Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Studies into the Failure Prediction of Brittle Materials

By P. D. Nguyen


This thesis is divided into six chapters. The first chapter provides a brief introduction concerning the behaviour of brittle materials. It also contains the justification for the undertaking of the study as well as a brief description of the method of approach adopted, and thesis layout. Chapter two provides a critical review of the current literature available at present in the failure prediction brittle materials. Both theoretical and experimental studies are discussed and the relevance to the present work is justified. Chapter three deals with the numerical analyses adopted within the thesis. Five different failure criteria were utilized in the initial analysis of the results presented. Among them, the empirical model using the Principle of Independent Action satisfactorily represents the biaxial fracture behaviour of brittle materials in both tension-tension and tension-compression quadrants. Its validity has never been tested before. Various statistical fracture models were used to analyze the failure of brittle materials under multiaxial states of stress, the experimental failure data for simple tension being a starting point for their calculation. It was shown that the Energy Density theory led to a better agreement with the experiments than any other well-known fracture criterion. The study investigates methods of evaluating the Weibull parameters which were crucial in the failure prediction of brittle materials. Monte Carlo simulation techniques are also presented as a method of evaluating the data ranking for the failure probability of brittle materials. Chapter four is devoted to the description of experimental techniques adopted in the study, using specially designed rigs. Six different tests were conducted to evaluate the performance of brittle materials in static loading and also to enable comparisons with the theoretical predictions. Attention was given to specimen casting, loading frames, alignment, measurement techniques and other relevant parameters. The use of the linear elastic fracture mechanics method to predict the behaviour of cracks in bodies, which are subjected to steady stresses, is discussed. The compliance function for the three-point notch bend specimen is presented in addition to the determination of the fracture toughness of Herculite LX plaster. The work was also supplemented by the use of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to failure analysis of plaster material. This is an extremely important tool in the study of brittle materials since the dimensions of small defects and fracture features on individual grains are often pertinent information to the failure analysis. Chapter five details the analysis of the theoretical results as well as the experimental findings. Based upon the previously mentioned approaches, a comparison was made between theoretically predicted and experimentally observed data. The comparison indicates that discrepancies exist between the observed and predicted results, the reasons for the discrepancies have been justified in this work. Chapter six provides a brief summary of conclusions derived from the complete study, together with recommendations for future work

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 1987
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. 842-76 Standard Specification for Application of Interior Gypsum Plaster. doi
  2. A biaxial fracture criterion for porous brittle materials". doi
  3. A Biaxial-Flexure Test for Evaluating Ceramic Strengths". doi
  4. A comparison of failure predictions by strength and fracture mechanics techniques". doi
  5. (1952). A criterion for the failure of cast iron".
  6. A critical review of mechanical failure criteria". doi
  7. A fracture theory for materials".
  8. A Fracture Toughness Criterion for Concrete". doi
  9. A General Approach for the Statistical Analysis of Fracture". doi
  10. A General Approach for the Statistical Analysis of Multiaxial Fracture". doi
  11. A metal/ceramic diagnostic X-ray tube".
  12. A method for determining the strength of sheet glass". doi
  13. A method for measuring the strength of sheet glass". doi
  14. A new approach to Weibull's statistical theory of brittle fracture".
  15. A new era for engineering ceramics ? ".
  16. A Parametric Study of the Diametral Compression Test for Ceramics". doi
  17. A Probabilistic Analysis of the Brittle Fracture Loci under Biaxial Stress State". doi
  18. A Probability Treatise of Rupture of Brittle Rotating Disks". doi
  19. A simulation study of estimators for the 2-parameter Weibull distribution". doi
  20. A statistical distribution function of wide applicability".
  21. A statistical Theory for the Fracture of Brittle Structures Subjected to Nonuniform Polyaxial Stresses". Trans. doi
  22. A statistical theory of the strength of materials".
  23. A study of the theories of fracture under combined stresses". doi
  24. A Theoretical Analysis of the Ring-on-Ring Loading Disk Test". doi
  25. (1985). A Two Parameter Fracture Model for Concrete". doi
  26. Adhesives and Installation Techniques".
  27. (1985). Advanced Ceramic Materials - Technological and Economic Assessment". doi
  28. (1986). Alumina Products Zircar fibrous ceramics, Zirca Products Inc.,
  29. An analysis of the Brazilian disc fracture test using Weibull probabilistic treatment of brittle strength".
  30. An Analysis of the Diametral-Compression Test".
  31. An engineer's approach to the prediction of failure probability of brittle components".
  32. An engineer's guide to books on statistic and data analysis".
  33. An Evaluation Method for the Tensile Strength of Britlle Materials by means of New Indirect Tension Test".
  34. An Improved Biaxial Flexure Test for Ceramics".
  35. An improved fracture criterion for three-dimensional stress states". doi
  36. Anti-abrasive-wear fine ceramics materials used on I. D. F impeller blades.
  37. Application de `L'essai bresilien' ä 1'etude des produits ceramiques".
  38. Application of a statistical method to brittle fracture in biaxial loading systems". doi
  39. Application of all-ceramic nozzle to radial flow turbine". doi
  40. Application of numerical methods in predicting strengths of brittle materials".
  41. Application of reliability technology in tool design".
  42. (1974). Application of the finite element method to problems in linear and nonlinear fracture mechanics".
  43. (1983). Application of the Pafec 75 Software Package".
  44. Applications of high performance ceramics in heat engine design". doi
  45. Appraisal of Biaxial Strength Testing". doi
  46. (1985). Army Standard Test Method for Flexural Strength of High Performance Ceramics at Ambient Temperature". Ibid.,
  47. Basic research needs on high temperature ceramics for energy applications". doi
  48. BASIC User's Guide Order No. AA-L335A-TK including AD-L335A-TI.
  49. Biaxial and Uniaxial Data for Statistical Comparisons of a Ceramic's Strength". doi
  50. Biaxial Flexure Tests for Ceramics".
  51. Biaxial Flexure Tests of Ceramic Substrates".
  52. Biaxial Fracture Studies of a Glass-Ceramic". doi
  53. Biaxial mechanical properties of AXF-5Q graphite to 40000 F".
  54. Bonded Strain Gage Load Cells". Process Instruments and Control Handbook,
  55. (1985). British Gypsum Limited, Private communication,
  56. Brittle fracture initiation under complex stress states". doi
  57. Brittle fracture of hard metals : Dependence of strength on defect size distribution". doi
  58. Brittle Fracture under Compressive Stresses". doi
  59. (1968). brittle material". 17,233-248,1950. brittle anisotropic Journal of Engineering Series H, 2,91-96, materials under biaxial ME, 39,320,1096-1105,1973. fracture criterion under Trans.
  60. (1979). BSSM Strain Measurement Reference Book". The British Society for Strain Measurement,
  61. (1985). CARBIDE - Today's engineering ceramic. BNFL Publication,
  62. (1986). Carborundum Resistant Materials,
  63. (1984). Cemented Carbide as an engineering material".
  64. Ceramic boundary-layer capacitors".
  65. Ceramic components : key to improve diesel effiviency ? ".
  66. Ceramic components in passenger-car diesel engines". doi
  67. (1985). Ceramic cut out cooling Engineering,
  68. Ceramic Cutting Tool Materials". doi
  69. Ceramic distributor rotor for electromagnetic interference (EMI) control".
  70. Ceramic fibres for the Automotive Industry". Paper presented at the Second
  71. Ceramic Foam Filter Toshiba Ceramics Publication,
  72. Ceramic Fracture Features, Observations, Mechanism, and Uses". doi
  73. (1985). Ceramic Heat Exchanger Concept and Materials Technology".
  74. Ceramic materials - Some product design considerations". doi
  75. (1986). Ceramic Materials/3M -A commitment to quality Ceramic Materials Department/3M, 98-0400-0510-4 (26.5) 11,
  76. (1985). Ceramic materials".
  77. Ceramic multilayer capacitors".
  78. Ceramic technology - Application to engine components".
  79. (1985). Ceramic tool materials".
  80. (1978). Ceramic tooling has what it takes but few takers".
  81. (1984). Ceramic turbochargers boost engine performance".
  82. Ceramics - Materials at the sharp end of defence".
  83. Ceramics :A Brittle material shatters ductile traditions".
  84. Ceramics and the Reciprocating Internal Combustion Engine". doi
  85. (1985). Ceramics faces its big test".
  86. (1984). Ceramics for Fusion Devices".
  87. Ceramics for Sensors".
  88. Ceramics in engines - process requirements and research activity". doi
  89. Challenging time for technical ceramics".
  90. (1983). Characterization of Ceramic Vane Materials for the 10KW Turbo-alternator". Ibid.,
  91. Combination of fracture mechanics, probability, and micromechanical models of crack growth in ceramic systems". doi
  92. Comments on an indirect tensile test on concrete cylinders". doi
  93. Comparison of methods for calculating stress intensity factors with quarter-point elements". doi
  94. Comparison of splitting tensile strength of concrete with flexural and compressive strength".
  95. Comparison of the Best Known Fracture Criteria".
  96. Compression fracture statistics of compacted cement cylinder". doi
  97. Considerations for tribological application of engineering ceramics". doi
  98. Construction of Models of Concrete damps for elastic tests".
  99. Crack growth resistance curve and size effect in the fracture of cement paste". doi
  100. Critical assesment - Transformation - Toughned Zirconia ceramics".
  101. Critical Survey of Mechanical Property Test Methods for Brittle Materials".
  102. Cure it with
  103. Demonstration of ceramic design methodology for a ceramic combustor liner". doi
  104. Design Analysis of an Automotive Exhaust Gas Sensor". Ceramic Engineering and Science Proceedings,
  105. (1982). Design with Non-ductile Materials".
  106. Designing with brittle materials subjected to complex loading systems". Conference organized by the British Ceramics Society,
  107. (1985). development in ceramics - Dublin University leads the pack. The Engineer,
  108. Development of ceramic pre-combustion chamber". doi
  109. Development of sprayed ceramic seal system for turbine gas path sealing". doi
  110. Diametral compressive testing method". doi
  111. Discussion of a paper by Sven Thaulow : Tensile Splitting Test and High Strength Concrete Test Cylinders". doi
  112. Double Punch Test for Tensile Strength of Concrete". doi
  113. Effect of Polyaxial Stress States on Failure Strength of Alumina Ceramics". doi
  114. Effects of multiaxial stresses on the fracture strength of silicon carbide". doi
  115. Effects of Specimen Size on Strength of Sintered Silicon Nitride". doi
  116. Effects of Stress State on ceramic Strength".
  117. Engineering applications of sialons".
  118. Engineering Ceramics".
  119. Engineering in Carbon". Engineering,
  120. (1980). Engineering Materials".
  121. Engineering performance prediction for ceramics". doi
  122. Engineering with Ceramics".
  123. Estimation of Parameters in the Weibull Distribution". doi
  124. Estimation of Weibull parameters by omission of some data in a sample". doi
  125. Evaluation of a Fundamental Approach for the Statistical Analysis Fracture". doi
  126. Evaluation of ceramics for passenger car turbochargers". doi
  127. Evaluation of Fracture Toughness of Nuclear Graphite".
  128. Evaluation of Stress Intensity Factors". doi
  129. Examination of size effects in the failure prediction of ceramic material". doi
  130. Fabrication, formulation, mechanical properties, and oxidation of sintered Si3N4 ceramics using disc specimens". doi
  131. Failure analysis of cast irons under general three-dimensional stress states". doi
  132. Finite Element Analysis of the Diametral Test of Polymer Moldings". doi
  133. Finite Element Model to Determine K, " doi
  134. (1942). Flexural Strength of High Performance Ceramics at Ambient Temperatures. Army Materials and Mechanics Research
  135. (1975). Formulas for Stress and Strain". doi
  136. (1982). Fracture Analysis of Reaction-Bonded Silicon Nitride Turbine Shrouds". Army Materials and Mechanics Research Center,
  137. Fracture Behavior and doi
  138. Fracture criteria for cast iron under biaxial stresses". doi
  139. Fracture Mechanics of Polymers and Adhesives". Fracture of Non-Metallic Materials, doi
  140. Fracture of brittle stresses".
  141. Fracture of compression". 455-457,1978. De S. and TRUSTRUM, brittle materials doi
  142. (1979). Fracture of Engineering Brittle Materials".
  143. Fracture of gray-cast iron tubes under biaxial stresses".
  144. Fracture of Solids". doi
  145. Fracture Statistics of Brittle Materials with Surface Cracks". Engineering Fracture mechanics, doi
  146. Fracture strength and thermal shock resistance of thick and thin-walled magnesium-aluminum-silicate ceramic heat regenerators". doi
  147. Fracture strength characterization of tubular ceramic materials using a simple C-ring geometry". doi
  148. Fracture toughness measurements of polymer concretes". doi
  149. Friction at Broad and Narrow Contacts Between Silicon Nitride and Hardened Steel".
  150. Friction on Griffith cracks in rocks under pressure".
  151. Frictional Effects
  152. (1985). Fundamentals of Engineering Materials'.
  153. Fundamentals Wiley & Sons, methodes d'essais des plätres Dnal des Industries du Plätre, Paris, J. of Classical Thermodynamics".
  154. (1976). Gauge installation with M-Bond 200 Adhesive Instruction Bulletin B-127-5. Welwyn Strain Measurement Limited,
  155. Gypsum - Building from the depths".
  156. Gypsum Analysis with the Polarizing Microscope". doi
  157. Gypsum Cements for the Ceramic Industry United States Gypsum, Bulletin No.
  158. Handbook of brittle material design technology".
  159. (1968). Handbook of Mathematical Functions".
  160. (1985). Handbook of Properties of Technical and Engineering Ceramics".
  161. Industrial Plaster "Herculite and Crystacal industrial plaster for engineering, pattern making, tooling". British Gypsum Limited,
  162. Inferences on the Parameters of the Weibull Distribution". doi
  163. (1986). Information doi
  164. Innovative design of ceramic utility gas turbine". doi
  165. Interlaboratory comparison of flexural strength of structural ceramics". doi
  166. (1985). Introduction to statistical quality control". doi
  167. Large-Deflection Solution of the Coaxial-Ring-Circular-Glass-Plate Flexure Problem". doi
  168. Macroscopic brittle multi-axial stress".
  169. (1984). Mark 11, Volume 6. Chapter S- Approximation of Special Functions Numerical Algorithms Group,
  170. Materials for the 80's and 90's". doi
  171. Measurement materials". 10,281-287, and BRODIE,
  172. (1969). Measurement of the an Indirect Method. Cement and Concrete TRA 419,
  173. Measuring the fracture toughness of cement paste and mortar". doi
  174. (1986). Mechanical Damage and Crack Growth in Concrete". Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, doi
  175. Mechanical engineering design".
  176. (1980). Mechanical Properties of Biomaterials".
  177. Mechanical testing of hard materials". doi
  178. Metal/ceramic X-ray tubes for non-destructive testing".
  179. Method for Tensile Testing of Brittle Materials". Review Scientific Instrument, doi
  180. (1985). Mineral Facts
  181. (1974). Model analysis of structure".
  182. (1983). Modern Ceramic Cutting Tool Materials". doi
  183. Modern Ceramic Engineering".
  184. Modified maximum likelihood and modified moment estimators for the three-parameter Weibull distribution". doi
  185. Multiaxial strength tests for brittle materials". doi
  186. (1986). New pouring filter improves casting quality Ceramic products for metal casting. Certech,
  187. Notch sensitivity in fracture testing of aggregative materials". doi
  188. Note on the use of the diametral compression test for the strength measurement of ceramics". doi
  189. On estimating the Weibull modulus for a brittle material". doi
  190. On the biaxial fracture strength of Reaction-Bonded Silicon Nitride".
  191. On the finite element methods in linear fracture mechanics". doi
  192. On the New Indirect Tension Test of Brittle Materials".
  193. On the Relative Coefficients of the Multiaxial Probability Distribution Function for Fracture". doi
  194. On the Statistical Approach to Brittle Rupture for Multiaxial States of Stress". doi
  195. Organization and financing of ceramics research and development - An overview". doi
  196. Pafec : The Pafec Finite. Element Analysis System". doi
  197. Photoelasticity". doi
  198. Plane Strain Crack Toughness Testing of High Strength Metallic Materials". doi
  199. Plaster of Paris in the southern 'Harz'-mountain". Borgardts - Sachsenstein GmbH,
  200. Potentialities of Egyptian Gypsum for Housing".
  201. (1985). Practical reliability engineering".
  202. Probabilistic Design and Reliability of Silicon Carbide Ceramics". doi
  203. Probabilistic Structural Mechanics Chances are...
  204. Progress on ceramic rotor blade development for industrial gas turbine". doi
  205. (1984). PTC ceramics heat automotive controls". doi
  206. Quality control in the plaster mold shop Tooling and Casting Division United States Gypsum, Bulletin No.
  207. (1985). Reaction Bonded Silicon Nitride "Application Data Sheet - Electrical Applications". AE Developments Ltd., Engineering Ceramic Unit,
  208. (1985). Reaction Bonded Silicon Nitride "Application Data Sheet - Handling molten metals".
  209. (1985). Reaction Bonded Silicon Nitride "Application Data Sheet - Jigs and Fixture".
  210. (1985). Reaction Bonded Silicon Nitride "Applications Data Sheet - Tribological and Gauging Applications".
  211. Recent trends in the development of fine ceramics in Japan". doi
  212. Reduction of Errors in Ceramic Bend Tests".
  213. Regenerative ceramic burner has highest efficiency".
  214. Reliability and durability of ceramic regenerators in gas turbine". doi
  215. (1977). Reliability in Engineering Design".
  216. (1976). Reliability Technology".
  217. Reply to comments on 'Estimating the Weibull modulus for a brittle material, ". doi
  218. Requirements for engineering ceramics in gas turbine engines".
  219. Requirements for engines". doi
  220. Requirements for Flexure Testing of Brittle Materials". doi
  221. (1984). Review of Valve Design for Coal-Gasification Lockhopper Service".
  222. (1984). Ring-on-Ring Tests and Load Capacity of Cladding Glass". doi
  223. Ring-on-Ring Tests and the Modelling of Cladding Glass Strength by the Weibull Distribution". doi
  224. (1965). Selection techniques for brittle materials".
  225. Si3N4 and Si2N2O for high performance radomes". doi
  226. (1982). Sialon tool materials". doi
  227. SiC as a structural material in the plasma chamber of nuclear fusion reactors". doi
  228. Sixty years in 'Glass"'.
  229. (1984). Small gas turbine".
  230. Some sub-critical crack growth parameters and their evaluation".
  231. Statistical analysis of the brittle fracture of sintered tungsten". doi
  232. Statistical approach to brittle fracture". doi
  233. Statistical Determination of Surface Flaw Density in Brittle Materials". doi
  234. Statistical fracture theory for Multiaxial Stress States using Weibull's three-parameter function". doi
  235. (1985). Statistical Methods for Engineers". doi
  236. (1967). Statistical Models in Engineering".
  237. Statistical Reproducibility of the Dynamic and Static Fatigue Experiments".
  238. Statistical theory of failure for ceramic in aggressive environments".
  239. (1958). Statistics of Extreme".
  240. (1985). Stochastic system reliability modelling". doi
  241. Strength and toughness in ceramic systems".
  242. Strength of hardmetals". doi
  243. Strength of magnesium biaxial stresses". 489-492,1968. silicate and graphite under Ceramic Bulletin,
  244. Strength tests for brittle materials".
  245. Stress Analysis of Cracks". doi
  246. Stress distribution in splitting tests".
  247. Stress Intensity Factor and Energy Release Rate for Three-point Bend Specimens". Engineering Fracture mechanics, doi
  248. Stress Intensity Factors for Single-Edge-Notch Beam". doi
  249. Stress Rupture Test Rig Design for Evaluating Ceramic Material Specimens". doi
  250. Stress-Intensity Factors for Three-Point Bend Specimens by Boundary Collocation". doi
  251. Structural Reliability :A Processing-Dependent Phenomenon".
  252. Structural reliability theory and its applications". doi
  253. Substitution of ceramics for conventional cutting tools". Materials -and Society,
  254. Successful Failure Analysis using Finite Elements".
  255. Sulfate". Concise Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, doi
  256. (1984). Surface - doi
  257. (1985). Taking advantage of new ceramics".
  258. (1977). Talysurf 10 Operator's Handbook Rank Taylor Hobson,
  259. Techniques for stress analysis of ceramics".
  260. Tensile Splitting Test and High Strength Concrete Test Cylinders". doi
  261. Tensile Strength Distribution for Silicon Nitride and Silicon Carbide Ceramics".
  262. Tensile strength of concrete : Double-punch test". doi
  263. Tensile Strength of Concrete".
  264. Tensile Strength of Dense Polycrystalline Ceramics by the Diametral-Compression Test".
  265. Testing Gypsum Cements & Plasters Tooling and Casting Division United States Gypsum, Bulletin No.
  266. The behavior and design of
  267. The brittle ring test".
  268. (1984). The ceramics age dawns".
  269. The concentric-ring-test and its application for determining the surface strength of ceramics".
  270. The deformation and rupture of gray cast iron".
  271. The Design of Ceramic Turbine Blade Roots".
  272. The Disk Test for Brittle Mat2r? als". doi
  273. The Effects of Temperature and Environment on the Strength of Two Polycrystalline Aluminas".
  274. The evaluation of Poisson's ratio and the modulus of materials of a low tensile resistance by the Brazilian (Indirect tensile) test with particular reference to concrete".
  275. The failure probability of bend test specimens".
  276. (1977). The Finite Element Method". doi
  277. The flow and fracture of doi
  278. The Fracture Resistance of Reaction-Sintered Silicon Nitride".
  279. The Indirect Tension Test for Concrete". doi
  280. (1978). The measurement of the surface finish".
  281. (1981). The Mechanics of Fracture and Fatigue".
  282. The phenomenon of rupture in solids".
  283. The Point-load Strength Tests".
  284. The Statistical Approach to Engineering Design in Ceramics".
  285. The theory of rupture".
  286. The unit strength concept in the interpretation of beam test results for brittle materials". doi
  287. The use of PTC heaters in diesel fuels".
  288. Tool fracture probability under steady state cutting conditions". doi
  289. Toscut scissors into the market Toshiba Ceramics News, 8,1987 Toshiba Ceramics Co.
  290. Toshiba Ceramics News, 7,1986 Toshiba Ceramics Co.
  291. Use of Statistis in Ceramic Design and Evaluation". Ceramics for high performance application II,
  292. Use of the Notched-Beam Test for Evaluation of Fracture Energies of Ceramics". doi
  293. Use of Weibull Statistics to Correlate MOR, Ball-on-Ring, and Rotational Fast Fracture Tests". doi
  294. (1984). User Manual Level 6.1, Pafec Ltd.,
  295. ZIRCONIA - Transformation Toughned. Nilcra Ceramics

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.