Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Feasibility of high frequency alternating current power distribution for the automobile auxiliary electrical system

By C. C. Antaloae

Abstract

This study investigates the feasibility and potential benefits of high frequency alternating current (HFAC) for vehicle auxiliary electrical systems. A 100Vrms, 50kHz sinusoidal AC bus is compared with 14V DC and 42V DC electrical systems in terms of mass and energy efficiency. The investigation is focused on the four main sub-systems of an on-board electrical network, namely: the power generation, power distribution, power conversion and the electrical loads. In addition, a systemlevel inquiry is conducted for the HFAC bus and a comparable 42V DC system. A combination of computer simulation, analytical analysis and experimental work has highlighted benefits for the HFAC power distribution sub-system and for low-torque motor actuators. Specifically, the HFAC conductor mass is potentially 70% and 30% lighter than comparable 14V DC and 42V DC cables, respectively. Also, the proposed cable is expected to be at least 80% more energy efficient than the current DC conductor technology. In addition, it was found that 400Hz AC machines can successfully replace DC motor actuators with a rated torque of up to 2Nm. The former are up to 100% more efficient and approximately 60% lighter and more compact than the existing DC motors in vehicles. However, it is argued that the HFAC supply is not feasible for high-torque motor actuators. This is because of the high energy losses and increased machine torque ripple associated with the use of HFAC power. The HFAC power conversion sub-system offers benefits in terms of simple power converter structure and efficient HFAC/DC converters. However, a significant limitation is the high power loss within HFAC/AC modules, which can be as high as 900W for a 2.4kW load with continuous operation. Similar restrictions are highlighted for the HFAC power generation sub-system, where up to 400W is lost in a 4kW DC/HFAC power module. The conclusion of the present work is that the HFAC system offers mass and energy efficiency benefits for the conventional vehicle by leveraging the use of compact lowtorque motor actuators and lightweight wiring technology

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 2011
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/6792
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2005). (a, b) show typical DC voltage and current drive circuits, respectively (Emadi,
  2. (2003). 42 V architecture for automobiles. doi
  3. (2004). 42 Volts - The View from Today. IN ASSOCIATION,
  4. (2006). 90In particular for the application described by
  5. (1989). A 20 kHz hybrid resonant power source for the space station. Aerospace and Electronic Systems, doi
  6. (2000). A Dual/High-Voltage Automotive Electrical Power System with Superior Transient Performance.
  7. (1996). A history of automobile electrical systems.
  8. (2004). A Low Torque Ripple PMSM Drive for EPS Applications. doi
  9. (1999). A new space vector modulation technique for inverter control. doi
  10. (2003). A semiintegrated sensorless PM brushless drive for a 42 V automotive HVAC compressor. doi
  11. (2003). A single phase high frequency AC microgrid with an unified power quality conditioner. doi
  12. (1992). A study of single-phase to three-phase cycloconverters using PSPICE. Industrial Electronics, doi
  13. (1988). A versatile power converter for high-frequency link systems. Power Electronics, doi
  14. (1993). AC/DC converter topologies for the Space Station. Aerospace and Electronic Systems, doi
  15. (2000). Active Filters with Control Based on the p-q Theory.
  16. (2004). Additional issues with 14/42V DC architectures reported in the literature include (Keim,
  17. (2002). AP32029 - Peak and Hold Current Shape Generated by TriCore Derivative TC 1775. Infineon Technologies.
  18. (2000). are illustrated in Figures 6.2, 6.3 and 6.4, respectively (Caliskan,
  19. (2006). Automotive Electrical Actuation Technologies. doi
  20. (1996). Automotive electrical systems circa doi
  21. (2010). based on the analysis presented in Chapter 5, an energy loss of approximately 10% can be attributed to the DC/HFAC module. This claim isg supported by efficiency figures in the order of 90% for commercially-available DC/AC inverters (Sinergex,
  22. (2004). Bosch automotive handbook. BOSCHMOTORS doi
  23. (2008). Cable designed by Juice Technology Ltd.
  24. (1998). Can an AC (alternating current) electrical system replace the present DC system in the automobile? An investigative feasibility study. I. System architecture. Vehicular Technology, doi
  25. (1998). Can an AC (alternating current) electrical system replace the present DC system in the automobile? An investigative feasibility study. II. Comparison and tradeoffs. Vehicular Technology, doi
  26. (2008). Characteristic Analysis of Interior Permanent-Magnet Synchronous Motor in Electrohydraulic Power Steering Systems. doi
  27. (1996). Characteristic Power levels Power levels Power levels Low Medium High Current [A] 100-200 200-300 300-400 EMF at load [V] 12 10.5-12 9-10.5 Time at load [s] 15-30 8-15 4-8 Calculated Power Avg.
  28. (1982). Comparative Study of the Losses in Voltage and Current Source Inverter Fed Induction Motors. Industry Applications, doi
  29. (2004). Comparison and review of electric machines for integrated starter alternator applications. doi
  30. (1996). Component development for a high-frequency AC distributed power system. doi
  31. (1999). Current status and future trends in More Electric Car power systems. Vehicular Technology Conference, doi
  32. (2008). Datasheet, Aluminium Capacitors, Document number 91000.
  33. DCR=0.29m# Cp,Cs 440 nF Transformer magnetization resistance and reactance, respectively 2055# and 2.29mH, respectively Transformer turns ratio 1:1.68 Table 5.4 Variables associated with each test
  34. (2005). Design and evaluation of an automotive integrated system module. doi
  35. (2004). Design and experimental evaluation of an electromechanical engine valve drive. Power Electronics Specialists Conference, doi
  36. (2004). Design and simulation of a moving coil linear actuator for automotive applications. Industrial Technology, doi
  37. (1983). Design considerations for large space electric power system.
  38. (2010). Design Issues of an IPM BLAC Motor Used for Electric Power Steering.
  39. (2005). Design of a Fault-tolerant IPM Motor for Electric Power Steering. Power Electronics Specialists Conference, doi
  40. (2007). Direct torque control of induction motor drives using high frequency pulse density modulation for reduced torque ripple and switching losses. doi
  41. (2007). Distributed Intelligent Energy Management System for a Single-Phase High-Frequency AC Microgrid. Industrial Electronics, doi
  42. (2007). Down to the wire. Automotive Engineer.
  43. (1996). Dual voltage alternator. doi
  44. (2003). Effects of Electrical Loads on 42V Automotive Power Systems. doi
  45. (1999). Electrical Systems: doi
  46. (2002). Electromechanical actuators, doi
  47. (2008). Electronics Specialists Conference, doi
  48. (1994). Energy-Efficient Electric Motors and Their Applications, doi
  49. (2010). Equation 7.3 has been used to calculate the switching losses in the H-bridge. Ploss_on and Ploss_off in equation 7.3 are the power losses in the MOSFET during switch turnon and turn-off. As shown in Figure 7.8
  50. (2006). Evaluation on basic resonant structures and voltage clamping techniques. doi
  51. (2011). Feasibility of High Frequency Alternating Current Power for Motor Auxiliary Loads in Vehicles. Vehicular Technology, doi
  52. (2006). Figure 5.10 Diagram of alternator output DC voltage control 704
  53. (2006). Figure 5.11 Example of control scheme for an ISG application
  54. (2004). Figure 5.7 Alternator efficiency vs speed
  55. (2006). Figure 5.9 ISG induction motor efficiency and power output, vs engine speed (Jain et al.,
  56. (2000). Figure 6.3 Dual stator alternator architecture (Caliskan,
  57. (2010). Figure 7.8 MOSFET turn-on: voltage, current and switching losses (MOSFET: IRF S4229PBF N channel, 250V, 45A, on-state resistance 0.042 ohm) (Lourdes,
  58. (2005). Figure 8.14 Representation of the modified HFAC/AC bridge and SV PDM control ! Page 177! A common way to represent the three phase machine voltages is by using a space vector model. This technique has been extensively covered in the literature (Emadi,
  59. (2010). Figure 9.1 Mass (kg) vs. power rating (W) for commercially-available DC/AC inverters (Xantrex,
  60. (1997). Figure A3.16 Bus voltage and current for -420 W load of front module (Kokes,
  61. (1997). Figure A3.18 Bus voltage and battery module current for 420 W load (Kokes,
  62. (1997). Figure A3.19 Bus current for a load impact from -800 W to -1.8 kW (Kokes,
  63. (2005). Figure A4.1 illustrates the attenuation of these losses as a function of frequency for a particular cable used in IGBT motor control applications (i.e. at high frequency) (Liming and Boggs,
  64. (2007). Figure A7.1 Full-wave, quasi-resonant buck converter with ZVS (a) schematic diagram, (b) circuit waveforms (Rashid,
  65. Figure A9.1 Concept of vehicle integrating micro gas turbines (Jaguar Land Rover) Figure A9.2 Micro gas turbine concept for the next generation of HEVs (Jaguar Land Rover)
  66. (2006). For the particular case of a 40Ncm DC motor, as employed for example in a throttle valve control actuator (Iles-Klumpner
  67. (2010). For this purpose, performance data has been collected from commercially available AC (SL-MTI,
  68. (2005). Handbook of Automotive Power Electronics and Motor Drives, doi
  69. (2008). High Frequency AC Power Distribution Platforms. IN SPRINGERLINK (Ed.) Power Electronics in Smart Electrical Energy Networks. doi
  70. (2010). High Frequency AC Power Supply. Power Systems and Drives, PhD Thesis, doi
  71. (1996). High frequency AC vs. DC distribution system for next generation hybrid electric vehicle. Industrial Electronics, Control, and Instrumentation, doi
  72. (1994). High frequency alternating current power distribution. doi
  73. (2010). High Frequency Alternating Current Power Supply for Automobile Auxiliary Electrical Systems. doi
  74. (2001). Highly efficient brushless motor design for an air-conditioner of the next generation 42 V vehicle. doi
  75. (1999). Hybrid high frequency AC power distribution architecture for telecommunication systems. Aerospace and Electronic Systems, doi
  76. (2010). Information on the mass of AC/DC converters has been collected (MurataPower,
  77. (2009). information related to the mass of 400Hz AC converters is necessary. Data for off-the-shelf DC/115V AC converters have been collated and is illustrated in Figure 9.3 (Xantrex,
  78. (1997). Initial circuit topology 1/ rb 1/ ra Figure A3.1 The process of obtaining the equivalent circuit representation (Kokes,
  79. (2006). Integrated starter generator for 42-V powernet using induction machine and direct torque control technique. Power Electronics, doi
  80. (2010). Investigation of High Frequency AC Power Distribution Benefits for the Automobile Auxiliary Electrical System. doi
  81. (2010). Isolated Mosfet Module - Test Report.
  82. (2006). MOSFET Power Losses Calculation Using the Data-Sheet Parameters
  83. (2009). MSc Thesis, An electric power-assisted steering test rig.
  84. (1996). Multiple voltage electrical power distribution system for automotive applications. doi
  85. (2008). Optimal PWM method for electric and electro-hydraulic power steering applications. doi
  86. (2003). Page 121Table 6.2 Auxiliary loads with continuous operation (Lukic
  87. (2010). Page 191Figure 9.2 Mass (grams) vs. power rating (W) for commercially-available AC/DC converters (MurataPower,
  88. (1983). Page 233Appendices Appendix A Akagi
  89. (1999). PC platform power distribution system-past application, today's challenge and future direction. doi
  90. (2002). Performance analysis of automotive power systems: effects of power electronic intensive loads and electrically-assisted propulsion systems. doi
  91. (1988). Power conversion distribution system using a highfrequency AC link. Industry Applications, doi
  92. (1999). power distribution systems 6.2.1 DC power distribution The present 14V DC network has a centralised topology as illustrated in Figure 6.1 (Miller et al.,
  93. (2007). Power Electronics Handbook. doi
  94. (1996). Power flow in the HFAC system proposed by
  95. (1997). Resonantes Wecselspannungsbordnetz für Kraftfahrzeuge und dessen Beschreibung mit Zustandszeigern.
  96. (1991). Review of Heavy Duty Dual Voltage Systems. doi
  97. (2008). right) power conductors Page 114 2 Result obtained based on Equation A4.1 in the Appendix CA suitable commercially-available HFAC conductor (Juice,
  98. (2005). shows the waveforms of the HFAC current and output DC voltage for the three modes of operation. T/2=10μs HFAC current input Q1 and Q2 (on/off) Q3 and Q4 (on/off) Current charging filter capacitor Output DC voltage 2
  99. (2009). SimPowerSystems Toolbox, Power Electroncis Library, MOSFET model implementation example.
  100. (2009). since the MOSFET operates on a ZVS basis, the circuit efficiency is only a function of the resistive conduction losses. Equation 7.2 has been used to estimate the losses in the resonant-switch buck converter: Page 137Losses = imax 2 ! "
  101. (2000). Six network topologies are the main candidates for the dual DC voltage power bus (Caliskan,
  102. (2005). Spacecraft Power Systems, doi
  103. (1988). Status of 20 kHz Space Station Power Distribution Technology. National Aeronautics and Space Administration Lewis Research Center.
  104. (1998). Switching Power Supply Design, doi
  105. (2002). System performance of a high frequency AC power distribution system. doi
  106. (2004). Table 8.3 Comparison between 160W DC and 425W, 400Hz AC motors Motor type Voltage[V] (line to line rms for AC) Nominal Power [W] Nominal Current [A] Nominal Speed [rpm] Nominal Torque [Ncm] Peak Stall torque [Ncm] Length [mm] Diameter [mm] Mass [kg]
  107. (2006). Table 9.6 42V DC cables characteristics for the high power electrical loads Load DC conductor length (m) DC conductor copper mass, based on AWG data (g) Resistive energy losses (W) Active Suspension
  108. (2007). The Design and Fabrication of BLDC Motor and Drive for 42V Automotive Applications. Industrial Electronics, doi
  109. (1999). The distributed topology of the HFAC architecture can potentially lend the proposed system to a better design, which in turn may improve the reportedly time-consuming and expensive assembly process of DC on-board wiring (Miller et al.,
  110. (1996). the examination of the HFAC power distribution system for 400Hz motor loads is no longer relevant since a lower frequency conductor should replace the flat HFAC conductor. The study conducted by (Miller,
  111. (1996). The former has been suggested by (Bose et al.,
  112. (1998). The next generation automotive electrical power system architecture: issues and challenges. doi
  113. (2004). Vehicular Electric Power Systems: Land, Sea, Air, and Space Vehicles. doi
  114. (2006). where V is the voltage across the MOSFET before it changes state, and I is the current in the MOSFET. Similar values for the power loss variables have been indicated in the study by (Graovac et al.,
  115. (2004). Why drive white LEDs with constant current? ( Application Note 3256). DENSO
  116. (2009). Xantrex Pro Watt 250. XANTREX doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.