Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Stereoscopic 3D Technologies for Accurate Depth Tasks:\ud A Theoretical and Empirical Study



In the last decade an increasing number of application fields, including medicine, geoscience and bio-chemistry, have expressed a need to visualise and interact with data that are inherently three-dimensional. Stereoscopic 3D technologies can offer a valid support for these operations thanks to the enhanced depth representation they can provide. However, there is still little understanding of how such technologies can be used effectively to support\ud the performance of visual tasks based on accurate depth judgements. Existing studies do not provide a sound and complete explanation of the impact of different visual and\ud technical factors on depth perception in stereoscopic 3D environments.\ud \ud This thesis presents a new interpretative and contextualised analysis of the vision science literature to clarify the role of di®erent visual cues on human depth perception in such environments. The analysis identifies luminance contrast, spatial frequency, colour, blur,\ud transparency and depth constancies as influential visual factors for depth perception and provides the theoretical foundation for guidelines to support the performance of accurate stereoscopic depth tasks.\ud \ud A novel assessment framework is proposed and used to conduct an empirical study to evaluate the performance of four distinct classes of 3D display technologies. The results suggest that 3D displays are not interchangeable and that the depth representation provided can vary even between displays belonging to the same class. The study also shows that interleaved displays may suffer from a number of aliasing artifacts, which in turn may affect the amount of perceived depth.\ud \ud The outcomes of the analysis of the influential visual factors for depth perception and the empirical comparartive study are used to propose a novel universal 3D cursor prototype suitable to support depth-based tasks in stereoscopic 3D environments. The contribution includes a number of both qualitative and quantitative guidelines that aim to guarantee a correct perception of depth in stereoscopic 3D environments and that should be observed\ud when designing a stereoscopic 3D cursor

Topics: Depth Perception, Stereo, Three-Dimensional Display, 3D Cursor, Evaluation, Methodology
Year: 2011
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Durham e-Theses

Suggested articles


  1. (2002). 100 million-voxel volumetric display. doi
  2. (2003). 2D/3D switchable displays.
  3. (2004). 3D direct manipulation interface by human body posture and gaze.
  4. (1994). 3D direct manipulation interface: Development of the Zashiki-Warashi system. doi
  5. (1999). 3D display systems hardware research at sharp laboratories of europe: an update.
  6. (2001). 3D surgery trainer with force feedback in minimally invasive surgery.
  7. (2005). 3D User Interfaces: Theory and Practice.
  8. (2009). A benchmarked automated progress measurement system for haptic motor rehabilitation. doi
  9. (2008). A comparative study of ¯ne depth perception on two-view 3D displays. doi
  10. (1991). A comparison of stereoscopic cursors for the interactive manipulation of B-splines. doi
  11. (1995). A contrast ratio constraint on stereo matching. doi
  12. (1987). A new sense for depth of ¯eld.
  13. (1993). A perturbation analysis of depth perception from combinations of texture and motion cues. doi
  14. (2009). A reevaluation of the tolerance to vertical misalignment in stereopsis. doi
  15. (2004). A stereotactic method for image-guided transcranial magnetic stimulation validated with fMRI and motor-evoked potentials. doi
  16. (1932). A technique for the measurement of attitudes. doi
  17. (1919). A test for the judgement of distance.
  18. Ä Uber ein neues pseudokoptisches bewegungs phanomen.
  19. (2008). A unique research platform,
  20. (1974). Achromatic color conditions in the perception of transparency. Perception: doi
  21. (2008). Age-related changes in optical and biometric characteristics of emmetropic eyes. doi
  22. (2005). Amblyopia: Prevalence, natural history, functional e®ects and treatment. doi
  23. (1970). An algebraic development of the theory of perceptual transparency. doi
  24. (1992). An algorithm to support 3D interaction on relatively low performance graphics systems. doi
  25. (2007). An augmented reality human-computer interface for object localization in a cognitive vision system. doi
  26. An evaluation of depth perception on volumetric displays. doi
  27. Analysis of performance of a °at panel display system convertible between 2D and autostereoscopic 3D modes. doi
  28. (1989). Applicability of infrared photorefraction for measurement of accommodation in awake-behaving normal and strabismic monkeys. doi
  29. (1989). Application of a perspective cursor as a 3D locator device. doi
  30. (2008). Assessment of qualitative stereo viewing and quantitative mapping of optic disc using polarized goggles verses autostereoscopic screen. doi
  31. Attention funnel: Omnidirectional 3D cursor for mobile augmented reality platforms. doi
  32. (1999). Aurally aided visual search in threedimensional space. doi
  33. (2005). Autostereoscopic 3D displays: bringing imax to the desktop?
  34. (2005). Autostereoscopic desktop display: an evolution of technology. doi
  35. (1969). Basic Color Terms: Their Universality and Evolution. doi
  36. (1991). Basic principles of stereographic software development. doi
  37. (2008). Beowulf 3D: a case study. doi
  38. (2009). Binocular depth discrimination and estimation beyond interaction space. doi
  39. (1989). Binocular fusion limits are independent of contrast, luminance gradient and component phases. doi
  40. (2001). Binocular Vision and Ocular Motility: Theory and Management of Strabismus - Sixth Edition. doi
  41. (1991). Bistability of point-light biological motion and necker cubes under stereoscopic and perspective depth cues. Perception 37 ECVP Abstract Supplement,
  42. (2005). Block Design: Analysis, Combinatorics And Applications. World Scienti¯c Publishing, doi
  43. (1928). Certain topics in telegraph transmission theory. doi
  44. (1988). Changes in accommodation with age: static and dynamic. doi
  45. (1991). Color in visual search. doi
  46. (1993). Color stereopsis: a model for depth reversals based on border contrast. doi
  47. (2005). Colour helps to solve the binocular matching problem. doi
  48. (1992). Colour inputs to random-dot stereopsis. doi
  49. (1993). Colour is what the eye sees best. doi
  50. (2004). Combining depth cues: e®ects upon accuracy and speed of performance in a depth-ordering task. doi
  51. (1949). Communication in the presence of noise. doi
  52. (1990). Comparison of depth cues for relative depth judgements. doi
  53. (1998). Conditions for perceptual transparency. doi
  54. (1994). Contrast as a depth cue. doi
  55. (2000). Contrast gain control in the visual cortex: Monocular versus binocular mechanisms. doi
  56. Contribution to the physiology of vision. - Part the ¯rst. On some remarkable, and hitherto unobserved, phenomena of the binocular vision. doi
  57. (2001). Controlling perceived depth in stereoscopic images. doi
  58. (1970). Correcting interperspective aliasing in autostereoscopic displays. doi
  59. (2002). Depth cue integration: stereopsis and image blur. doi
  60. (2010). Depth cues in human visual perception and their realization in 3D displays. doi
  61. (1988). Depth determination on stereoscopic digital subtraction angiograms. doi
  62. (1987). Depth from focus.
  63. (2000). Depth perception in computer graphics.
  64. (1991). Development of a stereoscopic three-dimensional drawing application. doi
  65. (1915). Developments in autostereoscopic technology at dimension technologies inc. doi
  66. (2002). Di®erential binocular input and local stereopsis. doi
  67. (2005). Discovering Statistics by Using SPSS - Second Edition. doi
  68. (1983). Disparity range for local stereopsis as a function of luminance spatial frequency. doi
  69. (2004). Do we need stereoscopic displays for 3D augmented reality target selection tasks? doi
  70. (1998). Dresden 3D display (D4D). doi
  71. (1995). Dynamic stereo displays. doi
  72. (1998). E®ects of cue context on the perception of depth from combined disparity and perspective cues. doi
  73. (1990). E®ects of Depth Cues on Depth Judgements Using a Field-Sequential Stereoscopic CRT Display.
  74. (1967). E®ects of exposure duration, cue reduction, and temporary monocularity on size matching at short distances. doi
  75. (1997). E®ects of image resolution on depth perception in stereo and non-stereo images. doi
  76. (1959). Echoes of bats and men. Doubleday Publishing Group - Anchor Books,
  77. (2009). Evaluating methods for controlling depth perception in stereoscopic cinematography. doi
  78. (2007). Evaluating the usability of an autostereoscopic display. doi
  79. (2005). Evidence for the formal equivalence between emmert's law and size-distance invariance hypothesis. doi
  80. (2000). Explaining the moon illusion. doi
  81. (1993). Facile 3D direct manipulation. doi
  82. (1987). Factors a®ecting ghosting in a time-multiplexed plano-stereoscopic CRT display system. In Three-dimensional visualization and display technologies, doi
  83. Flat panel autostereoscopic displays: characterisation and enhancement. doi
  84. (1971). Foundations of Cyclopean Perception. doi
  85. (1992). Further advances in autostereoscopic technology at dimension technologies inc. doi
  86. (1993). Geometric considerations for stereoscopic virtual environments.
  87. GrÄ ossenverhÄ altnisse der Nachbilder. Klinische MonatsblÄ atter fÄ ur Augenheilkunde,
  88. (2006). Handbook of Optoelectronics, volume II, chapter Three-Dimensional Display Systems. Taylor & Francis,
  89. (2002). Handbook of Virtual Environments: Design, Implementation, and Applications, chapter Vision and Virtual Environments, doi
  90. (2005). Head-mounted diplay and optical engine thereof.
  91. (1996). Head-tracked stereo viewing with two-handed 3D interaction for animated character construction. doi
  92. (1988). How contrast a®ects stereoacuity. doi
  93. (1996). Image blur as a pictorial depth cue. doi
  94. (2000). Image distortions in stereoscopic video systems. doi
  95. (1988). Implementation of true 3-D cursors in computer graphics. doi
  96. (2005). Implementing an improved stereoscopic camera model.
  97. (2002). In°uence of chromaticity on vernier and stereo acuity. doi
  98. (2004). Information Visualization: Perception for Design. doi
  99. (1993). Integration of depth modules: stereopsis and texture. doi
  100. (1994). Integration of stereopsis and motion shape cues. doi
  101. (2004). Interaction of color and geometric cues in depth perception: When does red mean near? doi
  102. (2002). Interactions between chromatic- and luminancecontrast-sensitive stereopsis mechanisms. doi
  103. (1997). Interactions of spatial frequency and unequal monocular contrasts in stereopsis. doi
  104. (1915). Interactive design of rational bezier tensor product surfaces in stereo. doi
  105. (1991). Interocular correlation, luminance contrast and cyclopean processing. doi
  106. (2010). Investigating the performance of path searching tasks in depth on multiview displays. doi
  107. (2001). Investigation of surface characteristic e®ects on real-virtual object alignment in stereoscopic augmented reality. doi
  108. (1996). Issues in the design of studies to test the e®ectiveness of stereo imaging. doi
  109. (1997). Lightweight, compact 2D/3D autostereoscopic LCD backlight for games, monitor, and notebook applications. doi
  110. (1990). Limits of fusion and depth judgements in stereoscopic color displays. doi
  111. (1988). Minimodularity and the perception of layout.
  112. (2009). Multimodal selection techniques for dense and occluded 3D virtual environments. doi
  113. (2004). Multirate Signal Processing for Communication Systems. doi
  114. (1933). New studies in transparency, form and color. Psychologische Forschung, doi
  115. (2001). Novel 3D stereoscopic imaging technology. In Stereoscopic Displays and Virtual Reality Systems, doi
  116. Observations on some remarkable phenomena seen in Switzerland: and on an optical phenomenon which occurs when viewing a ¯gure of a crystal or geometrical solid. London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine and doi
  117. (1996). Occlusion edge blur: a cue to relative visual depth. doi
  118. (1999). On the apparent collapse of stereopsis in random-dot-stereograms at isoluminance. doi
  119. (1997). On the independence of chromatic and achromatic stereopsis mechanisms. doi
  120. (1998). Optical system for the two- and three-dimensional representation of information.
  121. (1979). Organization in Vision: Essays on Gestalt Perception.
  122. (2001). Parallax barrier for an autostereoscopic display. United Kingdom Patent No.
  123. (2004). Perception of 3D spatial relations for 3D displays. doi
  124. (2002). Perception-based synthetic cueing for night-vision device rotorcraft hover operations. doi
  125. (2005). Perceptual attributes of crosstalk in 3D images. doi
  126. (2000). Performance of a convertible 2D and 3D parallax barrier autostereoscopic display. doi
  127. (2004). Pointing at trivariate targets in 3D environments. doi
  128. (1991). Positioning accuracy of a virtual stereographic pointer in a real stereoscopic video world. doi
  129. (1985). Properties of stimuli eliciting vergence eye movements and stereopsis. doi
  130. (1987). Psychophysical evidence for separate channels for the perception of form, color, movement, and depth. doi
  131. (1948). Quantitative relations among vernier, real depth, and stereoscopic depth acuities. doi
  132. Ray casting for modeling solids. doi
  133. (1999). Reduced thickness backlighter for autostereoscopic display and display using the backlighter. United States Patent No.
  134. (2001). Richer color experience in observers with multiple photopigment opsin genes. doi
  135. (1990). Salience of chromatic basic color terms con¯rmed by three measures. doi
  136. Sciences. Mmoires de Mathmatique et de physique prsents par Divers Savants,
  137. (2002). Seeing in Depth, doi
  138. (2002). Seeing in Depth, volume 1 - Basic Mechanisms, chapter Binocular fusion and rivalry,
  139. (2002). Seeing in Depth, volume 1 - Basic Mechanisms, chapter Vergence eye movement.
  140. (2001). Selected papers on three-dimensional displays, volume 162 of Spie Press Monograph. SPIE Optical Engineering Press,
  141. (1974). Sight and Mind: An Introduction to Visual Perception. doi
  142. (1940). Signi¯cance test for sphericity on a normal n-variate distribution. doi
  143. (1999). Size constancy and angular size matching in size perception of near objects. doi
  144. (1963). Sketchpad: A Man-Machine Graphical Communication System. doi
  145. (2005). Spatial 3-D infrastructure: Display-independent software framework, high-speed rendering electronics, and several new displays. doi
  146. (1997). Spatial scale in stereo and shape from shading: Image input, mechanisms, and tasks. doi
  147. (1998). Spatial-frequency and contrast tuning of the transient-stereopsis system. doi
  148. (2002). Spatial-temporal antialiasing. doi
  149. (2004). Spatiotemporally multiplexed integral imaging projector for large-scale high-resolution three-dimensional display. doi
  150. (2010). Stereo 3D mouse cursor: A method for interaction with 3D objects in a stereoscopic virtual 3D space. doi
  151. (1993). Stereo Computer Graphics and Other True 3D Technologies, chapter 1 -Introduction, doi
  152. (1993). Stereo Computer Graphics and Other True 3D Technologies, chapter 2 - Composition for Electrostereoscopic Displays,
  153. (1993). Stereo Computer Graphics and Other True 3D Technologies, chapter 4 - Visual and Perceptual Issues in Stereoscopic Color Displays,
  154. (1996). Stereoacuity and colour contrast. doi
  155. (1985). Stereoacuity degradation by experimental and real monocular and binocular amblyopia.
  156. (1989). Stereopsis and contrast. doi
  157. (1970). Stereopsis and stereoblindness. doi
  158. (1989). Stereopsis at isoluminance in the absence of chromatic aberrations. doi
  159. (2007). Stereoscopic display.
  160. (1927). Studies in Optics.
  161. (1993). Surround-screen projection-based virtual reality, the design and implementation of the cave. doi
  162. (1995). Synthetic image generation for a multiple-view autostereo display. PhD thesis,
  163. (1977). The aliasing problem in computer-generated shaded images. doi
  164. (1984). The analysis of stereopsis. doi
  165. (2006). The beam cursor: A pen-based technique for enhancing target acquisition. doi
  166. (2001). The British journal of ophthalmology, 85(11):1347{1351, doi
  167. (1965). The colour stereoscopic e®ect. doi
  168. (2006). The design and evaluation of selection techniques for 3D volumetric displays. doi
  169. (1999). The e®ects of contrast on perceived depth and depth discrimination. doi
  170. (1954). The information capacity of the human motor system in controlling the amplitude of movement. doi
  171. (1996). The interaction of binocular disparity and motion parallax in the computation of depth. doi
  172. (1990). The interaction of chromostereopsis and stereopsis in stereoscopic CRT displays. doi
  173. (2002). The interpolation of object and surface structure. doi
  174. (1988). The metric cursor. doi
  175. (2004). The moon illusion explained. Web site last visited on 30/03/2009,
  176. The omnidirectional attention funnel: A dynamic 3D cursor for mobile augmented reality systems. doi
  177. (1996). The partial-occlusion e®ect: utilizing semitransparency in 3D human-computer interaction. doi
  178. (2002). The perception of breast cancers: What di®erentiates missed from reported cancers in mammography? doi
  179. (1974). The perception of transparency. doi
  180. (1908). The probable error of a mean. doi
  181. (2001). The role of chromatic contrast and luminance polarity in stereoscopic segmentation. doi
  182. (2006). The role of occlusion in the perception of depth, lightness, and opacity. doi
  183. The Visual Neurosciences, volume 2, chapter 57 - Color Appearance,
  184. (2003). The visual neurosciences, volume 2, chapter 58 - Chromatic discrimination,
  185. (2003). The visual neurosciences, volume 2, chapter 59 - The role of colour in spatial vision,
  186. (2003). The visual neurosciences, volume 2, chapter 86 - The perceptual organization of depth,
  187. (2011). Three-dimensional displays: A review and applications analysis. doi
  188. (2006). Three-dimensional interaction with autostereoscopic displays. doi
  189. (1996). Time-multiplexed color autostereoscopic display. doi
  190. (2002). Toward a perceptual theory of transparency. doi
  191. Translation of dutour (1760) [on-line]. Available: oshea/WebPubs/dutour60.html, 1999a. Web site last visited on 31/05/2010.
  192. Translation of dutour (1763) [on-line]. Available: oshea/WebPubs/dutour63.html, 1999b. Web site last visited on 31/05/2010.
  193. (2008). Trichromatic reconstruction from the interleaved cone mosaic: Bayesian model and the color appearance of small spots. doi
  194. (2000). Unconstrained stereoscopic matching of lines. doi
  195. (2005). Unlocking the spatial dimension: digital technologies and the future of geoscience ¯eldwork. doi
  196. (2001). User experience with alignment of real and virtual objects in a stereoscopic augmented reality interface. doi
  197. (2004). Variation and extrema of human interpupillary distance. doi
  198. (2008). Vergence-accommodation con°icts hinder visual performance and cause visual fatigue. doi
  199. (1984). Vertical image registration in stereopsis. doi
  200. (1999). Vision Science: Photons to Phenomenology. doi
  201. (1982). Vision: A Computational Investigation into the Human Representation and Processing of Visual Information. doi
  202. (2004). Visual comfort of binocular and 3D displays. doi
  203. (2009). Visual discomfort and visual fatigue of stereoscopic displays: A review. doi
  204. (2003). Visual perception: physiology, psychology & ecology. Psychology Press, fourth edition,
  205. (2008). Visual Thinking for Design. Morgan Kaufmann Series in Interactive Technologies.
  206. (1921). Visuell wahrgenommene Figuren - Studien in psychologischer Analyse. Gyldendal, ¯rst edition, doi
  207. (2002). Volumetric three-dimensional display architecture. doi
  208. (2005). Wiley Encyclopaedia on Imaging Science and Technology, volume II,
  209. (2002). X-rooms: a PC-based immersive visualization environment.
  210. (2000). Zur Farbenlehre. TÄ ubingen, 1810.BIBLIOGRAPHY 245

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.