Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Community Hospitals - the place of local service provision in a modernising NHS : an integrative thematic literature review

By David Heaney, Corri Black, Catherine A. O'Donnell, Cameron Stark and Edwin R. van Teijlingen

Abstract

Background: Recent developments within the United Kingdom's (UK) health care system have re-awakened interest in community hospitals (CHs) and their role in the provision of health care. This integrative literature review sought to identify and assess the current evidence base for CHs. Methods: A range of electronic reference databases were searched from January 1984 to either December 2004 or February 2005: Medline, Embase, Web of Knowledge, BNI, CINAHL, HMIC, ASSIA, PsychInfo, SIGLE, Dissertation Abstracts, Cochrane Library, Kings Fund website, using both keywords and text words. Thematic analysis identified recurrent themes across the literature; narrative analyses were written for each theme, identifying unifying concepts and discrepant issues. Results: The search strategy identified over 16,000 international references. We included papers of any study design focussing on hospitals in which care was led principally by general practitioners or nurses. Papers from developing countries were excluded. A review of titles revealed 641 potentially relevant references; abstract appraisal identified 161 references for review. During data extraction, a further 48 papers were excluded, leaving 113 papers in the final review. The most common methodological approaches were cross-sectional/descriptive studies, commentaries and expert opinion. There were few experimental studies, systematic reviews, economic studies or studies that reported on longer-term outcomes. The key themes identified were origin and location of CHs; their place in the continuum of care; services provided; effectiveness, efficiency and equity of CHs; and views of patients and staff. In general, there was a lack of robust evidence for the role of CHs, which is partly due to the ad hoc nature of their development and lack of clear strategic vision for their future. Evidence for the effectiveness and efficiency of the services provided was limited. Most people admitted to CHs appeared to be older, suggesting that admittance to CHs was age-related rather than condition-related. Conclusion: Overall the literature surveyed was long on opinion and short of robust studies on CHs. While lack of evidence on CHs does not imply lack of effect, there is an urgent need to develop a research agenda that addresses the key issues of health care delivery in the CH setting.The Scottish School of Primary Car

Topics: Community health, hospitals
Publisher: BMC Public Health
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:aura.abdn.ac.uk:2164/146

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2005). A National framework for service change in NHS Scotland: Building a Health Service fit for the future.
  2. (2003). A partnership for a better Scotland. Edinburgh, Scottish Executive;
  3. (1996). A team approach to the audit of nutritional care in community hospitals.
  4. (2004). A: Integrative approaches to qualitative and quantitative evidence. NHS Health Development Agency,
  5. (2005). A: Synthesising qualitative and quantiative evidence: a review of possible methods.
  6. (2000). A: Telemedicine use in two nurse-led minor injuries units.
  7. (2005). Association BM: Healthcare in a rural setting.
  8. (2002). Audit of a collaborative care model suggests patients with acute myocardial infarction are not disadvantaged by treatment in a rural hospital. New Zealand Medical Journal
  9. (1984). Audit of surgical practice in a community hospital.
  10. (2001). Clinical profile and management of heart failure: rural community hospital vs. metropolitan heart center.
  11. (1998). Community hospital-issues for older people. Elderly Care
  12. (2001). Community hospitals and older people.
  13. (1989). Community hospitals: a review of role and function.
  14. (1998). Community hospitals: new wine in old bottles?
  15. (1990). Community hospitals: preparing for the future. London, Royal College of General Practitioners;
  16. (1995). Community hospitals.
  17. (1999). Community hospitals. Cornish hops.
  18. (1998). Community hospitals. Delivering the goods. Health Serv J
  19. (1987). Comparison of outcome of lowrisk labour in an isolated general practice maternity unit and a specialist maternity hospital.
  20. (1997). Contribution of community hospitals in East Devon to cancer workload. Health Trends
  21. (2005). Creating a patient led NHS:Delivering the NHS improvement plan.
  22. Developing primary care in Scotland. In Scotland's health and health services. Edited by: Woods
  23. Distance learning.
  24. (1986). Do general practitioner hospitals extend primary care?
  25. (1988). End of an experiment: report from an inner city community hospital.
  26. (1985). Example of intermediate care: the new Lambeth Community Care Centre. Br Med J
  27. (1986). General practitioner beds in Finland - lessons for the UK?
  28. (2001). Internetbased videoconferencing for physical rehabilitation consultations.
  29. (2004). Keeping the NHS local: a new direction of travel. London, Department of Health;
  30. (1984). Love DR: Terminal care: the role of the general practitioner hospital.
  31. (1986). Muir-Gray JA: Community hospitals in Oxfordshire: Their effect on the use of specialist inpatient services.
  32. (2006). Our health, our care, our community: Investing in the future of community hospitals and services. Leeds, Department of Health;
  33. (1999). Palliative care in community hospitals in the Borders.
  34. (2004). Pressure mounts over European Working Time Directive. Br Med J
  35. (2001). Rediscovering community hospitals.
  36. (1996). Respite care in an intermediate care centre: the views of patients and carers.
  37. (2003). S: An evaluation of a telemedicine fracture review clinic.
  38. (2004). S: Evaluation of an accident and emergency teleconsultation service for northeast Scotland.
  39. (2001). Seamark C: Community hospitals for the new millennium.
  40. (2004). Six month outcomes after emergency admission of elderly patients to a community or a district general hospital. Fam Pract
  41. (1987). SW: Outcome of women booked into an isolated general practice maternity unit over eight years.
  42. (1994). The influence of general practitioner community hospitals on the place of death of cancer patients. Palliat Med
  43. (2004). The NHS Improvement Plan: Putting people at the heart of public services. The Stationary Office, Department of Health;
  44. (1987). The role and function of community hospitals.
  45. (1983). The role of the cottage hospital in the UK. Ecology of Disease
  46. (1984). WE: First year of an inner city general practitioner community hospital.
  47. (1991). Why we need community hospitals for the elderly. Geriatric Medicine

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.