Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Using the literature to quantify the learning curve: a case study

By Jonathan Alistair Cook, Craig R Ramsay and Peter Fayers


Objective: To assess whether a literature review of a technology can allow a learning curve to be quantified. Methods: The literature for fibreoptic intubation was searched for studies reporting information relevant to the learning curve. The Cochrane Librar y, Medline, Embase and Science Citation index were searched. Studies that reported a procedure time were included. Data were abstracted on the three features of learning: initial level, rate of learning and asymptote level. Random effect meta-analysis was performed. Results: Only 21 studies gave explicit information concerning the previous experience of the operator(s). There were 32 different definitions of procedure time. From 4 studies of fibreoptic nasotracheal intubation, the mean starting level and time for the 10th procedure (95% confidence interval) was estimated to be 133s (113, 153) and 71s (62, 79) respectively. Conclusions: The review approach allowed learning to be quantified for our example technology. Poor and insufficient reporting constrained formal statistical estimation. Standardised reporting of non-drug techniques with adequate learning curve details is needed to inform trial design and costeffectiveness analysis

Topics: Clinical Competence, Learning, Systematic Review
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Year: 2007
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1995). A comparison of anesthetic techniques for awake intubation in neurosurgical patients. doi
  2. A comparison of the intubating laryngeal mask tracheal tube with a standard tracheal tube for fibreoptic intubation. Anaesthesia 2000;55:358- doi
  3. A training programme for fibreoptic nasotracheal intubation. Use of model and live patients. doi
  4. Acquisition and maintenance of endoscopic skills: dexterity training system for anesthesiologists. doi
  5. (1999). An alternative method to intubate with laryngeal mask and see-through-bougie. doi
  6. (1998). Assessment of learning of tracheal intubation with a new rigid fibreoptic laryngoscope (UpsherScope (TM)). Annales Francaises d Anesthesie Et De Reanimation doi
  7. (1995). Awake endotracheal intubation in patients with cervical spine disease: a comparison of the Bullard laryngoscope and the fiberoptic bronchoscope. Anesthesia & Analgesia doi
  8. Cardiovascular effects of fibrescope-guided nasotracheal intubation. doi
  9. (1989). Cardiovascular responses to tracheal intubation: a comparison of direct lar yngoscopy and fibreoptic intubation. Anaesth Intensive Care
  10. (1999). Clinical assessment of a plastic optical fiber stylet for human tracheal intubation. Anesthesiology doi
  11. Clinical assessment of a plastic optical fiber stylet for human tracheal intubation. Anesthesiology 1999;91:648- doi
  12. Clinical competence in the performance of fiberoptic laryngoscopy and endotracheal intubation: A study of resident instruction. doi
  13. (1997). Clinical trial of a new device for fiberoptic orotracheal intubation (Augustine Scope(TM)). Anesthesia & Analgesia doi
  14. (1995). Comparison between two fibrescopes with different diameter insertion cords for fibreoptic intubation. Anaesthesia doi
  15. (1991). Comparison of orthodox with fibreoptic orotracheal intubation under total i.v. anaesthesia. doi
  16. Comparison of two methods of fibrescope-guided tracheal intubation. doi
  17. (1998). Correlating fibreoptic nasotracheal endoscopy performance and psychomotor aptitude. doi
  18. Cricoid pressure applied after placement of laryngeal mask impedes subsequent fibreoptic tracheal intubation through mask. doi
  19. (1999). Cuffed oropharyngeal airway (COPA) as an adjunct to fibreoptic tracheal intubation. doi
  20. Ease of tracheal intubation through the intubating laryngeal mask during manual in-line head and neck stabilisation. doi
  21. (1997). Effect of the size of a tracheal tube and the efficacy of the use of the laryngeal mask for fibrescope-aided tracheal intubation. Anaesthesia doi
  22. Efficiency of a new fiberoptic stylet scope in tracheal intubation. doi
  23. Emergency flexible fiberoptic nasotracheal intubation: A report of 60 cases. doi
  24. (1994). Evaluation of the Bullard laryngoscope using the new intubating stylet: Comparison with conventional laryngoscopy. doi
  25. (1996). Evaluation of the Upsherscope. A new rigid fibrescope. Anaesthesia doi
  26. (1996). Fiberoptic intubation using anesthetized, paralyzed, apneic patients. Results of a resident training program. doi
  27. Fiberoptic nasotracheal intubation - incidence and causes of failure. doi
  28. (2000). Fibre-optic aided bougie (FAB) for simulated difficult tracheal intubation. Ann Acad Med Singap
  29. (1994). Fibreoptic intubation. doi
  30. for the CONSORT Group. The CONSORT Statement: Revised Recommendations for Improving the Quality of Reports of Parallel-Group Randomized Trials. doi
  31. (1994). Haemodynamic response to fibreoptic versus laryngoscopic nasotracheal intubation under total intravenous anaesthesia. doi
  32. Heart rate and arterial pressure changes during fibreoptic tracheal intubation under general anaesthesia. doi
  33. Intubating laryngeal mask for fibreoptic intubation - particularly useful during neck stabilization. doi
  34. (1997). Learning curves for fibreoptic nasotracheal intubation when using the endoscopic video camera. Anaesthesia doi
  35. (2000). Learning fibreoptic endoscopy - Nasotracheal or orotracheal intubations first? Anaesthesia doi
  36. Learning fibreoptic endoscopy - Nasotracheal or orotracheal intubations first?. doi
  37. (1996). Learning fibreoptic skills in ear, nose and throat clinics. Anaesthesia doi
  38. (1986). Meta-analysis in clinical trials. doi
  39. (1998). Nasotracheal intubation in patients with immobilized cervical spine: a comparison of tracheal tube cuff inflation and fiberoptic bronchoscopy. doi
  40. (2005). Need for expertise based randomised controlled trials. BMJ doi
  41. (2003). Prospective randomised controlled trial of laparoscopic versus open inguinal hernia mesh repair: Five year follow up. BMJ doi
  42. (2002). Randomised trials in surgery: Problems and possible solutions. BMJ doi
  43. Statistical assessment of the learning curves of health technologies.
  44. Statistical evaluation of learning effects in surgical trials.
  45. Teaching fibreoptic intubation in anaesthetised patients. doi
  46. (1994). Teaching fibreoptic intubation. Effect of alfentanil on the haemodynamic response. Anaesthesia doi
  47. (1993). Teaching fibreoptic nasotracheal intubation with and without closed circuit television. doi
  48. Teaching guided fibreoptic nasotracheal intubation. An assessment of an anaesthetic technique to aid training. doi
  49. (1999). The intubating laryngeal mask airway in fresh cadavers vs. paralysed anesthetised patients. doi
  50. (1999). The intubating laryngeal mask airway with and without fiberoptic guidance. doi
  51. (1998). The laryngeal mask airway as an aid to training in fibreoptic nasotracheal endoscopy. Anaesthesia doi
  52. (1997). The UpsherScope(TM) in routine and difficult airway management: A randomized, controlled clinical trial. doi
  53. (1992). Tracheal intubation in patients with cervical spine injuries using a fiber optic laryngoscope. Annales Francaises d Anesthesie Et De Reanimation doi
  54. (1991). Training in fibreoptic laryngoscopy. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.