Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Improvement of cost estimating internal practice.

By Petros Souchoroukov


This thesis is concerned with understanding the internal costing practices employed by commercial and engineering disciplines of cost estimating for generating estimates at the conceptual design stage of complex hardware products. It examines whether there is a formal structure in the interaction between the two groups that can be represented within a model. The aim is to develop a framework that will formalise and improve the communication of commercial and engineering disciplines in cost estimating. A literature review examines the role of different costing techniques and the information requirements for generating cost estimates. The review identifies that there is a lack of research in the information requirements for cost estimating of specific manufacturing industries, and that the interaction of commercial and engineering disciplines of cost estimating at conceptual design stage is hindered by the different focuses of these groups. By conducting a survey study the author identifies the internal practice in cost estimating for the automotive industry. The survey establishesth at in order to improve the internal practice it is essential to establish a data infrastructure that fortnalises and enables the reuse of the cost estimates and improves the interaction between the two groups. The author identifies a common cost estimating process for the automotive industry. This study establishes the required data and information elements and information sources that need to be collected in order to have reliable data infrastructure. Using a case study approach, the author also establishes that it is essential to analyse the product functions in such a way that will enable the development of a detailed cost estimating model at the conceptual design stage, which will improve interaction between the commercial and engineering groups. The function-based cost estimating process becomes the focus of detailed studies using experts from the automotive industry. This results in a generic framework that provides a formalised structure to represent functional requirements in the form of a detailed cost estimating model. The thesis concludes that product functions need to be captured and analysedd uring the conceptuald evelopmento f a product and be associatedto cost estimates. The developed results provide both groups of cost estimating a structured, consistent approach to developing cost estimates at the conceptual design stage. The data infrastructure and the function-based cost estimating framework is validated through case studies and expert evaluation. The approach contributes towards improvement of the internal cost estimating practice with the automotive industry

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 2004
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1993). A CAD for Functional Design.
  2. (2000). A conceptual framework for understanding business processes and business process modelling. doi
  3. (1999). A consistent manufacturing data model to support virtual enterprises. International journal of agile management systems, doi
  4. (1999). A framework for selecting business process modeling methods. In: Industrial management and data systems, doi
  5. (1997). A generalised cost-estimation model for job shops, in: doi
  6. (2000). A generic framework for cost estimation and cost control in product design', doi
  7. (1991). A generic IDEFO model of process planning. international journal of production research, doi
  8. (1993). A Parametric Approach to Cost Estimating at Conceptual Stage of Design. In: doi
  9. (2002). A structured approach to enterprise modelling and analysis.
  10. (1993). A systematic approach to conceptual design. doi
  11. AACE international recommended practices and standards.
  12. (2001). About AR Associates. Corporate Profile, http: //www. xrassociates.
  13. (2001). About BAE SYSTEMS. Corporate Infonnation, http: //www. bae-co. uk/,
  14. (2002). About Standardisation. http: //www. icoste. org,
  15. (1999). Accounting as a management tool for non. industrial private forestry. doi
  16. (1991). Activity Accounting.
  17. (1995). Activity-based costing and traditional cost allocation structures. In:
  18. (2000). Aircraft conceptual design synthesis. Professional Engineering Publication, doi
  19. (1988). Airframe structural design: practical design information and data on aircraft structures, Conmilit, Hong Kong.
  20. (1998). An architecturefor cost control, the use of cost infonnation in order-related decisions,
  21. (1998). An integrated process model driven knowledge based system for remote customer support. doi
  22. (1997). Analogy and complex software modelling. In: Computers inhuman behaviour, doi
  23. (2000). Application of IDEFO, IDEM and UML methodologies in the creation of information models. doi
  24. (1994). Applyingfunctional cost analysis in a manufacturing environment".
  25. (1996). Automated design-to-cost: integrating costing into the design decision. In: Computer-aided design, doi
  26. (1996). Basic cost engineering. 3rd rev ed.
  27. (1989). Bidder's Associate: a case-based reasoning system to improve cost estimates of manufactured products. In: doi
  28. (2000). Business modelling with UML: business patterns at work.
  29. (1998). Classifying functions for mechanical design. doi
  30. (1998). Concepts for Modelling Infonnation Formally. In:
  31. (1997). Conceptual Design, Manufacturability Evaluation and Preliminary Process Planning Using Function-Form Relationships in Stamped Material Parts. In: doi
  32. (1999). Conceptual designfor engineers, 3rd ed.
  33. (1998). Cost Analysis', Unpublished paper,
  34. (1996). Cost and management accounting. doi
  35. (1999). Cost estimation during design step: parametric versus case based reasoning method. In: Internationaljournal ofadvanced manufacturing technology, doi
  36. (1990). Cost information toolsfor designers, a survey ofproblems and possibilities with an emphasis on mass produced sheetmetal parts,
  37. (1996). Cost is a strategic issue. In: Long range p. lanning, 29(l), doi
  38. (2002). Costing support and cost control in manufacturing -A cost estimation tool applied in the sheet metal domain; PhD Thesis,
  39. (1995). Detailed cost estimating', In: doi
  40. (1997). Developing an integrated framework for featurebased early manufacturing cost estimation, In: doi
  41. (1983). Engineering Design: a Materials and Processing Approach.
  42. (1988). Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach', doi
  43. (1906). Enterprise modelling and integration: principles and applications. doi
  44. (2001). et al (2001a). Commercial and engineering activities within cost estimating: industry practise AS-IS.
  45. (1997). Examination of U. S. -based Japanese subsidiaries: evidence of the transfer of the Japanese strategic cost management. In: The international journal ofaccounting, doi
  46. (1996). Expert judgement as an estimating method. in: doi
  47. (1989). FDL-A language for functional description and rationalization in Mechanical Design. In: doi
  48. (1996). Feature-based cost estimation for packaging products using neural networks. doi
  49. (2006). Five Misunderstandings About Case Study Research". In: Qualitative Inquiry, doi
  50. (1973). Functional Analysis System Technique Manual,
  51. (2000). How to get a PhD: A handbookfor students and their supervisors. Yd edition,
  52. (2002). How to write a better thesis. 2d edition, doi
  53. (2002). http: //www. prosim. net/english. html (Accesses I st
  54. (1998). Implementation of activity-based costing in manufacturing. In: Internationaljournal ofproduction economics, doi
  55. (1990). Information and data modelling. Blackwell Scientific,
  56. (1996). Information modelling for manufacturing systems: a case study. Robotics and computer-integrated manufacturing, doi
  57. (1997). Information' technology for management, 6th ed.
  58. (2002). Interactive Statistics, [Thousand Oaks]
  59. (1975). Introduction to qualitative research methods. doi
  60. (2000). Introduction to research methods. Sage Publications Limited, Intemational Edition,
  61. (2001). Managing uncertainty in project portfolio Cost estimation. In: doi
  62. (2001). Manufacturing cost modelling for concurrent product development. In: Robotics and computer-integrated manufacturing, doi
  63. (2000). Manufacturing cost modelling for product design. In: Internationaljournal offlexible manufacturing systems, doi
  64. (1994). Manufacturing systems design and analysis: context and techniques, 2nd ed.
  65. (1997). Marginal costing: cost budgeting and cost variance analysis. In: Management accounting research, doi
  66. (1992). Memo to global competitors: it is time to replace cost accounting with process based information. doi
  67. (1995). Modelling the Information Access Methods of Engineering Designers. In:
  68. (2001). Models for estimating design effort and time. In: Design studies, doi
  69. (1998). Object-orientation in business process modeling through applying event driven process chains (EPQ doi
  70. (1986). Planning and Creating Successful Engineering Designs. doi
  71. (2002). PRICE H, the Hardware Estimating Model. Citing Internet resources
  72. (1991). Product design for manufacture and assembly, In: Design for Manufacture. doi
  73. (1998). Product life cycle cost analysis: state of the art review. doi
  74. (1984). Protocol analysis: verbal reports as data. doi
  75. (1980). Qualitative evaluation methods. Newbury Parký' CA: Sage Perera, Srinath et al.
  76. (1991). Qualitative methods in management research,
  77. (2002). Quantitative and Qualitative Cost Estimating for Engineering Design. In: doi
  78. (1993). Questionnaire design and attitude measurement, 2nd edition.
  79. (2002). Real world research: a resource for social scientists and practitioner-researchers. 2nd edition, Blackwell Publishers, doi
  80. (2001). Representing Background Information for Product Description to Support Product Development Process. In: The Annals of the CIRPý
  81. (2002). SEER tools.
  82. (1994). SSADM version 4: the advancedpractitioner's guide.
  83. (1997). Target costing and value engineering.
  84. (1993). Target costing support systems: lessons from leading Japanese companies. In: Management accounting research, doi
  85. (1969). The age of discontinuity: guidelines to our changing society. doi
  86. (1991). The design of cost management systems; text, cases and readings,
  87. (2002). The development of an information infrastructure for cost estimating in the automotive industry. MA Thesis, doi
  88. (1976). The failure-experience matrix-A useful design tool, doi
  89. (1993). The Information Requirements of Engineering Designers. In: doi
  90. (1997). The mechanical design process. doi
  91. (1997). The relationship between information and personal knowledge in new product development. In: Internationaliournal ofinformation management.
  92. (2002). The role of cost management in network relationships. In: Internationaljournal ofproduction economics,
  93. (1997). The role of information structures in design and engineering processes. In: doi
  94. (1980). The third wave. doi
  95. (1994). Three design to cost myths. In:
  96. (2000). UML distilled, 2nd ed.
  97. (1993). Using Activity-Based Costing to Improve Performance.
  98. (1994). What kind of activity-based information does your purpose require? In: International journal of operations and production management. doi
  99. (1971). XAST Diagrams For Creative Fýnctional Analysis.
  100. (2001). XPat: a tool for manufacturing knowledge elicitation. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.