Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Systematic review of economic evaluations and cost analyses of guideline implementation strategies

By Luke David Vale, Ruth Elizabeth Thomas, Graeme Stewart MacLennan and Jeremy Grimshaw

Abstract

Objectives To appraise the quality of economic studies undertaken as part of evaluations of guideline implementation strategies; determine their resources use; and recommend methods to improve future studies. Methods Systematic review of economic studies undertaken alongside robust study designs of clinical guideline implementation strategies published (1966-1998). Studies assessed against the BMJ economic evaluations guidelines for each stage of the guideline process (guideline development, implementation and treatment). Results 235 studies were identified, 63 reported some information on cost. Only 3 studies provided evidence that their guideline was effective and efficient. 38 reported the treatment costs only, 12 implementation and treatment costs, 11 implementation costs alone, and two guideline development, implementation and treatment costs. No study gave reasonably complete information on costs. Conclusions Very few satisfactory economic evaluations of guideline implementation strategies have been performed. Current evaluations have numerous methodological defects and rarely consider all relevant costs and benefits. Future evaluations should focus on evaluating the implementation of evidence based guidelines. Keywords: Cost-effectiveness analysis, physician (or health care professional) behaviour, practice guidelines, quality improvement, systematic review.Peer reviewedAuthor versio

Topics: Systematic Review, Cost-Benefit Analyses, Practice Guidelines, Cost-effectiveness analysis, physician (or health care professional) behaviour, quality improvement, RC Internal medicine
Publisher: Springer
Year: 2007
DOI identifier: 10.1007/s10198-007-0043-8
OAI identifier: oai:aura.abdn.ac.uk:2164/152
Journal:

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1978). 16: 962-70 6. Belcher DW. Implementing preventive services. Success and failure in an outpatient trial. doi
  2. (1995). A randomized trial of the effects of pharmacist intervention on the cost of antiemetic therapy with ondansetron. Support Care Cancer, 3, 183-9 MacCosbe PE, Gartenberg G doi
  3. (1992). A successful experiment to reduce unnecessary laboratory use in a community hospital. Med Care 1988; 26: 631-42 24. Gurwitz JH, Noonan JP, Soumerai SB. Reducing the use of H2-receptor antagonists in the long-term-care setting. doi
  4. (1996). Changing surgical antimicrobial prophylaxis practices through education targeted at senior department leaders. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol doi
  5. (1994). Diabetes Integrated Care Evaluation Team. BMJ doi
  6. (1991). Effect of a selective restriction policy on antibiotic expenditure and use: an institutional model. J Med Assoc Thai
  7. (1993). Effect of clinical guidelines on medical practice: A systematic review of rigorous evaluations. doi
  8. (1996). Effect of clinical pharmacy services on prescribing on an orthopedic unit. Am J Hosp Pharm 1983; 40: 1945-51 27. Hobbs
  9. (1992). Evaluation of a pneumonia practice guideline in an interventional trial. Am J Respir Crit Care Med,
  10. (1992). Guidelines for authors and peer-reviewers of economic submissions to the British Medical Journal.
  11. (1992). Guidelines for clinical practice: from development to use. Washington DC:
  12. (1994). Implementing clinical guidelines
  13. (1997). Medicare reimbursement for preventive care. Changes in performance of services, quality of life, and health care costs. Med Care,
  14. (2002). Methodological reviews of economic evaluations in health care.
  15. (1987). Methods for economic evaluation of health care programme. 1st Edition,
  16. (1997). Methods for economic evaluation of health care programme. 2nd Edition,
  17. (1995). Nursing home-acquired pneumonia: outcomes from a clinical process improvement program.
  18. (1998). Reducing vancomycin use utilizing a computer guideline: results of a randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Inform Assoc doi
  19. (1993). Reducing vancomycin use utilizing a computer guideline: results of a randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Inform Assoc 1998; 5: 554-62 51. Soumerai doi
  20. (1988). Reduction of incorrect antibiotic dosing through a structured educational order form. Arch Intern Med 1988; 148: 1720-4 3. Banks doi
  21. (1990). Should physicians perform their own quality assurance audits? doi
  22. (1990). Should physicians perform their own quality assurance audits? J Gen Intern Med 1998; 3: 560-5 8. Brufsky doi
  23. (2001). When is it cost-effective to change the behaviour of health professionals.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.