was "Aspiring principals can identify tools and skills, required for their training into principal's positions, based upon evaluation of their own abilities and capabilities in the fields of leadership, management and pedagogical skills". The hypothesis proved valid in substantial sections; therefore a conceptual model for recruiting and training suitable candidates for principalship drawn from other professions becomes a viable proposition.\ud \ud This research does not only have relevance for the educational system in Israel; the findings may provide pertinent information for other countries seeking to draw on wider ranges of recruits for teaching and headship

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2004
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/448

Suggested articles



  1. (1990). A Critical Theory of Education: Habermas and our Children’s Future,
  2. (1998). A Cross-National Comparison of Effective Leadership and Teamwork: Toward a Global Workforce,
  3. (1990). A Force for Change: How Leadership Differs from Management,
  4. (2002). A Handbook for Headteachers,
  5. (1984). A Place Called School,
  6. (1977). A Plan for Developing Preparation Programs for Senior Administration
  7. (2002). A proposal for the missions and task of a school principal in Israel’, The Forum 18, Reches, Even Yehuda,
  8. (1993). A Silent Success:
  9. (1996). Academic preparation of principals in Israel: empowering dynamic school leadership’,
  10. (1996). Action Research: A Handbook for Practitioners,
  11. (1994). Adjustment of retired military personnel on transfer from military to civilian career’, unpublished MA thesis,
  12. (1987). Adjustment to civilian appointments in second careers by retired military officers’,
  13. (1987). Administrator preparation in the United States’, in
  14. (1990). Adoption strategies for a second career among military retired personnel’, unpublished MA thesis,
  15. (1997). Allocating budgets for curriculum support’, in
  16. (2000). An evaluation of a leadership development programme’,
  17. (1999). An organizational perspective on values for leaders of future schools’,
  18. (1997). Analysing management for personal development: theory and practice’,
  19. (1993). and associates
  20. (1994). and Kenijio Tatashi
  21. (1984). Andragogy in Action,
  22. (1976). Are top executives transformable across companies? Business Horizons,
  23. (2000). Aspiring leaders academy: responding to the principal shortage’,
  24. (2000). Assessing the impact of professional development
  25. (2002). Attention!!! The principal is here’,
  26. (1983). Auditing naturalistic inquiries: the development and application of a model’, unpublished doctoral dissertation,
  27. (1999). Back to the future: the development of educational policy in England’,
  28. (1997). Balancing school and individual approaches to pupil behaviour’,
  29. (1990). Basics of Qualitative Research,
  30. (2000). Beyond Competence: The Challenge for Educational Management,
  31. (2000). Building a New Structure for School Leadership,
  32. (1988). Can there be a feminist ethnography?’,
  33. (1985). Career choice of military retired personnel: examining Holland’s theory in objective and subjective perspective’, unpublished MA thesis,
  34. (1984). Caring: A Feminine Approach to Ethics and Moral Education,
  35. (1988). Case Study Research in Education: A Qualitative Approach,
  36. (1989). Change of values during socialization for a profession: an application of the managerial men theory’,
  37. (1989). Changing careers: a qualitative study’,
  38. (1998). Charismatic Leadership, Tel Aviv University: Ramot (in Hebrew).
  39. (1992). Cohort groups and intensive schedules: Does familiarity breed learning?’
  40. (1993). Cohort groups in educational administration: promises and challenges’,
  41. (2000). Cohorts in educational leadership programs: Benefits, difficulties, and the potential for developing school leaders’,
  42. (1995). Cohorts today: Considerations of structure, characteristics and potential effects’,
  43. (1999). Commissioning for School Principalship, Jerusalem: Szold Institute (in Hebrew).
  44. (1997). Competence in educational management’,
  45. (1997). Context and capability in educational management’,
  46. (1989). Critical Pedagogy: The State and Cultural Struggle,
  47. (2000). Culture and Pedagogy:
  48. (1993). Culture, cost and control: self-management and entrepreneurial schooling in England and
  49. (1997). Curriculum evaluation as review and development: the curriculum leader’s role in creating a community of enquiry’,
  50. (1994). Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research, NJ:
  51. (1998). Developing a leadership programme for school leaders: an NPQH assessment centre manager reflects’,
  52. (2000). Developing comparative and international educational leadership and management: a cross-cultural model’,
  53. (1991). Developing Educational Leaders,
  54. (1992). Developing Expert Leadership for Future Schools,
  55. (1997). Developing expertise in school management and teaching’,
  56. (1999). Developing human capital: Training and mentoring for principals’,
  57. (1997). Developing managerial capabilities’, in
  58. (1999). Developing school leaders to work on the USMexican border: Lessons learned’,
  59. (1995). Discontinuous Change: Leading Organizational Transformation,
  60. (1985). Doing Your Own Research,
  61. (1987). Educating the Reflective Practitioner: Toward a New Design for Teaching and Learning in the Professions,
  62. (1973). Education in the seventies, implementing policies’,
  63. (1993). Education managers as leaders: some thoughts on the context of the changing nature of schools’,
  64. (1997). Educational Identity” as a Primary Factor in the Development of Educational Leadership, Jerusalem: The Mandel Institute (in Hebrew).
  65. (1995). Educational leadership cohort models: Changing the talk to change the walk’,
  66. (1997). Educational leadership: schools, environments and boundary spanning’, in
  67. (1997). Educational Management: Strategy, Quality and Resources,
  68. (1994). Educational/Pedagogical Vision - Proposal,
  69. (1998). Effective leaders and effective schools’,
  70. (1998). Effective School Leadership – Responding to Change,
  71. (1990). Effective School Management,
  72. (1989). Elaboration on working together: A collaborative approach to university/school system principalship career development’, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Council of Professors of Educational Administration,
  73. (1996). Encouraging Learning: Towards a Theory of the Learning School,
  74. (1993). Essential School Leadership: Developing Vision and Purpose in Management,
  75. (1998). Ethical challenges in school leadership’,
  76. (1998). Expectation of school leaders: an Australian picture’,
  77. (1994). Expert Leadership for Future Schools,
  78. (1998). Exploring New Horizons in
  79. (1999). Exploring recent developments and debates in education management’,
  80. (1985). Facilitating action research in school: some dilemmas’,
  81. (1999). Fifty Years of Israeli Education, Jerusalem: Israeli Ministry of Education.
  82. (1988). Focus Groups: A Practical Guide for Research,
  83. (1990). Focus Groups: Theory and Practice,
  84. (1999). Foreword’, in National College for School Leadership: A Prospectus,
  85. (1990). Fostering Critical Reflection in Adulthood: A guide to Transformative and Emancipatory Learning,
  86. (1983). Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences,
  87. (1992). Gender and curriculum’, in
  88. (1998). Globalization or democracy?’, in
  89. (1999). Governmental systems under transfer: from governmental collectivism to civil individualism – school selection as a case study’,
  90. (1991). Head Teacher Management Training and Development of Materials: A Planning Overview, London: Commonwealth Secretariat.
  91. (1995). Headteacher or manager? Implications for training and development’,
  92. (1998). How to build leadership capacity’,
  93. (1933). How We Think: a Restatement of the Relation of Reflective Thinking to the Educative Process, (rev. edn.) Boston: Heath (original work published
  94. (1962). Ideas: General Introduction to Pure Phenomenology,
  95. (1989). Improving the Preparation of School Administrators: An Agenda for Reform,
  96. (1998). In the firing line: the attractions of secondary headships’,
  97. (1993). Innovative approaches to clinical internships: The university of New Mexico experience’, in
  98. (1920). Intelligence and its uses’,
  99. (1985). Inter-sectoral administrative resource transfer in the process of development: retired military officers as civilian administrators in Israel’,
  100. (1989). Interpretive Biography,
  101. (1989). Interpretive Interactionism,
  102. (1996). Interstate School Leaders Licensure Consortium (ISLLC) Standards,
  103. (2000). Introduction: justifying a cross-cultural comparative approach to school leadership and management’,
  104. (1998). Is There a Shortage of Qualified Candidates for Openings in Principalship?: An Exploratory Study,
  105. (2000). L.(2000) ‘The changing role of principals in school partnership’, Bulletin, The National Association of Secondary School Principals,
  106. (1987). Leaders for America’s Schools,
  107. (1988). Leaders for American Schools,
  108. (2001). Leadership (What’s In
  109. (1999). Leadership and Leadership Development, Tel Aviv:
  110. (1999). Leadership and management in educational systems’,
  111. (1985). Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations,
  112. (1984). Leadership and reflection in action,
  113. (1994). Leadership for school re-structuring’,
  114. (1996). Leadership for the Schoolhouse,
  115. (2001). Leadership in a real world’, in
  116. (1957). Leadership in Administration,
  117. (1989). Leadership in the 21sst century’,
  118. (1994). Leadership Without Easy Answers,
  119. (1960). Leadership, Psychology and Organizational Behavior,
  120. (1991). Leadership: A New Synthesis,
  121. (1997). Leading and managing staff for high performance’,
  122. (1984). Leading by stepping down (the problem of burnout in school administrators’, The Clearing House,
  123. (1996). Leading Change,
  124. (2001). Leading in a Culture of Change,
  125. (1997). Leading Primary Schools,
  126. (2000). Leading the Learning Organization,
  127. (1998). Leading the Learning School, London: Lemos and Crane.
  128. (1995). Leading with Soul: An Uncommon Journey of Spirit,
  129. (1997). Learning organisations – re-engineering schools for life long learning’,
  130. (1997). Linking strategic planning with the budgetary process’, in
  131. (1977). Linking ways of knowing with ways of being practical’,
  132. (1983). Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology,
  133. (1988). Local Management of Schools: Training Material for Head Teachers and Other School Staff,
  134. (1982). Making Groups Effective,
  135. (1997). Making sense of change’, in
  136. (1998). Making sense of primary headship: the surprises awaiting new heads’,
  137. (1996). Management problems of new primary headteachers’,
  138. (1992). Managers and leaders: are they different?’,
  139. (1994). Managers as Leaders, Tel Aviv University: Ramot (in Hebrew).
  140. (1986). Managing People at Work: a Managers Guide to Behaviour in Organizations (rev. edn.),
  141. (1996). Managing Resources for School Improvement: Creating a Cost-Effective School,
  142. (1997). Managing resources in educational institutions: an open systems approach’,
  143. (1998). Managing Truancy in Schools,
  144. (1993). Mapping the leader/manager’,
  145. (2000). Mapping the way ahead: Leading educational leadership into the globalized world’,
  146. (2000). Measuring Teachers and Principals’ Autonomy Levels, Jerusalem: Szold Institute (in Hebrew).
  147. (1992). Mentoring for headteachers: A review of major issues’,
  148. (1999). Micropolitics, leadership and all that … the need to increase the micro-political awareness and skills of school leaders’,
  149. (1992). Moral Leadership,
  150. (1994). Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom,
  151. (1993). Narrative Analysis,
  152. (1998). National Standards and the training and development of headteachers’, paper presented at the MBA students’ day,
  153. (1985). Naturalistic Inquiry,
  154. (2000). New standards for the preparation of school administrators: what conceptualization of the educational planning do they portray?’, Planning and Changing,
  155. (1999). Officer I dag_skollerdare i morgen? Orebro: forsvarshogsklan, Utbildningsbyran och Orebro Universitet and Pedagogiska Institution Friedman, I.
  156. (1995). On fire: Charismatic leadership and levels of analysis’,
  157. (1989). On ideology and education: critical pedagogy and the cultural politics of resistance’,
  158. (1992). On Leadership, Tel Aviv: M.O.D.
  159. (1997). Organising learning’, in
  160. (1997). Organizational Culture and Leadership,
  161. (1998). Organizational learning and transformational leadership’, in
  162. (1978). Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action Perspective’,
  163. (1980). Participant Observation,
  164. (2001). Pedagogy: a point of view’,
  165. (1984). Perspectives on the Training of Head Teachers and College Principals,
  166. (1979). Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature,
  167. (1972). Positions,
  168. (1998). Postscript’, in MacBeath,
  169. (1992). Preparation, Induction and Support for Newly Appointed Headteachers and Deputy Heads, The Mere,
  170. (1991). Primary headteachers and ERA two years on: The pace of change and its impact on schools’,
  171. (2002). Principal Training Courses,
  172. (2003). Principal Training Programs 2003-2004, Jerusalem: Yuval (in Hebrew).
  173. (1993). Principals for our Changing Schools: the Knowledge and Skill Base,
  174. (1997). Principals’ responses to incorporation and the new funding regime’,
  175. (1996). Problem-based learning in leadership education’,
  176. (1990). Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods, (2nd edn)
  177. (1992). Qualitative Research for Education: An Introduction to Theory and Methods,
  178. (1990). Qualitative Research in Teaching and Learning, Tel Aviv: Modan (in Hebrew).
  179. (1997). Quality and equality: competing or complementary objectives?’, in
  180. (1997). Reflection on leadership in self-managing schools’,
  181. (1996). Reflections on department mission and operations’, unpublished internal memorandum, Teachers College,
  182. (1990). Reinventing school leadership’, working memo prepared for the Renovating School Leadership Conference,
  183. (1986). Research Interviewing: Context and Narrative,
  184. (1994). Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, (2nd edn),
  185. (1988). Research Methods in Cultural Anthropology,
  186. (1990). Research on teaching and teacher research: the issues that divide’,
  187. Research Software for Web Surveys and Written Questionnaires, (Online – http://www.statpac.com/surveys/index.html#TOC, retrieved 20/08/2002).
  188. (1990). Researching Lived Experience: Human Science for an Action Sensitive Pedagogy,
  189. (1997). Resourcing education: linking budgeting to educational objectives’,
  190. (1995). Results of a national survey of educational leadership doctoral programs’,
  191. (1997). Rethinking the educational context – a re-engineering approach’,
  192. (1996). Retraining military officers as school principals’,
  193. (1989). School Administration as Craft,
  194. (2001). School Effectiveness and School Improvement: Alternative Perspectives,
  195. (1996). School Effectiveness and School-based Management: a Mechanism for Development,
  196. (1999). School leaders as learners: what attitudes and preferences do they have?’,
  197. (1987). School management training in the United Kingdom’, in
  198. (1998). School-based Management: A Change in School Management Culture, Jerusalem: Szold Institute (in Hebrew).
  199. (1975). Schoolteacher: a Sociological Study,
  200. (1980). Selection and training of secondary school senior staff: some
  201. (1999). Shaping School Culture,
  202. (1955). Skills of an effective administrator’,
  203. (1992). Social intelligence: Conception and methodological problems,
  204. (1998). Soldiers march to battles new, and ‘back to Blighty’, Times Educational Supplement,
  205. (1974). Some aspects of the “Headmaster tradition”: plus postscript’, in
  206. (1956). Some aspects of the “Headmaster tradition”’,
  207. (1998). Some comparative learnings from the study’, in MacBeath,
  208. (1997). Some moral dilemmas in educational management’,
  209. (1992). Sources of support for beginning principals’, in
  210. (1999). Speech to the New Heads Conference, (Online http://www.ncsl.org.UK/index.cfm?pageid=college-nhc1999-tb, retrieved 7/03/2004).
  211. (2000). Stages of self-directed learning (SSDL) model’, in Teaching Learners to be Self-Directed,
  212. Statistical Analysis,
  213. (1992). Students’ perceptions of the cohort model of instructional delivery’, Paper presented to the annual convention of
  214. (1994). Studying Your Own School: An Educator’s Guide to Qualitative Practitioner Research,
  215. (1990). Subjectivity and objectivity’,
  216. (1999). Support structures for schools, a teacher in-service training manual’, Integrating Students into Schools:
  217. (1978). Survey Research Practice,
  218. (1988). Systematic Data Collection,
  219. (1992). Taking Stock: A study of the Danforth programs for the preparation of school principals,
  220. (1988). Tales of the Field,
  221. (1997). Teacher professionalism and managerialism’,
  222. (1994). Teacher Research and Urban Literacy Education: Lessons and Conversations in a Feminist Key,
  223. (1990). Teacher Researcher,
  224. (1995). Teachers and researchers in collaboration: reflections on the process’,
  225. (1993). Teachers are Researchers: Reflection and Action,
  226. (1990). Teachers for our Nation’s Schools,
  227. (1986). Teaching as research’,
  228. (1989). Teamwork: What Can Go Right/What Can Go Wrong,
  229. (1996). The Administrative Portfolio Development Institute: A Training Manual,
  230. (1990). The Adult Learner: a Neglected Species (4th edn),
  231. (1995). The Age of Unreason,
  232. (1993). The brave new world of leadership training’,
  233. (2000). The changing role of principals’, an interview with Philip Hallinger published by
  234. (2002). The developing role of the headteacher in English schools management: leadership and pragmatism,
  235. (2001). The development of school leadership preparation programmes in England and the USA: a comparative analysis’,
  236. (1985). The Educational Imagination,
  237. (1991). The Empowered School: The Management and Practice of Development Planning,
  238. (1991). The Enlightened Eye: Qualitative Inquiry and the Enhancement of Educational Practice,
  239. (1979). The Ethnographic Interview,
  240. (2000). The Everchanging Organization,
  241. (1994). The Feminist Classroom,
  242. (1994). The feminization of the principalship in Israel’,
  243. (1990). The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organisation,
  244. (1986). The first 120 days’, Human Relations in Education 3,
  245. (1999). The forest and its roots’,
  246. (1982). The General Managers,
  247. (1998). The Headteacher as Effective Leader,
  248. (1996). The Human Side of School Change,
  249. (1992). The inner world of school principals: reflections on career life stages’,
  250. (1973). The Interpretation of Cultures,
  251. (1992). The Landscape of Leadership Preparation: Reframing the Education of School Administrators,
  252. (1987). The Making of British Managers: A report for the BIM and CBI into Management Training, Education and Development, Corby: British Institute of Management.
  253. (1992). The meaning of scholarly activity and the building of community’,
  254. (2001). The military response’,
  255. (1999). The National Professional Qualification for Headship: perceptions of the providers of taught higher degrees
  256. (1998). The National Professional Qualification for Headship: The key to effective school leadership?’,
  257. (1975). The nature and content of management’, in
  258. (1973). The Nature of Managerial Work,
  259. (1987). The Office of Educational Research and Improvement,
  260. (1997). The Organization of the Future,
  261. (1989). The Oxford English Dictionary, (2nd edn) Oxford:
  262. (1988). The politics of reforming school administration’,
  263. (1989). The preparation of educational administrators’,
  264. (1992). The preparation, selection and development of headteachers’,
  265. (1995). The Principalship: A Reflective Practice Perspective, (3rd edn) Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
  266. (2000). The principalship’,
  267. (1993). The prospective principal’s program at Stanford University’,
  268. (2000). The question of competence: the origins, strengths and inadequacies’,
  269. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner,
  270. (1964). The relation of theory to practice in education’,
  271. (2001). The role of the principal,
  272. (1998). The school leader’s view’,
  273. (1966). The Social Construction of Reality,
  274. (1995). The status of student cohorts in educational administration preparation programs’, Paper presented at the annual convention of the University Council for Educational Administration,
  275. (2002). The supply and demand trends of public secondary school administrators in South Carolina from
  276. (1991). The Tact of Teaching: The Meaning of Pedagogical Thoughtfulness,
  277. (1986). The task of leadership’, Leadership papers no. 2, Washington DC, Independent sector,
  278. (1986). The Tone of Teaching,
  279. (1997). The Transfer of Retired Officers as Mid Life for a Second Career in the Field of Education, Bait Berl: Bait Berl College Research Unit (in Hebrew).
  280. (1987). The vaunted school executive shortage: how serious is it?’,
  281. (1998). Time for a change’, in MacBeath,
  282. (1999). To the General Director Armchair, Tel Aviv: Marive (in Hebrew).
  283. (1999). Training and development of teachers in Israel’,
  284. (1982). Training for Heads (School Leaders)
  285. (1995). Training for Principalship: Directions and Implication, Jerusalem: Educational Policy Planning, Ministry of Education (in Hebrew).
  286. (1988). Training for School Management: lessons from the American experience, London: Institute of Education.
  287. (1987). Training programs for school leaders in Europe’,
  288. (2000). Training Programs for School Principals: Principles, Topics and Process, Jerusalem: Szold Institute (in Hebrew).
  289. (1994). Transformational leadership theory: Using levels of analysis to determine Boundary Conditions’, Personnel Psychology,
  290. (1995). Transformative Curriculum Leadership,
  291. (1994). Transforming Qualitative Data,
  292. (2002). Under the male umbrella’,
  293. (1992). Understanding Curriculum as Phenomenological and Deconstructed Text,
  294. (1993). Understanding Organizations,
  295. (1990). Understanding Schools as Organisations, (2nd edn)
  296. (1996). Using cohorts as a means for developing transformational leaders’,
  297. (1997). Using success criteria’, in
  298. (1990). Ways women lead’,
  299. (1998). What teachers, parents, governors and pupils want from their heads’,
  300. (1992). What we now know about leadership’, in
  301. (1997). What’s Worth Fighting for in Principalship,
  302. (1998). Who really runs the school?’, in MacBeath,
  303. (1999). Who will lead? The top 10 factors that influence teachers moving into administration’,
  304. (2000). Women in educational management: a leadership training programme for women in education in Ireland’, Oideas,
  305. (1996). Women’s place in educational administration: past, present and future’,
  306. (1986). Women’s Ways of Knowing: The Development of Self, Voice and Mind,
  307. (1988). Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.